StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Describe the relationship between treaties and customary international law - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Relationship between Treaties and Customary International Law Name Institution Date Relationship between Treaties and Customary International Law Customary international law is the evidence emanating from general practice and which is taken as law1. This is explained by two factors: the general activities of states and what states regard as law…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
Describe the relationship between treaties and customary international law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Describe the relationship between treaties and customary international law"

Download file to see previous pages

On the other hand, treaties are deliberate agreements that create clear rights and/or obligations for the parties. Treaties are also referred to as convention, charter, protocol, covenant, pact, statute and concordat2. As far as customary international laws are concerned, peremptory norm (jus cogens) originate from principles of international/natural Law and surpasses all laws. Examples include those that govern international crimes such as slavery, mass evictions, torture, mass murders, aggression wars and criminal activities against humans.

Peremptory norms and international customary laws cannot be interchanged. All peremptory norms become international customary laws after states adopt them. However, not all international customary laws are considered as class of jus cogens. States can move away from international customary law by creating treaties and laws, but peremptory norms are not derogable3. There are two elements that are crucial for formation of the CIL. These are the general state practice behavior patterns and opinion juris, which is simply a legal expectation that certain point is appropriate.

It is always a requirement that both elements coincide, as much as element two is the one that matters in practice. Opinio juris is gathered from the general legal expectations that are shared by humankind, and not some groups. It is worth noting that none of the two elements are subject to universal acceptance, yet CIL has a universal obligation for people and nations. Additional, no consents from nations is necessary but it seeks to align the international community. These features are reflected in various cases. In UK V. Norway Fishing case, UK suit Norway over its claims over exclusive fishing rights and control over expansive waters.

The ICJ ruled that the claims by Norway were never in line with the international laws regarding water resources. In the Colombia v. Peru Assylum Case, ICJ made recognition of the Article 38 of the international court of justice statute comprising of general customs and local customs. Further stipulating that for customs to be proven they ought to have been uniformly and continuously executed. Countries that have an objection to international customary law may not submit to the laws unless deemed by peremptory norms.

The ICJ statute recognizes the existence of international customary law enshrined in article 38(1)(b), which was incorporated by Article 92 of the UN charter4. Treaty and customary international law combine together for the benefit of general international law. Customary international law directly reflects state behavior and so it evolves naturally to meet the needs of the global society. Customary international law is flexible and it can be dynamic in nature. Customary international law rules may be unclear and they cannot be developed quickly.

Treaties can clarify Customary International Law; for instance, the provisions of the VCLT codified CIL in this are of law. Treaties can develop Customary International Law, for example, the provisions of the United Nation Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982) developed CIL rules relating to the Exclusive Economic Zone. Lastly, treaties can inspire new Customary International Law5. Although treaty and international customary law are regarded as different law sources, separating these two entities is not

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Describe the relationship between treaties and customary international Essay”, n.d.)
Describe the relationship between treaties and customary international Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1472665-describe-the-relationship-between-treaties-and
(Describe the Relationship Between Treaties and Customary International Essay)
Describe the Relationship Between Treaties and Customary International Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1472665-describe-the-relationship-between-treaties-and.
“Describe the Relationship Between Treaties and Customary International Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1472665-describe-the-relationship-between-treaties-and.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Describe the relationship between treaties and customary international law

How the Treaties Might Relate to Existence of Hierarchy Amount the Source of International Law

Since there is no international legislation or parliamentary body that had the mandate of coming up with international law, the generally accepted source of the rule of law has been customary international law.... In case an ambassador is attacked in a country it would be considered as a violation of a customary international law.... The reason for which states that sign a treaty are bond to it is because there is a rule of customary international law – pacta sunt servanda- which requires all states to honour and adhere to the treaties they have signed....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

English Law Position of the Hijab on Muslim Customary Laws

Lately however the measures to counter terrorist acts have by states have been challenging to the rule of law and human rights .... he bedrock of fighting terrorism should be the respect for the rule of law and human rights.... The development of national counter terrorism strategies whose aim is to prevent the acts of terror, prosecute the perpetrators and offer protection of human rights and the rule of law is a major requirement.... It undermines the pluralistic civil society, affects the rule of law and its establishment and it has the ability to destabilize governments that are legitimately constituted....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The scope and application of jus cogens

It is the objective of jus cogens and erga omnes to promote and preserve the common interests of nations to a much greater extent than the international law.... They are also quite influential in determining the manner, in which international law is developed, preserved and modified.... Importantly, a few subjects of international law, acting in isolation or in association with other subjects, do not result in jus cogens; nor can they veto a decision of the majority of nations....
25 Pages (6250 words) Dissertation

International Law, the Vienna convention on the law of treaties 1969

international law is where International Organizations create or intend to create a relation between themselves operating within the spheres of international law.... The memorandum of understanding (MOU) is a well-accepted type of legal instrument in international law and practice.... These organizations often form treaties and agreements amongst different States of the world which are both binding… which is under law of treaties) and non-binding (such as MOU and other international agreements which are not binding under the treaties 1969....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

The Role of Soft Law in Contemporary International Law-Making

  This essay "The Role of Soft Law in Contemporary international law-Making" discusses the main sources of law and defines if the soft law is able to regulate the relations effectively.... Thus, taking into account that different sources of international law usually work together and are not taken separately, sometimes it is not possible to decide what source is more efficient.... Scientists define two major sources of international regulation: customary law and treaties....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Proper Functioning of International Law

Are the attitudes and interests of the world's different geo-political groupings of states too diverse to allow the proper functioning of international law?... Additionally, notwithstanding the theoretical importance of international law making in areas such as human To this end, some commentators have challenged the efficacy of international law as a result of competing political interests at international level, arguing that customary law has effectively been replaced by national concerns in inter-state relations3....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Discrimination in the Australian Law of Marriage

An author of the review "Discrimination in the Australian law of Marriage" seeks to critically discuss the legal vulnerabilities of marriage law in Australia.... hellip; The Australian legal system is based on English law.... This creates substantial difficulty for the Indigenous peoples, whose traditional laws are vastly different from English law.... These traditional laws are better suited to the culture and traditions of the Indigenous peoples, and English law is at best a poor compromise....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review

The Relationship between International Law and National Law

hellip; National courts generally interpret and apply international treaties, customary international law, and principles of international law.... International tribunals in turn attempt to fill gaps in customary international law by reference to national case law and codes.... However, since the law is not a science, national courts are not always consistent in their respective approaches to customary international law.... The paper 'the relationship between International Law and National Law' presents the principles applied by international tribunals which relative to the relationship between international and national law are primarily guided by identifying a balance between the practices of states....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us