StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
This discussion talks that Physicalism, the philosophy built upon the premise that life, as we know it, centers upon or supervenes on physical matter. Mankind, as a very complex and much more than a physical being, can never be reduced to a mere definition of the physical aspects of existence…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.6% of users find it useful
The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang"

The Case Against PhysicalismBy Jacky ChangAbstract While there may be many strong arguments in favor of physicalism, it lacks much in fully expressing the human experience and journey. Life is relational and individual; based on both physical and non-physical things. Through the content of this document I will attempt to discuss some of the reasons why physicalism, in its reduction theory, does not adequately describe life as we know it. Physicalism, the philosophy built upon the premise that life, as we know it, centers upon or supervenes on physical matter.

However, mankind, as a very complex and much more than physical being, can never be reduced to a mere definition of the physical aspects of existence. While there are many arguments against physicalism, the largest and most consistent one seems to be that of consciousness, intellect, freedom of choice, and all the qualities that make a human being fully human.The physicalist reasoning relies too heavily on reduction thinking. They define physical as either being expressed in physical terms or else in the broad sense as being anything that is part of a physical system or process.

In this way, they reduce all beingness to a matter of physical nature. In fact, there are non-physical things. Alter(2005) uses Descartes’ argument, that phenomenal consciousness is not physical due to the fact that one can conceive of the body as well as the mind independently of each other, therefore, phenomenal consciousness is neither functional nor physical, to prove that we have a fully conscious mind and a fully present body.According to physicalists, all knowledge is a mental function of learning by processes involving the five senses.

How, then, can we account for human intuition, experiential knowledge and the sense of general knowingness that comes with the journey of life? According to Alter(2005), human intuition and knowingness are justifiable by reason alone, with no empirical evidence needed; we don’t intentionally learn everything, How does the physicalist account for freedom of choice? Melynk (2007) uses the argument that choice cannot be free as it refers to a causal agent or, in the case of theism, a supposed intentional agent that predesigned or had prior knowledge of that choice.

Yet, Goetz and Taliaferro(2007) argue that choice is not causal or determined, but rather a function of our conceptual and intentional qualities, which in reality are abstract forms and therefore non-physical objects.How can the qualities that make us fully human be explained in physicalist terms? Melnyk(2007) argues that humans have minds, are examples of mental properties, and go through mental processes as part of their functioning in the physical system; much the same as one of the physical functions of the heart muscle is to pump blood to the body.

By this, then, the mind has mental representations which generate not only the mental representation of the world around us, but also a representation of ourselves. The main problem with this is that it doesn’t take into account all the intricate nuances that comprise the human mind; it presupposes that all mental activity is therefore neural activity. Goetz and Taliaferro(2007) argue that not all human phenomena are dependent on neural activity. For example, a person acts in relation to his/her belief systems; whereas the physicalist believes that neural phenomena create human phenomena, or, your movements create your behavior.

In conclusion, we are both physical and non-physical in nature; therefore we can never be reduced to the sum total of our physical components and systems. The human experience is rich and full of unexplainable mysteries which will always push mankind for anwers.ReferencesAlter, T. The Knowledge Argument Against Physicalism. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 14 Nov. 2005. Web. 21 Nov. 2010. www.iep.utm.edu/know-arg/Gardner, T. A., PhD. Physicalism and Qualia. Perdue University, 2002. Proquest Learning and Information Company. 2010. Web. 21 Nov. 2010.

Goetz, S. Taliaferro,C. The Case Against Physicalism. Internet Infidels, Inc. 2007. Web. 21 Nov. 2010. www.infidels.org/library/modern/stewart_goetz/against-physicalism.html Melynk, A. A Case for Physicalism About the Humand Mind. Internet Infidels, Inc. 2007. Web. 21 Nov. 2010. www.infidels.org/library/modern/andrew_melynk/physicalism.html Stoljar, D. Physicalism. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy(Fall 2009). Edward N. Zalta(ed.). Web. 21 Nov. 2010. http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2009/entries/physicalism/

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang Assignment”, n.d.)
The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1573123-my-argument-against-physicalism
(The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang Assignment)
The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang Assignment. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1573123-my-argument-against-physicalism.
“The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1573123-my-argument-against-physicalism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang

The Case of Employee of Karen's Bank

This paper "the case of Employee of Karen's Bank" presents the case and advises Jack regarding the possibility of him avoiding the consequences of the contract he had with the bank.... The facts of the case are that Karen's import-export business had been experiencing cash flow difficulties and financial problems for some time, at least fifteen months with no improvement.... hellip; Jack, an employee of Karen's for five years, entered into a contract with Karen's bank to allow his flat to be used as security against the company's overdraft....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Ricky Gervais & Co Ltd Case

It seems from a close reading of the case study that the organisation is not being professionally run which is another causal factor for such behaviour by workers.... In attempting to fully analyse the given case study, it is imperative to highlight and explain the tort law and negligence in brief as a way of gaining a clear understanding of the applicability of the laws to the case.... Tort law can be described as a civil wrong not arising from a contract and in the case of negligence, one should owe due consideration to one's neighbour (Capiro Industries vs....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Job Satisfaction, Service Capability, and Customer Satisfaction

The company has ignored Bob and actions have not been taken against him.... This made him feel discontented and started causing serious delays case ONE The salary system of Joan's workplace is not efficient at all.... case THREE Jack Otto should introduce a policy of rewarding the exceptional employees, who keep time on arriving in the morning and employees who get along with other employees well.... ASE FIVEThis case illustrates lack of HR Planning in that it does not retain the highly skilled staff....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Magical Realism And Transformation Of Characters In Animated Films

Character transformation is effectively used throughout animated feature films to enhance the dynamics of the story.... The paper "Magical Realism And Transformation Of Characters In Animated Films" discusses the context of character transformation in fairy tale adaptation films.... hellip; The ultimate character's transformation is largely outlawed by the culminating scenes of the battle between “die Hexe” (the witch) and “der africanische Zauberer” (the African sorcerer)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

The Inconclusive Ethical Case against Manipulative Advertising

Similarly, the use of photo shopped models in the cosmetic The Inconclusive Ethical case against Manipulative Advertising Question Manipulative advertising is form of advertising thatfocuses on the positive side of a product only and never gives the negative aspect of the same product.... One of the strongest ethical argument against manipulative advertising is that it encourages advertisers to ignore targets well being while encouraging targets to neglect consumption of nonmarket good....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Heart of Change with reference to Jack Welch and GE

In such case, the organization needs to help an employee to align his individual goals with the organizational ones.... The paper takes into consideration such issues: “retooling” disempowering managers by giving them new jobs that show the need for the change; feedback that can help people make better vision related decisions; finding individuals with change experience who can bolster people's self-confidence....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

A Few Good Women at the Top: The China Case

However, those women who take courage and go ahead into it have stood up against people's expectations and proved better than their male counterparts are.... The culture of the china people is against this and has caused a lot of resistance in a bid not to allow women leadership.... In his book, women, and leadership, Klenke states that the most successful people are those that fight against opposition and so is the state of women leadership (Klenke, 1996, pg 27)....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Change in Contemporary China

… The paper "Change in Contemporary China" is a perfect example of a political case study.... The paper "Change in Contemporary China" is a perfect example of a political case study.... China has a long history of government system from Shang Dynasty in 1766-1122 BC to the Nationalist revolution of 1911 and the 1949 Communist revolution that has had an influence on modern-day China....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us