StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Locke's Criticism on Descartes' Philosophy of Calling Extension the Essence of Body - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Locke’s criticism on Descartes’ philosophy of calling extension the essence of body Instructor Name December 5, 2011 Abstract Famous French philosopher Descartes presented his philosophy of mind-body dualism saying that mind & body are two mutually exclusive things & body is independent of thoughts…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful
Lockes Criticism on Descartes Philosophy of Calling Extension the Essence of Body
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Locke's Criticism on Descartes' Philosophy of Calling Extension the Essence of Body"

Download file to see previous pages

Our body is not the essence of anything like extension as this concept lessens the significance of human body. Our body is solid while extension is empty space, hence there is no match between these two. Locke’s criticism on Descartes’ philosophy of calling extension the essence of body Rene Descartes, a French philosopher come mathematician of sixteenth century, is unanimously called as 'Father of Modern Philosophy' & the Father of Cartesian Doctrine which describes the relation between body and mind.

"I think, therefore I am" is the most famous concept given by Descartes' about mind-body dualism. According to him, human beings are composed of two different things, body & soul or mind. The essence of soul (mind) is thought by which it controls the movements of body & the essence of body is extension. He argued that I can perceive my mind as an independent identity upon which there is no influence of extension (body) & I can distinctively perceive my body as a complete thing without the influence of my thoughts.

Thus God has made the two things independent of each other so they behave like distinct objects. Here, the idea of extension is not very clear, i.e., whether it describes our body as a combination of solid parts which are there to move or extend, or is there something else Descartes wanted to explain? The idea was contrary enough as it says that there is no particular connection or relation between body & soul & they are independent of each other. He tried to explain the idea but could not provide enough valid points & arguments to prove this.

One of his successors of seventeenth century, John Locke, an English philosopher, who is undoubtedly the philosopher of modern times & the originator of concepts like self & identity, presented his own theory of human understanding which is considered to be more authentic & reliable regarding the concepts of human identity & self. He contradicts Descartes’ Cartesian philosophy by saying that all human have innate ideas in their minds by birth & they acquire more knowledge through their vast experience & their individual use of senses & perception.

According to him, the essence of body is not extension but consciousness & mind is nothing but a blank slate on which anything can be written by acquiring knowledge & wisdom. Children & babies from their early stages of development & even during their gestation period acquire simple kind of knowledge like color & taste distinction etc. The child is not born with such kind of knowledge but experiences such situations & learns from them, either by sensation or by reflection (perception). Thus every person’s body & mind are not two exclusive identities but they are linked together & body is used to perform according to mind’s instructions (Locke. 1959) In his famous book “An Essay Concerning Human Understanding”, Locke explained his point of view very deeply.

He says that extension and body can never be the same things & if anyone says like that, he only tries to lessen the significance & importance of human body while the meaning or philosophy behind this still remains unclear & uncertain. Our body is not simply a combination of extended solid blocks of different shapes joined together for different movements; neither the extension only means the space or the area in which the body moves. Anything that simply occupies area or has some mass is termed as matter, not

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Locke's Criticism on Descartes' Philosophy of Calling Extension the Essay”, n.d.)
Locke's Criticism on Descartes' Philosophy of Calling Extension the Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1439435-locke-holds-that-descartes-was-wrong-when-he
(Locke'S Criticism on Descartes' Philosophy of Calling Extension the Essay)
Locke'S Criticism on Descartes' Philosophy of Calling Extension the Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1439435-locke-holds-that-descartes-was-wrong-when-he.
“Locke'S Criticism on Descartes' Philosophy of Calling Extension the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1439435-locke-holds-that-descartes-was-wrong-when-he.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Locke's Criticism on Descartes' Philosophy of Calling Extension the Essence of Body

Descartes Philosophy in Meditations

He makes a clear distinction between the human soul and body.... This paper ''Descartes philosophy in Meditations'' tells that Rene Descartes is widely considered the founder of modern philosophy.... hellip; This is through the analysis of his objections and replies as written in his meditations on the First philosophy book....     Position of Descartes in the Meditations In the Meditations, Descartes provides a means for the first philosophy hence the beginning of modern-day philosophy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Dependability of Science Based on Empiricism

The focus of the paper "Modern Philosophy" is on descartes's argument, mind and body to bond, Descartes Cartesian dualism, assumption, instructor Date From antiquity to contemporary times, Rene Descartes, a critical factor that emerges, from antiquity to contemporary times.... hellip; One of the most notable and controversial assertions and the subject of this paper was his claiming that one cannot entirely depend on their senses to provide true information about their surroundings....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Locke's Real Essence

These linkages had to be the essence of understanding the concept to its fullest.... The focus of the paper "Locke's Real essence" is on the fundamental principles of Locke's philosophy, the Interpretation of 'Substances', the outcome of this objective method, the qualities of substances, the integral constituents of the object, ideas of substances, simple modes, mixed modes, relations.... hellip; Factually speaking, he is the forerunner who helped revolutionize the cause of psychology, to be taken as a separate entity other than philosophy....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Locke's Argument on the Primary Qualities of Objects

Locke's discussions of the concept of body involve detailed points which are of some interest but which lie beyond my present scope.... One of them is his thesis that primary qualities are such as are utterly inseparable from the body, in what state soever it be; and such as in all the alterations and changes it suffers, all the force can be used upon it, it constantly keeps, and such as sense constantly finds in every particle of matter which has bulk enough to be perceived....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Purpose of and Philosophy behind Descartes Method of Doubt

Hence, Descartes decided to provide the scientists with a solid starting point that was in essence, an Archimedean fulcrum.... This essentially means that rather being a skeptic in essence, Descartes made use of skepticism as a means to critically analyze things, which is why he is known for his Method of Doubt.... “Descartes supposed that if we were really to reflect upon what it is to be certain, we would see that the radical skeptical grounds for doubt are a natural extension of the sorts of doubts we raise in everyday life” (Broughton)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Rene Descartes Philosophy

According to the text, Rene Descartes introduces a philosophy of consciousness and self-realization.... In a similar way, Descartes explains that man (I) exists because of some attributes like body, soul, and thoughts.... The present essay "Rene Descartes philosophy" deals with the ideas depicted by Descartes in his works....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Rene Descartes

In his arguments concerning mind and body, Descartes sought to prove that these are different things stating that 1) existence of mind is undoubtable while existence of body is uncertain; 2) the body is extended and mind is not.... Along with that, Descartes philosophical doctrine was dualistic as he admitted existence of two entities that, mind and body, that are in the relations of mutual dependence and interconnection.... In this case one might have no body at all with all he/she knows (perceives) being imposed by this God or Demon (SparkNotes)....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Descartes: Mind over Body

This essay "Descartes: Mind over body" has a goal of explaining the key features of the philosopher's work and outlook on things.... His path-breaking line of thought was the clear demarcation of the idea of the mind from the idea of the body.... Descartes' self-declared goal in writing his Meditations was to irrefutably prove “the existence of God --- (and) the real distinction between the human soul and body” (Meditations, Dedicatory Letter to the Sorbonne, paragraph 5)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us