StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Drug Dilemmas in the United States - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Drug Dilemmas in the United States" describes that the non-life-saving drug, ranolazine should be included in the list of essential drugs because the objective of providing access is not limited to saving lives but to improving healthcare systems as well…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Drug Dilemmas in the United States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Drug Dilemmas in the United States"

1. What explains the high price of prescription medicines in the United s What if anything should be done about it Do you believe that U.S. drugprices reflect the operation of a fair and competitive market The high price of prescription medicines in the United States may be explained by the marketing and administration costs of pharmaceutical companies, aside from the cost of drug research and development of new medicines. Administration costs include expenses for applying for approval to market a new drug, setting up business offices and training the sales force, setting up a distribution system, training doctors to administer the drug, and monitoring patients who take them. Unfortunately, in a free market economy such as the United States, nothing can be done about it, except by government intervention through price regulation. Considering what Marcia Angell, former editor of the New England Journal of Medicine, said about how pharmaceutical companies spend enormous resources in developing "me-too" drugs simply to get a share of the market of a top-selling drug, there is reason to believe that U.S. drug prices do not reflect the operation of a fair and competitive market, rather, the pharmaceutical companies have somewhat cartelized themselves resulting in a monopoly of the drug pricing. 2. Given the nature of their product, do pharmaceutical companies have ethical responsibilities that other corporations don't have In your view, are the large U.S. drug companies good corporate citizens According to the Case Resource, many drug companies enjoy larger profit margins than other U.S. corporations. At the very least, and considering the nature of their product, this writer believes that pharmaceutical companies should take on the ethical responsibility of reasonably pricing their products, at least at the level of most corporations. It would be more ethical of course, for pharmaceutical companies to reduce their profit margins in order to make their drugs more available to a greater number of people. After all, the mission and vision of most drug companies is to "lead the way to a healthier world by providing products that improve lives" (Wyeth, 2008), or "we are here for the people we serve in their pursuit of healthy lives" (Abbott, 2008). However, in terms of corporate citizenship, drug companies would be thought of as good corporate citizens especially if they pay the government the correct taxes from all the revenues and profits they make. 3. Are the large drug companies guilty of price gouging or charging an unfair or exploitative price for their products In general, what factors should determine the price of drugs Should Americans be permitted to import drugs from Canada or other countries Whether or not large drug companies are guilty of price gouging or charging an unfair or exploitative price for their products is highly debatable. On the one hand, if the drug company sets its price at a profit level well beyond regular profitability standards for U.S. corporations, then the company would be guilty of price gouging. However, to determine such profit level, various factors would need to be taken into account and some of these factors may not be existent in other corporations, such as costs of compliance with government regulations considering that such regulations may be stricter in the health industry than in other industries. In general, factors that determine the price of drugs would be production costs, distribution costs, marketing costs, administration costs and other overhead costs such as R&D. This writer believes that Americans should be permitted to import drugs from Canada or other countries for that matter. If the cost of imported drugs is less expensive than U.S.-manufactured drugs, this would be very beneficial to Americans. Moreover, it would provide a natural check and balance for the pricing practices of the U.S. drug companies. 4. Do drug companies have an obligation to make new drugs available to patients who were involved in their development, either here or overseas Does the size of the company make a difference What would you do if you were Dr. Lange What obligations, ideals, and consequences should he take into account There is a very strong ethical argument to support the view that drug companies should have an obligation to make new drugs available to patients who were involved in their development either here or overseas. These patients put their lives and health at risk with the testing of the new drugs. It is but fair to have them benefit from the success of the tests. The size of the drug company doing the testing should not make a difference. However, especially if a foreign country was involved, early on, agreements should have also been made with the foreign government to provide privileges to the drug company in terms of reducing administration costs in the foreign country. Considering that Dr. Lange's company is small and can ill-afford distribution and administration costs, there must be a way for the foreign government to assist in the effort in order to make the new drug more easily available to its citizens. Dr. Lange should take into account his moral obligation to make the drug available to the people he used in developing his drug, his ideal of inventing a drug, such as ranolazine, which although non-life saving, reduces the number of angina attacks in half, making a chronic sufferer's life less miserable. The consequence of making the drug available to the people used during its development, is of course the huge expenses it will entail, which is why assistance from external sources such as both the American and foreign government would be necessary. 5. Is it ethical for companies to decline to sell a useful drug like ranolazine in a poor country because they can make more money marketing it elsewhere In this writer's opinion, it is not ethical for a company to decline to sell a useful drug like ranolazine in a poor country simply because more money can be made by marketing it elsewhere. At the very least, the company should be agreeable to selling the drug in the poor country and should solicit the assistance of external groups to make this possible. 6. When it comes to life-saving drugs, do pharmaceutical companies have a moral obligation to make them available in poor countries at little or no cost Explain why or why not What about effective but non-life saving drugs like ranolazine There have already been many efforts in the past related to how pharmaceutical companies make available life-saving drugs at little or no cost. Recognizing the importance of this issue, the World Trade Organization had organized a workshop of experts to explore questions about ensuring access to essential drugs at prices affordable in poor countries and adequate financing for this purpose, while providing adequate incentives for R&D into new drugs (WTO, 2001). The summary report says that there was common thinking that indeed, access to essential drugs must be ensured and that funding may have to be sourced from the international community. The non-life saving drug, ranolazine should be included in the list of essential drugs because the objective of providing access is not limited to saving lives but to improved health care systems as well. References Abbott. (2008). Our promise. Retrieved 4 December, 2008 from http://www.abbott.com/global/url/content/en_US/10.10:10/general_content/General_Content_00003.htm Case Resource. (n.d.). Drug dilemmas. Part 4 - Business and Society, Chapter 10 - Consumers, Case 10.4. World Trade Organization. (2001). WHO/WTO workshop on differential pricing and financing of essential drugs, HSBJR 2001. Retrieved 4 December, 2008 from http://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/trips_e/hosbjor_execsum_e.htm Wyeth. (2008). Mission, vision and values. Retrieved 4 December, 2008 from http://www.wyeth.com/aboutwyeth/whoweare/mission Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Drug Dilemmas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532772-drug-dilemmas
(Drug Dilemmas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532772-drug-dilemmas.
“Drug Dilemmas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532772-drug-dilemmas.
  • Cited: 4 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Drug Dilemmas in the United States

Drug Shortage in Pharmaceutical Industry

he prolonged shortage of the growing number of drugs is largely impacting the patients and the healthcare sector in the united states and all across the world.... ccording to the records of the FDA, the drug shortages in the united states have raised from 157 shortages in 2009 to 178 drug shortages in the year 2010.... This paper ''drug Shortage in Pharmaceutical Industry'' tells us that in the developed and advanced world of the present century, the pharmaceutical industry has grown just like the other manufacturing and service industry....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

International Legal and Ethical Issues in Business IP Week 4

There are legal barriers that control the entry of drugs to the market in the united states.... International Legal and Ethical Issues in Business Introduction The antitrust laws were put in place by the federal and state governments in united states to regulate businesses.... This paper will address legal barriers in introducing a new product to market and possible dilemmas.... It is estimated that pharmaceutical companies spend an average of $800-1 billion and between eight and sixteen years to research a new drug (Crandal & Clifford, 2003)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Ethical Dilemma in Smoking Marijuana

hile many states such as the united states have opposed any move to legalize this substance, other nations such as Jamaica have legalized its use in the public (Jabelle, 2013).... Many times in life, human beings are faced with situational dilemmas in which they have to follow one path and leave the other.... The paper "Ethical Dilemma in Smoking Marijuana" states that generally, the deontological theories suggest that the correctness of an action is determined by its ability to fulfill the absolute duties that each person has, either legal, divine, or moral....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Unit 5 IP introduction to law enforcement

The paper will take the form of a case study with regard to a local enforcement agency in a large city in the united states.... Most states have law enforcement agencies at the local, national and international level.... This paper discussed the factor of ethical dilemmas that could arise when such cooperative action takes place.... It can be seen that several ethical dilemmas like ego clashes, racism, operational procedures and corruption do exist in this case....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Marijuana Is One of the Most Famous Drugs

The banning of marijuana in the united states occurred in 1937.... Cannabis, popularly known as Marijuana is a drug that people use either for recreational or medicinal reasons.... Since its discovery in the 1920s, people had been using it majorly for recreational purposes until the 1970's when they started using it as a medicinal drug.... The paper will dwell on how people use this drug and whether it has advantages or otherwise....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Specifics of Drug Addiction

For instance, statistics from the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) show that there was a general decline in property crimes and drug-related violence in the last decade of the 20th century in the united states.... This paper will discuss the application of social orientation as a major theory of motivation towards solving drug addiction as a societal problem.... The study leads to the conclusion that social orientation must address the setting (also referred to as environment) in which drugs are abused or made available and how the community norms facilitate the shaping of drug use tendencies....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Ethical Dilemma Faced by Pfizer

An approving review would allow Pfizer to sell the drug in the united states, the world's largest market both for adults and children.... ut it was having trouble finding the sufficient number of sick children in the united states to test the drug on.... Given the hazards and outlay of developing a new drug, pharmaceutical companies will jump at opportunities to diminish them.... The drug development process is time-consuming, dicey and costly....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Drug Shortage in Pharmaceutical Industry

he prolonged shortage of the growing number of drugs is largely impacting the patients and the healthcare sector in the united states and all across the world.... ccording to the records of FDA, the drug shortages in the united states have raised from the 157 shortages in 2009 to 178 drug shortages in the year 2010.... This work "drug Shortage in Pharmaceutical Industry" describes drug shortage that the pharmaceutical industry is encountering these days....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us