StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Effect of Context Difference to Comprehension and Recall - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper used three groups for context differences: no-context, context-before, and context-after to test its effect on comprehension and recall. This is to find out whether knowledge of the title or the subject prior to exposure to the material influences comprehension. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
The Effect of Context Difference to Comprehension and Recall
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Effect of Context Difference to Comprehension and Recall"

 The Effect of Context Difference to Comprehension and Recall Abstract Research evidence suggests that context has an effect at the encoding stage hereby assisting recall at the retrieval stage. Patterned after Bransford and Johnston (1972), this study used three groups for context differences: no-context, context-before, and context-after to test its effect on comprehension and recall. Context-before group had the highest mean of responses; T-test showed negative values both in recall and comprehension; comprehension and recall were positively correlated in all groups in Spearman’s rho where context-before had positively significant correlation at the 0.01 level. Results showed that the group in which context was given before reading the passage had performed better in comprehension and recall than the two groups in which no difference on recall was found and that comprehension and recall is significantly correlated when context was given prior to the introduction of material. Introduction Read the following as quickly as possible and see if the passage makes sense. The procedure is really quite simple.  First, you arrange things into different groups depending on their makeup.  Of course, one pile may be sufficient depending on how much there is to do.  If you have to go somewhere else due to lack of facilities that is the next step, otherwise you are pretty well set.  It is important not to overdo any particular endeavor.  That is, it is better to do too few things at once than too many.  In the short run this may not seem important, but complications from doing too many can easily arise.  A mistake can be expensive as well.  The manipulation of the appropriate mechanisms should be self-explanatory, and we need not dwell on it here.  At first the whole procedure will seem complicated.  Soon, however, it will become just another facet of life.  It is difficult to foresee any end to this task in the immediate future, but then one never can tell. (Bransford & Johnston, 1972, p. 722.) Bransford and Johnston used this passage in their study of comprehension and recall. Two groups of subjects listened to the passage, and were asked to understand and remember it.  One group was made to listen to this passage right away while the second group was informed beforehand that the passage was about washing clothes.  Bransford and Johnston found that people in the second group were much better at understanding and remembering the passage than those in the first group.  The first group had no context in which to incorporate the passage; the second group could readily integrate it into their prior knowledge of washing clothes. Prior knowledge is a factor in comprehending a material at the encoding stage. Integrating context to a base of knowledge allows comprehension thereby promoting recall at the retrieval stage (Bransford & Johnston, 1972; Dooling & Lachman, 1971; Stern, Dahlgren, & Gaffney, 1991). Within these context, this study used three groups for context differences: no-context, context-before, and context-after to test its effect on comprehension and recall. This is to find out whether knowledge of the title or the subject prior to exposure to the material influences comprehension. It also explored the effect of integration of context to previous knowledge in recalling information. A correlation between comprehension and recall was also being considered. Method Participants The study utilized the class of one hundred (108) 1st year psychology students from ARU as respondents. The students were randomly assigned to form three groups. Materials: The same passage from Bransford & Johnston (1972, p. 722) was used. A Recall Checklist which contains 12 essential data units from the passage was then employed to score the experiment. Design: The design type between subjects was used to test the effect of context difference: no-context, context-before, and context-after to comprehension and recall of material. Procedure: The class was randomly split into three groups. Though all participants read the same passage of text, they differ in context condition. One group received no background information about the passage at all (‘no context’ group). The other two groups were told that the passage was about washing clothes, but one group received the information before reading the passage (‘context before’ group), the other after reading the passage but before recall (‘context after’ group). Results To score, respondents worked in pairs and scored one another’s work using the Recall Checklist that contains the list of twelve (12) essential idea units from the passage. Marking was done either objectively or subjectively. Objective mark was done by awarding a mark for every ‘unit’ reproduced exactly in the participant’s recall sheet. Subjective marking accepted responses, which reveal that the participant recalled the meaning of a phrase but not the exact words in the passage. T-test on independent samples and spearman’s rho correlation at 0.01 (two-tailed) significance on comprehension and recall were employed. T-test values were found to be negative both in recall (-4.145) and comprehension (-4.771). As shown in table 1, recall and comprehension was found to have a not significant negative correlation both in no-context (-0.270) and context-after (-0.215) groups but was found to be significantly positive in context-before (0.486). Table 1. Spearman’s Rho Correlation of recall and comprehension in all groups Groups Correlation Coefficient (at 0.01level; 2-tailed) No-context -0.270 Context-before 0.486 (significant) Context-after -0.215 The mean of the responses was computed in each group and the standard deviation as well to give an overview of the distribution of responses in terms of comprehension rating and idea units recalled. As shown in table 2, the group responses were almost uniformly distributed but context-before group had the highest mean response both in recall and comprehension. Table 2. Mean responses of each group in recall and comprehension Groups Recall Comprehension Mean No-context 2.81 2.61 Context-before 4.42 4.28 Context-after 2.75 3.39 SD No-context 1.60 1.34 Context-before 1.70 1.61 Context-after 1.20 1.60 Overall Mean 3.32 3.43 Overall SD 1.69 1.65 Results showed that the group in which context was given before reading the passage had performed better in comprehension and recall than the two groups in which no difference on recall was found as shown in figure 1. Discussion The study has the following results. Responses showed that the context-before group in comprehension has the highest mean with the value of 4.42 while the two groups—no-context and context-after has 2.81 and 2.75 respectively. This shows that that comprehension is enhanced by context as prior knowledge. The same result was also apparent with the recall units. Spearman’s rho analysis showed that comprehension and recall are significantly correlated when context was given prior to the introduction of material. Results showed that the group in which context was given before reading the passage had performed better in comprehension and recall than the two groups in which no difference on recall was found and that comprehension and recall is significantly correlated when context was given prior to the introduction of material. This result is consistent with hypothesis & background work. To make it more generalizable, more passages should be developed for inclusion in the material and subjects of passage should cover wide range of interest Context given before exposure to a material serves as a cue of prior knowledge promoting comprehension and recall. Comprehension and recall is positively and significantly correlated with each other when context was given before the material is reviewed. References Bransford and Johnson (1972). Contextual prerequisites for understanding.  Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 11, 717-726) Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Effect of Context Difference to Comprehension and Recall Research Paper, n.d.)
The Effect of Context Difference to Comprehension and Recall Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1546303-psychology-report-memory-for-text
(The Effect of Context Difference to Comprehension and Recall Research Paper)
The Effect of Context Difference to Comprehension and Recall Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1546303-psychology-report-memory-for-text.
“The Effect of Context Difference to Comprehension and Recall Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1546303-psychology-report-memory-for-text.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Effect of Context Difference to Comprehension and Recall

Determining the Effectiveness of Graphic Organizers

What is an academic performance difference that is provided by the graphic organizers?... However, some difference such as adding the cloze-type sentences, for which matrix provides its base, are included to in the SSFA concept.... Cognitive Mapping Cognitive mapping facilitates developing significant ideas and relationships by employing arrows, spatial arrangements and lines with an aim of evaluating and understanding a particular text, context structure or a relationship between different concepts (Darch & Eaves, 1986)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

How Everyday And Laboratory-Based Research Works To Ensure The Latter Is Not Sterile

It employs the use of cue words as a starting point to trigger the recall of a related memory (McDermott et al.... This essay "How Everyday And Laboratory-Based Research Works To Ensure The Latter Is Not Sterile" claims that although laboratory-based research methods guarantee precision and control, the results acquired usually fail to reflect the multitude of variables that affect memory in real-life settings....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Divided Attention in Psychology

Divided attention has a long history.... Psychologists believe that consciousness can only get directed on one activity at a time.... Historically, conscious awareness between two activities is only… Through tests, investigators aimed at exploring the limits of consciousness through multitasking experiments....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Do Different Music Tempos Affect the Performance of Students

For instance, a study by Furnham & Stephenson (2007) found that lullaby-like, or soft music had the effect of improving people's cognitive ability and that high tempo or more upbeat music has the effect of decreasing people's cognitive ability.... In that research by Furnham and Stephenson (2007), 118 elementary level students were given four different tasks, which entailed free recall, mental arithmetic, reading comprehension, and verbal reasoning, to complete....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Proposal

Effects of Abstract and Concrete Total Recall on Undergraduate Students

  The aim of this paper determines the effects that concrete and abstract words had on total recall among participants.... A recall test was administered.... The result was such that, the difference in recall between concrete and abstract words was statistically significant.... The recall records were then scored and a t-test was carried out.... The recall of concrete words was found to be superior to that of abstract words....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Children with Learning Disability: Theory, Concept and Learning Programs

Other learning difficulties identified by IDEA include listening difficulty, verbal language, reading skills and fluency, reading comprehension, and so on.... The term “special” means “settings developed for 'other' children based on the premise that their difference requires specialist treatment in a segregated setting” (Thomas & Loxley, 2001 as cited in Nind, Flewitt, & Payler, 2011, p....
18 Pages (4500 words) Literature review

Cognition in Self and Religion

hellip; A comparison of the two empirical domains is difficult due to their difference in the level of closeness to an individual.... This term paper "Cognition in Self and Religion" presents an argument in support of the influence of both evolutionary and cultural factors on self and religion empirical domains with more effect on religion.... More effect on religion is because it comes as a by-product of cognition evolution to other traits....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Frontal Aging Hypothesis in the Context of Cognitive Aging

the effect of age on the efficiency of working memory has been reviewed comparing with other studies relating working memory and aging.... Thus, the findings of different studies are useful in estimating the effect of aging on the brain especially in frontal regions.... As the disruption of central control processes might result in impairment of relevant behaviour, the effect of age on central control processes is a significant factor that estimates the disruption....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us