StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Why South African Constitution is better than the United State's constitution - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Why South African Constitution Is Better Than the United State's Constitution
Introduction
One of the most important documents in the governing of a country is the constitution, in it, there are several issues articulated including the core values that a country upholds. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Why South African Constitution is better than the United States constitution
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Why South African Constitution is better than the United State's constitution"

Why South African Constitution Is Better Than the United s Constitution 3April Why South African Constitution Is Better Than the United State's Constitution Introduction One of the most important documents in the governing of a country is the constitution, in it, there are several issues articulated including the core values that a country upholds. The constitution also provides for the bills of right, how it enshrines bills of right is one of the most important issues that are being looked for in the constitution to demonstrate its efficacy.

One can make a conclusion whether the constitution is meant to suppress its citizen or for their prosperity. How it recognizes the freedom and the rights of the citizen for economic growth is also a factor to consider in assessing the accommodative nature of the constitution.1 Difference in the US and SA Constitution Mark Kende in his writing has compared the constitution of the US and that of South Africa with assertion that the South African constitution in this regard remains detailed and inclusive than that of the US.

Kende posits that the US constitution provides more for the negative values as compared with the South African constitution, this he summarizes in his theory that liberty should presume subsistence.2 Kende also urges that the human right experts have caste the fundamental human rights in to three generations; the political and civil rights, socio-economic rights, and green right. In this reference of human rights classification, Cass Sustein also resonates with Kende that in the consideration of the three classifications, the South African constitution remains admirable compared with that of the US.

3 This is because it elaborates on the provision of the socio-economic rights; this was deliberately crafted to help in cushion the victims of the Apartheid regime who had grown poor and vulnerable. The constitutional court of South Africa also requires the government to implement these rights without any hesitation. Contrary, the US courts have not put the government on task to implement the provision of the socio-economic rights for the protection of the vulnerable despite the proposal by Franklin D.

Roosevelt. The difference between the US and the South African constitution therefore comes when one looks at the manner in which the second and third human rights categories are detailed. For the US to catch up with the South African Court, they have to resolve the hurdle of separation of powers so that the implementation of two human rights can be achieved. The US has come to their defense that the separation of powers in their country has immensely contributed t the kind of constitution that they have.

4 Separation of Powers There are usually, three arms of the government that works in tandem in governance, the legislative, executive, and the Judicial arm, the writing of the constitution is made and enforced by the three bodies in a government. The US supreme courts have raised some of the concerns as being responsible for the failure of the constitution to shed light on the socio-economic rights of the US constitution. It says that it is the legislature and not the courts that should enact socio-economic rights and not the courts, they also says that the judiciary’ incompetence informs that they cannot make such decisions and finally, the problems of the separation powers can be minimized if the negatives rights are enshrined in the constitution.

5 To implement the constitutional requirement by the US, there should be a systematic flow of the law from the legislature to the judiciary for implementation and enforcement similar to the situation in South Africa. Conclusion It will be remembered that the American constitution is one of the oldest in the history of the world, in this regard, most of the people including the American can be deceived that it is the best constitution in the world but this is not the case. It is time that the Americans be conscious and less self-centered given that there are contemporary constitution in some of the countries that have come up with a better constitution compared to that of the US.

South Africa is one such country that has come with a constitution that is much inclusive and accommodative than that of the US, in South Africa, the constitution is much comprehensive, much detailed, and clearly enumerates the human rights as appreciated by the norms of the international human rights. The United States constitution does not enshrine this compared to that of South Africa, which detailed these provisions and upholds them. It is therefore a lesson that the US should open up and borrow from other foreign jurisprudence on the constitutional issues.

Bibliography Banks, Joan. The U.S. Constitution. Philadelphia: Chelsea House Publishers, 2006. Dickens, Thomas. "South Africa's new constitution." Faces: People, Places, and cultures, February 1, 2007. Kekana, Artwell Gomolemo. Justiciability of qualified socio economic rights. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 2011. Kende, Mark S. "Why the South African Constitution is BETTER than the United States's." autoredirect to main site. Race Relations 2011. Accessed April 3, 2013, http://academic.udayton.

edu/race/06hrights/georegions/africa/safrica03.htm

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Why South African Constitution is better than the United State's Essay”, n.d.)
Why South African Constitution is better than the United State's Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1472614-why-south-african-constitution-is-better-than-the
(Why South African Constitution Is Better Than the United State'S Essay)
Why South African Constitution Is Better Than the United State'S Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1472614-why-south-african-constitution-is-better-than-the.
“Why South African Constitution Is Better Than the United State'S Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1472614-why-south-african-constitution-is-better-than-the.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why South African Constitution is better than the United State's constitution

Causes of the Civil War

As an overview, the American Civil War lasted from 1861 to 1865 where 11 states from the south of the country secede.... nbsp; The cotton gin was invented by Eli Whitney, who graduated from Yale University, and was able to go to south Carolina to tutor the children of wealthy farmers.... As a graduate from Yale University, the people in south Carolina were aware of the intelligence of Whitney.... With the invention of Whitney, the south was able to experience a growth in the production of its cotton....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Main Successes and Failures of Tony Blairs Government

The main successes and failures of tony Blair's new labor government 1997- 2007 Name Institution Introduction Anthony Charles Lynton Blair was born in 1953 in the united Kingdom, a graduate of University of Oxford and many other recognized institutions.... hellip; During the 1997 general elections, the Labour Party won elections winning 418 seats enabling him to serve as the Prime Minister of the united Kingdom from 1997 to 2007.... This implies that the government was not stable and had no strong probability to solve governmental issues or give firm stands concerning the united Kingdom hence Blair had to work hard under his personal capacity to ensure that the UK was better placed as compared to earlier governments....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Analysis of Self-executing Treaties

The implementation of these treaties in the jurisdiction of each country, however, is a complicated matter.... Some nations have adopted a more open approach to… Nevertheless, most nations of the world have, in some form or measure, applied these laws and treaties onto their jurisdictions in order to comply with the requisites of international laws and to foster In an effort to assess how international laws and treaties are applied by nation-states, this paper shall discuss the application of self-executing treaties and the position of treaties recovering provisional application....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Status of Women in South Africa

From the united States of America to Australia, from Kazakhstan to South Africa, the status of women in the society has been a much discussed subject.... The progressive constitution of South Africa guarantees equality for women, access to socio economic rights e.... %) than men (23.... % was among black african women.... here was another survey done in 2006, the General Household Survey, indicated that 37% refers to households headed by women, and those headed by black african women tally up to 31....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Framing the State in Times of Transition

However, in the year 1950, neighboring Ethiopia joined hands with the united Nations to liberate Eritrea from the hostile hands of the British.... Therefore, the united Nations sent the observers.... An example was given of a nation called Kenya in Africa, which tried to draft the constitution of its former colonizer; Britain (Bekete, pg 65).... This is what facilitated the making of the new constitution.... In 1997, the approved constitution was ratified but has never been implemented fully to date....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Historical Basis of Modern Sovereignty

In this paper trace the notion of sovereignty in the united States of America which will allow recognizing its significant differences from the modern sovereignty.... That is why these can become the basis of the new sovereignty.... This paper also discerns the bases on which a new imperial sovereignty has been formed....
17 Pages (4250 words) Term Paper

In Favor of Slavery Abolition

show that about 4 million slaves costing almost $4 billion lived in the united States before the Civil War.... They argued that the constitution and the Declaration of the Union supported slavery and the right of white people to own black slaves.... The author takes into account the arguments of the south against the abolition of slavery, its detrimental effects, ideals declared in The Declaration of Independence.... Statistical data on the population in the North and south of the U....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Economic and Political Systems of the US, Japan, and South Africa

The 20th century demarcates a time of enormous changes in the political life of the united States.... However, a larger part of the political system of the united States is largely influenced by the decisions of the founding fathers who were seeking a different system from their colonial master, the British.... ust like any country, the fundamental principles upon which the united States is governed is enshrined in the constitution which is considered the shortest with only seven article and 27 amendments....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us