StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

300 Years after Lear:Two Daughters,a Fathers Legacy,in Proof - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
As one generation ages and the next one prepares to assume its place, there are always tensions at work.These tensions can exist on multiple levels at once: there are the tensions between the generations…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
300 Years after Lear:Two Daughters,a Fathers Legacy,in Proof
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "300 Years after Lear:Two Daughters,a Fathers Legacy,in Proof"

Download file to see previous pages

Shakespeare's King Lear, nearing the end of his life, asked his three daughters each to demonstrate that they loved him more than the other two. While his two treacherous daughters eagerly compete, Cordelia, his faithful daughter, refuses to take part in the charade and, ironically, is banished as a result. Proof looks more at the interaction of two daughters who must decide how to handle their father's affairs; this movie takes place after the death of Catherine and Claire's father, Robert, who had been a groundbreaking mathematician at the University of Chicago until mental illness debilitated him.

Each of these daughters is flawed, which makes their interaction more intriguing, and makes deciding who is the more stable sister problematic. Claire went away to New York City and made a financial success for herself. Indeed, it is her success that pays the bills and affords Catherine the opportunity to live at her father's house with no other occupation than taking care of him. Catherine shares her father's brilliance at mathematics and made an early attempt at success outside his shadow, by enrolling at Northwestern to pursue her own studies.

However, once his illness made him unable to take care of himself, she immediately moved home to care for him. Because neither sister could be said to have been ideal in the situation, it becomes necessary for them to engage one another to make the best decisions for their father's affairs, and to move on as adults after their father's passing. A key element to an analysis of the two sisters is an examination of Catherine's mind. It is fairly clear that Claire wonders whether or not her sister has the same susceptibility to mental illness that her father suffered.

The way that Catherine responds to Claire's smothering shows that, even in her own mind, Catherine at times wonders about her own stability. Catherine's stumbling speech at her father's memorial service is an excellent example of events that plant that seed of doubt in her sister's mind. Clearly, Catherine is a woman of conflicted desires. Should she have abandoned her own immediate prospects for academic achievement by coming home and taking care of her father, or should she just have arranged for a nurse to look after him while she advanced professionally Is Hal someone that Catherine can ultimately trust with her heart, or is he simply a mathematical vulture, seeking to loot whatever academic treasures he can from her father's notebooks Catherine's troubled looks and faltering speech demonstrate the ambiguity that results from inner warfare (Ebert), and so this scene shows many of the troubling questions that remain for the two sisters to answer.

What will be next for Catherine - a caretaker of her own, or a return to independence Another scene that gives some key insight into Catherine's mind occurs after she sleeps with Hal. One of the problems that Catherine mulls over in her mind is to decide how much she can trust Hal. After the funeral party for her father, Catherine ends up in bed with Hal, and then ends up giving him a key to a drawer in her father's desk, which contains some of her father's last work: paperwork that may represent a revolutionary proof in the field of mathematics (hence the title of the movie), or it may be a pile of gibberish from the last ravings of a mentally ill man.

It may also be not just the work of Robert; Catherine may have collaborated on the work. This question of authorship is one of the central concerns of the film, as well. What makes this scene of particular interest is the

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“300 Years after Lear:Two Daughters,a Fathers Legacy,in Proof Essay”, n.d.)
300 Years after Lear:Two Daughters,a Fathers Legacy,in Proof Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1522329-300-years-after-leartwo-daughtersa-fathers-legacyin-proof
(300 Years After Lear:Two Daughters,a Fathers Legacy,in Proof Essay)
300 Years After Lear:Two Daughters,a Fathers Legacy,in Proof Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1522329-300-years-after-leartwo-daughtersa-fathers-legacyin-proof.
“300 Years After Lear:Two Daughters,a Fathers Legacy,in Proof Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1522329-300-years-after-leartwo-daughtersa-fathers-legacyin-proof.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF 300 Years after Lear:Two Daughters,a Fathers Legacy,in Proof

Salem witch trials

She has written several books on historical themes, including The British-Americans: The Loyalist Exiles in England, 1774-1789; Liberty's Daughters: The Revolutionary Experience of American Women, 1750-1800; Founding Mothers & fathers: Gendered Power and the Forming of American Society, which was a Pulitzer Prize finalist, and is a coauthor of A People and a Nation, etc.... As Norton points out, the crisis began with the visions of “two little girls living in the household of the Reverend Samuel Parris of Salem Village” of ghostly specters that caused them to suffer from fits, and gathered momentum during the next months with a growing number of accusers claiming “to be tortured by the apparitions of witches” and to have seen “the ghosts of dead people charging the witches with killing them” (Norton, 2003, p....
10 Pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review

Should Parents Get Involved Who We Marry and Who We Date

hen we sight the whole range of history and at hand human societies matrimony can be portrayed as a ethnically accepted relationships or a amalgamation of one man and one woman that is monogamy, of one man and two or more woman which is polyandry, there is cultural support of sexual contact amid the wedded partners of the conflicting and, generally, the anticipation that children will be bear of the affiliation (International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, 1977)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Issues Intestacy Shares under Sharia Law and California Probate Code

Some of these rules are founded on the Hanafi School of law.... Moreover, several of the rules are based on other schools of law, such as the takhayyur.... Furthermore, there have been instances, wherein the rules… One such example relates to the possibility to testate to legal heirs.... The situation obtaining can be understood as a trust that replicates the rights and limitations enjoined by the Sharia law of the country of domicile of the settler....
35 Pages (8750 words) Thesis

Principles of Family Law

The introduction of the requirement to prove that the petitioner must find it intolerable to live with the respondent after they have committed adultery seems to make a mockery of the law's traditional insistence that adultery was a serious matrimonial offence which required a high standard of proof3.... nbsp;  These include where the respondent has committed adultery and the petitioner finds it intolerable to live with the respondent; where the respondent has behaved in such a way that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent; where the respondent has deserted the petitioner for a continuous period of at least 2 years preceding the presentation of the petition; where the parties have lived apart for a continuous period of 2 years and the respondent consents to the petition; or the parties have lived apart for a continuous period of 5 years....
16 Pages (4000 words) Assignment

Should Parents Get Involved Who We Marry and Who We Date

This essay "Should Parents Get Involved Who We Marry and Who We Date" discusses consequences of parents not being concerned in choosing the one their children should date or marry and the reason that parents are so strained in choosing the partner/suitor for their child.... nbsp;… People should have the final say in matters regarding their own marriage or choosing someone as a date....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Emergence of the Western Civilization

An author of the assignment "The Emergence of the Western Civilization" seeks to discuss a list of historical events that played a major role in molding the social, political, and economical principles of Western civilization to the state that is commonly known today.... hellip; The rise of the modern states was pioneered by men who, to achieve their goals, set out to do the following: first, ensure the obedience of their subjects; second, wrest control of the economy of their respective states; third, divert the people's perspectives from the local to the national level, and; fourth, gain control of the religious life of the people....
23 Pages (5750 words) Assignment

Families in a Global Context

The middle class of US was finding it difficult to balance their budget without two paychecks.... The author concludes that the changes happening to the family structure are putting more and more physical and emotional pressure on women.... This can further lead to situations where childcare gets more and more problematic and the whole family system disintegrates....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Authors Perceptions and Beliefs about the Life

The paper "Author's Perceptions and Beliefs about the Life" focuses on the critical analysis of the author's perceptions and beliefs about his/her life.... nbsp;At the moment, when s/he looks back, s/he sees a whole life that is not very successful as s/he can't get what s/he used to like all his/her life....
56 Pages (14000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us