StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Children as Vulnerable Witnesses - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay “Children as Vulnerable Witnesses” examines why children are considered vulnerable witnesses when providing evidence in legal proceedings. The Criminal Evidence Act defines vulnerable witnesses as all child witnesses who are under the age of eighteen years…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Children as Vulnerable Witnesses
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Children as Vulnerable Witnesses"

Children as Vulnerable Witnesses Introduction Providing evidence in a courtroom can be a hard task or even a torturous experience for many people. Several factors contribute to the physical discomfort experienced by a witness. These include the unfamiliar environment, the manner in which the legal process is carried out and the disputative and hostile nature of trials. It is virtually impossible for some people to undergo such difficult processes due to the nature of the case, their age and cultural backgrounds. Such individuals are referred to as vulnerable witnesses because they require special assistance and resources to provide satisfactory evidence (Judicial Studies Board, 2008). When children are required to provide evidence, they are as considered vulnerable witnesses. This essay examines why children are considered vulnerable witnesses when providing evidence in legal proceedings. It is vital to first define the term vulnerable witnesses, in a bid to understand its appropriateness when discussing children who are required to give evidence. Section sixteen of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999, defines vulnerable witnesses as all child witnesses who are under the age of eighteen years. The Act continues to state that witnesses who have physical disabilities or may be suffering from mental disorders or impaired intelligence are also considered vulnerable witnesses as these shortcomings may potentially diminish the quality of evidence (Judd and Peachey, 2013). The court has to take into account whether a witness would like to be considered as a vulnerable witness. This is quite essential especially in cases where a disabled witness would not like to feel intimated (Maffei, 2012). When it comes to children, precautionary measures need to be taken because of their unfledged intellectual ability, which limits their ability to make sound decisions (Smith and Tilney, 2007). As indicated in the introduction, intense legal proceedings or trials can result into traumatic experiences for witnesses. Asking a child witness to recall events that involved perpetration of horrendous crimes would trigger memories, which could be detrimental to the child (Legal Policy Division, 2011). Such cases could involve sexual ordeals where counseling programmes would be required to help the child cope with the situation. Children have fragile minds. It would be considered insensitive for a court to allow such a fragile mind to undergo grilling in a courtroom full of people and the perpetrators of the crime. Therefore, children are rightfully considered vulnerable as their minds are fragile and cannot handle excessive trauma. Children require guidance, as they are less conversant with many legal procedures compared to adults. This means that it is appropriate for the court to consider child witnesses as vulnerable witnesses because they are not fully aware of matters happening around them. Proper guidance provided by their parents, guardians and the court officials should be provided to ensure that the right procedures are followed. Take a case where a twelve-year-old child who is supposed to give evidence on a domestic feud that turned into a homicide (Luchjenbroers and Aldridge, 2008). The child is not aware of the legal proceedings and what is expected of him or her in the courtroom. It would be unfair to treat such a witness in a manner similar to that of an adult witness. The child witness, therefore, should be considered a vulnerable witness. Vulnerable witnesses are offered special preparations before they are allowed to testify. This assists them to cope physical and emotionally with the outcome of the trial. Child witnesses are offered the training, as they require support from their parents, family member or close acquaintances. Children find it easier to cope with certain situations when people who are closely related, provide assistance. This shows that children are indeed vulnerable and without support, they can easily crumble (Crown Prosecution Service, 2011). It is their right to receive the necessary preparations before and after a trial to ensure that they feel comfortable and move on with life. This further supports the need for children to be considered vulnerable witnesses. Pre-trial preparations also assist the vulnerable witnesses in providing complete and accurate evidence. These exercises ensure that the evidence given by the vulnerable witnesses can easily be considered by the court. Child witnesses need this exercise as it helps improve the quality of evidence. When child witnesses make an appearance in court, they are easily frightened and can end up providing inadmissible evidence. Video recorded interviews and live feeds are used during court sessions to limit alterations in the evidence. The court is required to consider if the child witnesses are in a position to give complete, coherent and accurate testimony to ensure a fair trial to the defendant (Aldridge and Luchjenbroers, 2008). Conclusion Children are seen to have difficulties when differentiating between the truth and a lie. This leads to the assumption that the evidence they provided is incompetent, therefore, inadmissible. However, some special cases require that children provide evidence and with the right guidance, the exercise is carried out successfully (Burton, Evans, and Sanders, (2006). Children have fragile minds that can easily be traumatized when subjected to courtroom proceedings (Maffei, 2012). Therefore, there is need to provide the essential and sensitive surrounding that offers the exceptional requirements and predispositions of every child witness in a court complex (Sharp and Ross, 2008). The aggravated emotional agony, physical and mental limitations that children experience compared to adults is enough to prove that they deserve consideration as vulnerable witnesses when faced with legal proceedings. References Aldridge, M., & Luchjenbroers, J. (2008). Vulnerable witnesses and problems of portrayal: A consideration of videotaped police interviews in child rape cases. Journal of English Linguistics, 36(3), 266-284. Berwickshire News (2010, August 25). Witness support volunteers needed. (Berwick upon Tweed, England), 17. Burton, M., Evans, R. and Sanders, A. (2006). Are special measures for vulnerable and intimidated witnesses working? Evidence from the criminal justice agencies. Home Office Online Report, 50-65. Crown Prosecution Service. (2011). Vulnerable and intimidated witnesses: A police service guide, Ministry of Justice, Daily Post (2006, May 9). Vulnerable given mobile phone link to the police; Help for witnesses and violence victims. (Liverpool, England), 14. Judd, T. & Peachey, P. (2013). Vulnerable witnesses to pre-record testimony to avoid trauma in Court. Retrieved October 24, 2013, from http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/vulnerable-witnesses-to-prerecord-testimony-to-avoid-trauma-in-court-8652998.html Judicial Studies Board. (2008). Guidance for District Judges (Magistrates’ Courts), Magistrates and Legal Advisors on Child and other Vulnerable Witnesses. Judicial Studies Board: London Legal Policy Division. (2011). Review of Vulnerable Witness Legislation. Department of Justice: Darwin. Luchjenbroers, J., & Aldridge, M. (2008). ‘Language And Vulnerable Witnesses Across Legal Contexts: Introduction To The Special Issue.’ Journal of English Linguistics, 36(3), 191-194. Maffei, S. (2012). The right to confrontation in Europe absent, anonymous and vulnerable witnesses. Groningen: Europa Law Publishing. Sharp, L., & Ross, M. L. (2008). The vulnerable witnesses (Scotland) Act 2004. Dundee: Dundee University Press. Smith, K., & Tilney, S. (2007). Vulnerable adult and child witnesses. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Children as Vulnerable Witnesses Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1488633-discuss-the-evidence-for-children-being-considered
(Children As Vulnerable Witnesses Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/psychology/1488633-discuss-the-evidence-for-children-being-considered.
“Children As Vulnerable Witnesses Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1488633-discuss-the-evidence-for-children-being-considered.
  • Cited: 2 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Children as Vulnerable Witnesses

Blood Transfusions for Jehovahs Witness Children

The insistence of Jehovahs Witness parents on refusing blood transfusions for their children during the course of medical treatment raises a dilemma for the State on the appropriate level of intervention in family and religious life.... The State The insistence of Jehovahs Witness parents in refusing blood transfusions for their children can be viewed in the larger context of alternative religious beliefs and their effect on medical treatment.... Whilst adults have the right to refuse medical treatment, their behavior becomes controversial when they refuse medical treatment for their ill children (Catalano, 2010, p....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

The Act of Parliament, Children Act 2004

This essay will discuss The children Act 2004 and the Every Child Matters (ECM) policy to see what improvements, if any have been made since the last Act, and whether the Act is working or not.... This act was formulated to appoint a regular commissioner for children and establish… The reason for writing this essay is to provide an analysis for the performance of the children Act 2004 and ECM.... I am affiliated with the prestigious Social Services Department and I feel obligated to It would be convenient to talk about the background of children Act 2004 before moving forward towards its analysis....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Eyewitness Testimony of Children

The greatest concern regarding childhood eyewitnesses is that their memory of the events may be vulnerable to outside influence.... This paper "Eyewitness Testimony of children" discusses a childhood eyewitness's dependence that holds significance legally and psychologically.... The researches provided in this paper help with the obtaining of accurate information from children, without pressuring them in any way.... Research shows that younger children give less reliant accounts of events....
11 Pages (2750 words) Literature review

Criminal Proceedings for Young People in England

In contrast, Children can become involved in the criminal justice delivery process as witnesses.... From the questioning by police investigators to the final appearance in the courtroom the process of giving evidence for the crime can be hallowing for young witnesses.... Over time the governments of England and Wales have developed a policy that addresses the unique challenges involved in ensuring justice prevails for youth offenders and witnesses alike....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

The Interview Process

It is expected that witnesses of violent crimes or witnesses who are also the victims of the violent crime or sexual abuse, may be suffering from stress which leads to the repression of the memory (Pozzulo, 2007).... he witness may also suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder that inhibits the witnesses from recalling explicit memory details....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

The Impact and Possible Effects of Witnessing Domestic Violence as a Child

Children who witness domestic violence are vulnerable to developing different kinds of age-dependent negative influences.... million children in America experienced domestic violence annually (Carlson, 1984).... Similar psychological effects may be noticed in children who are abused and children who witness abuse being done to someone else.... These children may experience a range of such internalized behaviors as depression and anxiety, as well as different kinds of externalized behaviors like bullying, cheating, lying, and fighting....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Law of Evidence Issues

Thus, in this instance, although the children may not be compellable, the Court may be able to call for them to be witnesses, by allowing them special protection when they are doing so.... rdquo;10, which is one of those offenses where witnesses can be compelled.... he prosecution can call upon all the witnesses – Nisha, Sunita, and the two children to testify, including making Nisha a compellable witness, while Indira's competence can also be established....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Effects of Domestic Violence on Children

Statistics reveal that 10 to 20 percent of children remain vulnerable to risks as they belong to families that experience domestic violence.... This coursework " Effects of Domestic Violence on children" describes domestic violence as a form of child abuse.... This paper looks at the various negative effects of domestic violence on children, factors determining the effects, the relationship between childhood trauma and domestic violence....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us