StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Instructor Course Date Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System Introduction The role of the court system is to protect the law by punishing those who break the law. A state must protect its citizens from the acts of law offenders through appropriate channels of punishment…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System"

Download file to see previous pages

These models are the inquisitorial and the adversary models. The Canadian Court System mostly applies the adversarial process in its legal processes. Adversarial justice system is the best approach to addressing justice and equality in court systems and the Canadian Courts should continue using it. Reasons for the Adversary Justice System The ultimate concern of the adversary court system is to ensure equal treatment between the prosecution and defense. The court assumes a neutral position and acts as referee between the two parties.

This system requires all parties to adhere to the law in responding to different issues in the court. For instance, police officers must use the procedures that the law accepts to obtain evidence from suspects or the accused. The court will determine whether the police used the appropriate ways of gathering evidence that are recognized by the law and are free from deception and other malpractices. The neutral state of the court ensures a fair trial for the accused (see Law Commission). Adversary system stresses on strict observance of the law in seeking justice for all parties involved in a case.

This characteristic gives the system an added advantage over the inquisitorial justice system. Inquisitorial justice system involves the court in determining facts and evidence about a case. Therefore, the system gives room for bias where the court can favor one side of the case. This is unlike the adversary system that advocates for observance of the law in determining facts about a case. Moreover, the inquisitorial system denies the accused the right of privacy. The system requires the accused to collaborate with the police and other court officials in the process of gathering evidence.

The accused has no right of remaining silent throughout the process unlike in the adversary system where the accused has the right of choosing to remain silent throughout the court process. Courts in the adversary justice system act as supervisors of the actions of the prosecution and the accused and eliminate any practices that conflict with the law. The system does not grant the court the authority of supporting the prosecution against the accused. This form of fairness does not exist in the inquisitorial justice system.

It is possible for the authority or the police to coerce their authority on the accused in their attempt to gather evidence against him or her. The law does not allow use of evidence that is a result of coercion of authority. Police officers are known to use excessive power in their attempt to gather evidence against victims of crime. Therefore, involving the court and the police in the process is not in the best interests of ensuring equal and just treatment for offenders (see Prasad). The adversary system becomes even stronger when looking at emerging trends in the field of law.

For instance, there have been efforts to introduce the system of restorative justice in the court process. Restorative justice is an emerging trend in the court system where victims and offenders interact in the process of seeking justice. Legal procedures are not the basic requirements of punishing an offender under restorative justice. Instead, the offender must take absolute responsibility for his or her actions by convincing the victims that he or she will not repeat such an offense in the future.

The system does not recognize the state as an agent that feels the effect of law breaking. It holds the notion that actions of offenders

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1463536-analysis-critique-of-canadian-court-system
(Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1463536-analysis-critique-of-canadian-court-system.
“Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1463536-analysis-critique-of-canadian-court-system.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System

Sociological Approaches to the Study of Deviance

Marxism sees crime and deviance in light of its general critique of capitalism, while functionalists are emphatic on the positive roles that criminality may bring upon a social system.... This is to say that while Marxism is primarily concerned with explaining why the criminal system is biased in towards the bourgeoisie, functionalists see crime as an integral part of all societies that are healthy.... In this case, the shoplifter's act of engaging in small time larceny will have served the society with the chance to make itself more egalitarian, in lieu of merely using the criminal justice system as a punitive measure against some riff raffs....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

THE ECHR AS A LIVING INSTRUMENT

?? A critique of judicial activism may criticize the use of the living instrument rule as an impermissible intrusion of the Strasbourg Court into the policy-making domain.... hellip; However, a perusal of the jurisprudence developed by the European court of Human Rights (the “ECtHR” or the “Strasbourg court”) reveals that the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the ECHR have been interpreted as applying in an ever-widening range of contexts, which could hardly have been foreseen by the framers of the Convention....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Structures of Criminal Justice

Criminal justice is the system of practices and arrangements distinct of local and national governments which are aimed at maintaining social order, preventing crime and sanctioning the law perpetrators through penalties.... In civil law, individual citizens get to settle their differences in court where one is the plaintiff and the other the accused.... The critique is set to establish the justification of the presence of correctional facilities, what type of correctional facilities do exist, who frequents these kinds of correctional facilities and for what reasons and for how long....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Cultural Globalization

Accordingly, globalization, as it exists today, rests largely on the shoulders of neoliberal economics and the global entrenchment of capitalism as the dominant economic system across the world.... This is an important and often neglected component of American cultural imperialism: the internationalization of the US economic system....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Human rights

(Beitz, 2009) The Declaration lays out the structure of rights system and describes the mechanisms that must exist within institutions.... What this means is that a legal system can be understood as a control system which is instrumental in controlling and regulating the actions of its individuals....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

MEDIATION between Saudi Arabia and The U.S

Alternative dispute resolution or ADR (also referred to external dispute resolution in countries, as Australia)1 is a process other than litigation or adjudication in court, in which there is the presence of a neutral third party who helps to resolve conflicts or disputes.... A current review of the global legal and business scenarios reveal that increasingly larger numbers of conflict resolution is taking place through arbitration, mediation and negotiation....
35 Pages (8750 words) Thesis

International Reward Management

This essay focuses on the critique of the three major orthodox economic theories regarding pay and reward structures, that is, the classical wage theory, human capital theory and efficiency wage theory.... he differences in economic arguments and thoughts across the eras provide different analysis, critiques and solutions concerning pay and reward systems.... In his studies, Hicks tackled wage problems in a free market economy and came up with a model of determining wages based on previous analysis of theories...
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Classic Liberalism: Which of the Theories Is the Most Convincing and Why

hellip; Arguably, conservatism is a political system that defines wrong and right based on shaky grounds, classical liberal courts are free of unsound tradition and maintain open interrogation of issues in making judgments (Handler 2012).... "Classic Liberalism: Which of the Theories Is the Most Convincing" paper argues that there are two crucial stipulations that this ideology award to the people....
11 Pages (2750 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us