StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Political Economy And the Coming Anarchy - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
In this article, the author argues that the depletion of resources such as water, the immigration of youths from villages, and an increase in the number of shanty towns within the developing countries of the world would increase sectarian and ethnic tensions…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
Political Economy And the Coming Anarchy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Political Economy And the Coming Anarchy"

Summary of the Authors Thesis and Main Arguments: In this article, the author argues that the depletion of resources such as water, the immigration of youths from villages, and an increase in the number of shanty towns within the developing countries of the world would increase sectarian and ethnic tensions. Kaplan further denotes that this would in turn create a condition necessary for a breakdown in the domestic political environment, and the transformation of war to a variety of irregular forms. On this note, Kaplan argues that this situation is not different from terrorism. Furthermore, the article gives a prediction on the security problems that will become an issue during the 21st century1. Kaplan identifies environmental problems such as pollution, and global warming, as well as the erosion of national borders of various states, as the major security issues that states in the 21st century will have to face. This article also talks about political instability that is brought forth because of poor governance. He identifies countries such as Sierra Leone, which experiences civil war because of poverty, and poor governance. Furthermore, Kaplan effectively talks about the problems of insecurity in West Africa, and the causes of this insecurity2. He identifies poverty as the main cause of insecurity in Western Africa. Kaplan also talks about Turkey, and predicts a rise of an Islamic state in Turkey, and other places of the world. In this paper, Kaplan is a critique of the Islamic religion, denoting that it is associated with poor people, who are badly urbanized, and they are willing to use violence as a means of achieving their objectives. Furthermore, Kaplan talks about racial division in United States, and wrongfully gave a prediction that it would escalate during the 21st century3. Persuasion of the Theorist: This paper is very persuasive in nature, and this is because he uses real life examples to bring out the various points that he wishes to communicate. For example, when he begins talking about the problems of West Africa, he uses a case study example of Sierra Leone, and what is happening in the country regarding political instability and governance. In explaining the problems of Sierra Leone, Kaplan manages to give the views of a Sierra Leone minister, and to identify some of the rebel leaders who were causing havoc in Sierra Leone4. For instance, he identifies Captain Valentine Strasser as one of the leading rebel leader, and he was able to usurp power. The use of examples is always effective in persuading a reader, and this is because the reader will manage to understand and believe the information passed. Use of examples is an easy way of passing information or message concerning a situation. Kaplan also uses dialogue to explain his points, and this is the dialogue that he has between the minister and himself5. Kaplan gets first hand information from an African leader who is aware of the problems facing the continent. People are likely to believe an individual who has experienced the problem, as opposed to an individual who does not have any experience to the problem. Readers will most likely believe the information that emanates from the minister, and this is because the information is real, and without bias. Interviews are very important methods of data collection, and on most occasions they are reliable, since the information provided emanates from a professional or a person who experienced the problem under consideration. Furthermore, while giving out his explanations on the problems of West Africa, and other regions of the world, Kaplan manages to deeply describe the problem and its effects. For instance, he manages to describe how the conflict in Sierra Leone managed to internally displace over 400,000 citizens of Sierra Leone, and also an external displacement of over one million people to different countries6. He identifies these countries by name, and gives out the figures of Sierra Leonean refugees they took. Based on this style of writing, this article is very persuasive. Threats, Challenges, and opportunities: In his description of threats, Kaplan manages to identify the erosion of the borders of countries, as well as environmental issues as the major threats that faces the international community in the 21st century. When talking about the environment, Kaplan denotes that the diminishing natural resources will greatly affect the security of the international system, and this is because people and nations will start fighting over the scarce natural resources. Examples include, the ever growing population, deforestation, soil erosion, air pollution, spread of diseases, as well as water depletion are challenges that will exist in the 21st century, and which have the capability of inciting group conflict. On the other hand, erosion of national borders will also be a great threat to security, and this is because it would lead to an influx of criminals and extremist groups within a particular country. The rise of radical Islamic groups, particularly in Asia is another threat described. For instance, Kaplan correctly predicted the rise of an Islamic political state in Turkey, and other nations of the world7. Islam is a threat to the security of the nation, because of the radicalized groups that emanate from this religion. On this basis, the challenge that government over the world would face is on how to develop a policy that would protect their natural resources, as well as their borders from infiltration by criminal organizations. However, there are a variety of opportunities that third world countries, as well as western countries face. One such opportunity is the rise of information technology, which can help in the free flow transmission of information. Furthermore, opportunities of economic as well as political stability arise, in case dictatorial regimes are able to enact institutions that would promote good and better governance. Analysis of Future Operational Environment: This article is an important piece that can guide the future operational environment of the US military policy. For instance, this article identifies the various threats that would face the 21st century states. One such threat is the issue of porous borders. This is a reality, and porous borders have been seen all over the world. For example, in East Africa, the Kenyan Somali border is porous, and it usually facilitates the entry of terrorists within the country. These people in turn will target US interests and that of their allies8. Porous borders are also seen in Asia, America, especially the Mexican-American border, which is notorious for drug trafficking, etc. Furthermore, there is an aspect of environmental degradation, and depletion. Resources such as oil, minerals are increasing being scarce, and conflicts usually emanates from their use. Countries such as Southern Sudan and Nigeria are experiencing civil strife because of oil. Based on these factors, it is therefore necessary for the United States to deploy its forces in areas where it has interests such as the Kenyan-Somalia border, and in Nigeria for purposes of securing those areas. For instance, in securing the Kenyan-Somalia border, the US will manage to protect its interests, and on the other hand, when securing Nigerian oil resources, the US will manage to secure a major source of its energy. On this basis, the US forces should be deployed to secure vulnerable borders, which if breached are a threat to its security, as well as to secure resources that are essential for its economic growth9. Furthermore, the type of enemy that United States is likely to face, is a radicalized Islamic faithful. This is a person who strongly believes that the best way to articulate their interest is through violence and terrorism. This is mainly because of the US support to Israel, which makes it an enemy to Islamic radical groups. However, there are a variety of issues that might limit effective military operations against these enemies of the US. For example, radicalized Islamic groups normally use terror as a means of articulating their demands. Terrorism is an example of unconventional warfare, and it is always a difficult war to fight. This is because it is difficult to know who a terrorist is, and who is not. On this basis, there is a need of the US to collaborate with various countries of the world, in order to fight this terrorism. However, some countries might be unwilling to cooperate, limiting the ability of the US to collect intelligence, and fight this war. On this basis, suspicions on the intentions of the US is one of the major factors responsible creating the complexity of these military operations. Bibliography: Besteman, Catherine. "Political Economy And Robert Kaplan In Africa: A Comment On "The Coming Anarchy"." PoLAR: Political html_ent glyph="@amp;" ascii=""/ Legal Anthropology Review 23, no. 1 (2000): 25-32. Kaplan, Robert D.. The coming anarchy: how scarcity, crime, overpopulation, tribalism, and disease are rapidly destroying the social fabric of our planet. Boston, Mass.: Atlantic Monthly, 1994. Williams, Paul D. D.. Security Studies an Introduction.. 2nd ed. Hoboken: Taylor and Francis, 2012. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Political Economy And the Coming Anarchy Assignment, n.d.)
Political Economy And the Coming Anarchy Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1644370-theorist-critique-assignment
(Political Economy And the Coming Anarchy Assignment)
Political Economy And the Coming Anarchy Assignment. https://studentshare.org/politics/1644370-theorist-critique-assignment.
“Political Economy And the Coming Anarchy Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1644370-theorist-critique-assignment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Political Economy And the Coming Anarchy

Structure And Anarchy

In theory and logic it is relatively easy to show that structure and leadership are more effective than anarchy and consensus in getting things done.... In historical experience, however, there is a good argument to be made that movements have made their greatest accomplishments at times when formal leadership and structure have been least important, and anarchy and consensus most prevalent.... "anarchy means without government, which is different forms of vertically organized, i....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Theory of International Politics by Kenneth Waltz

?? Therefore Waltz's central theory of neorealism in international politics is underpinned by Waltz's proposition that the system of international politics is inherently dependent on a system of anarchy.... This system of anarchy according to Waltz effectively creates the international order of hierarchy, which is further defined by states who are unitary rational actors on the one hand and rational actors on the other.... To this end, Waltz's discussion of the Cold War, highlights his propensity towards viewing the international political order from a systemic perspective as opposed to considering the intentions of individual states and human behaviour, which is arguably the inherent weakness of the book in context of contemporary international politics....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Neorealism and the international order

Seeking to address how realism, a positivistic theory of international relations, explains the international order despite the condition of anarchy in the international system following the demise of the Soviet Union in 1991, this essay will explore state interest and behavior.... Realism is as an explanatory theory of international relations which provides what are arguably the strongest definitions of what constitutes state interest, state behavior and the establishment of the international order....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Industrial Policy in the Middle East and North Africa

The paper 'Industrial Policy in the Middle East and North Africa' presents oil which is one of the primary exports and natural resources of the Middle East, and the distribution of it has proved to be determinative of quite a lot of elements of Middle Eastern politics and international relations....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Quebec Tuition Hikes from Three Perspectives

This discussion, Quebec Tuition Hikes from Three Perspectives, stresses that at the onset, the recent student protest over the proposed tuition fee increase indicates a social dissatisfaction on the educational system of Canada.... nbsp; The protest however is only an external manifestation....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Comparative Economic Systems

Canada is an industrially developed country, and like the US it has market-oriented economy with high level of production.... Since the WWII, rapid growth of “manufacturing, mining and service sectors” (The World Factbook) have resulted in the country becoming an urban economy from earlier rural economy.... Trade agreements with the US have a great positive impact on Canada's trade and economy.... The 2008 global economic crisis badly affect the country's economy in the...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Kenneth Waltz and Robert Keohanes Opposing Theories of Cooperation Among States

The purpose of the paper is to investigate why Kenneth Waltz's theory does not predict cooperation among states, examine the reasons and conditions under which Robert Keohane's theory does predict that cooperation will take place; and identify and explain why one of the two accounts is empirically more accurate....
5 Pages (1250 words) Literature review

International Politics Concepts, Theories and Issues

Liberalism is a political concept that advocates for the freedom and rights of individuals.... This research is being carried out to examine the concept that there is no legitimate authority in the international system.... In answering this question, the researcher will have to use a variety of theories, such as realism and liberalism....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us