StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Which Way, Natural Selection or Intelligent Design - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper talks that the intelligent design argument refers to the negative approach to the natural forces at work as well as to the natural selection as an essential factor in bringing different forms of life that are observed by humans. An intelligent designer was the force behind everything. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Which Way, Natural Selection or Intelligent Design
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Which Way, Natural Selection or Intelligent Design"

Which Way, Natural Selection or Intelligent Design The intelligent design argument refers to the negative approach to the natural forces at work as well as to the natural selection as an essential factor in bringing different forms of life that are observed by humans. This argument postulates that an intelligent designer was the force behind everything that is observed today. Indeed, this argument further postulates that the appearance of organisms has no significant contribution to the survival success of the ancestors which is experienced in the natural selection. Indeed, the intelligent design was significant in bringing life in all the forms observed today very quickly as compared to the gradual process witnessed in the natural selection theory (Roderick 1). In the Charles Darwin’s evolution theory also referred to as the natural selection, it is stated that initially before their variability species had common ancestors, where the differences in organisms were attributed to adaptations to a wide range of environments. As such, environmental conditions played a part in identifying species that were deemed as the best suited to survive. In addition, traits of different organisms are passed on to the new generations. Given some time, the traits could easily lead to the appearance of a new species (Roderick 1). It should be noted that, the natural selection theory was formulated after a long study period involving the study of different animal as well as various plant samples where inferences derived from the analysis which indicated that organisms had similar as well as dissimilar characteristics. This paper seeks to explore the raging debate on the intelligent design versus the natural selection. With this in mind, the underlying facts behind each of the subjects are going to be analyzed; however, the final goal is to show what is more likely to be true: the natural selection theory or the intelligent design one. Considering the evidence laid down by both approaches I do conclude that the theory of evolution offers a better explanation of the variability in life forms. As such, I will look through simplicity and explanatory power as well as the predictive success of the two ideas. In terms of simplicity, the evolutionary theory wins the whole show. Looking from the position of the ontological complexity, the two ideas include the existence of the different forms of life, however, in the case with the intelligent design the designer and the material employed in the design have to be included (Muggy 1). In addition, a problem arises regarding the intelligent designer origin. Since, this creator has a greater capability and more complexity than even the capabilities of the current human beings. This poses a question, are humans supposed to be designed? However, in regards of the dynamic complexity of a human life, both theories tend to agree on the reproductive capabilities of all the organisms, though this is not very clear in the intelligent design theory. On the other hand, the natural selection implies that there is a biological process which accounts for the observed similarities amongst offsprings and their parent organisms (Roderick 1). Indeed, it is easier to believe this since this phenomenon can be observed in many of the organisms, this further implies that there should be a particular activity that allows such functioning. However, the intelligent design theory postulates the presence of the design processes which are outside of whatever goes on during the reproduction. In regards to the explanatory power, the evolutionary theory also takes the lead. Due to the fossil records, the gaps between the species are completed. Indeed, fossils point out at the transitional period which a particular organism passes to another state as indicated in the Charles Darwin theory. However, the intelligent design does not account for the transitional fossils, thus, with the discovery of more fossils, the weaknesses of the intelligent design are laid bare. By and large, the intelligent design argument on irreducible complexity, that is contrary to the evolution principle, does not explain the reason why some forms of life exhibit similar characteristics and some organisms have parts in common, but perform different duties. Indeed this gives support to the evolution theory (Roderick 1). For instance, the bacterial flagellum, has been postulated by the intelligence design as an organism having an irreducibly complexity motor. Indeed, its motor has the same characteristics as a syringe-like part that belongs to the bacterium Yersinia pestis since they make use of a similar protein type, but Yersinia lacks the required number of proteins needed for the motor. Thus, despite lacking these proteins its structure still functions as a vessel for carrying diseases such as the Bubonic plague. Considering this evidence, the motor is, thus, not an irreducibly complexity. Last, but not least, I believe that an evolution still carries the lead on the predictive success. The intelligent design offers no predictions. As such, the initial claim in regards to the designing of species as well as the silent reference to the implications of the design leaves nothing to test against. Whereas, in the case with the evolution there is a plethora of predictions where no scientific proofs have been found to be contradictory to the evolutionary approach during the past 150 years (Plotkin 77). Indeed, Darwin’s predictions of the fossil records have been proven true, and, today, modern genetics has proven the Darwin’s view concerning the common ancestry of apes and humans. In fact, all the observation and experiments done in modern genetics and/or molecular biology, have confirmed the authenticity of the evolution theory. Thus, it is worth mentioning that evolution is a better argument as it has a higher degree of predictability. Notably, I have a personal view that the fundamental beliefs held by the intelligent design group is a major threat to some values held in the society since such intelligence has the capability to turn a man into well-guided mass destructive weapons. Notably, the move has been greatly driven by some fundamental Christians meant to forcibly introduce their scientific creation theory into the mainstream schools in the US through their teachings of biology and astronomy as well as geology and cosmology (Ward & Brownlee 29). Indeed they view this as a substitute for the scientifically proven natural selection theory. Though I have little knowledge and power to be influential over the way of thinking of those who believe in the intelligent design as well as the Bible interpretation as the only source of truth I still keep to a contrary opinion. I also have to point out to those who conform to the ideals of the intelligent design, that they still hold that stand due to the inadequacy of information they have, which, thus, makes them be mentally incapacitated (Polanyi 1). I have to admit that a number of metaphysical questions concerning the early beginning of the universe, what lies in the universe, and the like are typically beyond the thinking of the man and are basically based on his/her understanding of the physical laws. It should be pointed out that in general physics and other sciences explain nothing about the existence of the creator inside the bounds of science. Indeed, sciences that try to explain the universe conform to the theory of the natural section since no evidence suggests the existence of a supernatural force that plays a part in shaping the world. In fact, discoveries in relativity, as well as quantum mechanics have led to great revolutions in the world of science, but still supernatural force wasn’t necessary in order to gather the pieces together within the self-consistent knowledge. In conclusion, when a person examines both theories on the basis of simplicity and explanatory power as well as predictive success, it remains clear that the natural selection theory trumps the idea presented by the intelligent design and demonstrates a more coherent as well as testable prediction that concerns the origin of species. Works Cited Muggy, Smike. A Debate: Natural Selection Versus Intelligent Design. Muggsy’s Brain, 8 Aug. 2010. Web.1May 2013. . Plotkin, Haman. Darwin Machine and Nature of Knowledge. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1994. Print. Polanyi, Michael. Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958. Print. Roderick, Kate. Intelligent Design versus Evolutionary Theory. University of Michigan Students of Objectivism, 19 Apr. 2008. Web. 1May 2013. . Ward, Peter D., & Donald Brownlee. Rare Earth: Why Complex Life is Uncommon in the Universe. New York: Copernicus Books, 2000. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Which Way, Natural Selection or Intelligent Design Essay”, n.d.)
Which Way, Natural Selection or Intelligent Design Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1476693-which-way-natural-selection-or-intelligent-design
(Which Way, Natural Selection or Intelligent Design Essay)
Which Way, Natural Selection or Intelligent Design Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1476693-which-way-natural-selection-or-intelligent-design.
“Which Way, Natural Selection or Intelligent Design Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1476693-which-way-natural-selection-or-intelligent-design.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Which Way, Natural Selection or Intelligent Design

Artificial Intelligence in Multimedia Production

The code evolves through the process of natural selection.... The code improves itself with each change in the natural selection.... Evolution precedes the ecosystems natural selection.... natural selection is represented by the competition of the different genotypes for energy (CPU time) and material (memory space) (Ackley & Littman, 1990).... Artificial intelligence in multimedia production Name: Instructor: Course: Data: Introduction Artificial intelligence an approach used to design intelligent agents....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Evolution intellegence design

Ever since Darwin proposed his theory for the origin of the species, a debate has raged in the scientific and religious communities about the authenticity of the origins of human beings from the biological processes of evolution and natural selection or the presence of an… In recent times, the idea of an ‘invisible hand' (which has religious and spiritual connotations) guiding the development of human beings and other animals has surfaced under the label of Intelligent Design Evolution and Intelligent Design Ever since Darwin proposed his theory for the origin of the species, a debate has raged in the scientific and religious communities about the authenticity of the origins of human beings from the biological processes of evolution and natural selection or the presence of an outside influence which guides the path of biological development....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Greatest Show on Earth by Richard Dawkins

The author refers to intelligent design in terms of the ways in which every kind of life on Earth is created through some kind of natural selection, which is explained through reference to research on the evolution of bacteria carried out by Lenski.... Dawkins has taken pains in claiming that intelligent design is a valid explanation for every aspect of nature, which is supported by the theory of evolution.... In presenting arguments that are impeccably constructed, the author has introduced the concept of natural selection by… Dawkins has argued that evolution is an acknowledged fact of life and for those who do not believe in evolution he has drawn parallels by giving examples of artificial selection, such as when people train dogs so that Dawkins makes the case that every form of life on this planet was created by way of non random natural selection, which in other words is understood as evolution (Ings, 2009)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Is Intelligent Design a Scientific Theory

The focus of the paper "Is intelligent design a Scientific Theory?... is on the Discovery Institute, political institution, the intelligent design, the scientific community, factual and conceptual flaws, creation of American creationists, conjecture or hypothesis, the principle of parsimony.... t is evident that intelligent design begins with forms of information, which are commonly observed to produce agents of intelligence in the real world....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Intelligent Design is it Science

In the paper “intelligent design is it Science?... rdquo; the author analyzes William Dembski's view of intelligent design, which signifies that the objects and beings in the universe are created by someone, who is superior to all.... hellip; Dembski believes that intelligent design is a science, which directs toward the different signs of intelligence for example, like Mount Rushmore.... intelligent design is it Science?...
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Explain and evaluate Bebe's teleological argument for the existence of God

A design argument is He was one of the proponents of intelligent design supporting the existence of God, Behe initially supported the scientific theory, however after studying Evolution by Michael Denton changed his mind and started to question the evolution theory.... He argued that such system could not even by any rule, have evolved by natural selection as proposed by Charles Darwin.... His other side is that the flagellum cannot be produced through natural selection operating on random mutation or other unclear process....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Nature of Mentality

aley's argument of the intelligent designer has similar reasoning when he presents an analogy of a watchmaker.... In nature, myriads of imperfections such as starvation, epidemics of diseases, natural calamities, suffering, child deaths exist since time immemorial....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Teleological Arguments for the Existence of God

When these two attributes are combined, they endow upon the watch a complexity in the functional sense that allows one to distinguish objects with and without intelligent design.... Also known as arguments from design, they deduce from the intelligent designs in the world proofs that the universe could not possibly have occurred by accident but it reflects the mind of a creator who needs must be God (Nolan).... Conversely, teleological arguments have proven more convincing; these are arguments that based their proof of God's existence on the fact that the universe is full of evidence of an intelligent creator....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us