StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Machiavelli Is One of the Most Visionary Thinkers - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Machiavelli Is One of the Most Visionary Thinkers" describes that Machiavelli was clearly a visionary thinker.  He took an old format of the book and revolutionized its content and format, removing moral quibbling and focusing on pragmatic advice to a ruler on how to remain a ruler…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
Machiavelli Is One of the Most Visionary Thinkers
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Machiavelli Is One of the Most Visionary Thinkers"

?Machiavelli is one of the most visionary thinkers in the history of Western thought. Like any visionary, he made his mark on history by running counter to prevailing thoughts and attitudes, by being willing to say what he thought even at the risk of unpopularity. For hundreds of years, guidebooks had been written for rulers about how to govern; these usually focused on the lives and practices of laudable rulers who lived moral lives and tried to teach other rulers how to follow their example. Machiavelli chooses to break strikingly with this long standing and honored tradition, and write a different kind of guidebook for rulers. His guidebook did not tell rulers how to lead in an enlightened, moral way, but rather how to hold on to power, regardless of morality. This mentality was enshrined in his famous “the ends justify the means” attitude. Machiavelli’s choice to preclude moral discussions from his political analysis was bold, and had many benefits and drawbacks. Removing moral and ethical judgments from political analysis allowed Machiavelli to give a clearer guide to how to retain leadership, and differentiate traits that are praiseworthy in an individual from traits that are praiseworthy in a prince, but simultaneously perverted discussions of what the role of the ruler should be, focusing on how a ruler can help himself retain power rather than how to do the best thing for his subjects, necessarily. The first major benefit of Machiavelli’s choice to remove moral and ethical considerations from his political analysis is that it allows him to ask questions previous thinkers had not really been able to; instead of asking “what makes a good ruler?” he was able to ask “what makes a successful ruler?” or, put another way “what allows a ruler to achieve and to hold onto power?” This kind of thinking pervades Machiavelli’s texts – he writes that he intends his book to be a “practical text” (chapter XV), which, rather than following a line of moral absolutes, attempts to write something of “practical use to the inquirer” based on what actually happened to rulers who acted in one way or another (chapter XV). He insists that every action will lead to either “self-preservation” or “self-destruction” and that the primary goal of any ruler most be for all of his actions to be consistent with the former rather than the latter. Machiavelli, by eschewing moral questions, is able to focus on a completely different aspect of rulership than previous thinkers were able to. Focusing solely on how to achieve and hold on to power sounds a bit – well, Machiavellian for lack of a better term, selfish and disinterested with other’s wellbeing. Machiavelli’s focus on the maintenance of power is not, however, solely beneficial to the prince that takes his advice, but can also be of great benefit to the entire population. A ruler who behaves in a “self-destructive” way will surely be weak to attacks, and eventually others will try to attack his position and gain his princedom for their own. Such weak rulers who constantly have to spend time and energy defending their position always have less resources to put towards the public good, and the population suffers. Furthermore, weak rulers often invite anarchy, which can be much more damaging to a society than a slightly tyrannical leader. So, depending on the situation, Machiavelli’s admittedly cold advice could benefit not only the prince but also his population. Being able to ask and answer very different types of questions than previous thinkers had been able to was only one of the many benefit of Machiavelli’s amoral political analysis. Another major one was the ability to differentiate between qualities that are admirable in an individual versus qualities that are admirable or desirable in a leader. One of the prime examples Machiavelli uses to demonstrate the differences is the quality of generosity versus miserliness. Though generosity is obviously an excellent and admirable quality to have as an individual, Machiavelli points out that it is incredibly problematic in a leader. He points out that it is an admirable quality for an individual to have by calling it a “virtue” (chapter XVI) and by noting that it is very good to have a “reputation for generosity” (chapter XVI). But Machiavelli points out that a leader is in a very different position from the average person; a leader generates most of his income from taxing his subjects and thus his generosity is at the cost of the people (chapter XVI). Furthermore, generosity could prevent a leader from being able to defend both himself and his people by not having enough money to fight in a war if it becomes necessary. Machiavelli, by removing moral absolutism from his arguments, is able to recognize that traits that are generally recognized as positive in the normal population can be negative in a leader; a leader, for instance, has should not burden his people with incredibly high taxes merely to honor a moral code which advocates generosity. While avoiding moral and ethical issues in his analysis of governance has many benefits, it also has some drawbacks. The biggest among these is probably the fact that it removes the question of what a ruler ‘should’ do in a moral and ethical way from discussions of governance. As mentioned above, removing moral and ethical limitations allows Machiavelli to focus on the question “how does one develop and maintain power?” but it also inhibits the question “how should this power be exercised?” By focusing solely on actions that are self-serving to the ruler, Machiavelli misses what must be considered one of the supreme components of leadership – acting in a way that is positive for the people being led. While some of his discussions may lead to positive outcomes for the general population (such as, as mentioned before, creating strong leaders who avoid anarchy) these gains for the population are purely circumstantial. Machiavelli advises the ruler on how to make himself the most secure, and if sometimes this is good for the population, excellent, but if it is bad for the population he does not particularly care. This system, especially if extrapolated to the modern world where rulers have unheard of ability to oppress the populations they lead, can have horrible and devastating consequences. Machiavelli does warn a prince to avoid being hated, because it breeds rebellion, but it is also clear from his writing that the stronger a leader is the more he can afford to be hated. Machiavelli’s system could lead to a world where only a handful of people are happy and actualized, and the rest of the population toils in despair. Machiavelli was clearly a visionary thinker. He took an old format of book and revolutionized its content and format, removing moral quibbling and focusing on pragmatic advise to a ruler on how to remain a ruler. This was a good thing in many ways, allowing Machiavelli to think ‘outside the box’ and ask innovative questions, as well as realize that there might perhaps be a difference between acceptable morals for individuals and acceptable morals for leaders, but also had a drawback in that it could lead to horribly oppressed and dejected populations when questions of morals are removed. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Machiavelli Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1431568-use-your-discretion
(Machiavelli Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1431568-use-your-discretion.
“Machiavelli Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1431568-use-your-discretion.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Machiavelli Is One of the Most Visionary Thinkers

Organizations and Management

The gradual development of systems of work has been one of the most significant factors that have prompted the need to understand the internal relationships within the organizational culture.... The study of the science of management is relatively young, however, management has existed from ancient times The societal transition from that of an agrarian society to an industrialized one helped to create the need for knowledge of how to manage people in factory settings....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment

Self-Assessment Issues

The study "Self-Assessment Issues" presents an analysis of the author's assessment using self-assessment inventories.... The author's score for Tolerance for Ambiguity is 41, which is lower than the average range of 44-48 - this means that s/he has a higher-than-average tolerance to stimuli or situations....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Organizational Leadership

Particularly, Hunt cites Heifitz (1994) in suggesting that 'one of the critical tasks of leadership is to help the organisation face the truth about itself''.... This definition of leadership allows the reader to grasp the essence of leadership, but it is only one of the numerous of definitions that have been proposed in the literature.... In any group, regardless of its size, members differ in their degree of social influence over one another: " the person who exerts the most influence on the rest of the group thus affecting group beliefs and behaviour is usually addressed as leader" (Hollander, 1985: 14)....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Leadership and Change in Construction Industry

Attracting skilled labor and career-oriented employees (especially considering the growing share of part-time and casual jobs in the sector), retaining such employees in order to build bench strength required for succession planning, providing advanced training are only the most evident tasks to be fulfilled by the companies within the construction industry in the long-term perspective....
30 Pages (7500 words) Coursework

Warrior Politics

His book is a mix of aphoristic pronouncements, brief contemporary political analyses, rapid-fire parallels between conflicts ancient and current, and copious quotes from historians and thinkers through the ages (Livy, Thucydides, Sun-Tzu, Machiavelli, and Thomas Hobbes among them). ... aplan in his book had a discussion of the world's breeding grounds for rogue warriors out to disrupt daily life in bizarre new ways will strike a chord with most readers, as will his recounting of the brilliant Statesmanship of Churchill and Roosevelt during World War II....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Robert Kaplan's Warrior Politics

His book is a mix of aphoristic pronouncements, brief contemporary political analyses, rapid-fire parallels between conflicts ancient and current, and copious quotes from historians and thinkers through the ages.... aplan conducts a brisk tour through the works of machiavelli, Malthus and Hobbes, among others, to support his advocacy of foreign policy based on the morality of results rather than good intentions....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Distinction Between Leading and Managing

Although this definition of leadership allows the reader to grasp the essence of leadership, it is only one of the numerous definitions that have been proposed in the existing literature (Northhouse, 2004).... the most evident and celebrated of these changes are never yet seen dynamics of the business.... the person who exerts the most influence on the rest of the group thus affecting group beliefs and behaviour is usually addressed as a leader' (Hollander, 1985: 14)....
18 Pages (4500 words) Literature review

Political Thinker Niccolo Machiavelli

The great writer from Florence in Italy has variously been defined as one of the most controversial politicians of all time.... ven so, Niccolo Machiavelli argues that the most salient thing in any undertaking is the outcome.... Niccolo machiavelli is thought to be a mysterious political figure in the sense that he, at no time seemed to practice that which he preached.... The assumptions on which Niccolo Machiavelli constructs his systemAccording to most political scientists, anything described as Machiavellian is manipulative and excessively dictatorial....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us