StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Importance of Powers Separation - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Importance of Powers Separation" describes that the conflict itself can attempt to be remedied by a fuller and more complete understanding by the citizen that liberty itself is a right and an inherent gift that the founding documents have bequeathed the nation…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
Importance of Powers Separation
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Importance of Powers Separation"

In the legislative, judicial, and executive branches, the framers elaborated upon this within the Constitution. Ultimately, strict rules and regulations were employed to determine and govern the way that each of these aforementioned three actors can and should behave regarding the tasks they were responsible for fulfilling and the level of cross-jurisdictional activity that was allowed to occur between the two.

It should be noted that although a powerful judiciary and/or legislature were feared as well, the ultimate fear that the founders had was about the growth and overabundance of power that a strong executive might carve out for himself/herself. In this way, a secondary benefit of the separation of power can be seen to have an ancillary benefit of ensuring that none of the three becomes too powerful; however, the ultimate goal that was originally intended to ensure that the executive branch was not able to exact total control over the system. This was primarily born out of the fear that was a result of how the colonists had experienced the full might and whimsical wrath of King George III. After having a far less than pleasant experience with how a total monarch (the ultimate executive) could exhibit control over every aspect of life, the colonists and the framers wanted to ensure that they could create a system of governance that did not exhibit this particular flaw.

By refusing the power of the legislature to enact a law, by refusing the power of the executive to pass legislation, and by refusing the judicial power the powers associated with either the legislative or executive branches, the framers were able to create a system that most effectively represented how checks and balances could be ensured between all three branches. By not making any one entity or individual ultimately responsible, the framers sought to create a medium of governance that would not perish by nature of its very inability to provide rapid and/or radical changes based upon the whims or personal interests of a single individual or a cabal of self-interested individuals.

Question #3: Is there a conflict between liberty and patriotism?
These two constructs, liberty, and patriotism, represent unequal yet related emotions, duties, and actions. Firstly, with regards to liberty, is the greater virtue, right, and privilege that the United States offers. This is because liberty is guaranteed by a litany of the founding documents of the nation. Conversely, although patriotism is something that should be exhibited by every civically minded person, liberty is not something that originates from inside the individual rather it is something that originates from the state.
The ultimate conflict that arises from these two virtues is how patriotism can ultimately lead to a loss of liberty. An obvious example of this loss of liberty as a result of the widespread application of patriotism can readily be noted in the way in which the United States Congress and then President George W. Bush rushed through the Patriot Act and a litany of other legislative tools that ultimately reduced the total amount of liberty that was recognized within the United States as a result of the attacks of September 11th, 2001. Patriotism to one’s country is ultimately a love for the country and is oftentimes hijacked to mean a type of blind servility to whatever leader or plan that is being set in motion should be accepted. However, such is not the case. This is of course not to say that patriotism and liberty conflict perennially with one another. By the very nature of the republic in which the United States was founded, patriotism was described as the very epitome of what could lead to a type of extremist and dogmatic understanding of how the citizen integrates with the government (Fitzgerald 243). The ultimate conflict is then realized when reason, logic, criticism, and other constructive forms of analysis are put on hold instead of blindly supporting a given regime. This of course happens all too often as dissent is stifled by using the claim that any form of disagreement is somehow unpatriotic.

However, it cannot be understood that these two ideals cannot coexist simultaneously. Indeed it was the hope of the founders that they would coexist as all citizens and shareholders would be able to both be proud of the underlying rubric of their republic that allowed dissension and disagreement but championed a sense of pride and patriotism at the same time. This narrow differentiation between these two concepts makes it painfully clear why it can oftentimes be so difficult to retain the clear distinction between the two. Accordingly, it is something of an ongoing battle to continue to retain a sense of pride in the way that the republic operates while at the same time seeking to improve upon it by letting one’s voice of dissension and criticism be heard loudly and clearly. Without such a built-in process of self-improvement, it is impossible that there would ever be any form of development in a democracy that could or would be experienced within the system.

Conversely, patriotism is the outgrowth of an appreciation for such a gift and as such is not obligatory or demanded. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“American Heritage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 2”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1615739-american-heritage
(American Heritage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 2)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1615739-american-heritage.
“American Heritage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 2”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1615739-american-heritage.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Importance of Powers Separation

Separation of Powers

Separation of powers.... Much progress has to be made before the UK has a satisfactory separation of powers.... The separation of powers of the varied aspects of the state that are the legislature, executive and the judiciary is the strongest possible safeguard against the concentration of power and authority in any one single pillar of the British democracy.... The separation of powers is also the best possible protection against the possibility of misuse or manipulation of power by specific individuals, groups or institutions for achieving vested interests and gains, to the detriment of the will of the citizens....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Theory Separation of Power as Promulgated in the UK Constitution

The essay "Theory Separation Of Power As Promulgated In The UK Constitution" starts with the origin of the theory of the separation of powers dates back to the ancient days of Aristotle.... Thus, the above discussion clearly shows us that the Political System of UK is pervaded with the principles of 'theory of separation of powers' as promulgated by Lord Montesquieu and his predecessors.... On the other hand, he visited many countries where people enjoyed great freedom and liberty and concluded that their happiness was a result of separation of powers in the government of those countries....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Legislative Supremacy of Parliament and the Separation of Powers

The paper "Legislative Supremacy of Parliament and the Separation of powers" states that no new evidence can usually be introduced; restricting the power of the court of the petition to the process of law applied but the defendant's conviction can be appealed.... 'Fusion of powers' is the correct term used for the UK constitution because of the existence or presence of Parliamentary sovereignty, while the theory of separation of powers may be studied in Britain....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Separation of the Church and the State In the United States of America

This paper discusses the importance of factor of considering religion as a separate function in society away from the state is known to be among the most important part of the American legislature as it aims to leave the sacredness of religious procedures.... (Hamburger, 2002, 47) Certain Protestant clergymen of the United States give much lip service to the principle of the separation of church and state.... But do they respect that wall of separation between church and state when it conflicts with their own interests to do so They do not (Owen, 2000, 43)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Black Nationalism Ideology

Over the years, ideology has been used by individual persons and group of people to achieve certain ends especially liberations,.... ... ... Ideology is defined as a set of ideas that makes or constitutes an individual or group of individuals' expectations, actions, and goals (David 2).... Also, ideology can be viewed as a way of looking at ings in a comprehensive manner; comparing various views, common sense, philosophical tendencies, and/ or set of ideas that are proposed by class that is dominant in a given society (Michael 6)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Water and oil separator

The first design, which is also the oldest, is called the conventional/gravity separation or API separator, and the coalescing design or parallel corrugated plate.... The separation process... Army Aberdeen Test Centre 23).... Water and Oil separators are more often installed in maintenance and industrial areas to serve the purpose of....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Separation of Powers in the UK

In the paper 'Separation of powers in the UK' the author analyzes the separation of powers of the varied aspects of the state that are the legislature, executive and the judiciary, which is the strongest possible safeguard against the concentration of power and authority in the British democracy.... The author of the paper states that the separation of powers is also the best possible protection against the possibility of misuse or manipulation of power by specific individuals, groups or institutions for achieving vested interests and gains, to the detriment of the will of the citizens....
10 Pages (2500 words) Dissertation

The Doctrine of Separation of Powers

This report "The Doctrine of Separation of powers" focuses on the concept of separation of powers that holds that the executive, legislature, and judiciary should operate independently of each other.... Montesquieu is widely regarded as the father of the doctrine of separation of powers.... The concept of separation of powers is a critical part of any constitutional law.... Montesquieu, who strongly opposed to vesting powers in the hands of one arm of the government, advocated the development of the model that allows the separation of powers between three branches of the government....
8 Pages (2000 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us