StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Political Philosophy - What is the best form of government - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
It would not be an understatement to say that to pinpoint a political system and announce with conviction that it is a perfect system is without bias. The issue of saying which the right one is and which is not becomes a matter of opinion which is only to be hoped for to be…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
Political Philosophy - What is the best form of government
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Political Philosophy - What is the best form of government"

It would not be an under ment to say that to pinpoint a political system and announce with conviction that it is a perfect system is without bias. The issue of saying which the right one is and which is not becomes a matter of opinion which is only to be hoped for to be based on actual facts and experience. These are matters of belief and some may adhere to such more ardently than others. It is with the erudition and consequent knowledge of philosophers who are the authority to instigate accordingly what they believe to be the most suitable and appropriate system that is most justifiable.

Plato’s argument against democracy is dependent on the basis of it being centered on the power of the people to decide what they deem is good for them. The problem of the lack of specialization on matters of the state poses a problem on the choosing of the best possible solution. The Greek word ‘demos’ which translates to ‘the people’ is easily attributable to the concept of ‘the mob.’ This is where the concept of the silent majority and the loud minority may come to play. The word mob by itself sends a negative connotation that can be thought of as unruly and chaotic.

Plato proposes that a leader should be holistic in his education and approach to ruling the state. Foremost, he must be a philosopher as Plato thinks that this enables him to consider the importance of education for others. There are also other requirements which include knowledge in music, mathematics, military, and physical education. The analogy of a person’s health to a state directly explains why Plato does not favor democracy. The state and its health need to be attended to be by a doctor (Wolff, p. 67). A physician will be able to administer with skill and accuracy correct judgment because of his expertise.

This in essence undermines the capacity of the people to articulate good views.Mills idea of democracy is very straightforward, “to improve the citizens, and to manage their public affairs. Thus governments are to be judged by their effects on individuals, whether they improve them morally and intellectually, and by their efficiency in dealing with matters of public concern” This essentially means the need for representation and the importance of the power of the constitution becomes tantamount.

People thrive when they are given independence. Everyone plays a part in the realization of sovereignty by being protective against the danger of oppression (p. 94-95).Rousseau’s proposition is not so different from that of Plato but while Plato primarily thinks of educating only a chosen few, Rousseau argues that more should be educated in the same level to determine the most worthy. The significance of citizenship is especially highlighted by Rousseau. The belief on equality in democracy is recurring in his argument for democracy.

The general will must be adhered to for the maximization of the idealisms of democracy. That the logic that the law exempts no one is the primary message that all will end well in a functional democracy. This serves as a cushion for the differences as it would be obvious that there are going to be disparities in classes among the people. The general good is the ultimate goal as Rousseau sees it (p. 79-81).I prefer Mill’s contention over Plato. It is quite evident that there is truth to the idea that independence results to prosperity as long as it is not abused.

Plato’s idea is generally still restricted to a monarchy and the training that a future king should receive. The peace that comes hand in hand with democracy, compared to other systems, is something that I personally believe in. It eliminates, or at least diminishes, bloodshed. It is obvious that as Mill himself has said, direct democracy is almost impossible because of the large population sizes of states and therefore representation becomes necessary. As long as the people are properly represented and that these representatives rightfully stand for their constituents then a working democracy is in order.

Work CitedWolff, Jonathan. An Introduction to Political Philosophy. New York: Oxford University Press, 2006.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Political Philosophy - What is the best form of government Essay”, n.d.)
Political Philosophy - What is the best form of government Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1565157-political-philosophy-what-is-the-best-form-of-government
(Political Philosophy - What Is the Best Form of Government Essay)
Political Philosophy - What Is the Best Form of Government Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1565157-political-philosophy-what-is-the-best-form-of-government.
“Political Philosophy - What Is the Best Form of Government Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1565157-political-philosophy-what-is-the-best-form-of-government.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Political Philosophy - What is the best form of government

Warring States assignment

It is during the Zhou Dynasty that the kingdoms realized a dramatic shift in weaponry with the introduction of iron-ware in the form of helmets, arrows and spears.... hellip; This paper will attempt to scrutinize some of these philosophies in an attempt to suggest the best governing methodologies during the Warring States period.... As a result of his teachings, the Zhou emerged as undoubtedly one of the best political civilizations of its time (Creel, 1949)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Machiavelli and Hobbes Assess Aristotles Polity

Aristotle, Hobbes and Machiavelli each designated in their works the best "practical" kind of government.... Its parents were democracy and oligarchy, and Aristotle was God giving birth to the new thought from the best parts of both and without the worst parts of either.... Aristotle had a profound influence on political philosophy because he invoked challenging discussions of persistent concerns of political philosophy: the role of human nature in politics, the relation of the individual to the state, the place of morality in politics, the theory of political justice, the rule of law, the analysis and evaluation of constitutions, the relevance of ideals to practical politics, the causes and cures of political change and revolution, and the importance of a morally educated citizenry....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Ideal Society in the Republic of Plato

nbsp;The earlier contemporaneous city-state with democratic form of government had inflicted an exile and death sentence on Plato's master teacher, Socrates.... In this effort, he even discusses various other forms of government such as democracy, totalitarianism and aristocracy etc.... He finds his ideal state as the best possible option among them all.... The training and discipline of philosopher kings is such that they are provided all safeguards preventing them form indulging in any digression vis-à-vis justice in the state....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Social and Political Philosophy

He set forth his political agenda in the ‘The Two Treatises of government.... A relationship of trust existed between man and the government.... Locke wrote that man was moral and equal in the state of nature and he willingly enters into ‘social contract' of the civil society, to advance his ends of peace and security People surrender unto a government a measure of their natural rights to secure the... philosophical and political concepts of Locke, and his views on the nature and rights of man and stand at the cross-road from where, mankind took a definitive turn from the ‘Dark… A trained physician, Locke took to musing on socio-political questions in the Anthony A....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Best Form of Constitution: the Platonic and Aristotelian Discourses

This essay "the best form of Constitution: the Platonic and Aristotelian Discourse" discusses Plato's and Aristotle's idea of the best form of constitution.... This paper discusses Plato's and Aristotle's idea of the best form of constitution.... nbsp;Plato and Aristotle both identified what they believed as the best government or constitution.... lthough Aristotle had the same opinion with Plato about the best constitution, he studied the world pragmatically and hence identified the most sensible and ideal constitution....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Best Form of Governance

For example, Plato believes that a city should be ruled by philosopher-kings and the best form of government is a monarchy.... This work "the best form of Governance" describes why it is best for human beings to be governed rationally and explore the consequences of such a claim by looking into the works of three philosophers: Plato, Rene Descartes, and Albert Camus.... The author outlines that philosophers differ in the best form of governance and about the governors themselves....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Psychological Issues in Social and Political Philosophy

The following discussion will enumerate myriad different levels on which Marx and Plato differ from each other to illustrate the reality of this claim that “rule by the best reflects human ignorance and generates power relations in a society which leads to conflict and survival of the fittest.... This leads to the result that only the best or the fittest groups find it easier to survive and maintain a good life standard.... In contrast, Plato argued that an ideal society is that in which the political authority is granted to those who are the best or have the most power....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Role of Intuitions for Political Philosophy

The author of the paper titled "The Role of Intuitions for political philosophy" focuses on the role of intuitions for political philosophy.... hellip; political philosophy refers to philosophical thinking on how preferably humans can organize their lives in whole, rational political institutions, and logical social practices (Cartwright & Seta, 1996).... Notably, political philosophy traces its roots to ancient times among various communities and nations....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us