StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Raymond Fanchers Francis Galton and Phrenology - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The "Raymond Fanchers Francis Galton and Phrenology" paper examines Gillham's look at Galton and his early work on eugenics, Galton's 'Hereditary talent and character, and Bulmer's Book on Galton as a Groundbreaking Scientist on Biometry and Heredity…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
Raymond Fanchers Francis Galton and Phrenology
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Raymond Fanchers Francis Galton and Phrenology"

Fancher on Galton Table of Contents a) Research Preparation 3 A. Answers to Questions 3 B. Results of Conduct of Internet Search 4 b)Discussion 4 A. Biography and General Discussion 4 B. Fancher on Galton 7 References 9 a) Research Preparation A. Answers to Questions 1) Raymond Fanchers Francis Galton and Phrenology The article looks at Galton’s attitude towards phrenology. Fancher considers the contradictions between his disdain for it on the one hand, and his use of it in the early part of his work on heredity. The article basically posits that there are contradictions between the latter attitude toward phrenology, and Galtons early adoption of key concepts from that field (Fancher, 1993). 2) Gillhams Look at Galton and His Early Work on Eugenics The article looks at the life of Galton and focuses on his work related to the science of eugenics. His work on heredity receives special treatment. The article establishes Galtons seminal work as having substantial impact on the course of development of eugenics as a scientific and academic discipline (Gillham, 2001). 3) Bulmers Book on Galton as a Groundbreaking Scientist on Biometry and Heredity The book contains a biography of Francis Galton. It also discusses in the main the development of Galton’s thinking and theorizing relating to biometry and heredity. It is partly biography and partly a discussion of the work of Galton relative to the disciplines (Bulmer, 2003). 4) Galtons Hereditary Talent and Character The article posits that the traits and characteristics of individuals are born out of heredity, where those individuals inherit their characteristics from their parents. Similarly, Galton makes the case for so-called mental qualities or intelligence. He refers to intelligence as talent and character, which can be traced to heredity (Galton, 1865). B. Results of Conduct of Internet Search 1) History of Psychology Blog: Tredouxs Critique of Fancher on Galton Regarding Galtons Ethnographic Work The article evaluates Fancher’s look at the ethnography of Galton, and makes observations about how much emphasis Fancher has given to the merits of Galton’s scientific work on the matter. The article makes several observations relating to Fancher’s use of the biography of Galton to explain the roots of his disdain towards other races in Africa, among others (Tredoux, 2004). 2) History of Psychology Website: Fancher on Galtons Literary Style The writer looks at the literary merits of the work of Galton. Fancher makes the conclusion that though the content is objectionable in parts, Galton’s contributions to making ideas popular through his writing are real, and worth commending. Within he criticizes some of Galtons prescriptions, including those against the over-creation of new scientific terms, which Fancher deems as essential to new science writing (Fancher, n.d.). b) Discussion A. Biography and General Discussion The impact of the work of Sir Francis Galton is said to be wide-ranging and profound, extending from eugenics and human genetics, of which he is recognized as one of the foremost pioneers, to travel writing and exploration, meteorology and the anticyclone, statistical formulations relating to correlation and regression, and biometrics. In the biometrics field he is recognized as the founding father, with his work on fingerprints, for instance, cited as one of the foundational, seminal texts on the science. It is noteworthy that the two phases of his career, one traveling and writing and the interest in meteorology to get a better grasp of the weather’s whims; and the other focusing on his work relating to selective breeding, which arose out of his intent focus on the work of Darwin entitled ‘The Origin of Species. Tied to his data analysis relating to this latter interest, Galton progressed into creating some of the statistical analyses that were necessary to make sense of the data, including correlation analysis and regression analysis. While astoundingly broad by contemporary scientific standards, the ability of scientists to venture into many fields was said to be something that was ordinary and accepted during the time of Galton’s life, which is tied to the Victorian era. Further examples of his brilliant work include those that are tied to his interests with the ideas proposed by Darwin in “The Origin of Species’, including his work on how fitness can be inherited, making use of human body measurements, twin/double studies, and pedigrees. He made use of mental imagery as a proxy of mental ability, taking off from the idea that intelligence and mental fitness had a correlation with the physical characteristics that allowed men to thrive. Mental imagery, as Galton practiced it, entailed making use of criteria to screen and analyze fingerprints, as well as photos of men from the criminal and military branches of society, and creating images that are composites of men that share the same socio-economic backgrounds for instance, or occupational class (Gillham, 2001, pp. 83-86). Francis Galton was born on February 16, 1822 and died on January 17, 1911, a few years after the publication of his last works ‘Memories of Life’ and ‘Essays in Eugenics’, and four years after the death of his wife Louisa Butler Galton in 1897. He was in Cambridge, at Trinity College, from 1840-1844, where he studied Mathematics, and had prior to that had education in medicine from 1838-1840. The death of his father in 1844 prompted Galton to abandon his medical studies, and the year after that, Galton went on to explore Africa in a life-altering move that had great impact on the future intellectual life of Galton. His journeys in Africa and the Far East precipitated his first works ‘Tropical South Africa’ and ‘The Art of Travel’, sandwiched between those being his marriage to Louisa Butler. Between 1855, when ‘The Art of Travel’ first appeared, to his death in 1911, the landmark events of Galton’s life were the publication of ‘Hereditary Genius’ in 1869; ‘English Men of Science: Their Nature and Nurture’ in 1874; ‘Inquiries Into Human Faculty and Its Development’ in 1883; ‘Natural Inheritance’ in 1889; and ‘Finger Prints’ in 1892’, plus the last two works immediately prior to his death in 1911, as discussed above (Bulmer, 2003, p. xiii). The influence of Darwin in Galton’s life was crucial in the development of the intellectual life of Galton. It was Darwin, for instance, who was able to sway the father of Galton to let Galton study mathematics at Cambridge, as a break from Galton’s medical studies. It was Darwin too, as Galton’s cousin, who exerted considerable influence on Galton in the latter part of Galton’s life, through his work ‘On the Origin of Species’, which propelled Galton into his own theorizing and scientific and technical work (Gillham, 2001, pp. 86-87). By way of example, His seminal work on heredity and genius was in full display and development by 1869, with the publication of ‘Hereditary Genius’, and an earlier work that appeared in MacMillan’s Magazine in 1865 already showed marked signs of the maturity of his theorizing (Galton, 1865). The main thesis of his work ‘Hereditary Genius’, meanwhile, was that the natural abilities that are possessed by individuals spring from inherited characteristics, again taking off from the lasting imprint of Darwin’s ideas on his own intellectual work (Galton, 1869). B. Fancher on Galton Fancher’s work on Galton extends to several key aspects of the life and work of the man. There are the works by Fancher on Galton relating to Galton’s ethnography during the time of Galton’s sojourns into Africa (Tredoux, 2004). There are the works by Fancher relating to the aspects of Galton’s work as literary and scientific stylist artifacts, to be studied as such rather than for just strictly for the science that it contains (Fancher, n.d.). There are also the aspects of the work of Fancher on Galton relating to Galton’s phrenology and the wide import of that work on vital aspects of the science (Fancher, n.d. (b); Fancher, 1993). Always, and as already discussed earlier, Fancher on Galton is largely about shedding light on the work of the man from the personal circumstances of Galton’s unique biography and psycho-social and emotional makeup (Tredoux, 2004). Fancher’s treatment of the literary elements of Galton’s scientific work, for instance, is one that reflects a dichotomy with regard to Fancher’s attitudes towards Galton’s work in general. As far as content is concerned, Fancher was largely critical of the work of Galton, and criticized the content on many different levels. As far as style and literary merits were concerned, on the other hand, Fancher was all praises, and in agreement with those who gave Galton literary distinction and ascension into the Royal Society of Literature in Britain. On the other hand, based on the standards of the modern era, Fancher makes the assertion that Galton’s work fails to make the literary and scientific form grade, when Galton for instance makes the statement relating to the limiting of the use of scientific terms in writing. This latter prescription, according to Fancher, goes against the impulse from scientists then and later to introduce new terms to describe what they were thinking and doing, and to expand the scientific vocabulary. This, meanwhile, does not take away from the very real contributions of Galton in this regard, according to Fancher, and that Galton is to be credited with giving birth to, and making popular, new ideas (Fancher, n.d.). There are aspects of the work by Fancher on Galton, meanwhile, that deal directly with the science and the theorizing in Galton’s work, including Fancher tracing the development of some of Galton’s key ideas in ‘Hereditary Genius’ to Galton’s exposure to and use of aspects of work relating to phrenology. Here, for instance, Fancher notes that while Galton, in his later life, made mincemeat of phrenology as a science and disowned it entirely, Galton actually had favorable earlier views of phrenology, and leveraged insights from phrenology to benefit Galton’s own work on heredity (Fancher, n.d. (b); Fancher, 1993). References Bulmer, M. (2003). Francis Galton: Pioneer of Heredity and Biometry. JHU Press. Retrieved from Google Books http://books.google.com Fancher, R. (n.d.). Francis Galton as a Literary and Scientific Stylist. York University. Retrieved from http://htpprints.yorku.ca/archive/00000129/00/galton_as_stylist.html Fancher, R. (n.d.(b)). Francis Galton and Phrenology. York University. Retrieved from http://htpprints.yorku.ca/archive/00000121/00/Galton_and_phrenology.html Fancher, R. (1993). Francis Galton and Phrenology. Proceedings Tennet !V. Retrieved from http://htpprints.yorku.ca/archive/00000121/00/Galton_and_phrenology.html Galton, F. (1865). Hereditary Talent and Character. MacMillan Magazine 12. Retrieved from http://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Galton/talent.htm Galton, F. (1869). Hereditary Genius. MacMillan and Company. Retrieved from Google Books http://books.google.com Gillham, N. (2001). Sir Francis Galton and the Birth of Eugenics. Annual Review of Genetics 35. Retrieved from http://www.tc.umn.edu/~nydic001/docs/teaching/Fall2011_PSY3801H/readings/Readings%20-%2001Gillham%202001.pdf Tredoux, G. (2004). Fancher on Galton’s Ethnography. Galton.org. Retrieved from http://galton.org/reviews/FancherGaltonEthnography.htm WW Norton and Company (2012). Raymond E. Fancher. wwnorton.com. Retrieved from http://books.wwnorton.com/books/Author.aspx?id=10901 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Assignment part one Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1605143-assignment-part-one
(Assignment Part One Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 1)
https://studentshare.org/psychology/1605143-assignment-part-one.
“Assignment Part One Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1605143-assignment-part-one.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Raymond Fanchers Francis Galton and Phrenology

The Great Psychologist: Francis Galton

"The Great Psychologist: francis galton" paper focuses on Sir francis galton who had a myriad of professions, among them geneticist, psychologist, statistician, eugenicist, and meteorologist.... francis galton was a myriad of professions, among them geneticist, psychologist, statistician, eugenicist, and meteorologist.... galton's true passion, however, was studying variations in human ability.... The numerous publications galton made evidence of the real urge of educating and promoting a well-informed population....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

A History of Eugenics as It Pertains to Intelligence Testing

2006)During the days in which the work of galton was most widely accepted, schools tested children regularly, and those classified as feeble-minded were rewarded by veritable incarceration in an institution similar to Massachusetts Fernald school for the feeble-minded -- or to one of the more than 100 institutions like it....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Francher on galton

It does not come by surprise that the podcast author argues History of Psychology; Galton's Contribution It is evident from Francher's podcast that francis galton is one of the most successful early psychologists.... francis galton: and eugenics today.... odcast, it can be argued that galton was a genius of the early 18th century considering the overwhelming contribution to other fields of science such as anthropology, meteorology, genetics, and statistics among others....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Pioneers of Psychology by Raymond Fancher

The paper "Pioneers of Psychology by raymond Fancher" states that the modern-day psychologist may find the book an important tutoring tool.... In addition, the book may be recommended to any other person with the urge of learning the history and origin of psychology.... .... ... ...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Theoretician and the Experimenter - Eugenics and Francis Galton

This paper "The Theoretician and the Experimenter - Eugenics and francis galton" focuses on the fact that F.... Cowan (509) has described the work of francis galton as 'science stimulated by political theories and directed toward social goals.... galton is considered as the father of Eugenics, which is a fictitious science that believes that human intellect can be engineered to improve the genetic characteristics of the human race.... Waller has called galton, a scientific careerist who believed in the 'heritability of intelligence'....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Raymond Carver Stories

The paper "raymond Carver Stories" provides a biography review of one of the considered leaders of what many refer to as the 'American Renaissance' raymond Carver.... It was only until the late 70s and early 80s when this genre was revived, thanks, in part to the genius that raymond Carver was.... raymond Carver did whatever he had to do to survive, including working as a janitor, sawmill laborer, and library assistant before eventually moving to California where his writing career began....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

David Finchers House of Cards

Season Two began with Zoe's murder at the hands of francis Underwood.... The author of this book review "David Fincher's House of Cards" describes the main aspects of this drama.... This paper outlines the technique of foreshadowing, plotting, and characterization of personages.... ...
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Mark Twain Debunked Phrenology

The paper "Mark Twain Debunked phrenology" describes that Twain likened the readings to palmistry; he later indicates how the readings were different after he went for a second reading.... phrenology's only success is that it helped researchers to focus their attention on the localization of functions of the brain.... In the article, Snaring the Fowler; Mark Twain Debunks phrenology, we find that Lorenzo Niles Fowler had gained celebrity status by reading people's minds using phrenology....
1 Pages (250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us