StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning" discusses that the stages of moral development in Kohlberg’s theory tend to go with age. The first two stages of reasoning are most evident in children of the youngest age and as the stages progress so does the age of the individual,…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning"

Kohlberg’s theory of moral development

Lawrence Kohlberg's theory was a modification and expansion of Jean Piaget’s work. It forms a theory that explains the development of moral reasoning. While Piaget’s work described two processes of moral development, Kohlberg’s work has six stages that are in three levels. Kohlberg’s mainly proposed that development is a continuous process that takes place throughout one's life and it only stops at death. He carried out his research using “The Heinz Dilemma” scenario on children of different ages (Jorgensen, 2006).
The stages of reasoning are:
1. Pre-conventional Morality
• Stage one- Obedience and Punishment
This is the earliest stage of moral development and is mostly exhibited by young children although it can also be observed in some adults. This is whereby a child sees rules as fixed. Obedience comes as a duty to mainly escape being punished.
• Stage two- Individualism and Exchange
In this stage of moral development children judge their actions based on how their individual needs are served.

2. Convectional morality
• Stage three- Interpersonal Relationships
The main emphasis in this stage is conformity. Moral development lays focus on social expectations and roles (J.Welsh, Nix, Blair, Bierman, & Nelson, 2010). Choices are made based on how they will affect relationships with others.
• Stage four- Maintaining Social Order
This is the stage whereby people are entirely out to maintain social order by following the law and authorities.
3. Post Conventional Morality
• Stage five- Social Contract and Individual Rights
At this stage, people account for the values of others. Whereas the law is still there, people agree on some of the customs
• Stage six- Universal Principles
These are the universal ethical principles. People follow these principles which are internalized even if they are in contrast with the rules and law.
Carol Gilligan’s theory of moral development
She is a critic of Kohlberg’s theory and calls it male-centered. Therefore, she proposes a stage theory of moral development for women (Raman & Winer, 2004). Her theory is mainly based on the ethics of caring. Gilligan provides that there is a right place for impartiality, a universal principle, and that mature morality consists of a complex interaction between impartiality concerns and the concerns of personal relationships and care (Jorgensen, 2006). She noted that while girls are more inclined towards caring, boys are inclined towards justice.

Gilligan’s theory of moral development involves three levels:
1) Orientation to individual survival
In this stage, the self is the sole object of concern.
2) Goodness is equal to self-sacrifice
The main concern is others rather than self and also self-sacrifice.
3) Morality of nonviolence
In this stage it’s where the individual needs are uncovered but with the ability to balance with those of others.
Kohlberg’s moral development theory is more focused on the approach used in reasoning rather than on whether the choice that Jane makes is right or wrong. It is concerned with moral reasoning. Kohlberg’s main concern lay in what is just and one's obligations (Haidt, Koller, & Dias, 1993). Each level and stage provides a different basis for decision-making. Gilligan’s moral development theory on the other hand puts more focus on how gender affects moral development. Her theory is concerned with the effects of care on moral concerns.
According to Kohlberg’s theory, Jane’s decision would greatly be influenced by age. Each stage of this theory takes place at a certain age. In stage one; Jane would focus on her parent's rule not to buy the toy. This would be to avoid punishment. In stage two; she would be mainly concerned with her individual need. Therefore she would buy the toy since it is what she wants. In stage three; Jane would be concerned with meeting the social expectations. To be branded a good girl, she would return the money to the owner. In stage four; Jane’s concern would be to maintain social order and law by following the laid rules. Therefore she would give the money back to the owner. In stages five and six, she may feel justified to spend the money on the toy since the standards and the internalized principles vary.

Moreover, the occurrences in the stages of this theory are more universal and are similar in most cultures. The instilled principles in children tend to be similar in most cultures with similarities in rules and laws. Hence, the stage of Jane’s reasoning will depend on her age.
Based on Gilligan’s theory, in the first level, Jane would keep the money since her needs would be the main focus. On the second and third levels, however, Jane would return the money to maintain social order. However, based on her wish to have a toy, we would assume that Jane is just a young girl of maybe ten years and she would henceforth keep the money and buy her desired toy. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning sent sample paper with instructions Term”, n.d.)
Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning sent sample paper with instructions Term. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1599632-moral-dilemmas-and-moral-reasoning-sent-sample-paper-with-instructions
(Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning Sent Sample Paper With Instructions Term)
Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning Sent Sample Paper With Instructions Term. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1599632-moral-dilemmas-and-moral-reasoning-sent-sample-paper-with-instructions.
“Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning Sent Sample Paper With Instructions Term”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1599632-moral-dilemmas-and-moral-reasoning-sent-sample-paper-with-instructions.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning

Adapting Kohlberg to Enhance the Assessment of Managers Moral Reasoning

In the article,James Weber presents a conceptual adaptation of Lawrence Kohlberg's Standard Issue Scoring method and the Moral Judgment Interview emphasizing on the six stages of moral reasoning .... Adapting Kohlberg to Enhance the Assessment of Managers' moral reasoning.... Introduction In the article “Adapting Kohlberg to enhance the assessment of Managers' moral reasoning”, James Weber presents a conceptual adaptation of Lawrence Kohlberg's Standard Issue Scoring method and the Moral Judgment Interview emphasizing on the six stages of moral reasoning (Weber 294)....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

James Weber and Kohlbergs theory

This paper 'James Weber and Kohlberg's theory' intends to review on the facts laid down by James Weber on his article, Adapting Kohlberg in Assessment of a Manager's moral reasoning, to establish if the suggested methods are relevant in decision making process.... ohlberg's theory on assessment of managers' moral reasoning uses hypothetical situations when testing the practicability of the theory, which has several advantages such as; they can be easily understood by a wide range of people of different ages and classes, the hypothetical situation seeks to utilize their highest stage of moral reasoning since people do not often use their moral reasoning to the fullest....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

What Exactly Is a Moral Dilemma

(moral dilemmas and moral Ambiguity)What are the ethical issues involved in this case?... moral dilemmas can also arise when, for one, a competent adult patient refuses treatment on religious grounds, when the patient is incompetent, and his wishes are never expressed when the patient had expressed the wish to withhold treatment before he became incompetent, and the parent who decides to withhold treatment on behalf of her child.... (Issues in Bioethics, ethical dilemmas in biology and medicine) Doctors are faced all the time with moral dilemmas, and as far as Western medicine is concerned, the doctor-patient relationship gives rise to the 'principle of not doing any harm' or what is known as 'non-malfeasance'....
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

Are Reason and Emotion Equally Necessary in Justifying Moral Decisions

In considering dilemmas, defined as 'scenarios constructed to highlight a conflict between two moral principles', individuals engage in moral reasoning.... ohlberg based his work on this theory of cognitive development and emphasized reasoning as the key to moral development.... asing on a vast amount of evidence gathered from structured interviews, Kohlberg's rationalist model views moral judgments as primarily caused by complex reasoning.... Emotions also surface in moral dilemma situations without arising from the options themselves....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Moral Dilemmas: Kants Moral Theory

"moral dilemmas: Kant's Moral Theory" paper argues that dealing with a moral conflict can be a challenging prospect if not well dealt with since it involves choosing between two equally disagreeable things and that all the options, in this case, are mostly unpleasant.... In defining moral dilemmas, Kant's moral theory is seen as deontological whereby a person's actions are morally upright in terms of virtues of the individual's motives.... igorous application of similar methods towards this reasoning would result in equal success while dealing with moral philosophy problems....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Personal Cultures: Nursing Professional Moral Compass

The application of ethical or moral reasoning depends on individual consideration of ethics.... I am bound by spiritual reasoning to ensure that the patients receive due care in both primary and secondary care.... This essay "Personal Cultures: Nursing Professional moral Compass" is about a tool that evaluates the inner being of a person as far as ethics is concerned.... Religious views play an important role when I am faced with ethical dilemmas....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Process of Moral Decision

here were several experiments in which participants listened to stories, describing certain moral dilemmas—those who faced these dilemmas committed obscene deeds.... On the other hand, Kant states that moral judgment may be made through reasoning only.... The paper 'The Process of moral Decision' presents a moral decision that has always been a difficult thing to make.... That is why the mechanism of moral decision making is really interesting to analyze....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Business Ethical Dilemma

moral choices are unavoidable in business.... Using Jones construct of moral intensity (1991) helps in the assessment of the context in which a moral decision is made.... An ethical dilemma arises where moral, principles or values come into conflict.... Ethics refers to the system of moral guidelines that apply values and judgment in the field of business.... Business ethical dilemma relates to a type of behavior by entrepreneur where moral values that are used have the potential to become a problem....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us