StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Teaching versus Control a Parenting Challenge - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper “Teaching versus Control a Parenting Challenge” seeks to evaluate binaries that confuse the parents as it is difficult for them to determine the demarcation line between those pairs. For example punishment versus discipline and teaching versus control…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Teaching versus Control a Parenting Challenge
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Teaching versus Control a Parenting Challenge"

A well-taught child knows how to control impulses and takes responsibility for his actions. Parents cannot teach children everything, but can always inculcate the sense of responsibility for one’s own actions and self-control (Barber, Stolz, & Olsen, 2005). Teaching plays a crucial role in child development during the 4-8 years of age. On the other hand, parental control aims more at placing boundaries and setting rules than explaining why and how the children can avoid unacceptable behavior, or what will be the consequences (Skinner, Johnson & Snyder, 2005).

The children are not taken into consideration to a great extent as they are kept in the dark of the why’s, how’s, and what’s of it. They are punished if they violate the rules, as a discipline is not possible, without teaching. However, this is only an aspect of control, as empirical research brings out multiple layers of meaning to the word ‘control’. For example, Grolnick (2005) being in control and controlling the behavior of a child can be different. To be in control of the child’s behavior is to protect them from dangers and equally assure civil behavior.

This might at times be restrictive and sometimes allowing autonomy but under supervision. As a technical term, ‘control’ is more narrow and precise. It interferes with the human need to feel autonomous and competent. In this case, the children are bound without choices and the actions uninitiated by themselves. But, while parents teach children and then avoid control, the parenting is said to be autonomy-supportive, where the child feels the agent of causality (Grolnick, 2005). Teaching is to attempt at giving practical advice and guidance in the matters of what to do and what not to do.

In the non-autonomy supportive environment, where parents control a child’s behavior, the child has no choice and teaching makes no sense. In the stricter term, control cannot go hand in hand with teaching. However, ‘control’ is distinct from creating the structure or a system of rules and explicitly informing the child of expected behavior at the same time offering other acceptable alternative behavior. It is not always intertwined with some kind of reinforcement in the form of a punishment or a reward.

The manner in which parents convey this structure and implement it is what marks the demarcation between teaching and control (Baumrind, 2007). Threats and punishments in a non-supportive environment are clearly devoid of teaching and moral guidance. If parents provide emotional and psychological support even when the child has done a disapproved act, then they can make the child understand their self-responsibility and the necessity of obeying the structure. Without wielding control over the choices, the parent helps the child develop thinking skills, discipline, and obedience.

Virtues should be inculcated and not thrust upon them. If it is thrust, it is controlled and it may not last long if the string goes loose. What is good and how much is good depends on the age of the child. 4-8 years in a child’s life is the primary developmental stage and the pre-adolescent period (Roggman, Cook, Innocenti, Norman, & Christiansen, 2009). Parents need to balance teaching with control in order to prepare their children psychologically and emotionally ready for the vulnerable adolescent age.

Parenting is a challenge. Not only are every child unique, but also external forces come into play. Many a time, popular behavior succeeds and it becomes difficult for the parent to just stop with teaching. For example, if the child does not show restraint in watching television or using the internet, the parent may decide to refuse access to these. This act of control comes in desperate situations, which may, in turn, lead to rebellion from an otherwise normal child. In such cases, if the same control happens with a clear explanation and supportive guidance, then it becomes a structure than domination (Bergman, Larsr &Trost, 2006).

The child is made to understand the reason for the parent’s action and their intention, which is a psychological booster in the development. Therefore, parents need to discern when and how to use the two parenting tools: teaching and control in order to shape their child’s behavior. To allow them to develop is different from strictly thrusting them into the desired shape. The clay has to be in a suitable condition to undergo modification in the hands of the potter. Children in the age of 4-10 can be easily molded.

Teaching molds them. But, teaching without control can be disastrous as children are to be protected as they are still vulnerable and developing and may otherwise lead to behavioral problems in society. So, parenting should be a good balance of teaching and control and provide an emotionally supportive environment for the child to grow.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Teaching versus Control a Parenting Challenge Assignment, n.d.)
Teaching versus Control a Parenting Challenge Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1561439-teaching-versus-control-a-parenting-challenge
(Teaching Versus Control a Parenting Challenge Assignment)
Teaching Versus Control a Parenting Challenge Assignment. https://studentshare.org/education/1561439-teaching-versus-control-a-parenting-challenge.
“Teaching Versus Control a Parenting Challenge Assignment”. https://studentshare.org/education/1561439-teaching-versus-control-a-parenting-challenge.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Teaching versus Control a Parenting Challenge

How Families Affect the Development of Infants and Young Children

In such a parenting style, the children have to accept everything the rules state without any explanation from the parents.... In such a parenting style, the children are socially responsible and have a sense of self-regulation.... Different parents use different parenting styles in shaping up their children.... This is a vital approach as the child's development will depend on the parenting style.... Some parents have to use different parenting styles in ensuring their children have acceptable and balanced growth in the community....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Jesus Leadership Principles

Unlike other global icons whose legacies fade over time, Jesus' teachings have surpassed the test of time and the number of people adhering to his teachings has been increasing.... hellip; Jesus Christ lived over 2000 years ago, but his teachings have had immense significance in the two millenniums....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Parent Socialization Effects in Different Cultures

The paper "Parent Socialization Effects in Different Cultures" focuses on the critical analysis of the impact that parenting socialization has on children and the entire society.... The way of parenting is a great determinant of how the children grow and develop....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Training Objective

Autonomy versus doubt marks the second stage where children develop firm trust and attempt to explore the next stage is of initiative versus guilt where children exercise initiative inn activities by interaction with other children.... The fourth stage is of inferiority versus industry.... The watershed stage marks the fifth stage in the Erikson's model where identity versus identity diffusion is exhibited.... This is preceded by the isolation versus intimacy stage....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Personal Response Journal

The young students were a big challenge, unexpectedly.... Eric Eriksson and Sigmund Freud explained these in their theories of child development which gave clear warning to educators to handle the students with caution and to give them a lot of understanding. I was aware and forewarned about this that I planned strategies and developed ways to, if not control, guide the students towards more positive outcomes in school.... teaching younger students is quite a new experience for me since I have always handled higher grade students....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Spare the Rod, Spoil the Child

Spanking, as an effective enforcer of time out, is a component of several well-researched parent training programs (Forehand & Mc Mohan, 1981) and popular parenting texts (Clark, 1985).... The approach of balanced parenting by employing the occasional use of spanking, is advocated by several child-rearing experts.... He concluded from this study "did not indicate the negative reinforcement or corporal punishment per so were harmful or ineffective procedures, but rather the total patterns of parental control determined the effects of the child of these procedures'....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Patents and the HIV/AIDS Pandemic

Centers for Disease control and Prevention recorded a cluster of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (now still classified as PCP but known to be caused by Pneumocystis jirovecii) in five homosexual men in Los Angeles”... It would initially explain the social problem HIV/AIDS; determine why it is a problem; and identify from human service approach using concepts and intervention plans how it… A plan of action would be presented, outlining the reasons why the action is necessary to address the identified concern. “Health is wealth”....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Effects of Autism on Interpersonal Family Relationships

The results of this research study indicated that, as a group, the parents of children with autism experienced levels of depression and anxiety that were significantly higher than the control group.... The paper “Effects of Autism on Interpersonal Family Relationships” is a review of current research studies designed to assess the primary ways in which autism, a disorder that affects a child's capacity to communicate with others, changes the dynamics of family interactions....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us