StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

A Strong, Centrlized Government vs. Fifty Strong State Governments - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
A Strong, Centralized Government vs. Fifty Strong State Governments [YOUR NAME HERE] [YOUR UNIVERSITY NAME HERE] Abstract Should government reside with the powers of each state, or with a central power? The Founding Fathers were called upon not only to answer questions of life, liberty, and happiness, but this very important question as well…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
A Strong, Centrlized Government vs. Fifty Strong State Governments
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Strong, Centrlized Government vs. Fifty Strong State Governments"

Download file to see previous pages

Ultimately, it was decided that a stronger, centralized government was needed. Through the use of historical reference books as well as the internet and current, scholarly documents, I will show that this is the best situation for the United States of America, to promote unity, stability, and continuity throughout the country. Fifty States, One Nation, One Government: Unity, Stability, and Continuity for the United States of America The debate over who, exactly, should hold power as far as a government was concerned in the United States has stretched back to colonial times.

After securing victory in the War for Independence, the Founding Fathers came together to draft, frame, and ratify the Constitution, while the debate over who exactly should hold government power began. Two parties emerged, one who favored a strong “nation-state” with a centralized government over all the states, and another that favored the power being in the hands of the individual states with a more modest, almost powerless central government (Brinkley, 2004). Much, to be sure, was at stake, not the least of which was the future of the entire fledgling country.

Upon the end of the War for Independence, most people believed themselves to be citizens of separate countries, not states within one country, and were unwilling to turn over governmental power to a central government. The people had, after all, just dealt with the tyranny of one King, and were not keen to replace him with another (Davidson & Stoff, 1998). However, as history has proved, when states are given the power to do what they please, chaos can and will ensue, needing a strong and central hand to bring all parties to common ground.

In the seemingly endless debate between the rights of individual states versus a centralized federal government holding power, there can be no doubt that a strong, centralized federal government is needed to ensure unity, continuity, and stability throughout the United States of America. Historically, some things have caused disaster when put into the hands of the state governments. In the aftermath of the War for Independence, each state printed its own money, which caused confusion due to the fact that the money of one state was worthless or not worth the same price in another state (Davidson & Stoff, 1998).

This concept was proved even years later in the nation, when states once again tried to control their own banking system. In 1836, in a fit of rage, President Andrew Jackson vetoed the measure that would have allowed the Second Bank of the United States, a relatively stable national bank, to continue operations (Brinkley, 2004). Without it, the chaos of money madness that descended upon the country was literally unparalleled, and threw the country into the Panic of 1837 (Brinkley, 2004). It is therefore best that states have given control of all matters dealing with money to the federal government, and one nationalized banking system and one form of currency used throughout the nation.

Though it cannot be denied that such a national banking system has not solved all money woes, as was seen by the Great Depression, it is still better and preferable to finding exchange centers for money dotting state lines with their presence. Having one monetary system, under the control of one government,

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Strong, Centrlized Government vs. Fifty Strong State Governments Research Paper”, n.d.)
A Strong, Centrlized Government vs. Fifty Strong State Governments Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1442954-the-debate-over-states-rights-vsa-centrlized
(A Strong, Centrlized Government Vs. Fifty Strong State Governments Research Paper)
A Strong, Centrlized Government Vs. Fifty Strong State Governments Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/history/1442954-the-debate-over-states-rights-vsa-centrlized.
“A Strong, Centrlized Government Vs. Fifty Strong State Governments Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1442954-the-debate-over-states-rights-vsa-centrlized.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Strong, Centrlized Government vs. Fifty Strong State Governments

Englands involvement in the Enlightenment and its affect on the Constitution

The laws students could openly challenge the government policies, and compared their government with other governments and constitutions.... The group was aiming at hitting back at the church and state, and the goal was to promote intellectual discussions and scientific discussion because it was believed that the church was depending too much on superstitions and faith, (Mason 2010).... This smooth road to democracy in England proved to be a dynamite in the France because of the resistance from the church and state was strong, (Mason p210)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Social Security

— That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among Men,... It also seeks to showcase Liberalism, analysis of pluralism and elitism and how these variables can be of solutions to the state and how they can be of help to the citizens.... Social Contract (representative governance) This describes a model that typically shows cases and questions the origin of the society and the capability of the authority in place of a state over an individual (“The Social Contract”)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Rise of Qin in China

The Qin dynasty marked a new period in history of China but the essential components of Qin's new regime were created in the centuries prior to 221, while other vital elements of an imperial state were crafted only in the Han or still later.... Historians suppose that the Qin state came to political area late because of political and social problems affected Chinese society.... During the subsequent Warring States period, incessant wars and annexations were conducted among the remaining states until the unification of China under the domination of the sole surviving Qin state in 221 B....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Ancient Civilizations Governance

The structures of Israelites were conforming to those of Canaanites states in their monarchial government, religion, economy and social structures, where they improved on these structures to establish a strong kingdom (Collingwood, 1946).... The paper has focused on the ancient progression of governments in relation to the development of various ancient governments on how the rights and duties have evolved in different regions of the world up to the Middle Ages and how they exercised their rule over their citizenry....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Articles of Confederation and the US Constitution

There are taxes levied by the federal and state governments.... There is the need for a strong and central national government.... It made conditions better for succeeding national governments to build and maintain an army.... Considering the fact that the government at the centre must be endowed with enough powers to perform their rightful duties, the Constitution is clear in dissemination of adequate power for the president, the secretary of state, etc....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

French State during the French Fifth Republic

An observable lack of trust is part of the cultural identity of the French people, therefore the emersion of the state into an organization that is intent on making an overall European state that is unified under one policy does not culturally set well.... The constitution was re-written and ratified in order to create a more authoritative presence of a President, thus creating the circumstance of the Fifth Republic....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

The Declaration of Independence and the Major Issue of the US

An American Politician that served as the fourth president of America, Madison propagated for the US Constitution and the author of the Bill of Rights, which lead to a strong central government.... The Articles of Confederation was a document that was supposed to define the separation of powers in both the federal and state level.... The paper "The Declaration of Independence and the Major Issue of the US" highlights that profound leadership and drafting constitution was not only profound but necessary to investigate the notion of having a centralized government....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

POL2000 AMERICAN GOVERNMENT WK 1 ASSIGNMENT

??Touted as a hero in constitutional democracy, the author of the Declaration of Independence was a strong believer in the limits of a human being's spirits and the concept of common sense.... The collective rights of individuals give governments the authority and the power with these concepts diffusing through democratic ideals.... The distrust of state legislatures by delegates contributed to a rejection of the president's election by these bodies....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us