StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Rebuttal of an Evaluation - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Abortion Kraig Josiah Rice in his article, ‘ABORTION – AN INTERNATIONAL EVIL’ argues against the immoral act of abortion. The issue is no doubt much debated and people over the years have opined in favour and against of abortion in equal numbers. Rice delivered the first blow hoisting questions regarding abortion as a human right…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
Rebuttal of an Evaluation
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Rebuttal of an Evaluation"

Abortion Kraig Josiah Rice in his article, ‘ABORTION – AN INTERNATIONAL EVIL’ argues against the immoral act of abortion. The issue is no doubt muchdebated and people over the years have opined in favour and against of abortion in equal numbers. Rice delivered the first blow hoisting questions regarding abortion as a human right. According to him a child is a gift of god and a human being, as one of God’s creation has no right to terminate the life in a child. In other words, if a human cannot create life by himself then he has no right to terminate it at his own wish.

Rice has moved forward to claim that a foetus experiences equal pain in termination like any other living being. He has said that this pain is expressed through “The Silent Scream” (Rice) that cannot be heard but can be seen. God is the creator of life and Satan is the destroyer, hence he has opined that abortion in way worship of Satan himself. Rice strongly announces his vote for right to life for the foetus and also told not to impose a decision of someone else’s on a coming child through deciding on his life and death.

Rice’s argument against abortion lacks rationality and an emotional appeal rather than a reasoned one. The Silent Scream claim of Rice classifies the foetus as living and thus has a right to life. Biologically it is alive, but being alive neither provides it full human rights nor a right to live through the gestation period. Question might be asked why so? There are a bunch of reasons first of all a foetus carries human chromosome and left to grow it will be a human one day. It is a potential person, but our hair follicle also contains the same number of DNA that it has.

A zygote and a hair follicle contain the same attributes in terms of chromosomes and thus a zygote is as much a human as a hair follicle. If a hair can be plucked and thrown away what is different for a zygote? (Elroy) This kind of reasoning might sound little harsh to many ears; a little in depth analysis might sooth it; a zygote is humane in nature but not a person yet. It is a potential person but not independent one. Unless independent and conscious how can it judge its fate? Carrying a baby involves significant risks and it is solely on the mother if she decides to expose herself to those risks and get a baby.

If she decides against it; it’s her own will. Before birth the baby and the mother are two people occupying the same body and in such situation will of the dominant entity will always prevail. If that entity decides in favour of abortion, that will be his choice. Again if not independent from the mother’s body; termination of the zygote can never be termed as murder or sacrifice for Satan like in middle ages. Rice’s argument considering God as the creator of life and hence the sole terminator is still questionable in this era of cloning. (Elroy) In the above analysis I have used a practical approach based on scientific ground and encompassing human rights doctrines against Rice’s religious criticism of abortion.

I have used reasoning to prove that being alive not necessarily leads to rights that confer to a human being. Apart from alive, independence and consciousness are other two important factors that a zygote lacks and in that sense it is no different from any other human cell that contain exactly the same numbers of chromosomes. Furthermore on pure scientific basis I have raised question on the sole creator and terminator concept of god; hence with cloning on the horizon a human being is equally capable of creating life nowadays.

Works Cited McKinley, Brian Elroy, “Why Abortion is Moral”, 2008. April 15 2011 from: http://www.elroy.net/ehr/abortionanswers.html Rice, Kraig Josiah. ‘ABORTION – AN INTERNATIONAL EVIL’, 2005, April 15, 2011 from: http://www.breadonthewaters.com/abortion-_an_international_evil.htm

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Rebuttal of an Evaluation Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1416106-rebuttal-of-an-evaluation
(Rebuttal of an Evaluation Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/other/1416106-rebuttal-of-an-evaluation.
“Rebuttal of an Evaluation Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1416106-rebuttal-of-an-evaluation.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Rebuttal of an Evaluation

Arranged Marriage

Discussion: Toulmin Strategy for Arguments The conception of ‘Toulmin Strategy for Argument' comprises six different parts which include ‘claim', ‘qualification', ‘rebuttal/observation', ‘grounds', ‘warrant' and ‘backing'.... Arranged Marriage Table of Contents Introduction 3 Thesis Statement 3 Discussion: Toulmin Strategy for Arguments 4 Grounds 5 Warrant 5 Backing 6 Qualification 7 Conclusion 7 Works Cited 8 Introduction Marriage is regarded to be a social association or a legal contract between two people of opposite gender....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Use of Collagen in Medicine

rebuttal Name: Institution: Course: Tutor: Date: Abstract From the assessment report, it is sure that the assessors unanimously acknowledged the authenticity and the reality in the proposed research study, and this prompted their comments and approval of funding of the project.... hellip; The report incorporated the views and comments of three distinct assessors who separately assessed the workability and implication of the research study project....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Minimum Drinking Age in the US Must Be Reconsidered

The paper "The Minimum Drinking Age in the US Must Be Reconsidered" argues the need to lower the MLDA to 18, since already at this age people have the right to make independent decisions.... Opponents of such a position refer to cases when alcohol intake before the age of 21 turned out to be fatal....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

Mortgage Law and the Vitiating Factors

One of the major vitiating factors of the contracts in general and mortgage law in particular is 'undue influence'.... "Equity gives relief on the ground of undue influence where an agreement has been obtained by certain kinds of improper pressure which were thought not to amount to duress at common law because no element of violence to the person was involved" (GH Treitel, The Law of Contract) There can be actual undue influence and presumed undue influence. … In the case of Royal Bank of Scotland v Etridge Lord Nicholls ruled that evidential presumption of undue influence can be the second way that undue influence can be established against a party....
15 Pages (3750 words) Case Study

Toulmin Analysis

rebuttal: Staining caused by red wine, coffee and cola can be prevented by brushing the teeth soon after consuming these beverages (TTWK, 2009).... In this paper, a Toulmin Analysis is carried out, of the online advertisement for Smile Brite teeth whitener in the Top, Teeth Whitening Kits website....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Debate Reaction Paper / for management class

Assessment of Arguments Upon closer evaluation of both arguments, it is hereby deduced that the criteria needed to assist in coming up with a decision on which side wins the debate are as follows: (1) structure of the presentation; (2) clarity of arguments supporting the side being contended; (3) clarity of rebuttal to counter the contentions of the other party; and (4) the provision of appropriate, credible and authoritative support.... larity of RebuttalsNo rebuttal statement providedNo rebuttal statement providedProvision of Credible Support through SourcesThere were 4 citations noted for their arguments....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

The Status of the Business as for the Last Couple of Years

The paper "The Status of the Business as for the Last Couple of Years" discusses that the best strategy to combat an online rumor is to come up with a fast and comprehensive rebuttal.... A quick and consistent crisis response plan is essential for a company in responding to crises....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Blackfish: Myth and Reality

The paper focuses on the “Blackfish" movie which presents an emotional petition against SeaWorld for holding orcas unethically in captivity, mistreating these marine creatures, citing captivity as the cause of animal leading to the deadly attacks on people.... hellip; The research presents evidence to prove that the life of these creatures is not rosy even in natural habitats, where animals have problems related to the paucity of food and hygiene....
6 Pages (1500 words) Movie Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us