StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Obligations under a Contract - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper 'Obligations under a Contract' focuses on the issue in respect of consideration, whether existent acts stipulated within a contract can act as good consideration. Consideration has been developed by English law so as to determine the legal enforceability of a contract…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Obligations under a Contract
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Obligations under a Contract"

Contract Law The issue in respect of consideration, whether existent acts stipulated within a contract can act as good consideration and past consideration. Consideration has been developed by English law so as to determine legal enforceability of a contract. McKendrick states that the purpose of consideration is to give the ‘badge of enforceability’ to agreements. Currie v. Misa1 defined the concept of consideration whereby it was said that consideration revolves around the concept of benefit to the promissor, or detriment to the promisee, thus the requirement is mutually exclusive. An important principle is that consideration must be sufficient and need not be adequate that is it must be something which the court would consider to be legally capable of constituting consideration. (Thomas v. Thomas)2 The position in respect of existing obligations under a contract and whether they can act as good consideration will now be discussed. One of situation is the one where variation of existing obligations under a contract between the parties occurs.The principle has been modified but the extent to which such modification applies remains unclear. The long established principle in respect of variation of terms and promises in that respect was that of Stilk v. Myrick3whereby it was a long accepted principle that if there was an existing contractual obligation it could never be relied upon that is it could not as good consideration for a fresh promise with the person to whom the existing obligation was owed.. The decision of Stilk and it being good law is doubtful after the case of Williams v Roffey Brothers4the facts of the case were that carpenters, plaintiff, while doing their work, asked the defendants for additional amount of money to finish the work even though they were no doing anything more than what they were already obliged to do. After completion of the work the defendants refused to pay the plaintiff. The main argument that was put forward was that there had been no consideration for the defendants’ promise to pay the additional amount and the decision of Stilk and its application would lead to the promise being construed unenforceable. However, the Court of Appeal found that that plaintiff’ could recover the promised payments for completion of work of the flats, the Court gave a broader meaning to consideration than what had been previously given. The reasoning of Glidewell LJ in particular referred to the point of ‘practical benefits’ which were likely to have accrued to the defendants as a result of them paying the additional promised amount of money, these were that such a promise ensure that the plaintiffs stayed and continued work thus the contract was completed; the defendants avoid the penalty clause which they were bound to pay under a separate contract with the owners of the block of flats; and finally the defendant avoided the trouble and expenses that would have accrued for finding other carpenters so as to get the work completed. The decision has been criticized because of its resemblance to the facts of Stilk where practical benefits that had been derived as well. Thus the only difference that has been seen in respect of both the cases is there was no pressure put on the defendants in Williams so as to get an offer for additional payment. Thus the effect of such a promise of additional payment and work which is done in response to such a promise, which has already been contracted to can be enforced if it is done in response to a promise. Glidewell LJ provided for the circumstances of practical benefits and emphasized that there need not be economic duress and fraud; however, it has been argued that the courts would not be restricted to the criteria laid down in his judgment. In respect of the current situation at hand it can be seen that Angela is that Philip in no way pressurized Angela and she offered the additional payments and derived the benefits stipulated in Williams and so she would be liable to pay the additional 400 and cannot refuse to do so as per the decision of Glidewell LJ. In respect of the situation of Colleen the principle of Currie and Thomas need to be applied whereby it needs to be determined whether the complaints would constitute to be good consideration. In respect of the situation it can be said that this would be considered to be sufficient and so the courts would allow Collen to claim the payments as she has stopped complaining In respect of consideration another important principle is that it must generally be given after promise so as to make it enforceable. Thus a promise made after alleged consideration is complete is unenforceable (Re Mcardle)5. Thus past consideration is generally held not to be good consideration and this had been the contemporary practice. However, the courts in Pao On v. Lau Yiu Long whereby Lord Scarman laid down the three condition which were to be satisfied if the exceptions were to be relied upon and past consideration to constitute as good consideration, the first being that the act which was done must have been done at the request of the promisor; secondly the parties had understood that the work was to be paid for in one way or the other, which could have been by way of money or other benefit; finally the promise would be legally enforceable had it been made prior to the acts which constituted consideration. The most difficult of the condition would be the anticipation of payment. In respect of the current situation it can be seen that Angela promised John the amount of 100 after he had finished with his placement and so a claim cannot be made under Re Mcardle. As fat as Pao on is concerned John needs to satisfy the three conditions, and as per the facts the acts were clearly not done on the request of the promisor that is Angela; secondly it was in no way a paid work experience and so the second condition would also not be satisfied; and finally the final condition cannot be satisfied as the acts of John had been done before the promise and so these could not constitute as good consideration, thus no payments can be claimed by John. References McKendrick, Ewan. Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010. Print Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Obligations under a Contract Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1059 words - 1, n.d.)
Obligations under a Contract Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1059 words - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1575128-contract-law-problem-question
(Obligations under a Contract Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1059 Words - 1)
Obligations under a Contract Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1059 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/law/1575128-contract-law-problem-question.
“Obligations under a Contract Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1059 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1575128-contract-law-problem-question.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Obligations under a Contract

Law. Offer and Acceptance

a contract exists when an offer is made by one part and accepted by the other; offer and acceptance makes a contract legally binding.... a contract exists when an offer is made by one part and accepted by the other; offer and acceptance makes a contract legally binding.... Hence, there is no halfway through, either there is a contract or there is no contract at all.... The court held that a binding contract existed between the two parties as revocation would only take place on communication but acceptances take place as soon as they are posted....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Comparative law

Besides it also provides an in detail description about different legal principles and its applications at various situations concerning the contract law… This is done by resolving a case study which revolves around three parties – the lessor, the lessee and the contractor.... Besides it also provides an in detail description about different legal principles and its applications at various situations concerning the contract law.... The second section of the paper deals with the case study – an overview of the case, description of the parties involved, legal principles related to the different situations arising in the case and providing a solution in accordance with the contract law clauses and cases....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Business Law Core

Kapoor, contract II, 8th edition 1999). Persons who have entered into partnership with one another are called individually 'partners' and collectively a 'firm' and the name under which their business is carried on is called the 'firm name; there are several formalities to be followed or to constitute a partnership.... Therefore the relation of partnership arises from contract and not from status.... In undertaking the operations of the hotel and restaurant, both parties need to form ad incorporate the company either by special statute or by registration under the companies Act for the time being in force....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Law of Obligation Learning Outcome

There were different forms of contract which were all incorporated with religious elements due to the fact that Roman law evolved through and under the college of pontiffs and priestly caste.... The earliest Roman contract now was formed called the nexum.... Without these symbolisms, the contract will be regarded as void.... A formal contract then became part of Roman law where one party would perform a specific action and the other party would be expected to fulfill an obligation....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Varying of Contract Terms

The second one is that of obligations that are owed under a contract with a third party.... An evaluation of each of the concept would include the circumstances in which the courts is or is not willing to enforce promises which vary terms of a contract.... Consideration is an important principle for a contract as the English courts take that into when determining the legal enforceability of a contract.... Finally, the obligations which are existent by way of a contract with the person who makes the new promise, for which it is alleged that the existing obligations should be held to be a good consideration....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Contract Signed by the CEO and Situation Construction

A suspensive condition is that it is a condition which suspends the operation or effect of one or more of the Obligations under a Contract not until the condition is fulfilled.... The contract is enforceable because there was a contract signed by the CEO and Situation Construction.... However, contracts entered by parties which are dependent on a suspensive condition are not immediately finally binding on the parties, until a contract is signed to the effect that neither of the parties can terminate the agreement while the contract is subject to the suspensive condition....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Where does the law apply and the legal position in different organizations

Law of Tort guides the relationships of individuals in the society and deals with civil wrongs and omissions like defamation,… Contract law protects legally enforceable business contracts and agreements of the parties by ensuring all parties fulfill their obligations under the contract.... Tort is a civil wrong, breach of trust or equitable obligation, and it is independent of contract.... The person bring the case under private law is known as the claimant while the person being sued is the defendant (Cooke, 2011)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

The Doctrine of Frustration

A frustrated contract is a contract which becomes incapable of being performed.... hellip; The author states that the legal consequence of a contract found to be frustrated is that the contract is automatically terminated at the point of frustration.... This is an important distinction as the contract is not void “ab initio” (from inception) as solely future obligations are discharged on a strict interpretation of the doctrine of frustration....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us