StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Criminal Legal Principle - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay outlines the legal principles regulating criminal liability for 
omissions with reference to relevant case law, whether the principles for the act of omissions are too rigid in nature, the validity, status of common law in dealing with the jurisprudence of omissions under criminal law…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Criminal Legal Principle
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Criminal Legal Principle"

29th October, Criminal Legal Principle “The legal principles governing liability for omissions are too rigid and only ?impose liability invery particular proscribed circumstances. This state of affairs is ?unsatisfactory and actively discourages community responsibility.” This paper has been divided into three different parts. It has three different questions and all the questions shall be handled separately. The first question is as follows: 1. Briefly outline the legal principles regulating criminal liability for ?

omissions with reference to relevant case law. The legal principle regulating criminal liability for omissions consists of special duty, contractual duty and dangerous situations. In English Law the legal principle for omission rests upon these three principles, and the omission on the part of the individual to act upon any one of these attracts a criminal liability. The set of principles regulating criminal are extremely rigid and have not ben explained properly in the ambit of English Law. One of the most crucial cases governing this principle is R v.

Miller (1982) UKHL 6. This case outlines the legal jurisprudence behind the act of omissions on the part of an individual and how it attracts a legal penalty. In the facts of the case, the defendant accidently burned his mattress. Instead of trying to resist the fire and shut it out, he shifted to the other room and slept there afterwards. During this time, the burned mattress lit the whole building and there was destruction of property in the building to this act of omission on the part of the defendant.

The defendant was eventually convicted of arson. This act arises out of the first principle of omission described as failure to act on special duty, as the case was in the present proceedings. “Ashworth says that there is no moral difference between (i) a positive act and (ii) an omission when a duty is established. But even if this is so, he has already conceded a difference between the two when he says that an omission is culpable only when there is duty to act. The duty requirement sometimes involves considerations that are irrelevant to crimes of commission.

Of course, every crime is a breach of legal duty not to commit the crime, but this is part of the meaning of the word ‘crime.’ The point is that no requirement of a particular duty not to act (over and above the specification of the crime) applies to wrongs of commission.” Looking at the current picture, the laws for omission are very rigid and vague in nature. It implies the fact that common law has to step in whenever a situation arises with regard to the explanation of this point of law in cases.

Since the principles have not been defined in a separate act, it becomes imperative on the part of the judiciary to include such principles within the ambit of the basic criminal law. As proposed and argued by Ashworth, there is not any difference between an act or an act of omission, since both of these acts arise out of a criminal liability and a guilty mind. The second question of the paper which needs to be answered is whether the principles for the act of omissions are too rigid in nature, and if yes whether do we needs change in law to accommodate the amendments.

In my opinion and discussions pertaining to the present scheme of things, I don’t think that the current state of principles under the omission law is too rigid. It might be argued in hindsight that the principles are extremely vague, but the point to be noticed here is that act of omissions are harder to prove than an act done by itself. What is not implied is not implied but needs to be shown and understood in the light of the criminal jurisprudence. One needs to show and prove that a guilty mind existed during the act of omission, since we tend to be believe more in ant act done by itself rather than the omission of a particular aiding something dangerous.

Looking from an objective point of view, the legal principle resounding the act of omissions are bound to convey a strict message, since it is an unconventional form of criminal activity in nature, and therefore it is imperative and pertinent on the part of the State to structure the laws in a strict fashion. The third part of this essay questions the validity and status of common law in dealing with the jurisprudence of omissions under criminal law. In my opinion there is a need to govern the act of omission through common law.

This is because at the present moment we cannot afford to draft a specific legislation for an act of omission because theoretically that will only complicate the confusion with respect to act of omission. It is indeed quite precarious at the face of it to label an individual guilty in a failure to act or avoid a criminal act, where in those circumstances it is presumed that the failure in itself was the act of the criminal liability committed by the defendant. Keeping this in mind, it shall be left open for the judges and the common law to interpret each and every action according to its merits and the law, and then decide as to whether such an act is indeed an act of omission or some other kind of negligence.

There is a very fine line of balance between the omission to act and a genuine negligence on the part of the individual, in order to keep this balance in check and progress we should not bother to disturb its sanctity by bringing out a legislation which will complicate the matters even more. The common law approach is the best approach we have and therefore in my opinion we should not tinker with the existing approach, which allows for a careful examination of facts and law and only after that do the judges impart their judgments.

Work Cited Glanville Williams, ‘Criminal Omissions—The Conventional View’ (1991) 107 LQR 86

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Criminal Legal Principle Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1460048-criminal-legal-principle
(Criminal Legal Principle Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1460048-criminal-legal-principle.
“Criminal Legal Principle Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1460048-criminal-legal-principle.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Criminal Legal Principle

The Relevance of the General Principles of EU Law

Defining General Principles The general principle of law is identified as a overall proposition of law of some prominence from which concrete rubrics are derived.... Accordingly, it is this particular characteristic that is the inconclusiveness in respect to the quality and capacity of the cases upon which the respective principle can be applied, which differentiates a general principle of law from an ordinary principle of law....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The Rule of Law is not a Legal Rule, but a Political and Moral Principle

This research paper describes the rule of law as a  political and moral principle.... Rights, on extensive poverty, on racial isolation, sexual differences, and religious discrimination may, in principle, conform to the rations of the rule of law better than any of the legal systems of the more progressive Western democracies.... But in political and legal theory of moral principle that has come to be read in a narrower sense, that the government will be ruled by the law and subject to it....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

The Principal Rules of Evidence in Criminal and Civil Trials and Their Legal Basis

The paper "The Principal Rules of Evidence in Criminal and Civil Trials and Their legal Basis" discusses that there have been massive influences of recent legislation upon the basic principles of Evidence law particularly in the area of human rights and allegations of improperly adduced evidence.... The law of evidence recognises two principal burdens that are the legal and evidential burden.... The legal burden will put the responsibility on the party to prove a fact in issue....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Legal Principles Governing the Withholding of Life-Sustaining Treatment in Incompetent Adults

In extremely difficult cases, court should be approached to make an objective assessment as to the patient's best interests though it is not a legal requirement.... It is not an action but omission and there is no criminal liability if there is no duty to treat.... Doctors are not immune form criminal liability in the course of their clinical practice.... In criminal matters, rules of evidence are strictly followed though the jury can be satisfied by circumstantial or deduced evidence....
33 Pages (8250 words) Essay

Legal Issues from Case Study

The author examines various legal issues in the case study.... Jurisdiction is the authority granted to the coat by the authorities to adjudicate cases through legal proceedings.... nbsp;… A major fundamental question in law is whether a particular coat has jurisdiction to preside a particular legal or civil proceeding.... In the case study, one of a legal case arising on the jurisdiction is when the company violated the law by operating in three different jurisdictions, yet its plumber was licensed in only one jurisdiction....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

The Misuse of Drugs in the UK

nglish courts have failed to apply the principle of causation in a consistent and principled manner in most cases involving involuntary manslaughter11.... Further to that, the court needs to prove that the act of the supplier was sufficiently significant in the death of the user(legal causation).... This debate has been made… ven more complex due to the failure of the English criminal law to deal with drug suppliers whose clients die from self-injecting or ingesting in a consistent and principled manner. If John supplies Mary with some controlled drug and Mary dies after self-injecting the drug, is This is a question English criminal law seems to provide us with inconsistent answers....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Separate Legal Entity, Limited Liability and Criminal Responsibility of Company

The paper describes the various status of companies, like separate legal entities, limited liability, and criminal responsibility which has been contributed a number of recognition for English law, by which a company, as well as its members, possess some rights and liabilities.... hellip; Company law includes the body of legal rules relating to the creation, management, financing and operation of companies.... Scholars have constantly explored the issue on the recognition of corporation/company as a “legal person” (Farrar, (1991) (1) A company, when legally speaking, is an association of a number of individuals for the purpose of carrying on some legitimate business i....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

The International Criminal Court and the Legal Principles Developed by the Ad Hoc Tribunal

This paper under the title "The International Criminal Court and the legal Principles Developed by the Ad Hoc Tribunal" focuses on the fact of holding both leaders and individual offenders responsible for crimes against humanity as opposed to entire communities.... nbsp;  The establishment of the International Criminal Court (ICC) follows from these legal principles and carries over to the administering of justice to those who commit international crimes of a serious nature and to ensure that victims, as well as survivors, achieved some measure of satisfaction....
20 Pages (5000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us