StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Balancing Stakeholders Interests In Case Of A Conflict - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The idea that commerce is about capitalizing on profits for shareholders is obsolete. The paper "Balancing Stakeholders Interests In Case Of A Conflict" seeks to argue out both stakeholders positions in case of conflicts arises that puts both the employees and owners on different sides of the ring…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Balancing Stakeholders Interests In Case Of A Conflict
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Balancing Stakeholders Interests In Case Of A Conflict"

Balancing Stakeholders Interests In Case Of A Conflict Abstract The year 2012 saw big names like General motors loose out in the big scheme of economics. This is the year that general motors both the Canadian and American sections suffer greatly. The fall to financial oblivion was so dire that they had to borrow from their government. Some sort of a bail out that would allow them to get access to public funds. The American government agreed without too much lobbying from the congress. However, the Canadian government needed to be courted just a little bit longer. For this to take effect it required that General motors sit down with the Canadian Workers Union and chat a way forward. The CAW accepted a wage freeze that would last three years approximately. Vacations would have to go for lesser time and employees would have to contribute higher towards their benefit plans. After several months of negotiations a concession was reached and both G.M. and its rival Chrysler were able to obtain government funds that would be sufficient to propel them back to profitability. In this paper I will try to argue out both stakeholders positions incase a conflict or conflicts arises that puts both the employees and owners on different sides of the ring. From the abstract what is clear is that the bail out necessitated that employees do most of the heavy lifting. Suffering wage cuts, taking shorter vacations while the owners who happen to also be external stakeholders do not seem to suffer that much. How then can the interest of employees and shareholders be balanced incase a conflict arises? To answer this question I will use Edward Freeman’s stakeholder’s theory to delve in depth into this issue pitting both moral responsibilities and profit maximization objectives of the business unit. Reasons Stakeholder hypothesis is a theory of executive management and trade ethics that deals with principles and values in running an organization. In the conventional view of the firm, the investor view, they are the proprietors of the company and the corporation has a compulsory duty to put their needs first, to boost value for them. Stakeholder conjecture fights that there are added parties involved, including workers, clientele, providers, investors, society, legislative bodies, political lobby groups, trade links, and unions. Even rivals are sometimes counted as stakeholders - their position being consequent from their aptitude to affect the company and its stakeholders. The nature of what is a stakeholder is extremely contested The stakeholder view of policy integrates equally a resource and a market based view, and adding up a socio-political stage. This outlook of the corporation is used to describe the precise stakeholders of a firm (the normative presumption (Donaldson) of stakeholder identification) mutually examines the conditions beneath which these parties ought to be treated as stakeholders (the expressive theory of owners salience). Objection I object that employees’ interest should not be taken into much consideration in this scenario as it is necessary when balancing the interests of all stakeholders. Justification If employees interests are taken into consideration G.M and Chrysler would not have gotten the funds both from the Canadian and Ontario governments. For the funds to be made available for the bail out CAW had to contend with several changes. However, these changes were temporary but necessary. Some of the changes included pay cuts up to 10%, shorter vacations and higher employee contribution towards their benefits. These changes would ensure continuity of the business and job security. Alternative theories to further explain my stand point Thomas and Preston dispute that the assumption has various distinct feature that are uniformly supportive: expressive, helpful, and normative. The expressive approach is used in study to explain the characteristics and behaviors of corporations, including how companies are run, how the panel of directors deems corporate constituencies, the way that executives think about administration, and the nature of the company itself. The influential approach uses experiential data to recognize the relations that subsist between the organization of stakeholder groups and the accomplishment of corporate goals (most normally abundance and efficiency goals). The normative advance, identified as the nucleus of the theory by Donaldson and Preston, scrutinizes the function of the business and identifies the "moral or theoretical guidelines for the process and running of the business. Mitchell, et al. obtain a typology of stakeholders founded on the features of power (the degree a party has wealth to impose its resolve in a rapport), legality (communally accepted and probable arrangements or behaviors), and importance (time criticality of the stakeholder's declarations). By examining the mixture of these traits in a double manner, 8 types of stakeholders are resultant alongside with their insinuations for the organization. Friedman explores the inferences of controversial relationships involving stakeholders and associations by bringing in well-matched/mismatched interests and essential/dependent connections as additional characteristics with which to inspect the design of these relations. Robert Allen Phillips differentiates between normatively genuine and derivatively valid stakeholders. Criticism The biased philosopher Charles Blattberg has condemned stakeholder hypothesis for presumptuous that the welfare of a variety of stakeholders can be, at best, conceited or balanced adjacent to each other. Blattberg argues that this is a creation of its importance on conciliations as the principal mode of conversation for dealing with disagreement between stakeholder welfare. He advocates discussion instead and this leads him to preserve what he calls a loyal beginning of the conglomerate as a substitute to that linked with stakeholder theory. Conclusion “Every trade creates, and now and again destroys, worth for customers, purveyors, workers, communities and investors. The idea that commerce is about capitalizing on profits for shareholders is obsolete and doesn’t work very sound, as the current worldwide fiscal crisis has educated us. The 21st Century is all about “management of stakeholders.” The duty of directors is to generate as much worth as realizable for stakeholders devoid of tradeoffs. Great corporations tolerate since they manage to put stakeholder wellbeing allied in the similar course.” In the conventional view of the company, the investor, the shareholders and stockholders are the proprietors of the corporation, and the firm has an obligatory pecuniary requirement to put their desires first, to amplify worth for them. However, stakeholder presumption disagrees: that there are other people involved, as well as legislative bodies, political groups, employment associations, trade union, society, investors, purveyors, workers, and clientele. Sometimes even players are considered as part and parcel of the organization their position being resulting from their ability to have an effect on the company and its other owners. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Argumentative essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 2”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1629740-argumentative-essay
(Argumentative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 2)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1629740-argumentative-essay.
“Argumentative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 2”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1629740-argumentative-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Balancing Stakeholders Interests In Case Of A Conflict

Conflict management (case)

conflict Management: Case Insert Institution's Name According to Osland et al, (2007), towards the end of the 1990s the relationship between the Celestial and Voila was terrible that they threatened not to support each other in business.... Not inviting them was thus aggravating the conflict.... As a result, communication, ideas and decision-making elements would be discussed between them; Cooperation between them would have avoided the conflict....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Dancing in a Winter Wonderland Managing Stakeholders

The stakeholder approach deals basically with groups or individuals who can affect the performance of an organization and whose interests are taken care of by the management (Freeman, 1984; Frooman 1999) Power, legitimacy and urgency are identified as the basic attributes of stakeholders (Mitchell et al 1997) The network approach talks about the positions of different actors created by the links among them.... A paper "Dancing in a Winter Wonderland Managing stakeholders" outlines that business and fun have been found to be originating from time immemorial....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Conflict of Interest

hellip; The said cousin does not have any public or government duty or responsibility and there exists no conflict of interest or character of possible bias and/or prejudice.... Riordan is a partner of Litteral & Finkel and the latter law firm is the retained outside counsel of Riordan Manufacturing does not constitute any conflict of interest nor does it pose some possibility of bias or prejudice as will be contrary to public interest, public policy or public order....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Rolls-Royce Corporations Project Management Stakeholders

The paper "Rolls-Royce Corporations Project Management stakeholders" states that for the poor countries, creative financing schemes can be made available for them, like barter (part cash and part payment in kind, such as mining or agricultural commodities).... hellip; What keeps all stakeholders together is open, timely and accurate information as it is now considered a necessary prerequisite for corporate success because not only goods and services are exchanged in return for money but also developing the enduring type of stakeholder relationships built on trust and loyalty (O'Gorman & Pirner 89)....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

#3 - Stakeholder Analysis and Engagement Plan

Finally, women and children who Company Analysis, case Study Topic:  #3 - Stakeholder Analysis and Engagement Plan The stakeholders includes The World Bank, non-governmental organizations, World Health Organization, health experts, women and children, as well as the government.... Appendix 1 below shows how the various stakeholders will be involved in strategic decision making....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Conflict of interest

The case of Captain James CoBell is yet another example of a military official crossing his limits, and using his influence for satisfying his pleasure.... The prevalence of conflict of interest in the conflict of Interest Military institutes across the globe share two common aspects, first they are to guard the borders, and the second thing common among these institutions is their tendency to use their influence illegally (Andersen, 2014).... The prevalence of conflict of interest in the military institutes of the United States has long history....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Strategic Positioning and Strategic Direction of CRH Plc

To have a more clear understanding of the strategic positioning and its analysis Michael Porter's Five Forces Model will be used in this discussion which helped in generalizing the strategies for gaining competitive advantages in the industry.... hellip; This research will begin with the statement that the Strategic positioning of an organization is done with a purpose to find the best fit for the organization with respect to its external environment....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Environmental Impact Assessment for the Forth Replacement Crossing Project

… The paper "Environmental Impact Assessment For The Forth Replacement Crossing Project" is a great example of a case study on environmental studies.... The paper "Environmental Impact Assessment For The Forth Replacement Crossing Project" is a great example of a case study on environmental studies....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us