StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Modernity In Criminology - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Within the past two decades, judicial decisions, legislative modifications, and administrative alterations have transformed the juvenile court from a nominally rehabilitative social welfare agency into a scaled-down second-class criminal court for young people…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
Modernity In Criminology
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Modernity In Criminology"

Download file to see previous pages

These substantive and procedural reforms have converted the historical ideal of the juvenile court as a welfare agency into a quasi-penal system that provides young offenders with neither therapy nor justice. The positivists who created the juvenile court conceived of it as an informal welfare system in which judges made dispositions in the "best interests" of the child. In 1967 the Supreme Court in In re Gault granted juveniles some constitutional procedural rights in delinquency hearings and provided the impetus to modify juvenile courts' procedures, jurisdiction, and purposes.

(Feld, 1999, 24-25) The ensuing procedural and substantive convergence between juvenile and criminal courts eliminated virtually all the conceptual and operational differences in strategies of social control for youths and adults. Even proponents reluctantly acknowledge that juvenile courts often fail either to save children or to reduce youth crime. In short, the contemporary juvenile court constitutes a conceptually and administratively bankrupt institution with neither a rationale nor a justification.

According to Paul (2002, 69-70) social structural and cultural changes fostered both the initial creation and contemporary transformation of the juvenile court. Ideological changes in cultural conceptions of children and in strategies of social control during the nineteenth century led positivists to create the juvenile court in 1899. . s combined new theories of criminality, such as positivism, with new ideas about childhood and adolescence to construct a social welfare alternative to criminal courts.

They designed juvenile courts to respond flexibly to youths' criminal and non-criminal misconduct, to assimilate and integrate poor and immigrant children, and to expand control and supervision of young people and their families. (Tanenhaus, 2004, 111-112)The juvenile court positivists removed children from the criminal justice and corrections systems, provided them with individualized treatment in a separate system, and substituted a scientific and preventive alternative to the criminal law's punitive policies.

By separating children from adults and providing a rehabilitative alternative to punishment, juvenile courts also rejected criminal law's jurisprudence and its procedural safeguards, such as juries and lawyers. Juvenile courts' flexible and discretionary strategies enabled its personnel to differentiate and discriminate between their own children and "other people's children," those of the poor and immigrants. (Duffy, 2004, 39)A century later, social structural changes have modified the cultural conceptions of young people and the strategies of social control that juvenile courts employ.

These changes leave the juvenile court, as an institution, searching for a new policy foundation and legal rationale. (Kittrie, 2000, 156-157) Since Gault, social structural, demographic, and legal changes have altered dramatically juvenile courts' structure and functions, the characteristics of their clientele, and the crime and social welfare issues that they confront. The social construction of adolescence as a developmental stage distinct from adulthood and new sensibilities about children began to pose

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Modernity In Criminology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1511021-modernity-in-criminology
(Modernity In Criminology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1511021-modernity-in-criminology.
“Modernity In Criminology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1511021-modernity-in-criminology.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Modernity In Criminology

Modernity and Enlightenment Reason

The visible presence of class conflict and social misery in Europe,the rise of scientific interest and industrial innovation,and the idea of evolution and stages in human development were all to influence the establishment of positivism … The visible presence of class conflict and social misery in Europe, the rise of scientific interest and industrial innovation, and the idea of evolution and stages in human development were all to influence the establishment of positivism as an approach to human affairs....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Left and Right Realism Influence on Criminology

The paper "Left and Right Realism Influence on criminology" tells that realism criminology has undoubtedly changed the new generation views on crime.... Today, crime is considered a social dilemma with different socialist views adopted from Marx, Durkheim and other political and neo political approaches....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Debate Concerning the Transition from Modernity to Post Modernity

According to Robert & Jeanette (Pg 17-18, 2005), in the modernity context "Deviance" is challenging, yet indispensable and fundamental to any formation of Social Order.... It is challenging because it interrupts; it is critical because it explains the restrictions of our public authenticity; and it is fundamental to a formation of order in that significant what is factual and anticipated, significant what is tolerable, and significant who we are- constantly is completed in antagonism to what is illusory, surprising, undesirable, and who we are not....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Left Realism Theory

1999 "Race, Gender and Class in criminology", Retrieved January 16, 2009, fromhttp://books.... Contribution of Left Realism in the development of criminology can help shape society in a better way.... One of left realisms most substantial contributions to criminology is the square of crime.... What was necessary was a criminology which could navigate between these two currents: which took crime seriously but which was radical in its analysis and policy....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Marxist Criminologists and Social Inequality

hellip; Left idealism is also known as radical criminology.... This paper "Marxist Criminologists and Social Inequality" discusses the Marxists criminologists who believe in a concept which stipulates that as long as people have different interests and as long as some individual groups hold more power than others then crime will always be in existence....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Development Process of Criminology Since the 1970s

The period from early 1970s witnessed the development of the new criminology which later came to be known as the radical criminology.... 58), argues that the development of radical or critical criminology stems from conflict theory of crime and is indeed its branch.... 169), holds the view that it draws its ideas from the Marxist perspective of criminology.... In a nutshell, radical criminology was based on the concepts such as power, class in addition to ideology that was advanced by the Marxists during their analyses of the famous capitalist society....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Explain the reasons why left realism emerged

The perceived failure by the left-realists to take a position regarding practical interest in everyday crime led to the emergence of a different form of critical criminology perspective.... This perspective asserted that criminological behaviour is a matter of free will and choice, The Reasons Why Left Realism Emerged Grade (March 12th, The Reasons Why Left Realism Emerged The perceived failure by the left-realists to take a position regarding practical interest in everyday crime led to the emergence of a different form of critical criminology perspective....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Criminal Justice towards Crime Prevention, Victim Responsibility and the Minimization of Risk

This new language does not rely on the conventional concerns of criminology and criminal justice focusing on the individual.... Consequently, a new type of criminology is emerging to replace the one we have today.... The field of criminology has undergone numerous and radical changes since the beginning of the twentieth century to become the way it is today.... In order to understand this shift and its effect on criminology, a brief history of criminology is imperative....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us