StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Major Questions in Legal Management - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The study "Major Questions in Legal Management" focuses on the critical analysis of the major questions in legal management. The case was heard in the New South Wales Supreme Court. The judge is named Rein, and Rein is an administrative judge as evidenced by the title AJ…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Major Questions in Legal Management
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Major Questions in Legal Management"

Assignment (Answers in Bold) Part A The following questions were answered based on the case of: Peter Smythe v Vincent Thomas [2007] NSWSC844 (3 August 2007) Available at: http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/nsw/supreme_ct/2007/844.html. Question 1: In what court was the case heard (1 mark) The case was heard in the New South Wales Supreme Court. Question 2: Name the judge and explain his title. (2 marks) The judge is named Rein, and Rein is an administrative judge as evidenced by the title AJ. Question 3: Name the plaintiff and defendant and their counsel. (4 marks) The plaintiff is Peter Smythe and the defendant is Vincent Thomas. The plaintiff's counsel is B. Kasep, and the defendant's counsel is D.M. Loewenstein. Course Profile for: LAWS11030, 2009 Term Two - Page 6 Question 4: What particular circumstances led Rein AJ to doubt the credibility of the defendant's version of events (3 marks) The defendant's version of events were not credible, especially with regard to the fact that, in the eBay auction, the defendant had not stipulated that the aircraft be inspected first by the buyer. Question 5: The defendant argued there was no binding and enforceable agreement, what were the components of this argument (4 marks) The defendant's argument was manifold-one part of which was that since the plaintiff had been removed as a user from eBay, there was no agreement. There were four additional pieces to this argument, that: 1) there was no direct contract between the plaintiff and defendant, but that they each had parallel contracts with eBay; 2) the eBay listing was nothing more than an advertisement, and not an auction; 3) the payment had yet to be agreed upon so there was no agreement; and 4) the plaintiff gave up his bidding rights by participating in the auction. Question 6: How is agreement reached in a traditional auction (2 marks) Whoever made the last bid before a candle burnt out won the auction1 (in Holland years ago) Question 7: What differences did Rein A J outline between a traditional auction and an on-line auction (5 marks) In a traditional auction: 1) there is an auctioneer2; 2) the auctioneer is the agent of the seller; and 3) the seller can at any time before the hammer is lowered withdraw his goods from the sale. Question 8: What did Rein A J regard in an eBay auction as the equivalent of the fall of the hammer in a traditional auction; and what is the significance of each (2 marks) The fall of the hammer in a traditional auction is complete when the auctioneer announces its completion by the fall of the hammer or in other customary manner-and until any such announcement is made any bidder may retract his or her bid. The equivalent of the fall of the hammer in an eBay auction is the automatic close of bidding at a fixed time and the generation of an eBay advice headed "won" appear to have been accepted by the parties to an eBay auction. Question 9: Why was an order for specific performance of the contract appropriate in this case (2 marks) An order for specific performance of the contract was appropriate because of two reasons: 1) the Wirraway was not at the time in flying condition, and 2) the plane was in a hangar owned by a third party. Question 10: Why was the final order not made in this hearing (1 mark) It was ruled that a binding contract was formed between the plaintiff3 and the defendant4 and that it should be specifically enforced.5 Further, the two parties would be given a chance to reach agreement on the precise nature of the agreement. Question 11: Why was the matter heard in the Supreme Court (4 marks) This matter was heard in the Supreme Court because the defendant kept appealing to higher courts when the decisions in lower courts were against him (i.e., not in his favour). TOTAL 30 Marks Course Profile for: LAWS11030, 2009 Term Two - Page 7 Part B McMuffins Ltd is a fast food company. Yesterday, before work had started, an argument arose between three kitchen hands: Tom, Dick and Harry. Over the weekend, Tom had offered to sell his motorbike to Dick for $5000. Dick said this was far too much but he would pay $4000. Tom refused. Before Tom left for work this morning Dick phoned to say he would buy the motorbike for $5000 but Tom said he had already sold it to Harry for $4,500. It was not a good day for Dick: he was one of the six employees of McMuffins Ltd that buy a weekly lottery ticket, each contributing an equal amount of money. Every week the money is collected by Lotty, the office junior, who also buys the lottery ticket. The group has always agreed to share any winnings equally. Lotty discovered this morning that the lottery ticket has won $1,000,000, and tells the other members of the group that she intends to claim the money for herself and leave McMuffins Ltd. Question 1: Has Tom reached an agreement (up to 150 words) (4 marks): [112 words] According to Tom, he has already sold the bike. If there is a bill of sale6 made out to Harry, the bike has technically already been sold. However, if there is no evidence in writing that a transaction7 has taken place, nor record of any cash having exchanged hands (i.e. evidence of a transaction). So, technically the motorbike is still not sold, therefore it would be reasonable for Tom to take Dick's new offer of $5000. Even if Tom and Harry had a verbal agreement8, that is still not enough to stand up in court. Dick could technically still buy the bike from Tom because verbal agreements are not legally binding contracts. Question 2: Is Lotty obliged to share the lottery winnings amongst the group (up to 250 words) (6 marks): [140 words] Lotty is obliged to share the lottery winnings amongst the group. Although the group only had a verbal agreement that all the office members of McMuffins Ltd would share in the winnings should they strike it rich, there was a monetary transaction which took place in which Lotty took shares of money from each of the office members to donate to the lottery pot in order to purchase the ticket. Therefore, since there are witnesses to provide testimony that they each paid into the lottery pot, there would be enough evidence9 available to prove that Lotty was not the sole owner of the ticket. The winnings would be divided accordingly with respect to whom paid how much for the ticket and, consequentially, what share10 each office member would have in the million dollars' worth of winnings. This is only fair. TOTAL 10 MARKS REFERENCES Dictionary.Com Website, 2009. Definition of "Agreement." [Online] Available at: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/agreement. [Accessed 24 Aug 2009]. Dictionary.Com Website, 2009. Definition of "Auction." [Online] Available at: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/auction. [Accessed 24 Aug 2009]. Dictionary.Com Website, 2009. Definition of "Auctioneer." [Online] Available at: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/auctioneer. [Accessed 24 Aug 2009]. Dictionary.Com Website, 2009. Definition of "Defendant." [Online] Available at: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/defendant. [Accessed 24 Aug 2009]. Dictionary.Com Website, 2009. Definition of "Contracts." [Online] Available at: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/enforcement. [Accessed 24 Aug 2009]. Dictionary.Com Website, 2009. Definition of "Evidence." [Online] Available at: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/evidence. [Accessed 24 Aug 2009]. Dictionary.Com Website, 2009. Definition of "Plaintiff." [Online] Available at: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/plaintiff. [Accessed 24 Aug 2009]. Dictionary.Com Website, 2009. Definition of "Sale." [Online] Available at: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/sale. [Accessed 24 Aug 2009]. Dictionary.Com Website, 2009. Definition of "Share." [Online] Available at: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/share. [Accessed 24 Aug 2009]. Dictionary.Com Website, 2009. Definition of "Transaction." [Online] Available at: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/transaction. [Accessed 24 Aug 2009]. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case study Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502129-case-study-case-study
(Case Study Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502129-case-study-case-study.
“Case Study Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502129-case-study-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Major Questions in Legal Management

Reflective statement for previous case study Nestle

PESTEL is one such tool that helped in understanding the external factors influencing the organization on one hand and also to analyse the political, economical, sociological, technological, environmental and legal factors in a particular nation (Johnson, Scholes & Whittington, 2009, p.... 8) The case study focussed on a lot of marketing issues, the nature of the case study and its questions helped in analysing each of the components separately and finally generating a conclusive argument which is analogous with the tangram analogy shown in the figure above....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Police administration 2 questions

Consequently, a mayor has disciplinary obligations besides their management duties.... Similarly, a high school principal acts as a representative of his school in social, legal and government related meetings.... Indeed, a police chief draws his influence from legal obligations bestowed on him by the state.... Police Administration 2 questions Date Police Administration 2 questions Question 1 The American Bar Association has recognized the position of police chief as being among the most important and most demanding positions in the hierarchy of government officials....
4 Pages (1000 words) Coursework

Arthur Anderson' Management

This need for continuous top management and other levels of management participation and support in such programs is reinforced by four separate studies on establishing and implementing social responsibility programs (Ringle, 2002).... For Arthur Anderson, establishing and implementing a program was not a simple process and required continued top management involvement (Friedman, 1970).... When the course of action was decided upon, then detailed plans for necessary management activities were developed, such as basic tactics, sequences, and timing; organization; allocation of resources; staffing; directing and controlling; evaluation; and, if appropriate, provisions for recycling the project....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Major Questions in Law

The essay "major questions in Law" focuses on the critical analysis of the issues on the main questions in law.... Most of the characteristics commonly linked to English law and its management of righteousness are traceable to the early growth in Western Europe of the civil and common law customs.... The main feature of the English legal system is that it is living and constantly evolving to work in the future as well as it did in the past.... hus the single most unique feature of the English legal system is its inheritance from common law....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Challenges and responses in housing management

Housing management is basically the proper management of all these aspects.... This dissertation will mainly focus on the challenges that are faced during the In addition to that the dissertation will also include the responses that the housing management system or process have received.... The main objective of this research will be to identify and analyze the challenges that the housing management system or process have been facing throughout the world....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Discussion Board Questions 2

This way, each of the stakeholders will feel part and parcel of the process an aspect that will create mutual relationship not only among the top management team but also among the employees.... Question 4To avoid legal difficulties during the initial selection decisions, organisations should provide potential employees with adequate and reliable messages.... In this way, job applicants will be in a better position to make decisions without seeking legal support thus avoiding the employers from incurring expenditures to pursue legal cases....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

External Forces in the Market

Contemporary management.... olitical, legal and economic forces shape a nation's culture since these forces are the major Business questions Question1a It is important for managers to understand the external forces in the market as they depend on the environment for inputs and in the long run, outputs (Jones & George, 208).... Question1b Political, legal and economic forces shape a nation's culture since these forces are the major determinants of what is legal in a country and what is not....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Separate Legal Entity, Limited Liability and Criminal Responsibility of Company

Company law includes the body of legal rules relating to the creation, management, financing and operation of companies.... It is the name given to the body of legal rules relating to the creation, management, financing and operation of companies.... The paper describes the various status of companies, like separate legal entities, limited liability, and criminal responsibility which has been contributed a number of recognition for English law, by which a company, as well as its members, possess some rights and liabilities....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us