StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

EU Law: Katisa and Elijah - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "EU Law: Katisa and Elijah" states that Elijah’s claim for textbooks under the Directive has far more legal certainty than his claim for a student loan.  The doctrine of direct effect is necessitated by the principle of effete utile which seeks to harmonize EU law…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
EU Law: Katisa and Elijah
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "EU Law: Katisa and Elijah"

?EU Law: Katisa and Elijah The main issues for Katisa and Elijah are the free movement of goods, services and people within the single market of the EU and EU law relating to the direct effect of the Directive. Katisa’s issues falls more broadly within the EU’s general prohibition against quantitative restrictions in support of a single market.1 As Kennedy argues, the free movement of goods is “one of the principle features of the EU.”2 The law relating to quantitative restrictions is contained in Articles 34-36 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TEFU), formerly 28-30. Article 34(formerly Article 28) prohibits quantitative restrictions on imports and Article 35(formerly Article 29) prohibits quantitative restrictions on exports.3 Article 36 however, provides for exceptions to quantitative restrictions and includes restriction exceptions on the grounds of public health, morality, public police, public security, protection of animals or plants, national arts, history, archaeology, industry and commercial property but may not enable discriminatory treatment.4 The restrictions on Katisa’s export of balsamic vinegar to Member State Y must therefore be examined by reference to Article 36. The advertising and bottling restrictions appear to fall within the Article 36 exception to the ban on quantitative restrictions relative to the protection of commercial property and consumer protection. In this regard, the quantitative restriction can only be justified if it is necessary and proportionate for the ends that it seeks to achieve.5 In considering whether or not measures for the protection of consumers and commercial property were necessary and proportionate, the European Court of Justice had a packaging issue to consider in Walter Rau v De medf. 6 In this case, Belgium required that margarine be packaged in cube shaped packages to avoid consumers confusing it with butter. The ECJ ruled that this restriction could not be justified since other labelling measures could achieve the same end.7 Therefore, Katisa should be permitted to export balsamic vinegar to Member State Y with appropriate labelling distinguishing it from other similar goods. Similarly, Katisa should be able to advertise her goods by applying the same reasoning. Measures can be taken to ensure that the advertising is not aggressive and it would appear that a restriction against advertising altogether is tantamount to an unjustified quantitative restriction. Elijah’s case involved two distinct issues: freedom of movement of people within the EU and the direct effect of Directives. Freedom of movement of people within the EU is contained in Articles 20-23 of TFEU which includes the right of EU citizens to live and move freely within the EU.8 Freedom of movement is supplemented by Directive 2004/38/EC. Article 24 of Directive 2004/38/EC provides that EU nationals are entitled to be treated equally to citizens of the host state.9 However, the host state has no obligation to confer upon the EU citizen of another member state social assistance prior to the expiration of 3 months residence in the host state. Moreover, grants or other forms of vocational and student assistance are not mandatory unless the EU citizen of another member state has achieved the status of residence.10 In this regard, residency is achieved if the individual has lived and worked or studied with an accredited institution within the host state for more than three months.11 Therefore, if Elijah has been resident and enrolled at the accredited institution for more than three months and has not been collecting social assistance from Member State Y,12 he is entitled to the grant. Even so, the host state may require a longer period of integration to be satisfied that the student has sufficiently proven to be self-sufficient and has sufficiently integrated into society. The host state may establish a period of time for substantiating the student’s claim that they are settled in the host state prior to allowing the student to qualify for social assistance of any sort.13 In other words, Member State Y is at liberty to require that Elijah has resided in its territory for a reasonable period of time, without social assistance for a specific time period necessary for establishing that he is integrated into society prior to allowing him to collect the student grant. Whether or not 6 years is excessive is another issue and this might be overruled by the courts since a right of residence is acquired within 3 months of working and living or studying and living in the host state.14 Elijah’s claim for textbooks under the Directive has far more legal certainty than his claim for a student loan. The doctrine of direct effect is necessitated by the principle of effete utile which seeks to harmonise EU law.15 In general the doctrine of direct effect holds that EU citizens are entitled to enforce EU law throughout the EU via national courts.16 Whether or not a Directive had been implement or not, or was improperly implemented, it would be enforceable against the Member state, provided it was clear and unconditional and its expiration date has not expired.17 The main problem however is that the institution is not an emanation of the state and therefore the Directive cannot be enforced against the institution.18 However, while Elijah may not enforce the directive against the private institution, he may seek damages against the state for any losses he may have incurred as a result of the state’s failure to implement or improperly implement the Directive in question.19 Elijah must demonstrate that the Directive gives him a right, the right is identifiable and that his loss and damages are linked to the failure of the state to implement the Directive.20 Therefore, Elijah may not enforce the Directive against the private institution, but he is free to claim damages for the institution’s failure to distribute free text books. Elijah also has a reasonably good chance of success in a claim against the government agency for a student grant on the basis of his residency, if he has been studying at the institution for at least three months and has no previous claim for social assistance from the government. Bibliography Textbooks Kennedy, T.P. European Law. (Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2011, 5th Edn.). Journal Articles Inanilir, O. ‘Derogation from the Fee Movement of Goods in the EU: Article 30 and “Casis” Mandatory Requirements Doctrine,’ (2008)2 Ankara Bar Review, 106-113. Mayr, S. ‘Putting a Leash on the Court of Justice? Preconceptions in National Methodology v Effet Utile as a Meta-Rule.’ (Autumn/Winter 2012) 5(2) European Journal of Legal Studies, 8-21. Cases Cases 46/93 & C-48/93 Brasserie du Pecheur and Fatortame III [1996] ECR 11029. Case 91/92 Faccini Dori v Recreb srl [1994] ECR 1-3325. Cases 6 and 9/90 Francovich v Italian Republic [1991] ECR 1-5357. Case 157/86 Mary Murphy and Others v An Bord Telecom Eireann [1988] ECR 673. Case 148/78 Pubblico Ministero v Ratti [1979] ECR 1629. Case 120/78 Reve-Zentrale AG v Bundesmonopolvervaltung Fir Brantvein [1979] ECR 649. Case 209/03 The Queen (on the application of Dany Bidar) v London Borough of Ealing, Secretary of State for Education and Skills (15 March 2005] http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:62003J0209:EN:HTML (Retrieved 4 January 2014). Case 41/74 Van Duyn v Home Office [1974] ECR 1337. Case 26/62 Van Gend en Loos v Nederlandse Administratie der Belastingen [1963] ECR 1. Case 261/81 Walter Rau v De Smedt [1983] 2 CMLR 469. Statutes Directive 2004/38/EC. Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (Consolidated Version 2012). Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“EU Law Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
EU Law Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1498668-eu-law
(EU Law Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
EU Law Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1498668-eu-law.
“EU Law Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1498668-eu-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF EU Law: Katisa and Elijah

UK Public Law and European Law

This essay discusses that directives fall under secondary legislation of the source of eu law.... Directives fall under secondary legislation of the source of eu law.... The discussion seeks to answer the question: What is important that an EU directive does not surpass the laws of member nations but puts a commitment on the member nations to fine -tune their national law in harmony with Community regulations?... Its main aim is to bring together the dual aims of both ensuring the needed consistency of Union law and honouring the diversity of national structures and customs....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

The Case Laws in the European Court

This paper ''The Case Laws in the European Court'' tells us that the case laws in the European court have remained an indispensable source of jurisprudence and application of fundamental community law doctrines, as many of them cannot be found in Treaties as well as in EC legislation.... When it comes to the application of competition law amongst the different facets of European healthcare, the view of lawyers is at odds.... Neatherland2 established dual vigilance used to enforce the directives of the European law with every Member State....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Rationale for Differences among the Effects Ascribed to Directions, Directives and Decisions

The author of this paper "eu law" comments on the European Union law issues.... As it is mentioned here, the distinction between a regulation, a directive and a decision, which combined form part o the secondary law, is the one that has problems with the application of the doctrine of direct effect.... This means that the individual country has the advantage of refusing to implement a directive if it contravenes national law....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Elijah Muhammad

The relationship between the two leaders of African-American Muslims, Wallace and elijah Muhammad, started because of the suffering the African-American were experiencing from white people.... elijah Muhammad History shows that African-American people have always had problems in their lifetime.... Muslims leaders like elijah Muhammad and Malcolm X are some of the African-American leaders who came forward to solve such difficulties.... Many of the African-American people were converted to Islam by elijah Muhammad's teachings despite the fact that most of them were already Christians, probably followers of missionary teachings....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Race Viewed In Connection To Violence Ten Years Ago And Now

The study "Race Viewed In Connection To Violence Ten Years Ago And Now" explores the legal, moral and historical premises behind all this and conclusion is that it is true that the majority of the offenders are black and asian and are perceived as a threat to public order.... ... ... ... This study is aimed at exploring the social and academic attitudes of how race remains an integral variable in the determination of violence and perceptions of a criminal....
34 Pages (8500 words) Dissertation

The principles of ELISA and its application

The sensitivity and specificity of this analytical technique help to detect the presence of an antibody or an antigen in a sample with the help of the marker.... The marker is an enzyme linked to an antigen or antibody.... ELISA is also.... ... ... It is often used as a diagnostic test to detect autoimmune disorders, cancer related diseases, detection of animal and plant pathogens, detection of pregnancy, human viral infections like hepatitis B Virus, Hepatitis C virus, etc (Business The sensitivity of simple enzyme assays together with the specificity of antibodies/antigens aid in qualitative and quantitative determination of antigen or antibody concentration in samples....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Can We Really Trust Our Government, Do We Really Have Privacy

The paper "Can We Really Trust Our Government, Do We Really Have Privacy?... discusses that privacy protection is vital to building trust in the current world, as many businesses are transacted online.... Governments have been pioneers in security cover and we trust it will keep on being so.... ...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

How Was Race Viewed in Connection to Violence Ten Years Ago and How Is It Viewed Today

This study is aimed at exploring the social and academic attitudes of how race remains an integral variable in the determination of violence and perceptions of a criminal.... The Study is original in the sense that few if any of the members of the academia like to venture into sensitive waters of race ....
40 Pages (10000 words) Dissertation
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us