StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Direct Democracy in the US - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Direct Democracy in the US" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in direct democracy in the US. The electoral system in the US is such that there are only two political parties to the congress - the Democratic, and the Republican parties…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Direct Democracy in the US
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Direct Democracy in the US"

of the Direct Democracy. The electoral system in the US is such that there are only two political parties to the congress - the Democratic and the Republican parties. External funding is required to get candidates elected. The implication of this is that individual representatives must compromise their own values and those of the electorate, in order to conform to the party ideology. The change from one ruling party to another by the elected may cause governmental disruption and modification in laws. (Direct Democracy, Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia). In order to circumvent the drawbacks to fair and proper representation of the will of the people a new system of governance namely, the Direct Democracy has been propounded. Direct Democracy is a form of government in which all citizens can directly participate in the decision-making process. (Direct Democracy Campaign, Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia). Daniel B. Jeffs, founder, The Direct Democracy Center, states that the problems are due to the Government being too large and too dangerously powerful. He firmly believes that elected representatives are corrupted by a deeply flawed system that seduces them with money and power to gain and remain in office, or seek higher office and that in this process it has disenfranchised the overall electorate. Finally, he states that this system needs to be altered in such a way that it will override the practice of selective democracy by factions and vested interests. The solution according to him lies in nonpartisan elections and government with more democracy. In this age of communications and information technology, the Constitution should be amended so as to establish direct democracy by means of secure voting networks connected to voter's homes. All elections would be conducted over the voting networks. In this proposed system the elected representatives would be nonpartisan, highly qualified professional government managers. To keep it honest, with no more government than we need, well-informed voters should decide matters of taxation and public policy. And the collective judgment of our fellow citizens (which could be trusted because the direct democracy voting networks would require voters to be truthfully informed) would know what is best for all of us. (Daniel B. Jeffs, The Direct Democracy Center). The advantages of Direct Democracy are that first, it would remove the barrier between the electorate and the government. Secondly, in Representative Democracy the voter has to vote for one party or the other with no guarantee of either party addressing the issues facing the voter, on the other hand in Direct Democracy the voter will be voting on each issue separately. Thirdly, decisions will always be that of the people rather than that of a few politicians. Fourthly, it encourages people to be more proactive in the political process, this results in a more deterministic future for the voter. Fifthly, it curbs the power of the elite. Sixthly, the practice of elected representatives following the diktats of party leaders and civil servants to the detriment of the voter will cease. Seventhly, quid - pro - quo transactions between the elected representatives and the rich and powerful pressure groups will cease altogether. Eighthly, thorny and uncomfortable issues which elected representatives would do anything to avoid, will be addressed by this system. Ninthly, there would be control on governmental tendencies running towards the dictatorial. And finally, the system of Direct Democracy is more democratic. (Direct Democracy Campaign). The disadvantages of Direct Democracy are that: first, all citizens must be actively involved on all issues all of the time. For very large population groups, it might become well nigh impossible to do so. Secondly, the public generally gives only superficial attention to political issues and is thus susceptible to charismatic arguments. Thirdly, the decision of all or most matters by direct referendum will be a slow, expensive and a voter fatigue inducing exercise. (Direct Democracy). The present system of democracy obtaining in the US is the best. The most important aspect of this form of government is that of the principle of the separation of powers, wherein the Legislative, Executive and Judicial Powers are separated and entrusted to three different bodies. The theory of checks and balances is introduced in this system to safeguard individual liberty and to avoid concentration of power in any branch of the government. The threat to the US from its many detractors is not imaginary or negligible and over a period of time, its enemies have been emboldened by the lackadaisical response to their serious attempts to harm US interests. Adoption at this stage of a direct democratic system of governance, with its concomitant processes of referendums which take time to conduct, will prove disastrous as the US cannot afford to be slow in its actions or reactions. Therefore, at this crucial juncture it is inadvisable to opt for this form of government by the United States of America. In 1912, the Mississippi voters approved an Initiative and Referendum by a nearly two to one margin. This measure failed due to the state's requirement of super majority of all votes cast. In 1914 another attempt was made by I&R supporters through the legislature, and their attempt met with success. However, the State Supreme Court abolished the people's right to self-government by I&R in 1917. Subsequently, the power of initiative and referendum was granted to the citizens of Mississippi by the passage of Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 616 in the 1992 regular session. This initiative process is the most recalcitrant in the country and the two statewide initiatives made since 1992 were defeated. In this respect applicability of Direct Democracy has proved to be a failure. (Initiative & Referendum Institute at the University of Southern California, 2005). The Direct Democracy Centre was founded by Daniel B Jeffs is a fiercely independent voter and the author of America's Crisis: Democracy and Education, Letters to the Editor: From the Trenches of Democracy and three novels. Dan's passion for real democracy was a result of running for public office and writing the novel, Black Robes on White Horses, which gives a truly thought provoking account of the Supreme Court gaining absolute power in the US. His search for a solution to too much government and too little democracy resulted in founding the Direct Democracy Centre. This centre carries articles by writers who in the main oppose the present system of democracy. A lot of very interesting and important facts about the excesses committed by the government, in the name of national security and the like can be gleaned from this centre. (The Direct Democracy Centre, www.realdemocracy.com). References Direct Democracy, Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, 2006 Direct Democracy Campaign, http://www.homeusers.prestel.co.uk/rodmell/case Majority Rule is Good - Tyranny of the majority is nonsense, Daniel B. Jeffs, founder The Direct Democracy Center, http://www.realdemocracy.com Mississippi, Initiative & Referendum Institute at the University of Southern California, 2005 The Direct Democracy Centre, www.realdemocracy.com Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Direct Democracy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1520770-direct-democracy
(Direct Democracy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1520770-direct-democracy.
“Direct Democracy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1520770-direct-democracy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Direct Democracy in the US

Political Film Evaluation Project

the us electoral college voting is unique in the world, and is a control mechanism to avoid the reckless character of purely popular voting and not give Congress full power to select the President (History Central.... RECOUNT A POLITICAL MOVIE EVALUATION Submitted by FILM ANNOTATION The film Recount shows democracy in action during the 2000 U.... RECOUNT A POLITICAL MOVIE EVALUATION Submitted by FILM ANNOTATION The film Recount shows democracy in action during the 2000 U....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Democracy and Its Structure of Government

Direct Democracy It is that form of democracy in which all of the citizens of a political organization jointly make the decisions for that group.... Representative democracy in this form of democracy, people choose officials to represent their group and to make decisions on their behalf.... Example of a direct democracy is ancient Athens.... One of the main advantages of a direct democracy is that the citizens feel important and included in the matter....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Discussion on developmental Democracy

Particular attention is given to the democratic development model out of various models of democracy in the West.... Topic: Discussion on Developmental democracy Introduction The history of democracy is quite obscure, which is because it is a concurrent history and also because the there are no simple issues at stake.... It is taken in the interest of healthy democracy if democratic beliefs and practices leave a long lasting impression on the political, social, and economic life of the people....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Representative and Direct Democracy

The following essay entitled "Representative and direct democracy" explores the difference between mentioned concepts.... According to the text, representative democracy and direct democracy are two forms or systems of governance that both seek to govern people, establish law and ensure order.... The work at hand includes the relevant points linked to the actual differences between representative democracy and direct democracy.... This is a relevant feature of a direct democracy....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Direct Democracy in California

The essay 'direct democracy in California' is devoted to the examination of the history of democracy itself, of the direct democracy, how does it began and developed, and examines how does it work in contemporary in the state of California in the USA.... This paper illustrates the introduction of the notion of direct democracy in California State, unfolding its success and failures.... They have presented these thoughts to the society through the print and electronic media, as well as mass campaigns for direct democracy in activities that involve people of California directly or indirectly....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Modern Social Democracy

This report "Modern Social democracy" discusses modern social democracy that should not be perceived as being a socialist movement but a separate ideology and movement.... The term social democracy has been wrongly associated with a number of groups, which has spelled unfortunate consequences.... The argument today over globalization presents similar circumstances that led to the rise of democracy as a new ideology that would reconcile capitalism, democracy, and social benefit....
11 Pages (2750 words) Report

Direct Democracy as a Pipe-Dream - Sounds Good, But It Will Never Work

The author of the paper "direct democracy as a Pipe-Dream - Sounds Good, But It Will Never Work" will begin with the statement that direct democracy refers to the form of democracy where the people decide on policies directly by way of voting or forming a consensus (Atman, 2011, p.... direct democracy is opposed to the representative type of democracy where the people elect representatives to decide policies on their behalf.... Depending on a number of factors, the system of direct democracy might entail the use of sortition, the passage of executive decisions, making of laws, direct election of officials, and the conduction of trials....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Must Effective Democracy Be Limited to the Nation States

The paper "Must Effective democracy Be Limited to the Nation States?... According to Oxford advanced learner's dictionary, democracy is derived from two Greek words, 'demos' that is translated to mean 'people' and 'kratos' that translates into 'rule'.... It immediately follows that democracy is the 'rule by the people'.... The paper "Must Effective democracy Be Limited to the Nation States?... According to Oxford advanced learner's dictionary, democracy is derived from two Greek words, 'demos' that is translated to mean 'people' and 'kratos' that translates into 'rule'....
12 Pages (3000 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us