StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

PUBLIC/PRIVATE DIVIDE/STANDING IN JUDICIAL REVIEW - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The citizen when seeking to challenge the powers of the state is fundamental principles in the process of judicial review. The essence of judicial review is that an 'inferior body' (other expressions employed include subordinate body; administrative body, or administrative agency) has acted outside the scope of its power…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
PUBLIC/PRIVATE DIVIDE/STANDING IN JUDICIAL REVIEW
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "PUBLIC/PRIVATE DIVIDE/STANDING IN JUDICIAL REVIEW"

Download file to see previous pages

Sources of power, private law, and public law issues, order 53 and Locus Standi should be discussed gradually. This question raises some issues from public body, private and public law issues, and locus standi. In order to answer this question, it is necessary to have a clear knowledge about pre-1977, S 31(1) of Supreme Court Act 1981, O .53, and situation after reform. It is also necessary to explain the background to this development and decision of O'Reilly v Mackman 1, public body, private and public law issues, sources of power and the exceptions of O'Reilly v Mackman.

Prior to 1977, people were likely to use private law for its advantages. The problems were short time limit, requirements of LS, unavailability of discovery, and inflexibility regarding remedies. However, the decision of the Architectural Academy (AA) regarding the subject of scholarship will be amenable to claims for judicial review if it is public body and the issues are public law issues. Four weeks before the beginning of the coming academic year, the trustees of the AA decide to cease offering financial scholarships with immediate effect.

JR is only available against public bodies, not private bodies. The sources of inferior bodies power is the traditional approach to determine a public body. In R v Panel on take-overs and Mergers ex parte Datafin Ltd 2, the CA held that the Panel was amenable to JR despite the fact that it was a self-regulatory body operated by the City whose powers derived neither from statute nor the prerogative. This functional approach can be illustrated bellow. Section 6(3) provides that public authority will include 'any person certain of whose functions of a public nature' and s6 provides they uphold convention rights [Poplar Housing v Donoghue], [Leonard Cheshire Foundation] 3.

In R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board ex p Lain 4, the board should be subject to review as if it was set up under statute. In Harriot 5, an ad hoc committee and in Scott v National Trust 6, the national trust could be public body. Hoffman LJ observed in ex p The Aga Khan 7 felt that Jockey Club was not to be subject to JR because it did not form part of a system of governmental control. Court adopts sources of power test. The Aga Khan is to taken as indicative of the correct approach in determining reviewability.

However, form the question it is clear that AA would be amenable to claims for judicial review, if court adopt sources of power test, because the powers derives from statutes.In Cocks v Thanet DC 8, HL held that an action against local authority for breach of statutory duty is abuse of process. It would only be allowed by way of JR. In Ali v Tower Hamlets LBC 9 CA held that determination of suitability of accommodation also fell within the public law. Clarification finally came in British steel PLC v Customs and Excise Commissioner 101) If litigation touches only on public law issue, the complaint must generally seek remedy by way of JR.2) Where the complaint enjoys a

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“PUBLIC/PRIVATE DIVIDE/STANDING IN JUDICIAL REVIEW Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1502651-publicprivate-dividestanding-in-judicial-review
(PUBLIC/PRIVATE DIVIDE/STANDING IN JUDICIAL REVIEW Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1502651-publicprivate-dividestanding-in-judicial-review.
“PUBLIC/PRIVATE DIVIDE/STANDING IN JUDICIAL REVIEW Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1502651-publicprivate-dividestanding-in-judicial-review.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF PUBLIC/PRIVATE DIVIDE/STANDING IN JUDICIAL REVIEW

Digital Divide and its Consequences

In this review I will attempt to demonstrate what the consequences of the digital divide are.... I focused the review on the United States of America and the digital divide between immigrants and native born which is constantly widening in the last decade.... Specifically I will raise intriguing questions about race and the digital divide, ethnic differences in access, the role of community technology centers and the causes of the digital divide and the patterns of the internet use. … In his article Fairlie (2002) comments that in the recent years, there are numberless private and public programs in the U....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Educational differences in public institutes and in private institute

This thesis statement for this literature review runs on the opinion that private institutions have higher education standards as compared to public institutions; secondly, the educational curriculum of private institutions is much wider compared to public institutions.... Witham (1997) in his studies described private institutions as non-state/ independent institutions that are not under the control of the national government, State, or local authority.... hellip; On the other hand, public institutions are regarded as “commons” whereby each student has a right of admission and they are funded through the minimal tuition fee charged on each student, and also Hein (2004) noted that at the inception of the education system all institutions were public institutions and there was only an option of private tuition for interested students, which was offered to them as remedial classes....
4 Pages (1000 words) Literature review

Crime and Punishment in 18th Century China

All homicide cases and all cases attracting the death sentence were sent to the capital for review by the highest judicial tribunal, the Board of Punishments.... The Qing Legal code set up a criminal justice system that was based on a very detailed criminal code.... The code was categorized into two main components: penal law and administrative law....
10 Pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review

Should Polygraph Tests be Admissible at Trial as Valid Scientific Evidence

The purpose of the following review is to summarize the most recent developments in polygraph technology.... Particularly, the writer of the review will seek to investigate the legitimacy of the application of polygraph as scientific evidence in courts.... The use of the polygraph in the private sector is strictly regulated by the Polygraph Protection Act of 1988; however, use by government agencies is not as constrained.... The FBI currently requires polygraphs of new agents, as do private companies performing government work, such as nuclear energy facilities, those that engage in the transportation or storage of toxic waste, and those that supply proprietary information, to name a few....
11 Pages (2750 words) Literature review

What Is Justice and Where Is the Last Instance to Determine It

Laws do not "hook onto" the real world by themselves; they must be interpreted and applied by the people who want to obey them and by the judicial system that wants to enforce them.... The paper “What Is Justice and Where Is the Last Instance to Determine It?... rdquo; refers to the competent works who reason about the judges' jurisdiction on the adoption of verdicts, and considers it quite legitimate that judges, not being lawmakers, are the final authority making a decision on cases....
11 Pages (2750 words) Literature review

Public and Cultural Diplomacy

This literature review "Public and Cultural Diplomacy" discusses public diplomacy through the embassy that is largely alongside the lines of international aid.... Canada is rather different since it is comparatively more recognized for its public diplomacy.... The documentation of public diplomacy in the course of the cold war gives a number of significant lessons for the United States foreign legislators in the period following the cold war (Critchlow, 2004, p....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review

The Concept of Public-Private Partnerships

In the essay “The Concept of Public-private Partnerships” the author focuses on the concept of PPP, which is difficult to define.... hellip; The author states that a PPP is an agreement/partnership made between public and private sector partners which allow more private sector participation in an entity that is traditionally meant to be a public sector organization.... They are different from privatization which involves the handing over of a public sector entity to private entities in totality (Kuhne, 2010)....
20 Pages (5000 words) Literature review

Public Policy

The present study would focus on public policy.... It is more of what is done and not what is intended by the public sector.... This approach to distinguishing public policy from other public sector activities is important given the fact that not all issues of concern are given the same level of seriousness.... hellip; The fact is, that public policy is purposive meaning that it is deliberately put in place to achieve certain objectives....
20 Pages (5000 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us