StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of Fein and Spencers Study and Sutton and Hargadons 1996 - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Analysis of Fein and Spencer’s Study and Sutton and Hargadon’s 1996 " states that Sutton and Hargadon’s 1996 paper is about group brainstorming as part of company strategies to produce ideas. The paper discusses the effects of brainstorming in groups and the effectiveness of such a procedure…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Analysis of Fein and Spencers Study and Sutton and Hargadons 1996
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of Fein and Spencers Study and Sutton and Hargadons 1996"

Prejudice as self-image maintenance: Affirming the self through derogating others. (Fein & Spencer, 1997; particularly pp. 31-34 what the hypotheses are in Study 1. The hypotheses of Fein and Spencer’s study are based on the effects of ‘self-affirmation’ (31) Those participants who took the test designed to affirm were less likely to judge or negatively view individuals with respect to the groups or stereotypes to which they belong. In contrast, those participants who took the non-affirming test were hypothesised to react with a higher degree of prejudice in an attempt to ‘raise’ themselves up as a self-affirming technique. 2. What were the independent variables in Study 1? Fein and Spencer’s study is hinged on two independent variables. Firstly, the initial task where participants take the affirming or non-affirming test (the ‘manipulation of affirmation’) and secondly, the variation of the interviewee (the ‘manipulation of target’s ethnicity’) (Fein & Spencer, 32-3). Altering the variables of both the test (affirming or non-affirming) and the Jewish/Italian portrayals of the interviewee are the independent factors of the research. 3. How did they measure the dependent variables in Study 1? The dependent variables were measured using scales. Data of both the personality of the candidate and the suitability of the candidate for the job were obtained using seven point scales by which the participants note how strongly they agree with descriptions or specific statements about the job candidate. 4. What inferential statistical method did they use in Study 1? Analysis of variance, otherwise known as ANOVA, was used to test for statistical significance in the study. ANOVA method is useful for determining the variation between two or more means (as suitable for this study) as opposed to commonly used t-tests which only reliably analyses two means. 5. In your own words briefly describe what the main findings were in Study 1. The main findings of the study support the hypotheses. The results for the assessment of the candidate’s personality were not significantly affected by the affirmation test. The results, however, were significant concerning the ‘manipulation of target’s ethnicity’ (Fein & Spencer, 33) and a more negative approach and appraisal was attributed to the candidate when depicted as a Jew. Moreover, the results proved more supportive of the hypothesis by showing that those candidates who were not affirmed reacted more negatively towards the Jewish portrayed candidate than any other participants of the study. Similar patterns were revealed when assessing the candidate’s suitability for the job. The group of participants that weren’t affirmed offered more negative feedback than the affirmed participants, in the face of the candidate’s qualifications. The ethnic manipulation resulted in more positive feedback arising when participants believed the job candidate to be Italian rather than Jewish. The most negative assessments relating to the job candidate’s qualifications and suitability were contributed to the study by those not affirmed participants faced with the Jewish depiction of the interviewee. This is in stark contrast to those affirmed participants who, in the same evaluation of qualifications, did not discriminate between the two portrayals, Jewish and Italian. 6. Can you think of how this study may apply to behaviour in the workplace? Such results of this study throw into question ideas of competency, equal opportunities and discrimination in the workplace. The study is extremely relevant to the context of work and professional occupation where employees are daily faced with challenges and situations that may either affirm or not affirm the self (or their image of the self). The frequency of occurrences where employees are praised or reprimanded in a professional work setting can have implications on the kind of reactions produced with respect to members of stereotyped groups. Organisations with multi-cultural staff and employees are common in today’s world, as are race and gender stereotypes. Such interaction, as indicated by the study, between self affirming or not self affirmed individuals and attitudes and reactions to people falling in to particular stereotypes suggests an imminent problem for the professional world. Fein and Spencer’s study implicates behaviour in professional setting and if employees of a organisation, who are often highly motivated and competitive, strive to increase their feeling of self worth by ‘prejudiced evaluation’ of others (Fein & Spencer, 32), this can have a negative, derogatory effect on other employees. Not only can this lead to unprofessional behaviour but also to more serious implications such as prejudice or racism in the workplace. Brainstorming groups in context: Effectiveness in a product design firm. (Sutton & Hargadon, 1996; particularly pp. 685-689) 7. Using your own words, briefly summarise what this paper is all about. Sutton and Hargadon’s 1996 paper is about group brainstorming as part of company strategies to produce ideas. The paper discusses the effects of brainstorming in groups and the effectiveness of such a procedure. 8. Based on the literature review in the paper, explain how the research in this paper differs from previous research in the field of brainstorming research. Brainstorming research has been studied by many researchers in the past. Sutton and Hargadon’s literature review discusses the limitations of previous studies and highlights that the previous papers are concerned with the number of ideas generated in such brainstorming sessions rather than a wider acknowledgement of the uses and results of group brainstorming. In said literature effectiveness of group brainstorming is equated to (and only to) the quantity of ideas, good or otherwise, produced (and more importantly, shared) by each member of the group (Sutton & Hargadon, 687). In their paper, Sutton and Hargadon argue that group brainstorming should be considered in a wider context than previously studied. They suggest that the fundamental questions of ‘effective for what’ and ‘effective for whom’ are omitted from past research (689). Their paper aims to include such valuable perspectives as why companies conduct such practices as group brainstorming and what effect/benefit it can have for the company. 9. Does this article tell us anything about the benefits and shortcomings of quantitative and qualitative research methods? The article suggests that there are flaws in collecting only quantitative data for this study and topic area. The researchers argue that the past studies should have dealt with more than just numbers of ideas (quantitative data) and address ideas of quality and worthiness of ideas (687) as well as issues of why and what effect is produced by such sessions.. 10. To what extent do you think their findings can be generalised to other organisational settings? The six main findings of the group brainstorming study (apart from merely just producing ideas) can be applied to varying extents in other organisational settings. The first major finding, that group brainstorming supports the ‘organisational memory of design solutions’ (Sutton & Hargadon, 695) is somewhat confined to the design solutions market which covers specific information about design over a range of products. Such information retrieval of past products may not be relevant in organisations that don’t deal with products or design solutions. ‘Skill variety’ (Sutton & Hargadon, 695) provided by group brainstorming is good for employee morale and also to allow them to learn different skills and approaches. Group brainstorming for this effect is suitable and effective for any organisational setting as long as the sessions are relevant and remain professionally motivated. For any employees to gain new and often different skills and knowledge through group brainstorming is advantageous. Group brainstorming is described in the paper as supporting an ‘attitude of wisdom’ (Sutton & Hargadon, 695). That is ‘acting with knowledge while doubting what one knows’ (Sutton & Hargadon, 695). Sutton and Hargadon suggest that this attitude helps in the considering of advice, listening to different views and being ‘neither too confident nor too cautious to ask for help’ (703). This attitude is helpful in any organisational setting and the ‘wisdom’ of wanting to learn and challenge while having knowledge and information can only be beneficial for a company. Group brainstorming is active in creating a ‘status auction’ according to the paper (Sutton & Hargadon, 695). This is where employees compete for reputation and status based on their ‘technical ability’ (705) and differs from the hierarchical positioning of company organisation. Many companies work with the employment hierarchy (managers, staff etc.) and rarely are these titles compromised by aspects such as technical skill or design ability. Only in creative settings may this ‘status auction’ be present. Clients are often impressed by the fun nature of group brainstorming. Such practices where employees can be creative in more informal settings are interesting to clients who often enjoy seeing the creative process. This is limited to organisations where employees uses creative brainstorming, and is also only relevant in client facing roles or organisations. Providing income is viewed in the paper as a more minor result of group brainstorming. Often clients are willing to pay only for brainstorming sessions (Sutton & Hargadon, 709) and clients do not begrudge paying for such services (Sutton & Hargadon, 710) It is debatable whether group brainstorming would be effective for providing income in other organisations and companies would first have to work on presenting brainstorming sessions as productive and beneficial to the clients needs. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Analysis of Fein and Spencers Study and Sutton and Hargadons 1996 Assignment, n.d.)
Analysis of Fein and Spencers Study and Sutton and Hargadons 1996 Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1746371-coursework-assignment
(Analysis of Fein and Spencers Study and Sutton and Hargadons 1996 Assignment)
Analysis of Fein and Spencers Study and Sutton and Hargadons 1996 Assignment. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1746371-coursework-assignment.
“Analysis of Fein and Spencers Study and Sutton and Hargadons 1996 Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1746371-coursework-assignment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Fein and Spencers Study and Sutton and Hargadons 1996

Analysis of Marketing iPhone 5s

 This study considers an analysis of marketing iPhone 5s.... analysis of Marketing iPhone 5s Apple Inc has unveiled a number of products that have stormed the market.... This bundle of technology is advancement from a previous product.... Its market reception has been very impressive and the potential of the product remains to be fully exploited....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Impact of Outsourcing on Honeywell Company Performance

According to Mattiuzzi (2002) through outsourcing Honeywell company reduced its technical manpower costs by 75% to 90% and overall labor costs declined by 50%, … This paper highlights the impact of outsourcing on the company's performance with reference to dividends paid out, the paper also analyses the trend in labor productivity in the US and finally analyses the relationship between labor productivity in the aerospace industry and dividends paid, the following is an analysis of the trend in dividends paid by the Honeywell Company. Honey well company divided payout has increased over the years, this increase can be associated with the increased efforts to increase labor productivity through outsourcing, the following chart shows dividends paid out by the company over the years: data was retrieved from yahoo finance From the above chart it is evident that the divided payout level were low for the period 1976 to 1992 with only slight increases, for the period 1992 to 2000 the divided payout amount increased at an increasing rate and for the period 2000 to 2004 dividends remained constant and for the period 2004 to 2008 the divided payout amount increased at an increasing rate, this shows that there has been an increase in the profitability of the company and this has been due to increased efforts top outsource cheap labor in other parts of the world....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Kim Bassingers Final Analysis

hellip; An analysis of the plaintiff and defendant's arguments and on Main Line's potential $3 million “Boxing Helena” film revenue from domestic distribution, Main Line's maximum and minimum lost profit, which is $9.... equirement #2a Kim Bassinger's Final analysis salary of $3 million is relevant to the determination of lost profits to Main Line....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

The Lovers or The Dustman by Stanley Spencer

From the paper "The Lovers or The Dustman by Stanley Spencer" it is clear that Spencer wrote about his Burghclere murals depicting the resurrection of World War I soldiers, "I have avoided any too unpleasant scene.... ... ... ecause in this scheme, as in all my paintings, I wish to stress my own redemption....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Fundamental Aspects of Ecology

Calculate the average relative rate of population change, [N(t+1) – N(t)]/N(t), and its standard deviation from the population data for the southern resident population of the killer whale, British Columbia, Canada. 3.... Estimate the average time until extinction for a… Assume that for the killer whale population the average growth rate (r) is zero....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us