StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Death of the Author and the Life of the Audience - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "The Death of the Author and the Life of the Audience" it is clear that in Death of the Author, Roland Barthes states that the reading audience is affected by this death of the author. The core of Barthes’ argument is that the reader brings his or her experiences, values to the text…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
The Death of the Author and the Life of the Audience
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Death of the Author and the Life of the Audience"

There are as many interpretations of the authors’ work as there are readers, according to Barthes, because the reception and interpretation of the audience are what gives life to the book. The source of the writing, which is the author putting words to paper, is not the originator of the text. The reading of the text is where the actual texts originate because the interpretation is what is key.

Trimbur (2000) explains a little of what Barthes meant by the “Death of the Author.” Essentially, the textual construct, or the reception of the text, is really an amalgamation of cultural practices that informs the reader and the reader’s reception of the text. In other words, how work is interpreted and received depends upon the cultural background of the reader. Trimbur (2000) states that Barthes’ reasoning that the author is dead, and that, essentially, the reader is the one that brings life to the book, changed the way that critics interpreted books. The agency of a given work was assigned as much to critics and audiences as to the authors themselves. Stables (1997) concurs with this analysis. The readers are who make the text meaningful, and this does not really have anything to do with the author him or herself. “The meanings share a network, and this network is what informs the work.” (p. 106).  Patterson (2000) adds that the audience brings new meaning to the text, every time that he or she engages in the text. She states that the death of the author has implications for her schoolchildren, “who bring these multiple meanings that are shifting and changing to the text.”

That said, the theory is not without contradiction. It is often said that certain work is “autobiographical” in a sense, in that the writer writes what he or she knows. This is a contradiction to what is said because the implication of Barthes' essay is that the author essentially disappears from the work, and the interpretation is in the hands of the audience. If the author is attempting to make the work autobiographical, in a sense, then the audience is asked to interpret concrete events in the author's life.  These concrete events may not be open to interpretation, however, so this becomes problematic, and is contradictory.  Moreover, another possible contradiction is that many books are not that complex. If somebody reads a potboiler novel that is designed for the masses, then most people would interpret the text in the same way, simply because the story and the characters are not layered. In other words, in many simplistic novels, there is really only one way to interpret what is there. In such novels, it probably can be said, after all, that the author was present, and giving his or her vision, and that the interpretations would not be as multitudinous as Barthes might suggest.

The critical implication for what Barthes proposes is that criticism for any work would no longer necessarily revolve around the life of the author.  Critics often bring the author's background into their critique of a book and attempt to show how, possibly, the author's work was influenced by his or her own life.  However, according to Barthes, the author's life is not relevant to the work, because the interpretation is what matters.  The audience is all that really matters.  Therefore, using the author's life and experiences would not be appropriate for critical reviews of work.  Moreover, critiques of an author's work may not delve into the author's intent, whether the author is approaching the text from, say, a feminist perspective, or a Marxist perspective.  What matters is how the audience is interpreting the work – if the audience interprets the work as decidedly non-feminist or non-Marxist, then that is how the work will be interpreted. The writer's intention to show a certain ideological bent would be nullified, which might prove frustrating for the writer.

Barthes suggests that the author is not the most important aspect of a text, or even that the author’s thought processes and vision for their work are the most important part of the text. What matters is the interpretation of the text.  A reader will bring his or her own unique experiences, values, and culture to interpreting the text, and the text is living in this way. That said, it is naïve to assume that all books have the complexity that would necessitate multiple interpretations. Sometimes there is only one interpretation.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Death of the Author suggests that the author is an ideological Essay”, n.d.)
The Death of the Author suggests that the author is an ideological Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1608622-the-death-of-the-author-suggests-that-the-author-is-an-ideological-construct-rather-than-the-originator-of-a-text-and-it-also-suggests-that-we-too-can-be-correctly-considered-as-textual-constructs-rather-than-as-individuals
(The Death of the Author Suggests That the Author Is an Ideological Essay)
The Death of the Author Suggests That the Author Is an Ideological Essay. https://studentshare.org/english/1608622-the-death-of-the-author-suggests-that-the-author-is-an-ideological-construct-rather-than-the-originator-of-a-text-and-it-also-suggests-that-we-too-can-be-correctly-considered-as-textual-constructs-rather-than-as-individuals.
“The Death of the Author Suggests That the Author Is an Ideological Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1608622-the-death-of-the-author-suggests-that-the-author-is-an-ideological-construct-rather-than-the-originator-of-a-text-and-it-also-suggests-that-we-too-can-be-correctly-considered-as-textual-constructs-rather-than-as-individuals.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Death of the Author and the Life of the Audience

Literary Craft Analysis of Poem--Mid Term Break

The poem tries to depict that the poet arrives hove from school, but just before he arrives home, he is informed of the death of his brother who is later revealed as his younger brother.... The literary, the poem portrays a boy who arrives home from school where he was “moaning in the college sick bay” after receiving the news of the death of his younger brother who was involved in an accident.... Despite the simplicity of the text, the mood and poem leave the audience captivated....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Sex, Death, and the Drama of Aids by George Newtown

Likewise, the emergence of AIDS made it possible to expand the audience of gay plays to include male and female alike due to the universal impact that AIDS apparently causes in contemporary society.... As emphasized by Newtown, “the audience for pre-AIDS gay plays was largely made up of gays; only one... the author expounded on the experiences of Emma in Flaubert's Madame Bovary, and of Willie Loman in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, who both allegedly selected free personal and sexual expressions, and eventually succumbed to death, which likewise confirmed the presence of the sex despite the risks of death factors....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Meaning when the Author is Dead: Foucault on Gilliams Brazil (1985)

Foucault (1991) explores the creation of the author, an exploration that reveals that because an author is hard to define and to describe, authors become products of their own discourses.... The key historical debates on who controls meaning focus on the language that produces meaning in modern society, where scholars debate on the death of authors and the rise of textual interpretation from diverse perspectives.... This essay answers the question on who controls meaning and relates it to the idea that the author is dead....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Research paper on three plays

More specifically dramatic irony occurs when the audience or reader knows more about the lives of the characters than the characters themselves.... This prior knowledge usually creates a sense of tragedy in the audience because they can see just how helpless the characters can be.... Throughout the play Oedipus makes several allusions to sight and blindness only adding to the audience's sense of dramatic irony, making the play into the great tragedy that it is known as today....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Significance of a Text to the Audience/ Readers Experience

This article discusses how and to what extent authors establish sub-text to give different interpretations and meanings to the audience or readers in relation to Gabriel Marquez's Chronicle of a Death Foretold and Arthur Miller's All My Sons.... As the report Significance of a Text to the audience/ Reader's Experience stresses traditional values are well presented in both Marquez's Chronicle of Death Foretold and Miller's All my Sons....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Understanding of Different Literary Techniques

By appealing to the audience, the authors improve the target audience for their article.... The author's first attempt to appeal to the audience and gain their understanding is her choice of themes in the article; among the themes that the author of the article addresses are family, home, and belongingness.... The paper 'Understanding of Different Literary Techniques' highlights Rhetorical analysis which is an in-depth study of an article such as a speech or essay with the view of determining the author's strategic employment of words in order to influence his or her audience....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article

Gordimer 's Country Lovers and Hemingway's Hills like White Elephants

The paper "life-Changing and life-Threatening Conditions in the Two Scenarios Country Lovers and Hills like White Elephants' focuses on a comparison of the stories.... Perhaps, it may illustrate the disunion between death and life which reflects Jig's dilemma....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review

The Different Views of the Characters and Acceptance of Gay Rights

This style impacts the logic or reasoning of the audience to solve the mystery as the play unravels.... The sociological angle of the play leads the audience to formulate conclusions out of the given views.... Giving different sides of the coin helps the audience form their conclusions.... The views of the people regarding the suspects, namely, Aaron Mckinney and Russell Henderson are revealed, thus making the audience dig further into the reason for their behaviors on the night of the murder....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us