StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Jerusalem One City, Three Faiths - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
For the past millennia, Jerusalem has been the site of contention and contestation. From the Crusades to the present times, countless lives have been lost in the quest to lay claim to this city. Whether Christian, Jew or Muslim, all believe in the sacred and holy nature of the city of Jerusalem but do so within the limits of their religious doctrine…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Jerusalem One City, Three Faiths
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Jerusalem One City, Three Faiths"

Download file to see previous pages

The converse holds true for the remaining religions and it is, thus, that the struggle over Jerusalem has persisted, unabated, across the centuries. Karen Armstrong's Jerusalem: One City, Three Faiths, substantially contributes to readers' understanding of the roots of this conflict, the reasons for its persistency and the extent to which the convergence of sacred space can be so, paradoxically, divisive instead of unifying. Armstrong offers readers a compelling and concise account of Jerusalem's rather complex, convoluted and complicated history.

Commencing with an overview of the concept of Zion and the rise of Ancient Israel she, quite interestingly concludes with the same. This circular, repetitive movement of history, is very telling. In the first place, that the end should coincide with the beginning indicates that the struggle over the city has locked the three monotheistic faiths together in a vicious cycle which has no foreseeable end. No matter who emerges as the victor in this struggle, the victory, at best, will be fleeting because it will not be interpreted by other parties to the conflict as the restoration of a legitimate right but the wresting away of their legitimate claim to Jerusalem.

Within the context of the stated, Armstrong's review of the different phases of the city's history and the violent conflict which brought each of these phases to its end and paved the way for a new one, takes on special meaning. Armstrong tells her readers, through irrefutable historical facts, that none of the monotheistic religions will be ever satisfied if they do not have political and theological dominion over this city. Needless to say, this is a rather disturbing scenario and is rendered even more so by Armstrong's contention that when Jerusalem was controlled by Moslems, even Islam's pluralist acceptance of other monotheistic religions was impotent in keeping the violent struggle for dominion over Jerusalem at bay.

It is quite paradoxical, as Armstrong repeatedly points out, that this city of peace should be the centre of warfare and violence; warfare and violence which even a pluralist acceptance of the rights of all monotheistic faiths to the city cannot contain.Jerusalem is, theoretically speaking, a city of peace which has been transformed into a site of slaughter in the name of religion. It is in this land where all three religions, according to Armstrong, converge in terms of holy space and where their Abrahamic roots and the commonality of their beliefs are emphasized.

All three religions are rooted, not just in the Abrahamic tradition but in Near Eastern philosophy where, according to Armstrong, "social justice and concern for the poor and vulnerable were crucial to the concept of sanctity" (28). Yet, this concern always managed to limit itself to members of the same religion and, in their struggle for dominion of the city, Jews, Christians and Moslems turned a blind eye to their similarities with the others and began to see the others solely in terms of adversaries.

Indeed, as further clarified by Armstrong, perceptions of the others and adversaries soon created schisms within each of these religions as its adherents turned upon one another:Now Jews had begun to kill one another for the sake of that land. All over the world, Jews struggled with the

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Jerusalem One City, Three Faiths Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
Jerusalem One City, Three Faiths Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1524907-jerusalem-one-city-three-faiths
(Jerusalem One City, Three Faiths Book Report/Review)
Jerusalem One City, Three Faiths Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1524907-jerusalem-one-city-three-faiths.
“Jerusalem One City, Three Faiths Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1524907-jerusalem-one-city-three-faiths.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Jerusalem One City, Three Faiths

The First Temple Period

The Temple built by Solomon in Jerusalem earmarks the First Temple Period (1000BCE- 586) although this had actually commenced with his father, King David, displacing the native inhabitant of Jerusalem, the Jebusites, and renaming the place as the city of David.... It is mentioned in the book that King David acquired control of the city of Zion.... At the start of the First Temple Period, when Jerusalem was ruled by King David and Solomon, people tended to be faithful to one and only one God, the God who had blessed Abraham and his descendents....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Introspection of Jerusalem

In the united Jerusalem, the freedom of worship and freedom of access for all three religions to the holy sites will be guaranteed, and it is the only way to guarantee that members of all faiths, minorities, and denominations can continue living here safely.... Israel's sovereignty over Jerusalem is a trivial matter for debate because everyone knows that this Holy city has been the capital of Jews and the place of Jewish worship since the early history of Judaism....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Analysis of Jerusalem Video by Peter Jennings

Thus, it could be argued that the video provided a balanced view on all three Abrahamic faiths (Jennings).... Jennings presented the three principal perspectives of Jerusalem.... According to Jennings, the Jews believe that the Western Wall is the holiest site on Earth and they hold the city of Jerusalem dear to their heart and would do anything to protect the city against invaders.... The video also explains the relevance of Jerusalem to the Muslims with historical evidence on the exploits of Muhammad (the central figure in Islam) in the city as he was believed to have ascended to heaven from the Dome of the Rock....
7 Pages (1750 words) Movie Review

The Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem

This literature review "The Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem" discusses a structure in the city of Jerusalem, a town that represents the Christian and Jewish faith.... However, the growth of other monotheist religions who believed that Jerusalem was the holy city influenced the decision of the prophet to change and begin paying pilgrimage to mecca.... As compared to the Hindu sacrifices and holy sessions in which women were not allowed to attend, the pilgrimage in the temple of jerusalem was attended every year by all irrespective of gender....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review

The Dome of the Rock: Jerusalem

It is therefore apparent that the Dome of the Rock is looked at in terms of its relationship with existing beliefs and the sacredness connected to it including the prevailing principle of Islam, Abrahamic faiths, Judaism, and Christianity.... This literature review "The Dome of the Rock: jerusalem" discusses the Dome of the Rock as the earliest existing Islamic monuments and occupies a position as the main architectural work of the Umayyads, which is connected with many Islamic beliefs including the miraculous Night Journey of the prophet....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review

Abrahamic Tradition and Prophet Abraham

The basic concept, moral values, and faiths of religion are the same as the Abrahamic Tradition, which deals with peace and humanity for a better future with cordial relations amid the people of every community.... The reason behind the three religions together was known as Abrahamic Tradition is related to the fact that history clearly identifies the traces of Abraham in the Hebrew Bible in the Israelite Culture.... The followers of the Abrahamic Tradition across the globe are huge as compared to other religions as the traditions reflect upon a few of the common facts followed in the three mareligionsion of the world as mentioned above....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework

Palestinian Claim to Jerusalem

The writer of the paper “Palestinian Claim to Jerusalem” states that the war between the Israelis and the Palestinians is the fight over the rightful ownership of Jerusalem as a critical and significant city.... While the Palestinians are just interested in the city for political reasons.... The Jewish colonization and the Palestinian nationalism is the main course of the raging conflict over Jerusalem because the Christians believe that the city has the religious significance as Jesus walked through the city and declared it holy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Similarities Between the Different World Religions

Other than having a belief in one God and having the same founding father, the three faiths agree that Moses was the true prophet of God.... The three faiths attach some value to Jerusalem even though their reasons might be different.... The way the three faiths choose to worship also displays some similarities.... Understanding the similarities is the right way to get rid of the strive and get to know more about faiths than we do....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us