StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Challenges and Opportunities Facing a Unitarist Approach - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Challenges and Opportunities Facing a Unitarist Approach" presents an employment relationship that entails an inbuilt structured antagonism, in that it is characterized by the potential for conflict as well as for cooperation (Storey, 2007:82)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Challenges and Opportunities Facing a Unitarist Approach"

Challenges and Opportunities Facing a Unitarist Approach It is often argued by management scholars that ‘the employment relationship entails an inbuilt structured antagonism, in that it is characterized by the potential for conflict as well as for cooperation’ (Storey, 2007:82). In practice, however, several employers and managers implicitly or explicitly disagree and prefer to adhere to a unitarist frame of reference in the development of their employment and HR policies. Thus, if this is the assumption, there are challenges and opportunities which the adoption of a unitarist approach to people management may entail for employers. In abstract, the unitarist perspective is based on the fact that all employment units are, or are expected to maintain cohesive as well as harmonious grounds with a summative responsibility to a common goal. In such an approach, there is a single source of authority (manager) (Chidi and Okpala, 2016). Also, cases of conflict do not exist between the employer and the workforce (Leat, 2008). It is implicitly recognized that skilled and firm headship or management is a precondition to the pursuit of organizational effectiveness. However, a challenge is observed in practice where there are increased chances of giving rise to paternalism and authoritarianism on the part of the owners in their approach to employee relations matters (Wallace, Gunnigle and McMahon, 2004). Authoritarianism may put a little concern or forget all together matters pertaining to the welfare of the workers and infringe on their freedom of identifying with a union. A good example was during the nineteenth century when several employers implemented an antagonistic unitary approach, actively excluding trade unions while recruiting women and children on poor wages from protracted hours in unsanitary working environments (Wallace, Gunnigle and McMahon, 2004). A unitarist perspective to employee management does not allow an employment relationship which embraces collective bargaining. Instead, it permits individualization of the employment relationship (Wallace, Gunnigle and McMahon, 2004). By individualization, it implies that the employer can consult the workforce on a one-to-one basis. They are also inclined toward performance-based pay as well as discretely negotiated contracts. Such a setting rejects the need for unions (Wallace, Gunnigle and McMahon, 2004). In the modern business atmosphere, employers will find it challenging to channel effective communication to curb grievance and safety concerns as well as ensure discipline among their workforce The perspective does not justify an uneven share of power among the providers of labor and employers in the decision-making process since the manager is the sole source of authority (Bingham, 2016). Employers remain solely with the power. Therefore, there is no mutuality because in due course the employer can decide individually to terminate the company or auction it to another employer or person and the employees cannot do anything about it. Also, the inferior position of the workers is evident because, via the contract, the employee submits to the unequal exchange of relationship and defers himself or herself to the power of the company manager. A lousy business relationship is created between the employer and the employees. Bingham (2016) highlights that whereas there is undoubtedly lots of communication in companies today, the majority of it seems to be downward discourse since as stated, management gives more power and in several instances in the form of directives. Additionally, most of the organization layouts, particularly in the public area, are conventionally hierarchical, and this hinders communication. As a result, the importance of communication as an instrument for management by unitarist perspective may be a huge challenge in such organizations. The unitary perspective is based on management orientation which adopts an overall accepted value structure. This is an opportunity in any organization with a managerial ideology that has existed till today for various reasons: managers can legitimize their power by enabling the interests of management and workers as being similar and that managers control in the best interest of the whole company (Bingham, 2016). For instance, when management decides to entail workers, it can apply the unitary perspective to rationalize its rightfulness to take such actions. This is due to the reasons that it becomes strictly essential at times for management to act speedily on a situation without involving the workers. Managers’ right to manage stresses employers working in the interests of everyone in the company since they know best (Harney, Wilkinson and Dundon, 2017). At this instance, there is an assurance to the management by confirming that the blame for conflict can be placed with workers rather than administration. It is then possible to project it to the world outside the organization as a way of persuading them that management verdicts and actions are correct and that should any challenges arise then it will be regarded as a misguiding or even subversion. By the unitarist approach, management can assert itself. The unitarist approach is likely to yield more production at diminishing unit costs due to the efficient use of effort (Leat, 2008). Also, peace is expected to prevail in the organizations, as shown by the effective management of apparent conflict conduct. There is a good chance of good employee relations organizational control as well as minimized or absence alternatives for employee loyalty within the company. An employer, therefore, can achieve the production goals and objectives without worrying much on the turbulence in the organization like conflicts among employees or loyalty breach by employees to the employer (Leat, 2008). Conclusion In any practice, a unitarist perspective in any organization can be both disadvantageous or beneficial to the employer while managing the workers. It is possible to give rise to an authoritarianism or paternalism form of management of employees. Also, collective bargaining for a prosperous employment relationship is also denied. There is an unequal distribution of power between employers and the providers of work. In situations where a sudden decision needs to be made to provide a solution, a manager can do so without involving the employees and for the benefit of the entire organization. Sometimes, such times require such measures for the interest of the company. Another opportunity posed by the application of a unitarist perspective by employers is increased production and operationalized effort and also the open management of conflict conduct in an organization. References Bingham, C. (2016). Employment relations. Los Angeles: Sage, p.41. Chidi, C. and Okpala, P. (2016). Theoretical Approaches to Employment and Industrial Relations: A Comparison of Subsisting Orthodoxies. In Theoretical and Methodological Approaches to Social Sciences and Knowledge Management. [online] Pdfs.semanticscholar.org. Available at: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/3a29/7a999d9e097613a0d4f007f7485c9f38e808.pdf. Leat, M. (2008). Employee relations. Heriot-Watt University: Edinburgh Business School, p. 20. Harney, B., Wilkinson, A. and Dundon, T. (2017). Employment relations and human resource management. London: Routledge: In A. Wilkinson, J. Donaghey, T. Dundon, & A. Colvin (Eds.), The Routledge companion to employment relations, pp.108 - 124. Wallace, J., Gunnigle, P. and McMahon, G. (2004). Industrial relations in Ireland. 4th ed. Dublin: Gill & Macmillan, p.17. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Challenges and Opportunities Facing a Unitarist Approach Essay, n.d.)
Challenges and Opportunities Facing a Unitarist Approach Essay. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1892585-challenges-and-opportunities-facing-a-unitarist-approach
(Challenges and Opportunities Facing a Unitarist Approach Essay)
Challenges and Opportunities Facing a Unitarist Approach Essay. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1892585-challenges-and-opportunities-facing-a-unitarist-approach.
“Challenges and Opportunities Facing a Unitarist Approach Essay”. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1892585-challenges-and-opportunities-facing-a-unitarist-approach.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Challenges and Opportunities Facing a Unitarist Approach

Reflection on the Eating Challenge

I found out that the challenge can be difficult because many people have already set their ways in their daily activities.... In my case, the foods I have eaten before have… Like on my morning coffee routine, I caught myself many times in the morning unconsciously preparing a cup of coffee only to stop myself short when I suddenly And also with bread, I have also unconsciously picked up bread placed on the table....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Challenges and Opportunities for Immigrant Families

The paper "challenges and opportunities for Immigrant Families" discusses that white American families who only speak English are at a disadvantage because they are tempted to hold narrow views, and find it harder to think in concepts outside their own ethnic group norms.... What are some of the challenges and opportunities for immigrant families, Latinos, African American, Asian gay/lesbian families and multigenerational families?... Families who find themselves victims of racism will stick together more closely, but there are disadvantages in accessing full citizenship benefits if resentment builds up inside the family and opportunities are blocked in society outside the family....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Global Challenges

This is a brief outlook at the challenges facing urban centers planners and policy makers as well as how these challenges will affect the US in the near future.... Migrants into urban centers believe that there are many job opportunities in the urban centers hence necessitating the need for migration into towns to look for jobs (UN-Habitat, 2008).... This is due to the Urban Planning and Future challenges The issue of urban planning has always been a challenge to urban planners and policy makers....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Resourceful Approaches for Making Friends

hellip; The author of the paper states that creativity enables him to have a deep belief that there is a solution to many problems because challenges empower one.... The essay “Resourceful Approaches for Making Friends” describes the 34-year-old Muslim from Saudi Arabia with a daughter and a son....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Challenges and Opportunities Facing Qatar in the Next Ten Years

  This study "The challenges and opportunities facing Qatar in the Next Ten Years" discusses the use of the massive funds that it acquires from the oil reserves to develop its infrastructures.... For instance, the country should develop road and railway networks in the country within the next ten years....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

SDiverse learners as challenges and opportunities

As I am tasked with adult English as a Second Language (ESL) class with diverse learners, it is quite obvious that certain… In general, adult learning occurs in such settings, wherein the prevalent tools and the context get intersected with the interactions made amid the Diverse Learners as challenges and opportunities Considering as a facilitator of learning, it is indispensable to possess unique skills for promotingadult learning (Kasworm, Rose & Ross-Gordon, 2010).... The opportunities that are present in the aforementioned context include acquiring the idea about how community or adult education is being imparted to the learners holding different cultural backgrounds and also exploring distinct problems or issues that tend to generate democratic learning spaces in the stated procedure....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Important challenge facing management

One may also find himself Important Challenge facing Management Important Challenge facing Management One of the major issues affecting management, today hasto do with employee performance.... Many times, the employees of an organization do not perform their duties as per the level expected of them....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Challenges and Opportunities of the Organizations

Another challenge facing the organization relates to lack of proper marketing focus.... The author states that the organization of focus faces a number of challenges but also has reasonable opportunities that can improve its general performance.... Due to offering lower interest rates, the organization attracts many borrowers who have eventually exhausted its reserves Organizational Analysis The organization of focus faces a number of challenges but also has reasonable opportunities that can improve its general performance....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us