StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Conversation with theorists - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Dinner Well, my dear friends! I am fascinated by having a chance to communicate with you. Schizophrenia is a mental illness and it is very difficult for nurses to take care about the patients with this diagnosis. Anyway, it is interesting for me to penetrate in the depths of this illness and find out the reasons triggering it…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
Conversation with theorists
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Conversation with theorists"

Dinner Well, my dear friends! I am fascinated by having a chance to communicate with you. Schizophrenia is a mental illness and it is very difficultfor nurses to take care about the patients with this diagnosis. Anyway, it is interesting for me to penetrate in the depths of this illness and find out the reasons triggering it. I would like to ask you about different approaches to schizophrenia identification and treatment. Mr. Peplau looks confused, because he has many options to communicate with two different scientists providing their original points of view about schizophrenia treatment.

Albert Bandura is a cognitive therapist and Carl Rogers is a humanistic therapist. Hildegard Peplau would fight for an opportunity of nurse-patient communication approach. This approach is very attractive for me, since in nursing it is very important to bridge a gap in the communication between a patient and a nurse. It is easier for a patient to share his hallucinations and delusions with someone in the context his usual social environment. Bandura would surely argue that influence of the environment on a person is evident and behavior can influence environment too (Bandura 2002).

This mutual dependence can be surely illustrated by the example of patients with a diagnosis of schizophrenia. Actually, patients with this diagnosis would be considered by Bandura with respect to three different factors: environment, behavior, and internal psychological processes of a person. Supposedly, Mr. Peplau would ask: “Hey, Bandura, what is more important behavior or language of a patient with the diagnosis of schizophrenia?” The latter would think a little and then say: “Both of them, of course!

Language is the reflection of his thoughts, his mind. It is possible to understand the essence of language by penetrating in the imagery secrets of it.” And here comes Carl Rogers! “Dear Sirs! Don’t worry, be happy and your patients will be happy too! The only key to a successful treatment of schizophrenia or any other type of a mental disorder is an unconditional positive regard and empathy of a doctor. ” Now, let me interfere and say: “Wait, please, my dear great minded interlocutors!

I would claim that you are thinking about a person with schizophrenia in unreal context. It is better to be more practical and consider a current mental condition of a patient.” I would take my chance and strongly agree with Rogers and his claim that it is relevant to refer to a patient in a real time, with a great likeness and understanding. During psychotherapy hours a specialist is focused on particular symptoms of his patient and it is better to know how he is behaving at a given moment.

Bandura is focused on imagery and language and I think that is easy for him to focus more on observation and learning. Bandura would say: “Humans are agents and it is relevant to implement different practices in the process of patient’s cure”. Different conditions are influential and every man is captured under the influence of external factors. Still, there is no doubt that behavior of a person gives him out at once. For Bandura it is evident that a patient with schizophrenia is not responsible for his actions.

Of course, Rogers would hardly support such kind of a passive and observational manner of treatment (Thorne, 1992). He is more a proactive therapist and the one, who has an ability to inspire his patients. Peplau is more practical too and during this dinner these two theorists would move towards each other in their mutual understanding for sure, because of their proactive actions (Taylor&Lillis, 2001). Peplau: “Mr. Bandura, if actions are dominant, why your so-called human agents cannot take control over schizophrenia?

” Bandura would respond for sure: “Unfortunately, human mind cannot cope with a chemical reaction leading to schizophrenia. Human actions are lost in vain…but no one can hide words or images, which are hidden behind the words”. Rogers would respond: “my dear, both of you are not right. You took a wrong way to cure schizophrenia. I am telling you that these people suffer from schizophrenia, because such stubborn and gloomy persons like you do not want to understand them, but only oppress them and feeding with drugs them all the time”.

Let me argue, Dear Sirs! To my mind, to take care of a patient means a lot. It is evident that people, who have awful hallucination, misbehavior and are suffering from their damaged brains, are in need not only for a positive attitude, but also for medical treatment. Schizophrenia can be considered from various perspectives, but in the very essence it is a kind of a mental disorder and both cooperation of theorists and practitioners can bear fruits. Conclusion Therefore, my dear friends, I was very much impressed by having such a perfect opportunity to communicate with the leading specialists in the field of theoretical nursing and psychology.

Their cognitive and humanistic approaches widened my horizon and I started thinking about a necessity of implementing a holistic approach in the process of caring about the patients, a process of diagnostics, treatment or whatever. To my mind, Bandura’s approach is the most appropriate for treatment of schizophrenia. This illness can be considered from various perspectives, but in the very essence it is a kind of a mental disorder and both cooperation of theorists and practitioners can bear fruits.

I agree with Bandura and I think it is appropriate to consider the patients on the background of their environment, behavior, and their own internal psychological processes. References Bandura, A. (2002). Selective moral disengagement in the exercise of moral agency. Journal Of Moral Education, 31 (2): 101–119.  Taylor Carol, Lillis Carol. (2001).The Art & Science Of Nursing Care. Philadelphia:  Lippincott. Thorne, Brian. (1992). Carl Rogers - Key Figures in Counselling and Psychotherapy series.

Sage publications.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Conversation with theorists Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/nursing/1459059-conversation-with-theorists
(Conversation With Theorists Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/nursing/1459059-conversation-with-theorists.
“Conversation With Theorists Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/nursing/1459059-conversation-with-theorists.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Conversation with theorists

Why do language users sometimes use figures of speech

Metaphors – role and forms theorists and researchers have used different approaches in order to explain the role and the functions of metaphors in everyday language.... their characteristic to be open to different interpretations has been considered as one of the main reasons for their extensive study by theorists and researchers worldwide (Lakoff and Johnson 1980, 103).... Discuss with respect to both psychological and conversation analytic research....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Michael and Prinzes Profile and Their Background

conversation Analysis Name: Institution: Introduction Communication Analysis Communication analysis is defined as describing the important factors influencing communication experience or speech analysis.... The theories are; theories of the communicator, theories related to the message, conversation, relationship, group, media, organization and culture and society theories (2007, p.... This essay is an analysis of a telephone conversation between Michael and Prinze, based on communication analysis' theoretical concepts and features of communication....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Overhearing, Plan Recognition and the YOYO Algorithm

In the modern era of stringent global competition, businesses are finding it increasingly difficult to sustain their competitive advantages in the marketplaces.... Off late business owners have realized the immense benefits of knowledge management practices to sustain competitive advantages and hence have invested in tools and techniques to capture, organize, disseminate and reuse knowledge related to their businesses....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Polysystem Theory and the 'Cultural Turn'

Then, obviously, the politically engaged cultural theorists of translation-the postcolonialists and the feminists-become performative linguists: translating as colonizing, or as fighting the lingering effects of colonialism; translating as resisting global capitalism (Venuti); translating as fighting patriarchy, as liberating women (and men) from patriarchal gender roles (Munday 110).... For theorists in these schools it doesn't matter what the translated text looks like; or, well, it does, but not to the theorist, only to the receiving culture (DTS), the client (skopos), or the translator himself or herself (TAP)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Lesson Plan Observation

Each student will initiate a conversation like this, “Hello, my name is Mario.... The activities suggested in the lesson shift the focus from the social function of conversation, e.... As a consequence, students are not equally confident of their speaking and the ones with the lower level do not always choose to initiate the conversation and often end up responding to other students' verbal stimuli.... In this view, teacher's role is to clarify the instructions so that every student has a chance to both initiate a conversation and give a response....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

My Fierce Autobiography - Achieving Success at Work & in Life

The essay "My Fierce Autobiography - Achieving Success at Work & in Life" is a plan of action with descriptive strategy for the development of the author's skills in time management, critical thinking and writing, collaborative facilitation, iterative knowledge acquisition, peer-to-peer learning, and retention, etc....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Analysis of Communication Ethnography

The conversation also abides by a number of rules and theories explained by the literature reviewed above.... The conversation has served its academic and practical purpose of understanding the rules and procedures that follow communication  Communication is often perceived as the passing of messages and ideas from one person to the other through a variety of mediums.... In the case of a communicative event through dress code, it can be said that the conversation is bounded by the start and end of visual contact of the observer to the desired object....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

The Systems of Pragmatic Analysis

This has been transcribed using conversation analysis conventions.... This assignment "The Systems of Pragmatic Analysis" presents difficulties people are having with the systems of pragmatic analysis elements of context, speech act theory, and politeness theory.... To provide a chance for you to think about how these might be applied to an authentic spoken text....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us