StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Genetically modified humans: here and more coming soon by Nick Lane - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper is a critical analysis of an article which is, ‘Genetically modified humans: here and more coming soon’, written by Nick Lane, an honorary reader at University College, London…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
Genetically modified humans: here and more coming soon by Nick Lane
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Genetically modified humans: here and more coming soon by Nick Lane"

Critical Analysis of an Article by Nick Lane This paper is a critical analysis of an article which is, ‘Genetically modified humans: here and more coming soon’, written by Nick Lane, an honorary reader at University College, London. The thesis statement is that a baby can be created by two mothers genetically which can save him from inheriting dreadful diseases, and this procedure can lead to the development of designer babies. In his article, Lane has illustrated the genetic modification of human beings and has described the procedure that can be used to create babies using the eggs of two women.

He tells about the research work that is being carried out by a research team in UK whose purpose is the creation of an embryo with the participation of three parents and without any chance of the baby inheriting dreadful diseases. Lane further tells the role of mitochondria in the procedure. He tells that if the egg from one woman contains defective mitochondria, then these can be replaced by those attained from the donor egg from another woman, and since a mitochondrion itself contains DNA, this would mean that the baby is going to have genes from two different women or mothers.

However, Lane states that this procedure gives the baby chance to live with the healthiest genes. Lane has used a number of evidences to support his conclusions and also mentioned at times that the research work from the mentioned scientists is not complete and is on its way. Then, is not Lane jumping to conclusions? There has not been even one research that is completed successfully stating that this mixing up of mitochondria from two women is the perfect way of saving a baby from getting diseases in any stage of life.

For example, the article states the procedure used by Chinnery and Turnbull in which the nucleus is removed from the egg containing faulty mitochondria and is moved to the donor egg which contains healthy mitochondria, which results in the baby having nuclear DNA from its real parents and mitochondrial DNA from the donor woman. Chinnery has stated that they have only been able to swap the nuclear DNAs of those failed embryos which had failed the fertility treatments and had been left by the parents at the fertility clinics (Hayden, 2008); whereas, the article states that Chinnery and Turnbull have been using the procedure of transplanting nuclear DNA from a living embryo to a living donor egg.

Moreover, Lane has come up with contradictory conclusions in his article. On one hand, he states that this procedure of genetic engineering or genetic modification can lead to an individual leading a healthy, long, intelligent and active life with less or no risk of inheriting diseases; and on the other hand, he uses evidences to conclude that this technique is full of risks regarding the transfer of genetic or mitochondrial diseases from the mother to the baby. In short, the reader of the article is, at times, left confused what to believe and which direction to go.

One paragraph sustains the former idea while the proceeding one would support the latter one. Lane has been jumping to contradictory conclusions with such confidence that the reader finds difficulty to decide whether the concept of designer babies is just another research or is it really a big step towards genetic modification of the human species. References Lane, N. (2008, June 04). Genetically modified human: here and more coming soon. NewScientist. Retrieved 5 May, 2011, from http://www.newscientist.

com/article/mg19826591.700-genetically-modified-humans-here-and-more-coming-soon.html?full=true Hayden, E. (2008). A step toward three-parent babies? BioEd Online. Retrieved 5 May, 2011, from http://www.bioedonline.org/news/news.cfm?art=3797

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Genetically modified humans: here and more coming soon by Nick Lane Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1420369-genetically-modified-humans-here-and-more-coming-soon-by-nick-lane
(Genetically Modified Humans: Here and More Coming Soon by Nick Lane Essay)
https://studentshare.org/other/1420369-genetically-modified-humans-here-and-more-coming-soon-by-nick-lane.
“Genetically Modified Humans: Here and More Coming Soon by Nick Lane Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1420369-genetically-modified-humans-here-and-more-coming-soon-by-nick-lane.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Genetically modified humans: here and more coming soon by Nick Lane

Genetically Modified Food/Organisms

genetically modified Food/Organisms Background of the Issue “Between 1997 and 1999, gene-modified (GM) ingredients suddenly appeared in 2/3rds of all US processed foods.... On those lines, the genetically modified food materials such as the milk, eggs, wheat, fish, peanuts, soybeans and shellfish are alleged to contain specific proteins which can cause over 90 percent of the food allergies.... Thus the concept of genetic engineering and the resultant GM foods resulted in more foods including the soybean, corn, canola, and cotton seed oil....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Benefits Genetic Engineering in Food Production

Although many biotechnologists and organizations have proposed the use of genetically modified organisms in curbing world hunger, the technique of food production has faced an equal measure of opposition from the resilient and concerned quarters (Teitel and Wilson 36).... Although the use of genetically modified foods may have certain shortcomings, the global population should embrace the technique fully to ensure sustainable food production and hence global food security....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Young British Artists and the world

n the late 1980's, British art entered a new exciting chapter-a new wave of inspiration was borne of apathy and confusion, and the hearts and minds of a new generation and breed of artists-those who would soon become known as the YBA's, or Young British Artists.... Sometimes, it seems that the well of inspiration is particularly dry; during other times, like the wave of rising popularity for young British artists, particularly during the early and mid 1990's… Not only has contemporary British art become more popular here at home, but also abroad....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Impact of Family on Child Development

In understanding the patterns of cognitive development in infants and children and how families affect their development, the contributions of Jean Piaget (1896-1980) and Erik Erikson (1902-1994) hold a very significant importance.... Children go through a number of cognitive… in Coon 112), and they learn to develop emotional attachment right from their infancy with the help of “a number of attributes that help them to maintain contact with others and do elicit care giving” (Shaffer 142). Piaget This is because the infants get attached to those people around them who are responsive and provide them comfort....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Genetically Modified Food

Lately, genetically modified foods (GMF) have been a major aspect that has resulted to protest from public interest groups as well as various religions.... genetically modified foods refer to the foods that are produced from organisms that have their DNA changed through the process… The techniques of genetic engineering and molecular biology have resulted to creation of plants that have undergone modification in the laboratories in order to improve their resistance towards herbicides or improve their nutrition value....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Genetically modified food

 genetically modified or genetically altered foods are sometime in the field of medical or biomedical technology referred to as genetically modified organisms or in short, GMOs.... Most of the genetically modified food crops are produced so as maximize on their yield while at the same time allowing for introduction of resistance genes that help in surviving during infection with diseases.... It is however important to perform assessments of all genetically modified foods before they are brought into the market for human consumption since any mistakes done during the process of generating the GMOs may have a fatal effect on huge numbers of people (Kawata, Murakami & Ishikawa, 2009)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Fulfilment Factories and Modern Retail Methods

Higher inventory meant that the customer could finally be serviced and the retailer got loyal customers coming back for more supplies, but the downside was that the working capital requirements increased manifolds due to high inventories and their management became a sore point.... Mom & Pop stores still exist but are more a novelty than necessity.... Earlier there was a supplier who catered to many stores who in turn cater to many more customers....
20 Pages (5000 words) Article

Genetically Modified Food for Human Consumption

The "genetically modified Food for Human Consumption" paper argues that the approval of GM food for human consumption should be an astringent and comprehensive process that evaluates all the possible health, environmental and economic impacts of GM food.... genetically modified foods are produced by crops whose genes have been altered.... However, the rapid advancements in genetic engineering have led to the availability of many genetically modified food crops....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us