StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Observation of Australian Court - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Observation of Australian Court" discusses that the Australian courtroom has confines of procedural attributes that promote justice. He noted that most courtrooms are characterized by an overpowering number of designs of the courtroom and sitting arrangement that results in injustice…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Observation of Australian Court
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Observation of Australian Court"

The court demonstrates great power relation in the exercise of its jurisprudence, this is symbolized by the setting of its procedures, the architecture of the courtroom, the procedures, and the presentation of oneself from the judges to the defendants. This is illustrated as stated below:
The Architecture: this comprises the structure of the courtroom about the power relationships within the courtroom, the judge's position was raised above the rest the depicting high authority of the judge towards the other members. This does not accommodate equal power distribution among the participants. The fundamental architecture design of the courtroom, complimented by precisely calculated use and placement of furniture, did not accommodate equal power distribution among all courtroom participants (Carlen, 1976, pg50). Instead, such architectural features awarded the presiding judge with the position with the most superior power (Carlen, 1976, pg50).

The judge's place was elevated making the defendant inferior to the judge, the judge's dock was the highest positioning of the courtroom having it also centrally placed, ritualizing the judge's position as equal and non-partisan to any side. The defendant's dock was placed isolated with a police officer standing beside the dock this showed the position of defense as the case was to proceed. The furniture in the courtroom is set so that the occupants are facing and focused on the witness box which is placed at a lower level than any other furniture item allowing all the members of the courtroom to have a clear focus on the witness (Greenberg, 1976, pg87). Arguably, while looking down upon the defendant extents intimidation to witness, which makes them understand their position in the power hierarchy of the courtroom ensuring clear consciousness of the need to comply with the laid down system of the will and codes of the court.

The presentation: the judge's presence was followed by a peculiar silence depicting authority, on arrival on his docket the judge ordered all the people to rise, this was followed by addressing the attorneys of both the plaintiff's side and the defendant's side. This illustrated the authority of the judge. The judge's and the attorney’s rhetoric have shown some high-level legal discourse in the manner of speech in the courtroom (Smith, 2005, pg125). The complex, academic, and highly formal speeches were directed to each other by the attorneys and the judge. The legal representative's fluency in employment and comprehension of legal discourse reflected their background in tertiary education
The judge's physical appearance which is merely a manifestation of his attire is typical, a black gown with a white collar, and a white curly wig. The police and the bailiffs will also wear uniforms which distinguishes them from the other people present in the courtroom. This demonstrates their roles and authority levels (Rapoport, 1982, pg43). The length of turns of the occupants of the courtroom, as they participate in the proceedings of the court, showed the power hierarchy in the set system of the court. The judge and the attorneys gave lengthy speeches as the trial was being introduced and later and the end of the trial displays their higher status in terms of authority over the witnesses and the jurors in the courtroom.

When the attorney issued asking questions, which are made up of slightly more or just a lesser number of statements, this transcript questions and statements to the witness with only the witness contributing statements to the interrogation (Carlen, 1978, pg97). This is a clear indication of the authority of the lawyer over the witness since; the lawyer asks the questions while the witness is compelled to answer them without the ability to ask him, this power is unidirectional from the lawyer to the witness with no otherwise. This also shows the willingness of the witness to cooperate with the code of conduct of the court by only answering questions and challenging and trying to have the ability to question the lawyer or attorney (Rapoport, 1982, pg67). The questions asked by the lawyer in the interactions were a matter of answering with no or yes answers establishing the lawyer’s authority further as opposed to explanatory answers, which are lengthy. The questioning of this nature allows the Lawyer to be in a position to control the direction the examination takes; this will gloss the information, which was likely to be brought up.

Conclusion
In conclusion, the courtroom is a social setting that is highly structured and its operations have been ritualized this is because their certain norms and rules that one is required to adhere to such as standing as the judge enters the courtroom and addressing him/her as ‘your honor’. The atmosphere is also very reserved with modest dressing, and people conduct themselves properly and respectfully. This is repeated in every other trial making ritualized and the power hierarchy is defined and demonstrated. This language is used by emphasizing the separation, exclusion, and manipulation of questions. In essence, this means that the language used in the courtroom intimidates the inferiors such as defendants and lawyers. Moreover, this language aims at causing fear and stress to the defendant. Moreover, defendants who are not familiar with courtroom structure can be intimidated and remain passive. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Court observstion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1638745-court-observstion
(Court Observstion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1638745-court-observstion.
“Court Observstion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1638745-court-observstion.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Observation of Australian Court

Assessment Two: Unit Plan Details

ultural construction important to discuss in Australia's present educational system is that it has been born in the formation and nature of australian schooling.... Today there is evidence to show that indigenous culture has a role to play in the formation and nature of australian schooling.... Indigenous Australians are the original inhabitants of the australian continent and nearby islands.... According to the australian Institute of Health and Welfare (2006), 'As of 30 June 2001, the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander population of Australia was estimated to be 458,500, or 2....
13 Pages (3250 words) Assignment

Family Court of Western Australia

The paper describes an innovative Pilot Project of the Family court of Western Australia.... court Officials and Counselling Service Staff of the court gained new insights and skills in these very complex scenarios of family break-ups and litigation.... The need to liase more closely with internal as well as outside service providers, such as counsellors, social workers, psychologists, and other experts, brought a greater feeling of common purpose and it was soon clear that a potential model of an integrated family court system was beginning to emerge....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Government of South Australia

(2) In the case, Thad had to face a rather huge loss, on account of the unauthorized earthmoving operation of Bobette, as he lost the highly lucrative offer from australian Conservation Council.... The following assignment "Government of South Australia" concerns the law system of South Australia....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Ecologically Sustainable Development and the Australian Court

It will take into consideration the role of the court for workable solutions as suggested by Brian Preston, Swearing-In Chief Judge of the Land and Environment court of New South Wales.... The author of this paper tries to present how the international concept Ecologically Sustainable Development (ESD) has taken a root locally with the articulation on the precise mechanisms for the translating laudable principles into specific actions....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

The Australian and the US Healthcare System

Much of the funding according to the observation of Hall (1999: 8 (8): 653-660) is not equitably distributed to service publicly funded healthcare instead much of it goes to service the private health insurance premiums.... The goals and objectives that politicians deliver towards a sustainable healthcare system are not translated into actions and amount to strategies to court the voters.... The paper "The australian and the US Healthcare System " is an outstanding example of a health sciences and medicine literature review....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

Observations of Realist Hans Morgenthau

According to Adeney, Elizabeth, 'Australia's first moral rights decision: A critical approach to Meskenas v ACP Publishing', (2008) 19(2) australian Intellectual Property Jornal 7, Realism still remains the fundamental and most controversial perception of the international politics; the meaning of realism has been explained by one of the most realists of modern times.... he discussions on the australian Copyright Council, Digital Agenda Amendments: A Discussion Paper (2001), illustrates that Professor Hans Morgenthau in his new edition highlights that most comparative analysis should not only engage in the study of non-Occidental systems but also give attention to greater influences caused on non-Occidental systems....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Observing Court Proceedings

The assignment "Observing court Proceedings" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in observing court proceedings.... The position of each court in the court hierarchy determines the type of case that it is going to handle.... I attended a Paramatta Local court.... It is the lowest-ranked court hierarchy in Queensland below the Supreme court of Queensland District and the court of Queensland....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

Kahn-Freunds Observation, Salomon v Salomon

In this essay, the validity of this observation in light of the current state of australian corporations' law is presented.... Throughout the essay, it is argued that in light of the current state of australian corporations' law, Kahn-Freund's observation that the principle of separate legal entity was 'calamitous', is no longer valid.... The paper 'Kahn-Freund's observation, Salomon v Salomon" is a great example of a law case study.... The paper 'Kahn-Freund's observation, Salomon v Salomon" is a great example of a law case study....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us