StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of the Hitlers Table Talk, 1941-1944 - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper contains a book review of "Hitler’s Table Talk, 1941-1944" written by Cameron, N., and Stevens, R.H.which shows what Hitler was like when he was off guard, and in the last years of his life, when many of his early ideas had largely been enacted upon…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Analysis of the Book Hitlers Table Talk, 1941-1944
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of the Hitlers Table Talk, 1941-1944"

Term Paper on Hitler’s Table Talk, 1941-1944. The loose collection of recorded and reconstructed conversations with Hitler throughout the of the Second World War is an interesting historical source because it gives plenty of insight into Hitler the man, as well as the military leader and strategist. Despite some issues relating to the doubtful authenticity of the remarks, and the difficulty of rendering a full account from partial notes, and in translation as well, there are revealing snippets which show how Hitler felt about things as a mature leader. A great deal of work has gone into his early life and writings, where he laid out his great plans for Germany, and philosophized about the Aryan race and the way it was destined to create a great and wonderful Reich that would conquer all other races. The special importance of this book is that is shows what Hitler was like when he was off guard, and in the last years of his life, when many of his early ideas had largely been enacted upon. He was not speaking here to huge assembled crowds, and in the more intimate setting of the dinner table, he may have revealed some of his innermost thoughts, including ideas, fears and wishes that he would have hesitated to make known in a more public setting. The first paragraph selected (Paragraph A, p. 298) shows just how impressed Hitler was with one of the greatest British politicians of the twentieth century, the Welshman Lloyd George. People tend to forget that Hitler was an admirer of the British, and that he retained this admiration even through the war years when pursued a bitter conflict against them. It is interesting that he admires the speaking style of Lloyd George, and contrasts this with the “repulsive, affected type of English” spoken by Anthony Eden who was British foreign secretary at that time. It is true that Lloyd George quite rightly believed that the Treaty of Versailles amounted to an unjustly harsh repression of Germany after the First World War, and that this was bound to be popular with Hitler, who did everything in his power to evade the conditions of that treaty. The intriguing message in this paragraph is, however, that Hitler stresses it is not just what a man believes that is important, but also the way that he conveys his message to others. Lloyd George and Hitler were both charismatic speakers, who declaimed their views in a loud and manly way, not mincing their words, and saying even things that were unpopular with conviction and pride. This paragraph shows that Hitler was very conscious of the power of rhetorical skills, including his own, and it would be a great irony indeed if, as suggested here, he modelled his style on someone like Lloyd George of Britain. The power to convince others and carry forward strong views is one of the key reasons behind a politician’s success. This shows that Hitler was always conscious of the emotional and physical effect of other men on their followers, and he shrewdly spotted this talent in others. He could hardly shout his admiration for Lloyd George from the rooftops, but it appears that he did harbour a secret admiration for one of the enemy leaders. The second paragraph (Paragraph B, pp. 494-495) shows a side of Hitler that is not often mentioned in biographies of his life. He is usually depicted as a strong leader, running a number of paramilitary organizations which were segregated quite strictly along gender lines. He never married, and it is disputed just how far Hitler really appreciated women as romantic partners or as equal citizens. In his vision of Nazi Germany, young men went into the Hitler Youth, which prepared them for eventual service in one of the military services while young women had their own separate organization which prepared them to be successful wives and mothers, producing more population to sustain the growing German Reich. There is an inherent bias in this structure, which privileges the men to an active and leading role and relegates the women to a lower position of support for their men. The comment that it is better to pay women well rather than to have rely on a male friend or partner is an indication that Hitler may have changed his mind on women throughout the course of his life, coming to value them more as he got older. This paragraph shows Hitler expressing a rather modern view, and one which places women on a more equal footing. He argues that working women should be paid a fair wage, on a par with men, in return for their hard work. It may be that he noted how important women had become in sustaining the morale of the population while the men were at war, and increasingly also, how critical women’s work was in maintaining industrial output, and a smooth running of society. No doubt these ulterior motives influenced his thinking on this point, but nevertheless this paragraph is evidence that Hitler respected women, and valued their contribution, at least in the case of German women. The final paragraph selected for discussion (paragraph C, p. 170) is one which occurs early in the book, at a time when the winning the war appeared still to be within Germany’s grasp. Hitler looks back on his earlier life and speaks of “my setback in 1923” which refers to his mis-timed and failed attempt to seize power during a public meeting in Munich. His resulting arrest, trial and imprisonment were a huge blow to his self-esteem, and he reveals here that saw this as a temporary “setback” using the image of a coiled spring, waiting to be released again so that it could spring into action as if nothing had happened. This reveals the resilience of his self-belief as a young man. It appears that he has transferred some of this faith into his followers in middle life, since he says “I believe blindly in my nation.” What is new in his later reflection in this paragraph, is that he is beginning to realize that he is mortal, and he fears the possibility of losing faith again, because he is not the same resilient youth that he once was. Hitler’s philosophy is curiously fatalistic. He believes that one is born either to be an optimist or a pessimist, which denies the freedom of an individual to make his or her own destiny. He further believes that optimism grows weaker, which in effect is to say that even optimists tend towards pessimism as they grow older. On the surface this is just a generalization about life which need not be taken too seriously, but it is possible that there is also some deeper psychological truth about Hitler hidden in this paragraph. It seems that Hitler is not able to tolerate the prospect of gradual decline. In this respect he is fighting against human nature because everyone will one day, if they are fortunate, reach old age and discover that their powers are becoming less. Life becomes more of a struggle and it takes great courage to keep going in the certain knowledge that decline is inevitable. Hitler reveals here that he can imagine a situation where he would not have the strength to recover from a setback. He implies that he could not face being let down by the nation that he so blindly has placed his confidence in. Saying that he would have no other alternative but “to shut up shop” if he lost this belief in his country is in fact a very prophetic remark. It turned out at the end of it all that he took his own life, and in effect closed down the huge apparatus of Nazism, rather than face the shame of defeat and the strenuous challenge of dealing with the aftermath of a war which Germany had lost. These three small paragraphs contain clues about the emotional make up of a man who is often viewed as a monster. He shows a human side in these paragraphs, admitting emotions like admiration, pride and fear of failure and this gives the reader a more rounded picture of him as a human being. In between the rather repetitive and boring sections about Nazi ideology these personal touches show good and bad points in his character that illuminate his actions. One could speculate, for example, that if he had been less fatalistic about the human ability to be optimistic, and to retain resilience in maturity, then he might have survived the war and been a focal point for revival of the ideas he so strongly believed in when he was alive. He had argued all along that the Jews were to blame for everything, and he could have continued in this vein through another arrest and trial. It seems, however, that Hitler in his heart of hearts knew that he might one day face another “setback” and his intriguing off-hand dinner conversation suggests that he had already planned his response to this, several years before it came to pass. Reference Cameron, N. and Stevens, R.H. (Eds) Hitler’s Table Talk, 1941-1944. New York: Enigma Books, 2000. Extracts from Hitler’s Table Talk, 1941-1944. Paragraph A. (p. 298) The Briton who made the deepest impression on me was Lloyd George. Eden speaks a repulsive, affected type of English, but Lloyd George was a pure orator, and a man of tremendous breadth of vision. What he has written on the Treaty of Versailles will endure for ever. He was the first man to declare that this Treaty would lead inevitably to another war. The idea that a people like the German people can be destroyed is madness, he said. Britain, he added, had no alternative but to live on terms of friendship with Germany. Paragraph B. (pp. 494-495) Of primary importance were the measures we took to ensure a living wage for working women, such as secretaries, shopgirls, artistes and the like. By insisting that they receive a regular wage in accordance with their qualifications—instead of the sort of pocket-money they formerly received—we have delivered them from the doleful necessity of being dependent on an ami for their existence. Paragraph C. (p. 170) One is born an optimist, just as one is born a pessimist. With age, optimism gets weaker. The spring relaxes. When I suffered my setback in 1923, I had only one idea, to get back into the saddle. To-day Id no longer be capable of the effort which that implies. The awareness that one is no longer capable of that has something demoralising about it. I believe blindly in my nation. If I lost that belief, wed have nothing left to do but to shut up shop. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Analysis of the Book Hitlers Table Talk, 1941-1944 Report/Review, n.d.)
Analysis of the Book Hitlers Table Talk, 1941-1944 Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1761355-germany-hitler-book
(Analysis of the Book Hitlers Table Talk, 1941-1944 Report/Review)
Analysis of the Book Hitlers Table Talk, 1941-1944 Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/history/1761355-germany-hitler-book.
“Analysis of the Book Hitlers Table Talk, 1941-1944 Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1761355-germany-hitler-book.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of the Book Hitlers Table Talk, 1941-1944

The Tale of Kiu by Nguyen Du

The main propeller of immorality is the main character but in this paper, I will talk about Thuc.... The paper "The Tale of Kiều by Nguyen Du" presents a masterpiece of Vietnamese poetry about life and trials of Tui Kigu, a beautiful and talented young lady who sacrificed herself to save her father and younger brother from prison....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

The Tell-Tale Heart

In the paper “The Tell-Tale Heart” the author analyzes the narration of a mentally unstable and deranged mind.... The narrator comes across an old man for whom he professes affection except for hatred towards one of his eyes which is like a vulture's.... hellip; The author states that the narrator's hatred for this eye is so strong that he plots to kill the old man....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Pre 1914 Prose

Thomas Hardy is infamous for presenting us with tales that expose some of the most deplorable conditions of man ever known.... His fiction works well within the realm of realism and that is exactly what makes it so painful to read sometimes.... We know that his characters could very well be our neighbors or friends and sometimes this is chilling, as most of Hardy's character analyses are painfully critical....
11 Pages (2750 words) Book Report/Review

The Handmaids Tale as a Feminist Dystopian Work

the book has a disjoint and unfinished ending of how Offred is taken away in the Eye van.... The author of this book report "The Handmaids Tale as a Feminist Dystopian Work" casts light on the novel where the narrator is a fertile woman called Offred.... As the text has it, the story is set in the Republic of Gilead and is the story of the widespread issue of infertility....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

Analysis

The Marshall Plan emphasized on military preparedness putting into consideration the sacrifices that were made by the allies in pursuit 2nd World War victory.... In the excerpt, For the Common Defense, 1945, Marshall blamed the leaders, both foreign and domestic, of being too… Security policies do not translate to war policies and the Germans have defined war because they gave it considerable thought....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Adams, R.J.Q. (ed.), The Great War, 1914-18 (1990)

the book also provides an insight into how United States of America entered into the war through covert and overt means.... It had a totally new dynamics and outlook to it.... However, the Second World War would outsmart the First World War in different proportions and would stun the entire world and… In short, these two wars changed the parameters and metrics in which wars, global peace, diplomacy, political affiliations, alliances and counter alliances were being held and were to be held in coming years. The works are a The First World War is often dubbed for the Great War....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

The cat's table

Below the tideline, The Cat's table is a… He is travelling all by him to be reunited with his mother.... ) On board the Oronsay, the young Michael, soon nicknamed Mynah, is assigned a dining seat at the lowly Cat's table.... It is an adventure story detailing the journey of an eleven-year-old boy sailing from Ceylon (now Sri Lanka) to England in the 1950s....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Strange Defeat by Marc Bloch

This paper analyses the book "Strange Defeat" by Marc Bloch, where he  explores both social and military factors, that had diluted the national solidarity of France.... nbsp; … He wrote the book after he returned home from service following the fall of France.... In the book he also explores all the other factors, both social and military, that had had diluted the national solidarity of France.... His is an insightful book giving us details and arguments about the flaws that led to the collapse of the army....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us