StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Refusal for a Future Life-Sustaining Treatment - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
As the discussion, Refusal for a Future Life-Sustaining Treatment, stresses the symptoms of Huntington’s disease (HD) are evident for patients in their 30’s or 40’s. HD, however, begins at any age from infancy. The offspring of an affected parent has a 50% chance of HD transmittal. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
Refusal for a Future Life-Sustaining Treatment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Refusal for a Future Life-Sustaining Treatment"

The symptoms of Huntington’s disease (HD) are evident for patients in their 30’s or 40’s. HD, however, begins at any age from infancy. The offspring of an affected parent has a 50% chance of HD transmittal. Huntington’s disease is autosomal dominant. By and large, HD is a progressive neurodegenerative genetic disorder. In contrast to cognitive symptoms, physical symptoms are the first observable signs of HD. Random and uncontrollable twitching called chorea is the most noticeable of these symptoms.

Gradually, the patient’s cognitive power is impaired. HD is hereditary and incurable. Affected patients experience irreversible dementia leading to fatality. The only thing that they can do for now is to avail for genetic counseling to ease their level of discomfort and anxiety. John is a lawyer in his 30’s. Several months ago, he noticed rapid movements twitching in his face. John then went to two neurologists and found out that he has Huntington’s disease. John’s mother died from that disease.

He knows that he has ten years or so to live. The issue in John’s case is whether or not it is ethical, upon paralysis, to refuse future life-sustaining treatment. Whether or not John is in his right mind is also an issue here. Huntington’s disease affects the patient’s cognitive abilities. Despite the symptoms he unbearably experienced, John remains to be a productive lawyer. His productive work only shows that he is in his right mind. Moreover, John wrote a note before ingesting all his antidepressant medicine.

Writing a note that states a clear message implies that the writer knows what he is doing. John, to my mind, is unquestionably competent in deciding what is good for him. His concept of good lies not in his biological good but rather in his perception of good. To die without life-sustaining treatment is what constitute good for John. John’s psychiatrist refused to help him commit suicide. Well, that’s what psychiatrist is paid for: to help their patients live a normal life. At this point, one might challenge the credibility of John’s right mind.

I would still say that John was in his right mind when he spoke those words. The fact that John reassured his psychiatrist that he do not have plans to commit suicide “any time soon” implies that he consciously knows what he is saying. John’s case is comparable to cases concerning physician-assisted suicide or PAS. First, John has an incurable disease. Second, he expressed his refusal for a potential life-sustaining treatment. And third, John asked for his psychiatrist to help him commit suicide.

In PAS, obviously, it is the physician who performs the procedure. The ethical problem that usually arises from Huntington disease involves the practice of genetic test. Confidentiality matters in the disclosure of a patient’s health condition. Also, it is questionable whether or not insurance companies and the like should compel its clients or employees to reveal their diseases. In addition, it is argued whether or not children with HD affected parents should undergo genetic test. The consensus is that the mentally-competent legal-age person should be the standard measure in allowing for genetic test.

What should be done for this patient? First, look and study John’s disease and see if that disease has a merit for permitting him to serve aid in dying. Evidently, John has undergone genetic counseling in vain. And second, give what John desires -- namely, refusal for potential life-sustaining treatment. Let’s assume, for the sake of the argument, that John has a questionable competency to decide for himself. We know for a fact that Huntington’s disease gradually affects the cognitive and mental state of the affected patient.

Thus, John’s mentality was corrupted by his very disease. HD plagues John’s right mind. In fact, his words and action were inconsistent.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Refusal for a Future Life-Sustaining Treatment Essay”, n.d.)
Refusal for a Future Life-Sustaining Treatment Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1569033-discussion-4b-huntingtons-disease-case-study
(Refusal for a Future Life-Sustaining Treatment Essay)
Refusal for a Future Life-Sustaining Treatment Essay. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1569033-discussion-4b-huntingtons-disease-case-study.
“Refusal for a Future Life-Sustaining Treatment Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1569033-discussion-4b-huntingtons-disease-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Refusal for a Future Life-Sustaining Treatment

The Analysis of the Health Ethical Issues

The Right of a Terminally Ill Patient to Refuse Medical Treatment Under the informed consent guidelines, the doctors and nurses should properly inform the patients about the main purpose, advantages, and disadvantages of each prescribed drug and other medical care intervention such as the use of life-sustaining treatment like tube feeding devices, mechanical breathing ventilation and dialysis machines, and/or diagnosing devices like x-ray and CT scan (Kaufmann & Ruhli, 2010; Ganzini et al....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Euthanasia in Australia

The Advance Health Directive and statutory regime- a failed purpose Admittedly, the only purpose of Advance Health Directive (AHD) is to allow individuals to decide their future course of treatment if they are incapable of taking independent decisions in future.... The Power of Attorney Act (1998) (QLD) declares that in order to proceed with the AHD to remove life-sustaining measures; one of the four conditions should be met: the patient has a terminal illness from which death is certain; the patient is in a vegetative state; the patient is permanently unconscious; or the patient has such an illness or injury from which patient is highly unlikely to recover....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Medical Law in the UK

Doctors have to ensure that their medical treatment does not infringe the patient's freedom.... The appellate court also upheld this decision; and it became very clear that patients were at liberty to choose any particular medical treatment.... It was also established, that patients could refuse to accept treatment; even though such treatment would save their life5....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

End of Life Issues

It addresses ethical issues such as life-sustaining treatment.... Ethical issues such as life-sustaining treatment must be adopted only with the proper consultation with the patient and the relatives.... The author states that doctors need training in dealing with aged persons as far as the medical profession is concerned … Advance directives are a better option for both the patient and the doctor in order to decide upon the future course of treatment in case of an emergency....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

The History of Euthanasia and Its Future

This act leads to criminal homicide charges or civil law for withholding treatment.... nbsp;Looking back at the history of euthanasia, one can see a frightening future for the reason that floodgates of euthanasia are now opened not only in Europe but other states in the US as well (Schadenberg, 2008)....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

For and against the Legalization of Euthanasia

Focusing on ethical cases whereby terminally ill patients are seeking euthanasia, this report will discuss whether or not a terminally ill patient has the right to refuse medical treatment.... In the paper “For and against the Legalization of Euthanasia” the author discusses health ethical issues related to the 'right to live' and the 'right to die'....
12 Pages (3000 words) Dissertation

Euthanasia in Australia

dmittedly, the only purpose of the Advance Health Directive (AHD) is to allow individuals to decide their future course of treatment if they are incapable of taking independent decisions in the future.... The Power of Attorney Act (1998) (QLD) declares that in order to proceed with the AHD to remove life-sustaining measures; one of the four conditions should be met: the patient has a terminal illness from which death is certain; the patient is in a vegetative state; the patient is permanently unconscious, or the patient has such an illness or injury from which patient is highly unlikely to recover....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Patient-Facing the Capacity to Refuse Life-Sustaining Treatment

… The paper "Patient-Facing the Capacity to Refuse life-sustaining treatment' is a perfect example of a case study on health sciences and medicine.... The paper "Patient-Facing the Capacity to Refuse life-sustaining treatment' is a perfect example of a case study on health sciences and medicine.... E has been admitted and received different medications and has written the advance directive to refuse life-sustaining treatment.... Questions exist on the significance of the advance directive in refusing life-sustaining treatment and the role of different bodies in addressing E requirements....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us