StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Is David Hume's argument against William Paley here a strong one - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Hume’s first argument against Paley is presented in the lines, “if any agent S believes that the order and complexity in some object O strongly points to design, then that is because S has had direct experiences of objects that resemble O and which have been produced by…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Is David Humes argument against William Paley here a strong one
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Is David Hume's argument against William Paley here a strong one"

Task Hume’s first argument against Paley is presented in the lines, “if any agent S believes that the order and complexity in some object O strongly points to design, then that is because S has had direct experiences of objects that resemble O and which have been produced by design” (Pojman and Vaughn).This argument against Paley cannot be considered a strong argument because of several factors, the first factor being that other designers like Edison came up with new ideas. According to Hume’s argument, there was no possibility that an individual would encounter something made out of design and fail to relate it to another object made out of design.

From the evidence of inventors who developed new ideas, this argument is flawed because there would be no logical design that the inventors had encountered before designing their inventions. This indicates that Hume’s argument was based on ignorance; there was no way that he would know that new designs would be invented; designs that would negate his argument.Hume’s argument is also flawed because of the apparent contradictions present in the argument itself. A summary of the argument indicates that Hume believed that an individual should only believe that an object is made from design if the individual had previously encountered similar design.

Therefore, the argument by Hume seems to indicate that an individual who had not encountered design should not attribute designs to the working of a designer. This argument means that Hume preempts the human mind; the argument tries to negate the working of the human mind in deducing the result of design.The other factor that indicates that Hume’s argument was a weak argument is in the design of the universe. Contrary to the biological argument presented by Hume, the universe is an infinite product of design.

This means that any human being can attribute the design of the universe to some supreme deity, a fact that Hume tries to negate in his argument. The anthology that an individual has to have experienced design in order to recognize other instances of design would serve to negate the possibility of a supreme deity who gives humans deductive ability. Therefore, the argument by Hume can be considered weak because of its structural failures and the proposition.The fact there exists unique designs in the universe is also proof that Hume’s argument was not strong.

This is because design is the product of the intellect, creativity, and innovativeness. Hume’s argument seems to propose that design is born of previous design; a fact that would indicate that design cannot be created but just recreated. This means that Hume’s argument concludes that design is never new, just a variation of existing design. However, the universe is filled with many instances of new design, a fact that indicates the invalidity of Hume’s argument. In conclusion, it can be said that Hume’s first argument against the propositions of Paley is of no impact; the arguments are baseless and centered on ignorance.

After an analysis of the arguments presented by Hume and Paley, it seems that Hume did not actually understand the analogy presented by Paley, and instead thought of the universe in a singular manner. This means that Hume did not consider the existence of new design and a deity in the supreme order of the universe. Therefore, the conclusion is that Hume’s argument against Paley in this case is a weak argument.Work CitedPojman, Louis, and Vaughn, Lewis. Philosophy: The Quest for Truth. London: Oxford University Press. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is David Hume's argument against William Paley here a strong one Essay”, n.d.)
Is David Hume's argument against William Paley here a strong one Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1580539-is-david-humes-argument-against-william-paley-here-a-strong-one
(Is David Hume'S Argument Against William Paley Here a Strong One Essay)
Is David Hume'S Argument Against William Paley Here a Strong One Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1580539-is-david-humes-argument-against-william-paley-here-a-strong-one.
“Is David Hume'S Argument Against William Paley Here a Strong One Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1580539-is-david-humes-argument-against-william-paley-here-a-strong-one.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is David Hume's argument against William Paley here a strong one

Citing William Appes, Discuss His Bible Based Arguments against Racism

one of the most significant quotations from A Son of the Forest is the following one: “I felt convinced that Christ died for all mankind – that age, sect, color, country, or situation make no difference.... one cannot change the equality proclaimed by God.... If it is not done so, if one of skin colors is neglected, then, it means that the Lord died in vain.... His arguments are convincing and very strong....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Summarize William Paley's argument

Paley's Teleological Argument Derived From A Watch Examination william paley's narrative regarding a watch one may stumble upon while walking on the road yields several philosophical arguments that may lead to deeper implications and applications in one's life.... The discovery of the watch may seemingly be an innocent and simple activity, but Paley gets one to think much deeper than the surface.... While taking a leisurely walk and one finds a stone and a watch on the ground, an examiner may be curious about those objects....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

How persuasive are the design arguments

william paley in his book Natural Theology (1802) paralleled between the living things intricacy and subordinate intricacy of a surveillance that was created by an intelligent creature, as it was known.... paley underlined in his works that a watch could not become possible without the creator of this watch, thus it became clear that living creatures had no opportunity to exist without an intelligent creator.... paley states: “[S]uppose I found a watch upon the ground, and it should be inquired how the watch happened to be in that place, I should hardly think … that, for anything I knew, the watch might have always been there....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Compare David Hume's ideas

hume's argument is that assumptions of cause and effect between two correlations are not obviously true.... Comparison David Hume and Descartes Ideas david hume's excerpt “Of the origin of our ideas” David Hume was a famous Scottish philosopher widely known for his philosophical experimentation and uncertainty.... Comparison David Hume and Descartes Ideas david hume's excerpt “Of the origin of our ideas” David Hume was a famous Scottish philosopher widely known for his philosophical experimentation and uncertainty....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Outline the Arguments against Free Trade

This paper ''Outline the Arguments against Free Trade'' tells that The issue of free trade is one of the most controversial in the modern world.... nbsp; It is one of the most long-standing controversies in the world since the tide of globalization started to take root.... hellip; Free trade remains to be one of the most debatable issues of the 21st century.... In its simple definition, free trade can be said to be the art of existence of the free flow of goods, capital, and labour from one country to the other....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Strong Arguments In Dispute

The reader gets engrossed in the book as he aligns such evidence one after the other in various places.... He included simple questions like: “Name a sacred text of Hinduism”, and the student's answers showed “… only one in four could name a single Hindu scripture” (Prothero 196-197).... He adds further that one in three United States Christians can give the names of the gospels.... The reader gets engrossed in the book as he aligns such evidences one after the other in various places....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

On Miracles by David Hume

This paper gives information about David Hume's essay On Miracles which is a strong refutation of supernatural phenomena, often linked to divine intervention.... On Miracles by David Hume David Hume's essay On Miracles is a strong refutation of supernatural phenomena, often linked to divine intervention.... Since every religion claims its own set of miracles, the devotee to a religion believes in one set to the exclusion of the rest.... n my view, if I have to pick one flaw in the essay, it would be the element of circularity in one of the arguments....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Humes Posteriori Argument against Miracles is not Valid

"Hume's Posteriori argument against Miracles is not Valid" paper argues that although the first of Hume's three 'a posteriori argument succeeds in showing that there may be no miracle proofs, it doesn't show that there is not a sufficient probability for establishing our test case.... The 'a priori argument' argues that miracles are incredible events that cannot be believed because I) The testimonial evidence will never provide enough verification conclusively, that one has occurred (this is his main point), and 2) by a miracle's definition and principle (of violating natural law), it cannot be believed (a sub-point) (Spencer 99)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us