StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Significance of the French States Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946 - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The focus of this paper is on the issue of the significance of the French States adoption of indicative planning in 1946, which is one of great importance and relevance, and there are many different matters within this which is addressed and discussed in this essay…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.2% of users find it useful
The Significance of the French States Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Significance of the French States Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946"

Economic History: The Significance of the French s Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946 2007 Economic History: The Significanceof the French States Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946 The issue of the significance of the French States adoption of indicative planning in 1946 is one of great importance and relevance, and there are many different matters within this which need to be addressed and discussed in order to properly understand, and this includes recognizing and understanding about the meaning and purpose of indicative planning, the distinctive features of French indicative planning, as well as the importance of the years between 1945 and 1975, and any and all other key and related issues. The aim of this paper is to thoroughly address and discuss all of the previously mentioned issues, in order to allow the reader to attain a much more informed and knowledgeable understanding on the subject matter at hand. This is what will be dissertated in the following. One of the most major market failures in the world is the presence of imperfect information, and indicative planning is considered as being one of the best attempts that can be used in order to bridge this information gap. Basically, the aim of indicative planning is "to improve the performance of the economy by the provision of better economic information: forecasts or targets are published but compliance with them is voluntary. The underlying logic is that the plan, via collective action, can supply economically valuable information which, as a public good, the market mechanism does not disseminate efficiently" (Young & Holmes, 2000). There are many different reasons as to why it is believed that we need this indicative planning, and namely: if there were complete and efficient forward markets there would be little need for indicative planning or any shared set of assumptions because enterprises could use such markets to hedge the risks attendant on their investment decisions; the economic forecasts embodied in an indicative plan give both buyers and seller's confidence that the general levels of demand for products and supply of materials would be forthcoming; by identifying early the existence of any oversupply or bottlenecks, investment behavior can be modified in a timely fashion and the incidence of market disequilibria reduced; and both business and consumers can benefit from exercise in collective and consistent market research, which is freely distributed to all the relevant actors in the economy. (He, 2007). In regards to French indicative planning, there are many other issues that need to be discussed here, and the theory of French indicative planning is an issue which is of primary importance; the founder of the French indicative planning was a man named Pierre Masse, and it was he who actually introduced the concept of information pooling, where planners carry out 'generalized market research', thus allowing a common view of the future, and "This research involves consulting with leading actors in the economy for their input, a process called concertation. After this step the elements of the plan are adjusted to assure coherence and to guarantee policy coordination. The goal is concerted economy" (He, 2007). The French adoption of indicative planning had many steps involved within it, and this begins around the year 1500, when France surpassed China as being the nation with the largest GDP in the world; Jean-Baptiste Colbert, who was the finance minister under Louis XIV at that time, was pursuing strongly for aggressive and comprehensive governmental policies, and in fact, during this time, Colbertism became a word that was used to describe interventionalist state activity. Similarly, in the 19th century, France was considered as being a 'late' industrializer, and policy was more directed towards the nurturing and protecting of the industry as a whole. In 1830 France was surpassed by the UK; in 1936 a leftist regime came to power, led by L'eon Blum, and resulted in establishing a Ministry of National Economy; and in 1940, Germany easily defeated France, and it was this defeat which in fact inspired the original introduction of indicative planning after the war, when the leader of the anti-Nazi Resistance, General Charles de Gaulle, headed up the government in the year 1946. The organization and planning of the French adoption of indicative planning is incredibly important here, and in France, the planning is carried out by whoever is in the position of Commission General du Plan (CGP, General Commission of Planning), of which was established in 1946, and which as well is subordinate to the Ministry of Finance. Then, "The concertation process is carried out by the Economic and Social Council, which has been concerned more recently with social issues such as education, women's rights, and income distribution. Also involved in concertation are the Modernization Commissions" (He, 2007). There are many different plans which have taken place over time in regards to the French adoption of indicative planning, and the First Plan (1946-1952) had one major goal, which was to gain industrial reconstruction from previous war damage. This plan more than any other later plan had a more command character, because CGP played an important role here in regards to the distributing of Marshall Plan monies based upon it. The plan also focused on six sectors in particular, those being: coal, electricity, steel, cement, agricultural machinery, and transportation. Then there was a Second Plan as well (1953-1957), and this plan was the one which basically introduced the concept of concertation, and as well the Modernization Commissions. Furthermore, both this and the Third Plan (1957-1961) were considered as being the most successful of all the plans, mainly because they were able to more properly introduce macroeconomic forecasting and produced better growth overall. The Fourth Plan (1961-1965) was one which included a variety of different goals from those before it, and this included expanded social infrastructure investment as well as emphasis on regional planning. With the Fifth Plan (1965-1970) "contained detailed microeconomic elements but had a macroeconomic focus particularly on international competitiveness and controlling inflation. Growth exceeded the target for the last time in a French plan, but was disrupted by the 1968 student-worker uprisings" (He, 2007). Following this, the Sixth Plan (1970-1975) fell miserably short of its goals after the first oil shock hit France in 1973; the Seventh Plan (1975-1980) tended to ignore microeconomic aspects entirely and as well sought to achieve macroeconomic balance alone and resulted in failure; the Eighth Plan (1980-1984) "had a microeconomic emphasis, pushing for high-technology development. This major focus was continued in the Ninth Plan (1984-1988)" (He, 2007). Finally, in the Tenth Plan (1989-1992), there was more focus on European integration and as well more of a preparation of France for the complete removal of market barriers in the EU on January 1, 1993. As we can see from this, the plan changed after the late 1950s, for a variety of reasons, namely because of how dramatically life in France was changing at that point, and consequently how drastically different things were after this point compared to the years before. From this review we are able to conclude a number of different things, several which are of particular importance and significance, such as the fact of how critical the issue of indicative planning is considered to be in France. The French adoption of indicative planning was a process in the works, which truly spanned over decades and which, although losing its prestige at a certain point and as well having the actual overall plan fail, greatly and positively influenced France in various different ways, particularly on an economic basis. Indicative planning in general is an issue which is studied in wider economic, social, historical and cultural context, particularly with an emphasis on French economic thinking and historical circumstances; furthermore, from the years of 1946 - 2003, principles, methods, tools, and institutions of this indicative planning truly experienced an incredibly important evolution which was characterized dramatically by the rising decentralization that was taking place across the world, and as well the shift that was present towards the so-called 'strategic planning'. France especially had to cope with the limited possibilities of planning in open economy, and through the role of France in regards to the construction of the European Union, there was a specific evolution of French economic policy which took place. From this we have been able to understand about why and how the French adopted indicative planning, as well as how positively or negatively it has worked for them over the years. We have also been able to see that there are many different solutions which could be presented to the problems in this type of situation, and only once these sorts of solutions are taken will France be able to get back to the high point economically and financially that it was once at. References He, H (2007). French Indicative Planning, online article retrieved March 30, 2007, from http://72.14.205.104/searchq=cache:UtOoJ6qgy5QJ:www.econ.umn.edu/hhe/TEACHING/ECON4337/Frencheconomy.pdf+french+indicative+planning&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=1 Young, P. & Holmes, R (2000). The English Civil War. New York: Combined Publishing. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Significance of the French States Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
The Significance of the French States Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/history/1527607-economic-history
(The Significance of the French States Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
The Significance of the French States Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1527607-economic-history.
“The Significance of the French States Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/history/1527607-economic-history.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Significance of the French States Adoption of Indicative Planning in 1946

Shanghai Commercial History

France and America were the next invaders around the city, with France settling in the western part of the town (later called the french Concession), and the American establishing themselves to the north of Suzhou Creek in 1863 (combining with the British settlement to be the International Settlement)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

St.Paul's and St.Peter's Baroque Styles

It is worth noting the significance of the two church buildings: St.... Zirpolo (2008) confirms this when he states that Baroque started as a protest to the adoption of Mannerist Art, and as a way to effect the wishes of Counter-Reformation Church, which wanted to stamp its authority....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Malta in World War II

British government had other worries about whether to retain the island in May 1940 when the french Prime Minister, Paul Reynaud, stated that the state of affairs in France was horrible, however that Italy might be pacifies with the surrendering of Malta.... It had been, ever since 1800, after two years of Napoleonic invasion, a division of the British Empire, its geographical significance had been recognized by Britain for the whole occupation....
34 Pages (8500 words) Essay

Eisenhower and U.S. Policy in Southeast Asia

By the time the last American troops were being withdrawn from Southeast Asia in March 1973, America was suffering from a war on two fronts – one abroad in Southeast Asia and one with itself.... … Vietnam policy under Eisenhower can be summed up with two headings.... First, a reluctance to actively go to war in Vietnam using the full power of the American military attack force, in spite of the fact that Eisenhower acknowledged the Communist threat from China in Southeast Asia....
45 Pages (11250 words) Essay

Revealing Degenerative Joint Disease on Earlier Societies

It has often been difficult for archaeologists to determine just how very ancient people lived in their daily activities and lifestyles because of a general lack of any kind of written or oral history regarding these people.... While tools and materials can often be found in… places, giving indications of what was important to these people, these do not always give evidence of the types of activities the people practiced on a regular basis....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Displaced People as a Social Outcome from WWII

The paper "Displaced People as a Social Outcome from WWII" presents the problem of displacing populations in the world.... nbsp;German and Soviet offensives in 1939 and 1940 generated waves of immigrants in swift succession; then followed the banishments of civilians from the invaded territories into the Reich and incarceration of millions of prisoners of war from the Allied party....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

United Nations Emergency Force

nbsp; At this time, it was very crucial for the United Nations to respond immediately to the crisis to avoid any warfare in the region, and it did react firmly and quickly by planning to establish its emergency force for the objective of peacekeeping globally, but mainly for the conflict of Egypt and Israel (United Nations, 2009).... ne of the major factors for the need of an emergency force of the United Nations was the pandemic characteristic of this Egypt-Israel conflict that had the ability to involve major powers like the United states, the United Kingdom, France, etc (Hudson, 1960)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Dreams versus Practicality: The Legacy of Modernism on the Planning of London

The author states that it is not the same thing to plan a city for a new location as it is to organize on-going planning for a city with a long history.... Before having a look at the influence of Le Corbusier and others like him, such as Ebenezer Howard and Patrick Abercrombie, a brief look at how London has viewed and received planning and development is necessary.... Looking at its planning history, as well, one finds a very strong and clearly dominant ideology of private property for a long time preceding World War II (Simmie 1994) The bearers of this ideology - mostly, but not always, embodied in landed gentry - have been in conflict with attempts to over-ride it, mainly during the two planning periods of 1947-68, that is, the years that closely followed after the destruction of the war, when London was heavily bombed, and the 1969-78 period....
14 Pages (3500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us