StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The law of tort: an analysis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The researcher of this paper endeavours to explore the concepts related to the Law of Tort specifically its relation to the medical profession. Tort is a French word which means wrong. Thus, tort law is the law of wrongdoing or perhaps of wrong…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
The law of tort: an analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The law of tort: an analysis"

?THE LAW OF TORT: AN ANALYSIS Introduction Tort is a French word which means wrong Thus, tort law is the law of wrongdoing or perhaps of wrong.2 A tort is not a criminal wrong although the two concepts have much in common and may often overlap; conversely, tort law establishes the conditions in which an individual whose interests have been jeopardized by another can be compensated through the civil courts.3 This paper endeavours to explore the concepts related to the Law of Tort specifically its relation to the medical profession. This paper also deems to critique the statement: Considerable deference is, however paid to the practices of the professions (particularly the medical profession) as established by expert evidence and the court should not attempt to put itself in the shoes of the surgeon or other professional person,4 as guided by underpinning theories. Definition of Tort and Tort Law The word tort is derived from the Latin word tortus which means twisted.5 The term was also used to mean wrong and it is still utilized in French in the phrase: J’ ai tort meaning I am wrong.67 Likewise, in English, the word tort has a purely technical definition which is a legal wrong for which the law offers a solution.8 Conversely, Black’s law dictionary defines a tort as a private or civil wrong or injury for which a court will provide a remedy in the form of an action for damages.9 Tort law is only one part of the civil law of obligations.10 Tort law is not in general concerned with contracts; hence, it if frequently labelled as the extra-contractual law of liability.11 In the formative age of the nineteenth century, the line between tort and contract was viewed as the main division in civil law; later, Sir Percy Winfield was the one responsible to draw on this distinction, defining tort law as the breach of an obligation imposed by the law, a meaning that aligns tort and crime.12 Moreover, tort law is also defined as a body of rules establishing specific injuries uncoordinated by general principles.13 Conversely, Sir Percy view negligence as a unifying thread for tort law.14 Tort law is the law of compensation for accidents that involve damage to a person or property.15 The task of tort law as defined by Fleming is determining only whether a specific loss sustained by an individual should be left to lie where it fell or should be shifted to someone else branded as a tortfeasor.16 The Traditional Tort System The major aims of tort law appear to be prevention of wastefully risky conduct and compensation of accident victims injured by overly risky behaviour; hence, tort law is viewed as a means that serves ends outside itself.17 The traditional medical malpractice tort law endeavours at helping to keep doctors on the right track by pressuring them to comply with the standards of their profession.1819 Toward this objective, negligence is defined in terms of the general concept standards of the medical profession and each case is then resolved on its own specific facts where juries determine not only what happened but also what is the suitable standard.20 The DCE System In comparison with traditional tort, the DCE system aims more at compensating the victims of adverse medical outcomes; in addition, it maintains a commitment to preclusion by defining compensable circumstances in terms of adverse outcomes that healthcare providers may control through the exercise of care.21 Hence, the DCE approach compensates victims not only when to do so but also raise the level of care among health care providers; furthermore, it is concerned with the reduction of transaction costs.22 Legal Concepts and the General Principles of the Duty of Care Giving emphasis on tort law, the common law states that the plaintiff, or injured person who brings a suit, must prove four elements in order to gain compensation from the person who injured him or his property called the tortfeasor23 or who is also labelled as the defendant.24 The first element that one must show is that the tortfeasor had a duty to conform to a specific standard of care.25 Second, the plaintiff must provide evidence that the tortfeasor failed to obtain the mandated standard of care.26 Third, the plaintiff must establish that there was an actual injury and finally, the plaintiff must demonstrate a link known as the proximate cause between the failure to fulfil the standard of care and the injury.27 Statement Analysis After gaining insight on the concepts surrounding tort law, it is fitting to analyze one of the known statements with regards to tort law in lieu of the context of the standard of care and that is, Considerable deference is, however paid to the practices of the professions (particularly the medical profession) as established by expert evidence and the court should not attempt to put itself in the shoes of the surgeon or other professional person.28 This statement emphasizes that significant reverence and respect should be given to the practices of a variety of professions specifically the medical profession hence, the court should not try to be in the position of the surgeon or other professional individual. The aforementioned statement is in accordance with the principle: the standard of care for experts, which highlighted that the standard of care expected from professionals is not a higher standard; rather the standard remains one of equanimity under the conditions.2930 However, what is reasonable for a professional is not the same as what is reasonable for a layperson.31 Rather, a professional is held to an exclusive form of the fundamental reasonable person standard for the reason that in addition to that degree of care; they are expected to possess a higher degree of skill, care and learning than the average person at least in the area of his or her profession.32 Generally, professionals are entailed not only to exercise reasonable care in what they do, but also to acquire and employ a standard minimum of special knowledge and ability within their specific areas of expertise.33 Hence, as implied by this, no individual can speak for the actions and the decisions made by the medical professional, also the court cannot put themselves in the place of the medical professional for the mere reason that specifically they do not share the same expertise as that of the surgeon or any other health professional. The court even though has knowledge on the law; they are not in particularly familiar with the scope and standards of medical practice. Conclusion The tort law is mainly concerned on the compensation for any damage incurred on a person or property. A variety of concepts are necessary to gain an understanding of the law of torts. With regards to the medical profession, tort law is commonly focused on the liability of the medical professional in the injury that resulted from treatment provided. However, the court respects that there are specific standards that the medical professional upholds with regards to the decisions and actions he or she makes concerning the treatment of the patient; thus, courts have traditionally felt that they could trust the medical profession to set their own standards.34 Moreover, courts continue to defer to professional custom regarding how the different medical procedures should be performed35 and do not attempt to make judgement without considering such standards for the reason that they do not share the same expertise and standards. References Baez, B. (2010) Tort Law in the USA. Great Britain: Kluwer Law International. Baudouin, J.L. and Linden, A.M. (2010) Tort Law in Canada. Great Britain: Kluwer Law International. Harlow, C. (2005) Understanding Tort Law. London: Sweet & Maxwell. Harpwood, V. (2009) Modern Tort Law. Oxon: Routledge-Cavendish. Koziol, H. and Steininger, B.C. (2008) European Tort Law. Germany: Springer-Verlag. Madden, M.S. (2005) Exploring Tort Law. United States of America: Cambridge University Press. Morisette, E.L. (2009) Personal Injury and the Law of Torts for Paralegals. New York: Aspen Publishers. Rogers, W.V.H., Winfield, P.H. and Jolowicz, J.A. (2010) Winfield and Jolowicz on Tort. London: Sweet & Maxwell. Rostow, V.P. and Bulger, R.J. (1989) Medical Professional liability and the delivery of Obstetrical Care. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press. Vevaina, J.R., Bone, R.C. and Kassoff, E. (1989) Legal Aspects of Medicine. [n.p.]: Springer. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The law of tort: an analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1394211-the-law-of-tort-an-analysis
(The Law of Tort: An Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1394211-the-law-of-tort-an-analysis.
“The Law of Tort: An Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1394211-the-law-of-tort-an-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The law of tort: an analysis

The Liability for Tort for a Company

The analysis of liability will therefore be pursued in a manner that will ensure that people that were harmed by negligence and battery will be justly compensated and the persons who breached the law are punished.... hellip; The case in question concerns three parties of who this analysis will attempt to determine liability.... The analysis of the torts committed will be taken from the perspective of a plaintiff suing from the perspective of battery, and negligence....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Introduction to Law of Tort

Therefore, the law of tort establishes the circumstances in which a person's interests have been harmed by another and how he can be compensated through the civil courts (Harlow, 2005).... The objectives of the law of tort are to compensate victims of injury and loss and protect the interests of individuals that are their reputation, property etc.... The other objective of the law of tort is to ensure that individuals check their actions and realize that they affect other people....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Tort Law: Case Analysis

hellip; The author studies the case damages within the context of tort Law since it is the only law being practiced at SmallVille where this accident was taken place.... It should be noted that the case damages will be studied within the context of tort Law since it is the only law being practiced at SmallVille where this accident was taken place.... The Economic Structure of tort Law.... This paper “Tort Law: Case analysis” aims to provide guidance for understanding the nature of the case chosen for this assignment where one plaintiff named Jerry who was diagnosed with a think skull since childhood....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

What Are Tort Laws

the law of tort has a good structure where upon justification of personal liability in causing harm on someone else, then the accused should compensate the claimant as per the provision of the law of the land.... the law of tort holds the supremacy of individual rights and therefore works to ensure that other persons do not infringe personal rights through negligence or carelessness4.... The application of tort laws provides that individual persons have distinct rights, which the law of the land identifies, and protect2....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Tort Law and Efficiency: The Hong Kong Context

Most business elites do not expect to face one another in the courtroom, and studies of corporate behaviour in the United States demonstrate the reluctance of businesses to invoke the formal processes of the law.... Despite academics such as Friedman suggesting that the law became a tool for those few at the top of the new economic structure, it is more reasonable to concede that law was unable to stagnate in a period of such rapid development.... Horwitz in particular is adamant that the law was used as a subsidy for the new economy as taxes would be both obvious and a politically undesirable thing....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Contract Law Degree Case Study

the law of tort is regarded as a legal injury.... the law of tort with regard to negligence is being examined in this essay.... egligenceThe law of negligence was originated in a court case Donahue v Stephenson (1932) in which a woman named Donahue suffered from gastro-enteritis after drinking ginger beer from a bottle which contained a dead snail.... Nominate tort is a sharp contrast to the open Continental approach to tortuous liability....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Tort Law: Analysis of Watkins v Secretary of State for the Home Department and Others Case

nbsp;… Considering similar cases, it can be said that as employees of the Home Office, the Prison Officers are legally responsible to act within the limits and ambits of their duties and since they have broken the law within the ambit of their employment, even the employers may be legally responsible for tort.... Watkins had suffered any loss or damages such as constituted an essential ingredient of the tort of misfeasance in public office.... Thus it was held that this tort was not actionable per se and the claim was subsequently dismissed....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Analysis of The Tort of Law

hellip; The duty of care concept in the tort of negligence was firstly introduced by Lord Esher in Heaven v Pender as a precursor to the modern law of negligence.... ince the foreseeability test, the tort of negligence developed into the requirements of duty of care, breach of duty and damage....
26 Pages (6500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us