StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Music and History: Joan Towers' Music - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Music and History: Joan Towers' Music" paper contains a foregoing analysis of Joan Tower’s compositions, with a particular focus on Fanfare. It is amply evident that her music arises from within her environment and is an affirmation of her identity, profession, musical inclinations, and gender. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Music and History: Joan Towers Music
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Music and History: Joan Towers' Music"

Composers are a product of their environment and times. Even those who are described as `ahead of their times’ are a product of their environment and their music a reaction against, or a commentary upon, it. As such, musical compositions are influenced by a wide array of exogenous and internal, authorial factors, from the characteristics of the time to the composer’s own reaction to them, including his/her perception of, and stand towards their musical heritage. Joan Towers is no different. Her music is made up of the materials of traditional music. As Scholes (1979) points out, the listener to Towers music can hear octatonic scales which Stravinsky, Bartok and Messiaen used, melodic lines rising in fourths reminiscent of Schonberg, intricate rhythms which also recall Stravinsky, free-associative harmony like that employed by Debussy -- all combined into works which have their own individuality, their own character and their own context, performed in traditional concert halls by chamber or symphonic ensembles. Towers works, moreover, evoke an energy, a use of color and texture which are uniquely her own, and which make them not only exciting to listen to, but continue the traditional lineage of Western art music (Scholes, 1979). Conductor Leonard Slatkin states that Towers works come from the "roots" of the "traditional playing repertory. “He describes her work as being “a continuation of historical musical line, but … late twentieth century work” (Slatkin, 1984, p. D3). As will be illustrated through reference to her works, with particular focus on Fanfare for the Uncommon Woman, although Towers music has strong ties to much of the music which came before her, through her use of orchestration, form and musical materials, her final product which combines these elements is not simply a repetition or imitation of what has been written, but an intertwining of these characteristics into the context of her own new musical work. Towers practical process of dealing with music as these raw materials from the "traditional playing repertory" actually began at Bennington College where she attended college and first began writing music. While there she worked on music twelve hours a day – playing music, practicing music, performing music and composing music. Her hands-on compositional process continued as she worked at the Greenwich Music School after she had graduated from Bennington, and with the Da Capo Chamber Players, a group which she co-founded, performed with and composed for from 1969 to 1984 (O’Brian, 1982; Tower, 1984; Humphrey, 1988). The sounds she heard were an ever present sound source for her own works. As she experienced music with the Da Capo players through study and performance of numerous pieces, these sounds came to be present in her own works, several of which were written especially for members of the ensemble whose performances and the sounds she heard them making in these performances were inspirational. Andre Emelianoff, a cellist from the Da Capo players for whom she wrote Music for Cello and Orchestra (1984), worked in close collaboration with Tower, allowing her to hear and work with the sounds of the instrument and the player making these sounds. She states, “We spent six months together meeting, working on bowing, on register. We really created this piece together” (Tower, 1984, n.p.). Wings is an excellent example of how the sounds to which Tower was listening affected her composition. As Humphrey (1982) explains, there is nothing new or revolutionary in her writing a solo clarinet piece. Rather, this work clearly shows the influence of Messiaens well known piece for solo clarinet, “Abime des Oiseaux,” the third movement of the Quatuor Pour La Fin Bu Temps. Although Wings was written many years after Messiaens work, Tower acknowledges her debt to Messiaen stating that “his use of slow time is astounding in that piece. It is really quite a brilliant piece, and its [a] very risky piece because of its slow terrain” (Humphrey, 1988) As well as drawing some of her musical materials from already existing works, Tower perceives her own art as the manipulation of raw materials, an image more often applied to other art forms. She refers to dance and dance-like moving of her materials, for example, as if she were the choreographer. In an interview with Robin Epstein of the Louisville Courier Journal, she states, “I consider myself a choreographer of sound, a dancer of sound. I am interested in what direction it goes” (Epstein, 1990, p. 1). Not only does Tower discuss her compositional process in terms of dance, but she also uses non-musical images, clearly pictorial in nature, as beginning ideas, titles and subsequent explanations of her works. In an interview with Jeanyne Bezoler Slettom, Tower discussed the use of an image as a starting point for a composition. "What I like about composing is that it starts with an image or idea," she said. "Then it is the composers task to discover the identities and feelings of things and to give them musical shape and form" (Tower, cited in Slettom, 1984, n.p.) The search for, and discovery of, identity is also reflected in the titles she chooses for her works and the images and imagery they evoke. Among such works, one may mention Silver Ladders, Sequoia and, of course, Fanfares for the Uncommon Woman. Should one reflect upon these titles one would realise that they evoke images of height (ladder, tall tree, fanfare) and success. Indeed, taken together, they are suggestive of the struggle associated with the climb to success and the fanfare which accompanies the attainment of one’s goals. In commentary upon the titles she selects for her works, Towers once explained that they reflect the basic idea which led to the composition itself (Wierzbicki, 1987). As she informed Wierzbicki (1987) in an interview, she begin with a rough idea and then begins to shape music out of that idea. The guidelines for each of her creations are her titles. Therefore, understanding Towers’ work is dependant on understanding and appreciating her titles. Tied up with her concept of shaping music out of a basic idea contained in a working title, is her idea that the work comes from its own past into the present toward the future. As Humphrey (1988) explains, Towers’ works are rooted in her own past as an individual, as a female composer and in the tradition of Western music. Humphreys goes on to argue that the aforementioned is reflected in Towers’ color, texture and rhythm, insofar as the string contrasts contained within them express the division between the past and the present and between femininity and masculinity, among others. Indeed, if the images of her works are examined, one can see that she sets the stage for contrasts in all these parameters. In Sequoia there are the contrasts of the huge, stately trees and the very small pine needles which make up so much of their whole. In Amazon there is the seamless flowing action with the many changes that occur along its course -- changes of pace, cascades, ripples, among others (Humphreys, 1988). In Fanfares, the contrast is between the past and the present, what is and what was, between the masculine and the feminine, and between the common and the uncommon woman. Proceeding from the above stated, a close listening of Fanfares not only evidences the contrasts outlines in the above but indicates the many ways that Tower manipulates the musical materials of her predecessors and uses them in combination with her own original ideas to create unique, energetic and colorful music. There is, however, a greater underlying difference between her work and that of her male influences which is perhaps easiest seen if, as McClary (1991) writes, we look at the common semiotic codes of European classical music from which their music, and her music, stem. Although many of the qualities of Towers works are based on the works of her predecessors, when her symphonic works, such as Fanfares, are examined with regard to these codes, interesting differences occur (McClary, 1991). McClary (1991, p. 68) defines these codes as “the gestures that stereotypically signify masculine or feminine, placidity or violence, the military or the domestic realm, and also the standard narrative schemata that underlie most nineteenth-century instrumental movements.” McClary (1991, p. 68) explains how classical music connects the erotic to feminine evil and the pure to masculine high culture. In classical music, the erotic continues so often to be framed as a manifestation of feminine evil while masculine high culture is regarded as transcendent. And the pervasive cultural anxiety over women as obstacles to transcendence justifies over and over again narratives of the victimized male and the necessary purging or containment of the female. McClary (1991) sets the opening movements of the nineteenth-century symphony, the sonata-allegro form, as the supreme example of such a narrative. The first theme, the "masculine" theme, presented in an opening movement is "usually somewhat aggressive," and is frequently described as having "thrust." It is first presented in the tonic key, establishes it as such, and sets the "affective tone" of the movement. Midway through the exposition of the movement, the first theme (which can be considered the protagonist of the narrative) encounters the second theme, the "feminine" theme, more lyrical and in a different key from the first. “As the tonal, sonata-based movement is concerned with matters of maintaining identity, both thematic and tonal, the second area poses a threat to the opening materials” (McClary, 1991, p. 68). The development section presents the various thematic materials of the exposition in several combinations and keys. Finally, in the recapitulation, the materials of the exposition are repeated, but the secondary theme is overcome and “must now conform to the protagonists tonic key area. It is absorbed, its threat to the opening keys identity neutralized” (McClary, 1991, p. 68). Each work elaborates this basic plot in various ways. Some composers intensify the triumph of the masculine theme over the feminine one, as does Towers in Fanfares. Indeed, in examining Towers symphonic works, we encounter several other issues, the first being that her works are not written in the traditional symphonic form of a multi-movement work. Rather, each of her three fanfares may be described as extended one movement pieces with several themes and changes of tonal centers. They also have, however, contrasting themes and moods reminiscent of the those described in the traditional forms. Furthermore, although they do not follow the traditional sonata-allegro narrative, they most certainly have a linear direction which outlines a narrative with connections to the traditional sonata-allegro. Fanfares clearly illustrate many of the qualities of the traditional sonata-allegro narrative. While there are not distinct first and second themes, there are passages which contain the qualities of a first or "masculine" theme which alternate with passages maintaining qualities of a second or "feminine" theme. These qualities have to do with the strong presence or absence of rhythm, heavy use of percussion as opposed to fluid wind and string textures, large ensemble playing versus concertino passages (duets or solos), and a strong tonal center as opposed to a freer tonality. The piece begins with a strong, rhythmic, and heavily percussive section with the full orchestra playing. Then, the strong, rhythmic, masculine first section ends with an intense rhythmic flourish, followed by a section which begins with one long tone, played by a single trumpet swelling from piano to mezzoforte and returning to piano. Another trumpet is soon added so that the passage becomes a trumpet duet. This second more feminine mood is immediately juxtaposed with short softer segments reminiscent of the opening section. The rhythmic element of these segments continues to be added, by other instruments as well as the trumpets themselves. Slowly the orchestra builds back up to the tutti. Horns play long extended tones which are then taken over by a rhythmically freer duet than the "masculine" passages which are dominated by rhythm. The "feminine" theme continues to appear throughout the piece, interspaced between the "masculine" sections, but never completely escapes the rhythmic identity of the "masculine" theme until the very end of the piece. At that point a violin is heard with only a selected number of the gentler instruments, all playing long arrhythmic tones. Finally, only on this last chord does the "feminine" theme escape all of the qualities of the dominant masculine theme: aggressive rhythm and movement, heavy percussion, intense dynamic level, strong tonal center, and full orchestration. Proceeding from the above stated and as evidenced through the foregoing analysis of Joan Tower’s compositions, with particular focus on Fanfares, it is amply evident that her music arises from within her environment and is an affirmation of her identity, profession, musical inclinations and gender. While original, her compositions pay tribute to those who have influenced her; while cross-gender, her music expresses the interplay between the feminine and the masculine; while thoroughly subjective and personal, her music speaks to her times and to the triumph of the female sex. The implication here is simple: Joan Towers’ compositions may be unique but they are undoubtedly the product of a specific musical heritage, a particular environment and a unique set of psychological forces. The greater meaning, or the lesson which one may derive from the aforementioned, is that to understand and fully appreciate any musical piece is contingent upon an awareness of its source, as in where it came from. This does not mean knowledge of its composer but what produced that composer, the time within which the piece was written and, importantly, that which the composer is trying to say. Once one understands the aforementioned, one will understand a composer and his/her music. Bibliography Humphrey, M.L. (1988) Joan Tower. New York: G. Schimer. McClary, S. (1991) Feminine endings: Music, gender and sexuality. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. O’Brian, V. (1982) Joan Tower. Musical America. Scholes R. (1979) Fabulation and metafiction. Urbana: University of Illinois Press. Slatkin, L. (1984, Sept. 14) The composer lends a hand to the baton. St. Louis Globe-Democrat. Slettom, J.B. (1984, Oct. 25) Success amazes composer. St. Paul Dispatch. Tower, J. (1984, Nov. 9) Tower rising in music world. Time Union. Wierzbicki, J. (1987, Jan. 4) Every instance of music has a past, present and future. St. Louis Post-Dispatch. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Joan Towers' Music Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2250 words - 1, n.d.)
Joan Towers' Music Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2250 words - 1. https://studentshare.org/music/1710632-music-and-history
(Joan Towers' Music Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2250 Words - 1)
Joan Towers' Music Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2250 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/music/1710632-music-and-history.
“Joan Towers' Music Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2250 Words - 1”. https://studentshare.org/music/1710632-music-and-history.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Music and History: Joan Towers' Music

Guido of Arezzo A change in Music History

This essay describes how Guido d'Arezzo changed music history by creating his own system.... As a conclusion, a short summary of is Guidonien Hand and how it changed music history giving the possibility for more people to learn solfege more rapidly.... music notation in the 10th century was complicated and non comprehensible to the majority of the catholic monks.... Guido d'Arrezo A change in Musical history Early notation of pre d'Azzero church chants were signs above the words....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Heritage of music. Bla Bartk

Also while at the Academy, at about the same time that he discovered Strauss's and Debussy's music and adapted the genre and style of the tone poem to his own innovative compositions, Bartok met the composer Zoltan Kodaly, with whom he became a lifelong friend.... It is possible that this lack of stability could have contributed to his development as an artist, that the music inside of him was a constant that was not present in his outside world.... During his teen years, Bartok continued to advance in his performance level and began composing chamber music, a skill he learned by reading musical scores....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Harlem Renaissance in the NYC

The essay "Harlem Renaissance in the NYC" focuses on the critical analysis of the history and major issues on Harlem renaissance in New York City, in the suburbs of which, there is a small place named Harlem.... This participation of Negros in plays boosted their morale and the event was termed as the most important event for Negros of the US of their entire history....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ways in which Music Copyrights are exploited

The following paper explores the nature of copyright and publishing as it exploits music to its fullest financial potential.... Throughout the 20th century, and more specifically in the last half of the century, the music industry had to undergo rapid changes as new revenue streams were opened up in relationship to technology.... A host of problems had to be solved in order to support the rights attributed to publishing a piece of music Ways in which music Copyrights are exploited ...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Music and Baroque Period

The researcher of this essay "music and Baroque Period" aims to analyze the music in the era of Baroque.... The advancement of music and its various genres found competent handling from the likes of great musical composers such as Johann Sebastian Bach, George Friederic Handel, Antonio Vivaldi and Jean-Baptiste Lully.... This was the age of 'absolutism' when the power of the Church and the state created the need for organized public music and Chamber music....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Harlem Renaissance Development

They used traditional black folk material to encourage black people to regain their dignity and to inspire other communities from their enriched talent in music and other forms of art.... From its beginning it was associated with every form of art, whether it is music or some other form of creative art.... She inherited a successful hair-care products empire from her mother and by use of her extreme wealth, she build a famous saloon which turned into a restaurant named 'the dark tower', during the peak era of the Harlem Renaissance, where most of the black literature and music flourished since many of the writers and poets used to visit there and were very good friends of Walker....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

American 20th Century Music

"American 20th Century music" paper considers the development of music in America during the 20th century, in particular looking at the differences from the music of native Americans, in style, content, and purpose, and then on through time to the development of rock and roll in the 1950s.... In the case of all the artists mentioned above their interest in music, in whatever genre, started at a very early age, often encouraged by parents or other family members, but who were also the products of their time and environment, as well as being innovators, creators, developing distinctive styles of their own....
11 Pages (2750 words) Literature review

The Impact of Music Performance

The essay "The Impact of music Performance" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the impact of music performance.... music is one of the things that help us to build and strengthen our language skills by helping us to know how to socialize.... Most people who develop their interest in music are those who get introduced to music at very tender ages and this is what helps them to continue liking it and thus helps them in their music-performing abilities (Graham, 2009)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us