Adornos Criticisms of Television - Article Example

According to him, “Enlightenment is a Myth and Enlightenment reverts to Mythology”. The criticism more or less conveys the same meaning as critiques made by Adorno.

The most powerful claim and argument placed by Mr Robin Collingwood were “art is an attempt to achieve beauty”. According to him physical transformation and appearance are not beauty but art, inner self, purity of heart, and sculpture is important which define beauty. And the one or the thing which looks beautiful is a sublime i-e looks beautiful, inspires you but then evaporates soon.

I will go with the second philosopher because Edmund Burke’s view was that the sublime and the beautiful are mutually exclusive. So Collingwood’s thought was much better. Beauty is when it rests in the hearts of the people watching or experiencing it and is not meant to evaporate or vanish as the ages fall.

Stories Homer and Iliad have marked effects on public opinions and shaping ancient Greek values. The reason why Iliad has so much admiration among the ancient’s Greek is that it is an epic poem, which means it was used to speak narrative of “elevated matters”. Plato also put forward an instruction or an alternative view of poetry as well.

Aristotle was steeped in Homeric tradition and saw another side which Plato failed to recognize and analyze. He construed more positively the role of mimesis in art opposite of Plato and sees more positivity in Homer’s stories in the shaping of Greek culture and values.

Robin G. Collingwood has expressed his views in the words that the stories of Homer and Iliad have failed to empathize properly, with the historical actors or comprehend their behaviour accurately in their terms. He also said that they have failed to elucidate the past and they were only used to condemn it.

The views of Aristotle were best as they were analyzed by Aristotle after considering both negative and positive aspects. And though he continued to build on Plato’s views and art still he took Homer’s work differently and positively.