StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Dilemma That Exists - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
Matt’s mother feels that the child should be brought up in the most natural way just like she was brought up during her early age. Her argument is that her seven year old child should take up his responsibilities without necessarily being rewarded for doing what he is supposed to do. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
The Dilemma That Exists
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Dilemma That Exists"

Case Scenario College: The Dilemma That Exists In this scenario, Matt’s mother feels that the child should be brought up in the most natural way just like she was brought up during her early age. Her argument is that her seven year old child should take up his responsibilities without necessarily being rewarded for doing what he is supposed to do. On the other hand, the psychological approach is that behaviorism principles be applied to help the child learn to distinguish right and wrong behavior by rewarding the child’s positive behaviors (Bailey and Burch, 2013).

While it is right to reward a child’s behavior, it is more appropriate if the child learns to take up their responsibilities without necessarily expecting a reward. The dilemma that exists is that there is a conflict on whether to use the Matt’s mother’s intuition or to apply a psychological approach in helping the child to appreciate their duty of doing homework or even using respectful language. According to McNamara’s decision making model, if there exists a situational dilemma it is important to identify the basis of the conflict while choosing the right path to take on the situation (McNamara, 2008).

The Basis of the Conflict A keen look at the scenario shows that there exists a conflict of interest between Matt’s mother and the welfare of the child in the child orientation program. The mothers wish is that the child learns to respect people, do its homework and doing his chores in the same manner that she learnt without necessarily receiving tokens for doing what they are supposed to do. On the other hand, there is an obligation to change the child’s attitude towards their roles and the end objective is to turn them into a responsible person.

The mother suggests that the child be punished for the wrong actions rather than be only rewarded for doing what in her opinion should be done by any responsible child. McNamara (2008) provides that the role of a psychologist is to protect the interests of all the parties that are entangled in a dilemma without sacrificing the primary objective of the therapy program. In this scenario, the therapist would require to achieve the objective of transforming the child’s behavior without hurting the feeling of the mother about child appraisal.

By upholding the Matt’s mother’s opinion, it would be satisfactory for her but at the end the reform process is likely to be ineffective. Consequently, the psychologist has a role to consider the best course of action that would resolve the dilemma effectively by harmonizing the interests of their client. Available Courses of Action After identifying the basis of conflict resulting to the ethical dilemma, McNamara (2008) recommends that the psychologist be able to plot the possible paths that they could use in resolving the dilemma.

One of the possible actions that a therapist in this situation would take is to give the mother a go ahead in withdrawing the rewards that she had used to entice Matt and instead resort to punishment when the child does wrong. Going by this, the child would learn to associate wrong behavior with punishment and may at the end of it drop such behaviors. The danger with this method is that the child might develop a negative attitude towards the parent and to her homework which might affect their academic performance.

Another option would be to disclose to the parent the essence of rewarding good behavior in encouraging a child and helping them to improve its relationship with the parent. The danger of this would be that the parent may be more likely to overwhelmed by her feeling to bring up her child naturally and the consequently the risk of withdrawing from the therapy program. This may have a negative impact on the child’s interest given that the priority of a therapist is to solve the primary problem of rehabilitating the child.

Lastly, another path to take would be to provide harmonize the mother's idea with the behavioristic approach recommending the application of both punishments for wrong behavior and reward for positive behavior. In this case, Matt’s mother may be satisfied by the partial adopting of her intuition and is likely to respond to positively to such a procedure. Course of Action and Outcome Evaluation The best course of action in this scenario would be to harmonize the two methods of child rehabilitation by allowing the parent to discipline the child for its wrong behaviors and reward them for responsible behavior.

The expected outcome of this course of action is that Matt would learn to associate the wrong behavior with punishment and the right behavior with a reward, which is likely to encourage him to be responsible. Consequently, the action would achieve the primary goal of rehabilitating the child through an affirmative reform process. The possible negative impact of this course of action would be the kind of attitude that is likely to be impacted on the child especially if the mother inflicts severe punishment on the child wherever they wrong, which would be a hindrance to the primary objective of therapy plan.

To ameliorate the negative impact of this course of action, I would make Matt’s mother aware of the dangers of excessive punishment. Also, like Bailey and Burch (2013) points out, it would be necessary to start a re-evaluation program to check the success of this course of action after every one week by obtaining feedback from Matt’s mother on the progress. Consequently, it would be possible to modify the therapy program depending on the response of the child behavior to the rehabilitation scheme.

References Bailey, J. and Burch, M., (2013). Ethics for Behavior Analysts. UK, London: Taylor & Francis. McNamara, K. (2008). Best practices in the application of professional ethics: Best Practices in School Psychology. National Association of School Psychologists. Retrieved from: < http://www.nasponline.org/standards/ethicstrainingpackage.ppt>

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Dilemma That Exists Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1487592-case-scenario
(The Dilemma That Exists Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1487592-case-scenario.
“The Dilemma That Exists Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1487592-case-scenario.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Dilemma That Exists

Types of Social Dilemmas and Tragedy of Commons Dilemma

This paper "Types of Social Dilemmas and Tragedy of Commons dilemma" tells that the individual interests are not only selfish but also harmful to the group and later on to the individual.... hellip; A social dilemma is where an individual faces a tensional situation in deciding what best is for them and what best is for the larger society.... nbsp; There are different types of social dilemmas; the tragedy of commons dilemma, resource dilemma, and prisoners dilemma....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Salvage of Endangered Species

The Dilemma That Exists in man's life is whether to give up on the gains from other creatures to avoid extinction or continue gaining at the cost of the almost extinct creatures.... The paper 'Salvage of Endangered Species" discusses that man is part of nature, and extinction of other creatures does have various effects on him....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Society of Composers, Authors and Music Publishers of Canada v. Bell Canada

The famous case between the Society of Composers, Authors, and Music Publishers of Canada and Bell Canada emerged from The Dilemma That Exists on the extent of the right to access copyrighted information (Hovenkamp 48).... The study will concentrate on the information that exists and the interrelation of different entities on the validity and significance of copyright laws in a society with special interest to Canada and focusing on the Society of Composers, Authors, and Music Publishers of Canada v....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Proposal

Ethical Dilemmas at Workplace

There exists a dilemma on whether this issue should be forwarded to the council or the matter should just be ignored.... Mackenzie is in a dilemma on whether to reject the whole recruitment process just because a few of the interviewee's ignored the basic rule.... In the paper “Ethical Dilemmas at Workplace” the author discusses the case of Mackenzie and Elena, sorority's president, who saw other sorority people talking in the hallway during lunch time....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

The Society of Composers, Authors, and Music Publishers of Canada

hellip; The study will concentrate on the information that exists and the interrelation of different entities on the validity and significance of copyright laws in a society with special interest to Canada and focus on the Society of Composers, Authors, and Music Publishers of Canada v.... The study will concentrate on the information that exists and the interrelation of different entities on the validity and significance of copyright laws in a society with special interest to Canada and focus on the Society of Composers, Authors, and Music Publishers of Canada v....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Fundamental Element of a Dilemma

hellip; the dilemma with the above-mentioned trolley may also be easily solved by Virtue Ethics.... The paper "The Fundamental Element of a dilemma" discusses the outlook of a person.... Speaking of moral dilemmas, one might argue that this theory is a rather useful one since it will always be able to prove a clear answer to a dilemma....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ethics, Professionalism and Contemporary Issues

The Dilemma That Exists in the case is that on one hand, if Tom tells the owner that the product had failed and that he had conducted only three tests rather than ten under the high humidity conditions, he might be fired from the job as a result of which, he would not only become unemployed but also would run short of money to finance the medical treatment of his son.... This report "Ethics, Professionalism and Contemporary Issues" analyses the dilemma in the case that Tom might lose his job and fail to manage the expenses for the medical treatment of his son if he tells the owner that the product failed one of the tests....
5 Pages (1250 words) Report

Situations of Moral Dilemma

This essay "Moral dilemma" discusses decisions that are bestowed on a human being.... When faced with a moral dilemma a decision has to be made.... hellip; The best way to take the approach is to understand all elements that are manifested in a certain dilemma.... The decision made on moral dilemma must also reflect sacrifice and love for humanity.... That is, one has to find the best moral standards in order to solve the moral dilemma....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us