StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Handmaids Tale by Margaret Atwood - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
This book review analyzes the famous novel The Handmaid's Tale, that was written by Margaret Atwood and made an interesting pronouncement which has been debated in the field of knowledge for several decades and has vital application in the Theory of Knowledge - "Context is all." …
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
The Handmaids Tale by Margaret Atwood
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Handmaids Tale by Margaret Atwood"

"Context is all" (Margaret Atwood). Does this mean there is no such thing as truth In her famous novel The Handmaid's Tale Margaret Atwood makes an interesting and essential pronouncement which has been debated and discussed in the field of knowledge for several decades and has vital application in the Theory of Knowledge - "Context is all." An important subsequent question of this important statement by Atwood which has great bearing in an understanding as well as analysis of the major knowledge issues is whether this declaration means that there is no such thing as truth. While attempting to answer the question, it is important to realize the terms context and truth. Whereas the term context may refer to something that encircles a particular incident or situation and that can change its meaning, truth is a difficult term to define. Truth may be comprehended as the reality behind the specific situation in question and it is commonly believed that there is no one truth, but only truths. In fact, the question under discussion is challenging and any inquiry into this essential pronouncement requires much thought and contemplation in relation to the concept of truth. In opposition to the common belief that truth is subjective and entirely associated with context, one cannot conclude too effortlessly that context is all. In reality, one can hardly determine things as truth or fallacy due to context and the various theories of truth seem to be conflicting on the issue of context. Thus, it is important to consider that mass acknowledgment or recognition of an idea determines if it is truth or falsity. According to N M F Smith, who made a reflective analysis of the question, it is vital to comprehend both these concepts exactly and he defined context as the set of realities or circumstances needed to comprehend different things. "To fully grasp any one thing or idea, its context must be understood in terms of the way any viewpoint is informed by the perceptual, language, reasoning and emotional milieu in which the knower operates. Truth may be defined as a simple accordance with reality. Like context, however, truth too is a function of the impact of the ways of knowing on the knower. However, in order for the idea of truth to integrate more seamlessly with that of context, one might make the claim that the more about a given thing or idea's context that is understood, the more inherently true that thing becomes." (Smith) Therefore, Atwood's argument that context is all may, principally, be comprehended as correct as the object of truth in any significant scope of knowledge or existence mostly on the context. In other words, the context of an idea or thing has the most important role in determining the truth of the same idea or thing and the knowledge issues can be understood only in the context of the truth. In the background of the 'Theory of Knowledge', one can assume that truth is contextual and the process of contextualization is the basic activity in the process of finding truths of ideas and things. Only human beings who are able to think and reflect on the reality of things can determine the truth and falsity of ideas and things. Truth, according to John Dewey, is also determined by the human interests, which means that context is important in understanding truth. "Nothing in the world, no object or event, would be true or false if there were not thinking creatures. John Dewey drew two conclusions: that access to truth could not be a special prerogative of philosophy, and that truth must have essential connections with human interests. He was contemptuous of the philosophical tradition that viewed truth as correspondence between thought and a reality inaccessible to experimental research and ordinary practice." (Davidson, 8) According to Dewey, such a view of the philosophers was designed to prove that the philosophers have superior way to comprehend truths which neglects scientific means. The theories of truth, including the correspondence theory, seem to substantiate the idea that context is vital in determining truth. The agreement and correspondence of idea and fact can be understood as truth and an idea becomes true when it leads one to what it claims. The problem that the pragmatists have been addressing - the problem of how to connect truth to human desires, beliefs, intentions, and the use of language - can help one in determining what truth is in relation to context. "To see this as a main problem about truth, or indeed as a problem at all, is to assume that the concept of truth is related in important ways to human attitudes - something it is not uncommon to doubt." (Davidson, 9) The concept of truth is determined by several different factors in one's life and there is fundamental connection between truth and context. On the basis of the definitions of both the concepts, the degree of clarity of an idea's context is closely linked to the ways in which the reality of the idea is comprehended. Thus, the connection between truth and context is primary in the 'Theory of Knowledge'. It is indubitable that, in the framework of the given definitions of context and truth, there is essential connection between the ways in which the reality of a particular object is understood and the degree of clarity of its context. Smith gives an important example to argue that there is essential relationship between context and truth and he mentions the example in art, "where the context of a work's creation has enormous effect on the meaning of the piece to its recipient. George Orwell's Animal Farm is ostensibly a simplistic narrative about animals and their life on a farm. Only with some knowledge of the writer and the book's background and historical setting can we appreciate that it is in fact a satirical allegory of soviet totalitarianism and a critique of Stalinist rule. The more that is seen then of an object's surroundings and situation, the truer and more real that object becomes." (Smith) However, the context of an object has basic connection to its setting. Therefore, in the perspective of an individual, the supposed reality of any idea or thing is intensely interconnected with his background. In other words, the personal truth, rather than universal truth, has a major role in this context as it changes the role of context as well as truth. To illustrate this idea, N M F Smith provides an illumining example of the reality concerning the keyboard of a computer. One can see the keyboard with one's eyes, while sensing the keys with the fingertips and hearing the sound of each key with the ears. As he is able to perceive that the keyboard is in existence, it becomes a reality to him. "Furthermore, if I only knew there was a computer in front of me, and I could not perceive it, I could still deduce the presence of the keyboard simply because of my previous knowledge that keyboards accompany computers. My perception of the existence of the keyboard as a finite, inanimate object then can be attributed to my personal knowledge of computers as well as to my ability to recognize the keyboard in a variety of ways So then context is largely determined by socio-historic background and location." (Smith) In the general framework of the ways of knowing, which include language, reason, emotion and perception, context is interrelated with truth and the various areas of knowledge, such as science, history, etc, depend on context to determine the truths of things and ideas. However, the idea of context brings about several issues connected with the ways of knowing and context has been comprehended as a limited kind of relativism. When the truth lies in the middle of swamp uncertainty, the validity of the truth is questioned. In other words, the ways of knowing depend on context, but there is uncertainty about the context itself. According to Ben-Ami Scharfstein, there is no real relevance to the truth that knowing depends on context when we try to ascertain a context that we sink into doubts. He purports that we normally accept the idea of context without any question. However, we do so only because we do not follow it very extreme. "We do not see that dependence on context is a limited kind of relativism and that relativism, looked at philosophically, is hard to limit. We seem to feel that the idea of context is clear, stable, and sufficient and does not need qualifications or a context of its own. Because context is most often used in literary study, history, and social science, it is not analyzed as closely as the standard philosophical questions, such as that of relativism itself. The price paid is intellectual slackness because to neglect to see where the idea leads is as intellectually unjustified as to neglect to use it." (Scharfstein, 59) In other words, if the truth of an idea of knowledge is comprehended in the context of the idea, there is a possibility that the idea is not consistent and the truth about this idea is not reliable. Language, reason, emotion and perception are the major ways of knowing the various ideas and concepts, four areas entwine with the 'areas of knowledge' such as science, history, etc. A profound understanding of the major ways of knowing can be useful in comprehending the connection between truth and context. Thus, linguistics or the language element makes the understating of an idea greatly complicated. That is to say, an object or an idea is understood by an individual in the context of a particular language. For example, my understanding of the term 'pen' is limited by my understanding of English and this particular term is meaningful to me merely for the reason that it has a reference in English which is the language I am acculturated to understand. The truth concerning the object 'pen' is meaningful to me in the context of the language I use. Similarly, reason, emotion and perception also determine my knowledge about realities. Smith points out, "I have very little emotional connection to my keyboard. I know nothing about it through how I feel towards it on a sentimental level. So then, the keyboard - whose reality I can clearly perceive and reason - is still limited by emotion and language, both ways of knowing context. One example of this contextually born limitation is detachment or disassembly." (Smith) Therefore, the truth behind an object or idea can only be understood in the context of one's language, reason, emotion and perception. Here, it is important to consider the meaning of truth and there is deep-seated connection between absolute truth and the context. Absolute truth about a thing, situation, or event occurs only when a specific context corresponds with the reality. In fact, context is everything and it has an important relevance on truth. Therefore, truth is undividable from context. "This has two larger implications. First, that there are no independently true truths; and second, that if there are absolute truths, they depend on a context that is equally absolute The ideas of truth, context and their complex intermingling forge a dynamic relationship in which neither entity could exist without the other. The more contexts are known about a given truth, the truer it ultimately becomes." (Smith) In conclusion, Margaret Atwood's pronouncement that "Context is all" has an important bearing in the theory of knowledge and it is indubitable that there is essential connection between truth and context. A reflective analysis of the ways of knowing, which include language, reason, emotion and perception, illustrates the vital connection between truth and context. Every idea or object is understood as truth in the context it is presented and a truth is understood more exactly as the context becomes more known. One's context with regard to language, reason, emotion and perception determines the truth presented in these means. Therefore, Atwood's declaration about the importance of context in realizing the truth of ideas and objects has a serious bearing in various areas of knowledge such as science, history etc. Works Cited Davidson, Donald. Truth and Predication. Harvard University Press. 2005. P 8. Scharfstein, Ben-Ami. The Dilemma of Context. New York: New York University Press. 1991. P 59. Smith, N M F. "Context is All." Socyberty. Stanza Ltd. 2008. 10 May, 2009. . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Handmaids Tale by Margaret Atwood Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1505473-the-handmaids-tale-by-margaret-atwood
(The Handmaids Tale by Margaret Atwood Book Report/Review)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1505473-the-handmaids-tale-by-margaret-atwood.
“The Handmaids Tale by Margaret Atwood Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1505473-the-handmaids-tale-by-margaret-atwood.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Handmaids Tale by Margaret Atwood

The Handmaid's Tale

In margaret atwood's work, the narrator states that “We yearned for the future” (4).... Then, both the handmaids walk towards a checkpoint guarded by two young Guardians.... The Handmaid's tale Summary: In the opening of the novel, the narrator (Offred) portrays her confined life in a gymnasium....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

A Comparison of Margaret Atwoods The Handmaids Tale and Zadie Smiths White Teeth

hellip; As such, for purposes of this brief essay, the author will examine the following two works of fiction and draw inference as to the ways in which narrative structure and imagery are utilized to compound the thematic nuances that their respective authors are attempting to engage the reader with: margaret atwood's The Handmaid's Tale and Zadie Smith's White Teeth.... atwood's character, Offred, is one which experiences the stifling effects of a male patriarchy and chauvinist dominated religious society....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Critica/Scholarlyl Analysis of Margaret

Critical/Scholarly Analysis of Margaret The Handmaid's Tale is an anti-utopian novel that was written by margaret atwood during the early 1980s in Alabama and West Berlin.... hellip; The role of the handmaids is to unwillingly provide children to infertile women who belong to the higher social class.... The protagonist, Offred, who accepts the handmaid's role, appears as a “wimp” (atwood, 122) compared to Ofglen, Moira, and Offred's mother....
3 Pages (750 words) Term Paper

Comparison of the Handmaids Tale and 1984

Abstract This critical study looks at the major themes in the book, the Handmaid's tale by margaret atwood and 1984 by George orwell.... b) Comparison of the handmaids tale and 1984 The handmaid's Tale is more of a science fiction novel that depicts a dystopian way of life.... The same issues are found in the handmaids tale.... The same issues are found in the handmaids tale, where people and especially women are monitored everywhere (Orwell)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Towards a Greater Understanding of Margaret Atwoods A Handmaids Tale

This essay discusses margaret atwood's novel "A Handmaid's Tale".... … margaret atwood presents the fictional story of a woman trapped in a post-modern world of strict social structure based upon a religious ideology and patriarchal worldview.... While a reading of "A Handmaid's tale" is illuminating in many ways regarding the silence of women these ideas become more clear, emphasizing the details that work to erase Offred's identity and existence, reduce her to little more than an object and detract from the entire society in so many ways....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Role of Women in The Handmaids Tale, by Margaret Atwood

The novel explores the various ways in which women were silenced in the fictional world of atwood's creation, but also in the similarly restrictive world of the past.... n her novel, atwood presents the fictional story of a woman trapped in a post-modern world of strict social structure based upon a rigid Puritan-like religious ideology and a patriarchal worldview reminiscent of the middle ages.... The paper states that the reading of A Handmaid's tale is illuminating in many ways regarding the silence of women by emphasizing the details that work to erase Offred's identity and existence, reduce her to little more than an object, and detract from the entire society in so many ways....
8 Pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review

How and why is a social group represented in a particular way

margaret atwood is one of those who have heavily supported the balance between men and women and have represented women perfectly through her… In her writings, she has heavily supported the rights of women in the male-dominated society.... The point to be noted is that the leading characters of her novel who happen to be In this writing, the emphasis will be on margaret atwood's literary writing of The Handmaid's Tale, as well as on the way Atwood has supported and written against the balace bwteen the two genders....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Handmaids Tale Written by Margaret Atwood

“Offred in the handmaids tale is victimized by a totalitarian system that attempts to control her thoughts and deny her humanity”.... The Handmaid's Tale written by a Canadian author named margaret atwood is a work of science fiction set in a not-too-distant future, where an oppressive… The totalitarian regime affects people's lives, particularly women, who are subjugated and deprived of their rights and freedom.... Because of the declining birth rates, the oppressive puritan government of Gilead focuses on increasing its population by recruiting handmaids to repopulate the state....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us