StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free
Premium+

Healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of Resisting the Moralization of Eating by Maxfield - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This is the "Healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of Resisting the Moralization of Eating by Maxfield" essay. Was She Right?…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of Resisting the Moralization of Eating by Maxfield"

Healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of “Resisting the Moralization of Eating” by Maxfield: Was She Right?

Obesity and being overweight has become a continuous issue in modern society. Regardless of what you think about it, your lifestyle, and whether you are eating healthy ae more than important factors for living a happy and healthy life. The catch is there is no single fixed diet that will earn you the bodyweight you desire. Some people will eat cake, ice cream, and other high sugar foods and gain no weight while others have to stick a strict regime. This is because people react differently to different foods, and each has different basal metabolic rates.

These are the very issues addressed in healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of “Resisting the Moralization of Eating” by Maxfield. In the piece, Maxfield doesn’t approve of how Michael Pollan addresses the topic in an article titled “Escape from the Western Diet.” Mary Maxfield believes that Americans eat healthy in a different way. Healthy eating in the nation is not about quantity; it is about the quality of the food people consume. In her opinion, this has a bigger impact on Americans' health and is directly linked to whether they will be overweight or not. With this in mind, Maxfield argues that we should all work towards meeting our body nutritional and calorific value expectations rather than subscribing to an established notion of what is healthy or what is not.

People have become so keen on what they or those around them eat to the extent of labeling some food choices moral while frowning upon others. The immoral food happens to be the most delicious, the one that our bodies naturally want to indulge in. Since it is often hard to say “no” to such food, people are more susceptible to being overweight and developing diet-based health problems. Science and researchers like Maxfield also believe that diet, coupled with a sedentary lifestyle with little to no exercise, is also to blame. Maxfield states that many people in America like sugar enhanced fast drinks instead of water to satisfy their sweet tooth. This, coupled with the fast-food trend that even employs food science to come up with delicious foods that are not necessarily fit, is fueling the American obesity problem and even exporting it to the world.

While many individuals and researchers feel that simple regulation can reign the bucking fast food market and bring sanity to the obesity rates, Maxfield brings contradictory arguments. Her points might still be valid, but the only problem is they are not based on a specific study and do not have credible sources backing them up. A good example is how she goes about proving her hypothesis that there is no relationship between diet and our health. She needs a lot of research to send such a point home since science studies came to a different conclusion.

Maxfield combines her opinions, personal belief, and opinion of other scholars to come to this conclusion. While this might take some wind off her sails, her arguments are still valid. Maxfield backs up her approach by arguing that even most scientific studies are still a scientist's opinion about the body backed up by potentially flawed statistics. Either way, her goal is to prove that there is no fit, moral, or right way to eat. Eating is a personal preference. People should be educated about different foods but still be allowed to eat the food they want without being victimized.

In her effort to deconstruct the conception that diet leads to health, Maxfield looks at the existing correlation between different cultures and their view of health based on their beliefs. Different cultures define health differently. While here premises might be true, science has proven that there are specific, measurable points that can be used to determine whether a food diet is good for health. To make matters worse, Maxfield uses unreliable sources to back up her efforts to discredit the standard notion of fit or not full of health. Her entire article is based on these sources. Maxfield even goes as far as quoting a known fat acceptance activist to validate her claim, while such a source has all the motivation to be biased. Maxfield fails in her efforts to convince us since there is no international standard of health, there is no way we can label food unhealthy.

Another idea floated around is that there is a capitalistic motivation behind current views of health. The problem is that this doesn’t rhyme with her prior argument that culture begets health principles. In her article, Maxfield had previously explained how different cultures have a different view of who is fit and who is not. The argument in this line of thought is some diets, and even body types are linked to social status. For instance, rich people might indulge in high fat, high sodium meals, while poor folks have access to basics, so their eating will not feature some of the high-fat meaty foods. This could be a way to measure affluence since rich individuals will be full-bodies while the poor will be thinner. But again, instead of this argument pushing her main agenda, it ends up giving a societal interpretation of body weight without directly linking the understanding to health.

In retrospect, the societal decision of what is fit and what isn’t is opinion-based. For instance, cultures that value thinner frames serve smaller portions of food and will steer clear of anything that will make them gain weight. Cultures that value a fuller-bodied frame naturally have fattier foods and focus on eating bigger portions. They will think of thin persons as emaciated and underfed. Maxfield might have constructed a better argument with her essay only if she had chosen better sources and tailored her paper differently. She should have used dieticians or health experts first to clarify that health and diet are related before moving on to argue that the moralization of eating has nothing to do with whether something is scientifically healthy or not – it is but a means to achieve a look the society believes of as fit for health.

It is also important to note that the fact that her paper quotes a fat acceptance activist downright makes her biased. She also uses an unbiased and unsupported argument that discredits science findings by saying there is a lot of religious influence in science that makes her paperless credible. A solid argument cannot be based on such an accusation without evidence. Maxfield says that religion in science plays a vital role in moralizing foods and the decisions we make when choosing our diet. Maxfield has no credible way to back her claims; hence they, also cannot be taken seriously in the scholarly world.

The basis of her article is our misunderstanding of the relationship between health and food, which is driven by the moralization of some foods. While she does have a valid point that the relationship between weight and diet choice is culture-driven, she doesn’t debunk the empirical data medical teams have concerning body weight and health-conscious living. Her argument that we should trust our bodies and focus on eating whatever foods we desire to live a long and fit life has no backing whatsoever.

While Maxfield tries hard to address an essential topic, it is clear that judgment is clouded. Her decision to contest science and call it an idea we have been taught to believe in is skewed. It is well-known that obesity can lead to diabetes, hypertension, and sometimes heart failure. She doesn’t, in any way, try to give evidence to the contrary that is based on reliable studies. She urges us to discredit this information or, in the very list, make us question it. Her conclusion is that we should not listen to scholars or studies. Instead, we should focus on eating what our body wants to live healthily might have had some weight if only she could have handled the argument section of her essay better than she did. Maxfield leaves us more lost than we were at the start since she introduces a valid argument but fails to back it up or grow it to a sound conclusion.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of Resisting the Moralization Essay, n.d.)
Healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of Resisting the Moralization Essay. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/2089310-healthy-or-unhealthy-food-on-the-example-of-resisting-the-moralization-of-eating-by-maxfield-premium-essay
(Healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of Resisting the Moralization Essay)
Healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of Resisting the Moralization Essay. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/2089310-healthy-or-unhealthy-food-on-the-example-of-resisting-the-moralization-of-eating-by-maxfield-premium-essay.
“Healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of Resisting the Moralization Essay”. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/2089310-healthy-or-unhealthy-food-on-the-example-of-resisting-the-moralization-of-eating-by-maxfield-premium-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Healthy or Unhealthy Food on the Example of Resisting the Moralization of Eating by Maxfield

Food choices:the formula of being healthy

Meanwhile, a different perspective on diet and food choices was presented by Mary maxfield in her article, Food as Thought: Resisting... In the United States, the issue is that of obesity which has increased in prevalence during the last decades of the century These matters point to the question on what is really healthier: eating more or eating less.... Notable among the few and that I do not agree on is that “people eating a Western diet are prone to a complex of chronic diseases that seldom strike people eating more traditional diets” (Pollan 140)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Adopting Good Eating Habits for a College Student

This paper is about the health eating.... Frequently misunderstood, healthy eating is one of the crucial aspects that guarantee one a content life as it allows one to prevent and manage diseases, maintain a good mood, keep stress away and have the vitality to get through each day.... hellip; The main problem is that many people fail to commit to healthy eating because it is not an easy thing to sustain.... For a college student, adopting good eating habits is especially necessary because of the indulgence that one is frequently tempted by in their youth....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Difference between healthy people and unhealthy people

When the body is functioning properly producing, for example, the right kind of hormones at the right time, the brain is also working normally, and the thoughts are normal too, then that person is a healthy person.... This paper discusses the differences between healthy and unhealthy people.... In order to better understand the difference between healthy and unhealthy people, it is important to give the reader an idea regarding the characteristics of healthy and unhealthy people....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Eating Healthy and Heart Disease (Cause and Effect)

For some people, eating healthy food helps; but for others, it does not affect their health (even if they consume unhealthy food).... Over the years, humanity has realized that eating the right kind of food is essential for a healthy living.... eating the right kind of food is very important for a person to stay… A balanced diet provides the body the necessary nutrients, the nutrients which are required for the proper functioning of the body parts....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Why Is Obesity a Serious Problem

Concerns have been raised over the contribution of fast food companies like McDonald in the development of obesity.... They have been accused of giving adverts that do not contain warning signs as that of cigarette and that thus the contribution of fast food to the worsening human population in America is comparable to that of the cigarette, which was fiercely fought in America generation after generation (Kava, Gilbert, and Elizabeth, 34).... From school he did not have any option but to seek the services of the fast food stores; MacDonald, Taco Bell, Pizza Hut, and Kentucky Fried Chicken....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

A Healthy and Balanced Diet

I ravenously ate a plate and a half of fries, three Healthy eating Number The following is a brief summary of the foods I have eaten over the last 3 days.... This is a very alarming and dangerous eating habit as it is lacking in a plethora of foods from other vital groups (such as vitamins).... Healthy eating is an absolutely essential component toward health and well-being.... There are numerous changes and additions that I can make in order to improve on my eating habits as the overall quality of my dieting is very low and unhealthy....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Dealing with Unhealthy Food

Apart from this, most of the establishments that operate up to late at night are fast food places and this is quickly increasing the number of overweight people.... The children are required to eat all their food even when they are already full.... nbsp;Unavailability and unaffordability of healthy foods are some of the main issues....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Affects of Unhealthy Eating on the British Population

hellip; Some of the changes that can be made in a child's diet that is not meeting nutritional standards is the increase of fruits and vegetables with a reduction in sugar and saturated fat consumption: “Like many adults, British children are typically eating less than half the recommended five portions of fruits and vegetables a day”.... The guidelines are intended to educate individuals on healthy eating and better food choices and portion sizes....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us