StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Ancient Flood Stories (Problems for Critical Scholarship) - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The allure of ancient flood stories has a powerful hold on people because the stories allude to the way how the world was created and came into being…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Ancient Flood Stories (Problems for Critical Scholarship)
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ancient Flood Stories (Problems for Critical Scholarship)"

Download file to see previous pages

However, it is not an easy task to find out the important details of these flood stories because of their extreme antiquity and the lack of supporting evidence except for a few broken shards or fragments of pottery that detail these flood stories. It is unswervingly a very daunting task indeed to verify the stories that will anchor them on historical details as many of these stories are seemingly myths or legends. This brief paper examines some of the challenges encountered in critical scholarship of stories like great floods which occurred a long time ago and for which records are incomplete.

Discussion The aim of critical scholarship is to set historical records straight but problems are inevitable when the records are themselves incomplete or at times even contradictory. Many scholars, academicians, historians and archaeologists realize these limitations but still try to carry on with the task. In this regard, to claim certainty in the absence of corroborating pieces of evidence is not only risky but also considered as reckless in terms of academic scholarship. To refer to something without a degree of certainty is likewise faulty, even deceptive.

Several issues with regards to critical scholarship concerning these ancient flood stories pertain to the provenance of these stories, their lack of correspondence and the contradictions, the use of varying terms or emergence of several versions by different authors that hinders the task. The two most famous and well-read flood stories are that of the Biblical Noah's Ark and the Epic of Gilgamesh. The latter predates the former by a good thousand years or more, going back to at least the period of an actual king named Gilgamesh who had ruled a kingdom of Uruk in ancient Sumeria at around 2700 B.C.E.

(before current era) but was written down on clay tablets only at around 2000 B.C.E. which were discovered only fairly recently in the libraries of King Ashurbanipal, who ruled around 700 B.C.E. by a young British museum curator named George Smith back in 1872 and translated even much later (Mitchell 4). It is a story considered as the oldest-ever written story but what is even more remarkable is that it is very similar to Noah's Ark, especially the story about an immortal named Utnapishtim and a massive flood in his time.

There are also many other similar stories about a great deluge in other cultures, namely that of the massive waters released by the Greek god Zeus, the Chinese version of a deluge in the great central river valley of the mighty Yangtze and the Indian story of Manu mentioned in ancient Sanskrit religious texts dating back to around 600 B.C.E. These stories have a familiar theme, the futility of fighting against the force of Nature or the powers of God although the themes may vary a bit, depending on context (History-world.org 1). Provenance – as stated earlier, the exact or precise origins of these flood stories defy even scholars and historians because of the passage of extremely long periods of time, dating back to antiquity itself.

Based only on fragmentary records, with many pieces of evidence lacking, the best that can be done is make a conjecture or an approximation of their origins. It believed that the Epic of Gilgamesh is actually a literary masterpiece constructed by several authors and not just one writer, the story embellished with each successive re-telling. In many instances, the similarities between the Noahic story and Gilgamesh made historians surmise it was actually copied and translated into Hebrew by Moses circa 1450 B.C.E.

and the Israelites brought

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ancient Flood Stories (Problems for Critical Scholarship) Essay”, n.d.)
Ancient Flood Stories (Problems for Critical Scholarship) Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1459280-what-problems-do-the-flood-stories-present-to
(Ancient Flood Stories (Problems for Critical Scholarship) Essay)
Ancient Flood Stories (Problems for Critical Scholarship) Essay. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1459280-what-problems-do-the-flood-stories-present-to.
“Ancient Flood Stories (Problems for Critical Scholarship) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1459280-what-problems-do-the-flood-stories-present-to.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ancient Flood Stories (Problems for Critical Scholarship)

Champagne Scholarship letter

It is therefore that I am applying for the Champagne scholarship. Your scholarship will help me attain a degree beyond my vocational certificate.... This scholarship will allow me to continue studying as a full-time student. I am a United States citizen and I am an independent student under the U.... Itis therefore that I am applying for the Champagne scholarship.... Your scholarship will help me attain a degree beyond my vocational certificate....
1 Pages (250 words) Scholarship Essay

Why I Deserve This Scholarship

The scholarship essay entitled "Why I Deserve This scholarship" demonstrates reasons why the author deserves to have one.... These prompted me to seek this scholarship.... It would be a happy blessing if I would be able to win this scholarship.... Be rest assured that this is not only for my personal gain, but this scholarship would also pave way for me to serve my country in a more efficient and quality-oriented manner....
1 Pages (250 words) Scholarship Essay

Applying for International Scholarship

A thorny path of knowledge gaining would Solbridge International School of Business Master of Business Administration (MBA) 2nd year, 3rd semester ID: 05046 scholarship: to be or not to beMy Dear Solbridge International School of Business!... It means that I could not react properly at once and did not appreciate my scholarship.... Now I see that my scholarship is your trust and your hope for me....
1 Pages (250 words) Scholarship Essay

Request for Scholarship from local businesses

I have a 14 year old XXX (Enter postal address here) of contact person (Position) of office or scholarship foundation) (Postal address)3 August 2012Subject: Request for ScholarshipDear Sir / Madam;As one of the hard working and honest citizens of this great country, I would like to be given an opportunity to help shape the future of our nation as one of its foremost medical practitioners .... It is with this intention that I humbly come before you with a request that your office consider me for a scholarship....
1 Pages (250 words) Scholarship Essay

Union County College Scholarship

The scholarship essay titled "Union County College scholarship" presents Thank You Letter.... I would like to thank you for the scholarship grant for the year 2012-2013.... Therefore I believe this qualifies me for the scholarship.... I would also like to have my scholarship extended for three years.... This scholarship will help me be able to pay my tuition fees to be able to complete my academics....
1 Pages (250 words) Scholarship Essay

The Real Estate Scholarship

The author of the paper under the title 'The Real Estate scholarship' focuses on majors in real estate and his graduation which will be completed in 2016.... Additionally, I am looking forward for this scholarship as it will allow me to polish my competent abilities required in this field.... At present time, I have insufficient funds available for carrying out my education and this scholarship will allow me to move ahead in my lucrative career....
1 Pages (250 words) Scholarship Essay

Scholarship Award Issues

scholarship Award I guess I would have to say that I did not come to choose my major by accident.... I would not have been in a financial position to actively pursue these socially conscious ambitions of mine without the help of this scholarship grant as the education that I am pursuing comes at a very steep price that is not affordable to many college students....
1 Pages (250 words) Scholarship Essay

Why Do I Need VWF Scholarship

The essay “Why Do I Need VWF scholarship?... nbsp;  The VWF scholarship Application Essay.... My application to the scholarship is therefore influenced by a strong desire for knowledge and attainment of future career goals.... In conclusion therefore, I believe the VWF scholarship program will greatly contribute to my attainment of the career goals of being a global business manager, successfully leading in the global business environment and hence influencing policy in the corporate world so as address the immediate problems affecting society....
1 Pages (250 words) Scholarship Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us