StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Is there an afterlife and what would be required for an afterlife - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name: University: Course: Tutor: Date: Is there an afterlife and what would be required for an afterlife Personal identity is best looked on as “all that makes one who he or she is. (Baillie 1993).” In this case, it might be his/her body, mind, memories, personalities, or anything else…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Is there an afterlife and what would be required for an afterlife
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Is there an afterlife and what would be required for an afterlife"

Download file to see previous pages

Death has been considered the only certain thing in life. There is even consensus to the effect that a number of changes take place during the transition from life to death, which therefore follows that changes making up life are distinct from those making up survival. In distinguishing these two varying changes, we can give a number of personal identity criteria through time to explain death (Baillie, 1993). First, we can use a criterion that has been popularized by Hume, Plato and a multiplicity of world religions.

According to this criterion, human beings are either immaterial souls or even pure egos (Hume, 1739). This can be construed to mean that human beings possess the physical bodies only on a contingent basis and therefore not a necessity as far as living (in this life and the afterlife) is concerned. This being the case therefore, it is proper to argue that human being continues to live even after death. If anything their bodies are contingent and not necessarily a must-have in their living and especially their afterlife (Ayer, 2006).

The second criterion has to do with the claim that a human being has two distinct components namely a body and a mind. This criterion, the so-called Cartesian Dualism, named so in honor of Rene Descartes, claim that the two components namely, the material body and the immaterial mind are distinct and therefore can exist separately. In fact it goes on to claim that the immaterial mind can exist separately from the material body particularly when the material body dies. This idea has however failed to convince many people because of a number of obvious faults in the reasoning behind it.

For instance, is it logical for an immaterial mind to effect any change in a material body? This is the main problem that this idea has been unable to address, a problem that has since assumed the name “the problem of interactionism” (Levine, 1989). The reasons that Hume advance in arguing that death is survivable are convincing in whichever one looks at them. For instance, I am convinced that there must be another component that leaves the body to rot, otherwise what happened when a human being is resurrected by a supernatural being.

Does he/she resurrect with another body or the same body which at the time must have long decomposed. This clearly demonstrates just how probable a human being might possess a separate invisible component that is left behind after his/her fresh dies and subsequently decomposes (Jerome, 1966). In opposing the idea of an afterlife, Hume argues that every creature’s ability is always proportionate to the task ahead of it. This is best demonstrated in a Hare’s or an Antelope’s ability to out-run a fox or a Lion respectively.

It is also the reason why a Hare have not been equipped with the ability to appreciate Operas, which would be superfluous to its life. Given that a match between abilities and tasks has been found to cut across all creatures, it is reasonable to assume that we are also matched to the tasks before us (Hume & Sayre-McCord 2006). Looked in the context of our ‘design flaws’ as far as having the ability to anticipate an afterlife is concerned, one can only conclude that there is no afterlife. Look at the way we are normally less concerned with doing good for a reward in our afterlife. Look a

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is there an afterlife and what would be required for an afterlife Essay”, n.d.)
Is there an afterlife and what would be required for an afterlife Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1439692-is-there-an-afterlife-and-what-would-be-required
(Is There an Afterlife and What Would Be Required for an Afterlife Essay)
Is There an Afterlife and What Would Be Required for an Afterlife Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1439692-is-there-an-afterlife-and-what-would-be-required.
“Is There an Afterlife and What Would Be Required for an Afterlife Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1439692-is-there-an-afterlife-and-what-would-be-required.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is there an afterlife and what would be required for an afterlife

The Building of Egyptian Pyramids

From the paper "Egyptian Wonders of the Ancient World" it is clear that researchers and archaeologists have to piece the bigger picture from all aspects of the pyramids in order to understand the science and architecture for the reason why the Egyptians build such massive structures.... hellip; Egyptians also had a great understanding of astronomy....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Death and Dying, Rituals and Afterlife, Beliefs of the Ancient Greeks

The ancient Greek strongly believed that if the soul was not buried; then its entrance into the Hades would be compromised and thus the fundamental purpose of these rituals was extremely important to the future of the soul after death.... When an individual passed away, it would be his responsibility to direct the soul to the underworld (Obayashi 24-33).... The superstitions surrounding the Greek beliefs of the dead is quite an interesting issue to discuss for they were strongly religious and they designed certain concepts about human soul, afterlife and the taboos associated with death (Robben 34-46)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Dissertation

Life and Death: Mystery and Realism that Provokes Meaning

More importantly, the rituals are often believed to hold sway over the course of the soul into the afterlife which can create a deeper tragedy even than death when those rituals are denied to a loved one.... The essay "Life and Death: Mystery and Realism that Provokes Meaning" critically analyzes the human concept of life and its oppositional state of death as it is framed by the beliefs that create meaning through a ritual so that life and death are manageable ideas in the context of experience....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Different Religions and Cultures

Different religions and cultures have developed their own explanation as to what happens to a person when they die but majority of them share similar opinion that there is afterlife.... The afterlife is distinct to people according to their culture and religion.... The rationale behind the belief of afterlife needs the ability to view part of the self, which is the soul as having the ability to exist and live autonomously of the physical body....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Research about the realtionship between Mausoleum of the First Qin Emperor and the Great Wall

They really took time preparing for the afterlife and took with them all that they thought they might need in their next life after death.... The Emperor of Qin has always emphasized on his wealth and kingdom, so not only is the burial army represented as his guard of his kingdom afterlife but also the Great Wall, which supposed to prevent the Xiongnu from invading China.... Especially since Chinese emphasized so much on their afterlife.... We can see the Emperor of Qin has great plans for his afterlife or death for both of these constructions started building since he first became the King and was young (O'Connor 13)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

In the afterlife, will Leonard deserve punishment for the muders he committed in the flim The Momentum

The motion picture makes splendid use of non-linear storytelling, as well as photographic… It also raises profound questions about the nature of personhood and of moral culpability. Assuming an afterlife in which virtuous behavior is rewarded and evil behavior is punished, how ill Leonard For this essay, it means this: the willful, deliberate commission of a morally incorrect act.... Given this definition, what sort of acts would be excluded from it?...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Differences and Similarities between Christianity and Islam

In the paper “Differences and Similarities between Christianity and Islam” the author tries to understand the features of these two religions; he considers their attitudes to such five issues as the nature and the main characteristics of God, the role of the great preachers.... hellip; Considering the nature of God, Christianity focuses on the concept of the Trinity....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Pyramids at Giza

The article develops the assumption that pyramids at Giza matters for great amazement.... These structures, whose height is equivalent to a 50 story skyscraper, remain a specimen of architecture, testifying to social, political and spiritual concepts of its time in its construction and style.... hellip; The technical details of the Great Pyramid itself are a source of modern marvels....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us