StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Law of Tort and Negligence - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Law of Tort and Negligence" it is clear that the claimant suffered a psychiatric injury that was caused by the shock of seeing her son dying after 36 hours of admittance at the hospital as a result of the health officials’ negligence…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful
Law of Tort and Negligence
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Law of Tort and Negligence"

1. The claimant should prove that the negligent behavior of the defendant has caused injury or loss to win the case. in the case of North Glamorgan N.H.S. Trust v Walters, it can be seen that the defendant was negligent in that the “claimant's infant son developed an epileptic fit as a result of the admitted negligence of the defendant trust, which caused irreparable brain damage and death when the child's life support system was turned off.” The act of turning off the support system aggravated the problem and this led to the claimant suffering a pathological grief reaction. The claimant is a secondary victim and is entitled to claim damages as a result of the horrific experience she encountered at the hospital. The psychiatric injury experienced by the claimant is a direct result of the action of the medical staff at the hospital and this is the reason why she is entitled to get damages. Though the defendant does not directly accept the charges, the facts are so glaring that it can be seen that they are responsible for the illness experienced by the claimant after the horrific incident.

2. a. The control mechanisms relating to a second victim that was identified by the trial judge as clearly satisfied in this case include the following: First and foremost, it can be seen that there is proximity in terms of the relationship between the claimant and the victim. The claimant is the mother while the victim is the son and there is true love between the two. In other words, the actions of the medical staff at the hospital led to the unfortunate scenario that resulted in the death of the infant which later affected the mother. The harm is a direct result of the actions of the medical staff and these factors were taken into consideration by the trial judge.

b. The control mechanism that was in dispute is that the 36 hours involving all the events that transpired could be held in law as one horrifying event. The defendant also argues that the judge erred when he concluded that the case was sudden since it transpired over a certain period that was characterized by changing events. However, the judge upheld that the control mechanisms were satisfied by the claimant in this particular case.
.
3. a. The ground for appeal by North Glamorgan N.H.S. Trust is that the judge expanded the control mechanism involved in the case. In other words, the defendants are saying that the judge did not take into account the provisions of the law about the facts that should be considered in the case of a secondary victim suffering psychiatric harm as a result of the actions of the defendant. The defendants also argue that the mother appreciated the removal of the life support system from the child which led to his death. The dependents also tried to invoke certain sections of public policy but it was established that the judge did not take any incremental position in passing the judgment in favor of the claimant.

b. The Lord Justice Ward considered the issues that constituted the necessary event in dismissing the appeal by the defendants. The events took place in a progressive way which led the judge to believe that there was an element of secondary causation of psychiatric injury to the claimant. The other issue that was taken into consideration by the judge is that the aspects of proximity in terms of time and relationship between the two were proved beyond any reasonable doubt. Therefore, the judge did not err in passing the judgment which resulted in the dismissal of the appeal by North Glamorgan N.H.S. Indeed, the medical institution had a duty care to give proper treatment to the child which they failed.

5. The acknowledgments by both Lord Justice Ward and Lord Justice Clarke of criticisms of the decision in Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1992] state that the claimant was not a participant in the case. The judges argue that the claimant ought to prove how she or he has been affected by the event if they have not been part of it. However, as illustrated in the case of Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1992], the claimant is a secondary victim who suffers as a result of the action that transpired. In most cases, nervous shock is a result of the situation experienced by the claimant which leads the judges to rule in their favor.

Nervous shock does not only result as a result of the direct involvement of the victim but he may experience a certain situation where the events that unfold will impact negatively on the person involved depending on the relationship that exists between them and the victim. Therefore, the major criticisms, in this case, are causation and the relationship that exist between the two parties involved. In the case of causation, it may not be direct but it may result in the third party suffering from nervous shock from what they have experienced or gone through. The other criticism is related to the aspect of proximity in terms of the relationship between the two people involved. Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Law o tort Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Law o tort Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1495638-law-o-tort
(Law O Tort Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Law O Tort Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1495638-law-o-tort.
“Law O Tort Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1495638-law-o-tort.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Law of Tort and Negligence

Negligence and Tort Law

This essay "Negligence and Tort Law" focuses on the branch of tort law covering negligence involves harm that results from a failure to take due care that a prudent person in the same circumstance as the tortfeasor would have.... negligence is a fairly recent entrant in tort law that is still experiencing developments.... Where no duty is owed there can be no liability The Structure of negligence The definition of negligence in ordinary parlance is carelessness....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Psychiatrict-negligence in Tort Law

Psychiatry-negligence in Tort Law Name Tutor Course Date For tortuous claims of liability in a negligence case to be successful, various basic pre-requisites require immediate and keen consideration.... The requirements of the contemporary tort stipulation of negligence appeared in a case that is under assessment in this explication, whether the claimants deserve rightful damages for their asserted claims of negligent psychological injury.... The modern tort of negligence as observed in numerous cases requires the existence of a care duty that the claimant owes the defendant, violation of duty and considerable injury or sabotage, which emanates from that violation....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Relationship between Contract and Tort in the Law of Obligations

The paper "The Relationship between Contract and Tort in the Law of Obligations" states that generally speaking, contractual obligations have been falling under the umbrella of a tort, especially through the duty of care and negligence aspects of tort law.... In discussing this relationship, he states that the 'ambiguity was never resolved'; the pervasive theme was the 'friction on boundaries' between contract and tort and that the 'scars are plainly visible in the Common law of the end of the twentieth century....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Clinical Negligence in UK Hospitals

"Clinical negligence in UK Hospitals" paper focuses on the report of the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust public inquiry, which is one of a number of recent reports that have highlighted appalling levels of neglect within some hospitals in the UK.... Cases of clinical negligence have become increasingly common in UK hospitals raising concerns for the UK government and the hospital authorities as well.... hen cases are lodged against such clinical negligence in hospitals against the hospital staff and healthcare treatment, not much can be done by the court as they cannot change the way the hospitals would deal with their clinical care and performances....
21 Pages (5250 words) Assignment

Tort Law of Negligence

The law of tort is closely related to the law of agency because a business entity, or principal, can be held liable for torts committed by its agents in the course of business dealings.... The paper "Tort law of Negligence" is a good example of a law essay.... The paper "Tort law of Negligence" is a good example of a law essay.... The paper "Tort law of Negligence" is a good example of a law essay.... tort (French for 'wrong') refers to a civil wrong inflicted on another person or the person's property....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Drug and Substance Abuse

The paper explains the case in detail, along with providing an analysis of the case with reasonable evidence taken from several other cases based on the same Law of Tort and Negligence.... The paper, before delving into the details, however, explains the law of tort to polish the claims and the judgments of the case van Horne v Gibson's GymThe Case - van Horne v Gibson's GymGibson's Gym is a professional training institute for boxers.... Generally, when Tort is referred to, it means that there has been the commitment of a civil wrong, and has been recognized by the law to be so, in which case, there is an obvious and apparent case of tort....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Advantages and Disadvantages of Partnerships

Business law literature defines a partnership as an express or implied agreement between two or more individuals to carry out a business for a profit (Miller & Jentz 2010; Pride, et al.... The paper "Advantages and Disadvantages of Partnerships" discusses that Josephine may prove to the court that the defendant owed her duty of care....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Bullying in the Workplace

ibrary/ workshop session I had earlier visited the law section in the library hence my visit this time was not the first.... For first-time visitors in the law section of the library, getting the right book can be a tiring experience especially if one does not have a specific title in mind.... This is because the section has a lot of law literature which can be confusing to a beginner.... I learned about the law on price fixing and the policy that is behind it....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us