StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Wal-Mart's Recovery from the Bribery Scandal - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The study "Wal-Mart’s Recovery from the Bribery Scandal" is devoted to the investigation of the scandal of the world-famous corporation, the consequences of its influence on the brand reputation and ways to regain the lost trust of stakeholders, the need to introduce a code of business ethics…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Wal-Marts Recovery from the Bribery Scandal
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Wal-Mart's Recovery from the Bribery Scandal"

Wal-Mart’s Recovery from the Bribery Scandal The first step towards recovery is an apology from the current chief executive officer. For many years, Wal-Mart has held a reputation for integrity and transparency, which was damaged after the scandal. Massive bribery occurred in Mexico in order to acquire different permits from the Mexican authorities. Giving bribes is against both the Mexican and American laws, and it was a breach of customer trust by the retail shop management. The executive management of Wal-Mart de Mexico was aware of the bribes and hid the report from the headquarters in Bentonville (pp.1). They covered evidence from the previous investigation, and the accused were never punished. This was against the moral and ethical standards upheld by the company as it pursued growth in Mexico (pp.2). Giving bribes and promoting the accused employees did not display any morals or business ethics. This was an example of impunity by a leading world retail market. Investors believed the significant growth experienced by Wal-mart de Mexico was a model for future growth and the most successful investment business. Corruption allegations and evidence that was unearthed by investigators was a substantial setback to investors. The top executive was supposed to prevent any misconduct by the company, but they orchestrated the bribes. This was against what investors expected from them, and a break of their trust. According to Cicero (pp.3) he had dispatched lawyers to deliver large amounts of cash to government officials who dealt with issuing of permits. This enabled the company open several branches within a short time. The company had hired gestores to conduct the bribes, who would in turn receive 6 percent of the bribe money. These were additional expenses by the company. This was an enormous misuse of investor money and an apology from the CEO would be one way of regaining their trust. The company has to commit itself to improve its corporate affairs and citizenship through corporate accountability. After the eruption of the bribery scandal, trust in business declined and corporate citizenship is necessary when rebuilding their reputation. The chief executive at that time had claimed internal investigators were overly aggressive. It was discovered a few days later that a top lawyer planned to ship files of internal investigators to Mexico (pp.2). The company executives had failed to cooperate with FCPA, which was against corporate conduct. After the first allegations in 2005, a group of executives began working secretly to conceal those claims and prevent deep investigations (pp.3). Investigators also received resistance from powerful executives implicated in the scandal in order to impede and conceal the evidence (pp. 3). The company had hired an external law firm to conduct investigations, but their approach was rejected by the company leaders. They were replaced by internal investigators who conducted a preliminary inquiry (pp. 8). Investigators found that gestores had received millions of shillings and the top executive was aware of the payment. They had used codes that different from other billing records, which could only be understood by specific workers. These payments were to speed up expansion plans by the company instead of following legal procedures to acquire those permits. The management worked hard to end the investigations and hide any inquiry until it was reported again in 2012. This was a sign of poor leadership and corporate citizenship. The company had acquired market dominance through fraud, and corporate accountability is necessary for rebuilding its reputation. This would open the company to scrutiny by shareholders and the public regarding its business activities. A corporate website would help accountability and the public scrutiny process. With the current development in internet technology, a public website would provide accurate information to the public and other interested parties. The company can make crisis information available on the website as a method of informing worldwide customers and the general public. According to Cicero, the company executives had worked hard to conceal the allegations from the public. The scandal erupted in 2005, and some findings were never made public until 2012. Some of the executives argued that the lead investigator should not hand over corrupt employees to law enforcers (pp. 16). They aimed at covering the findings from the public and other interested parties. A corporate website would be a key information source about such investigations and legal actions taken against the corrupt employees. This would build their confidence on the investigators, executives, and the company as a whole. Public scrutiny would help the general public and business partners reconsider conducting business with Wal-Mart. The top executive was aware of corruption, and some of them were implicated in the allegations. Changing the executives would be another step of rebuilding the company’s reputation. Cicero gave amounts, dates, and names of those involved including top company executives (pp.5). After the investigators recommended expansive investigation, Wal-Mart leaders shut down the process. These leaders continue to serve in several positions within the company. Castro-Wright was identified as the driving force behind the bribes but was promoted in 2008 to become the Vice chairman (pp.1). According to Cicero, bribes soared up when he took office in 2002 due to pressure put on employees to use necessary ways to obtain permits. Lee Scott was the chief executive and continues to serve in the management board. He accused investigators of being overly aggressive in order to transport some of their files to Mexico (pp. 2). The top executives received reports after bribes were made and identified officials to be paid. Changing the top executives would serve as a way of recovering from the scandal and ending future corruption. Thorough investigation on the case is required, and it can only be done by external auditors. When the initial allegations emerged, the company hired Willkie Farr & Gallagher to lead the investigations. The firm proposed scrutinizing all payments and interview all implicated employees. Wal-Mart leaders rejected this proposal and settled on internal investigators to conduct investigations. They conducted limited preliminary inquiries within two weeks (pp. 8). The executives had control over internal investigators and limited the investigation process. Some of the lawyers conducting the investigation had been implicated in the allegations. The internal investigating unit was ill equipped, and only four members were assigned to corporate fraud (pp. 8). External audit firm, Kroll Inc., was hired in 2003 to conduct investigations. They discovered that the company had helped high-volume customers evade taxes. External investigators identified specific individuals who received the largest share of bribes and the main leaders involved. However, these leaders were promoted into different positions, and Cicero’s allegations were discarded. An external auditor and investigator are required to unearth the findings and the leaders that covered up the implicated executives. These recommendations should be applied in both Mexico and USA without any alterations. The bribery activities occurred in Mexico with the help of top executives in the country. Although these practices were concealed from the headquarters, little was done to punish those implicated. The top seat in Bentonville promoted some of the implicated employees such as Castro-Wright. He was promoted in 2005 to serve in USA despite allegations made against him. Other executives such as Lee Scott were absorbed into the executive board in USA. Investigations conducted in Mexico require their response since they served in the country when the bribery took place. This would enable the company acquire back customer trust by American citizens. According to lead investigator Mr. Halter, gestore payments stopped when Castro-Wright moved to the U.S. in 2005 (pp. 10). This shows that they were actively involved, and they should face the law as part of Wal-Mart’s code of ethics. The company is required to respect American and Mexican laws, which guard against corruption. The top executives disregarded American FCPA rules and the Justice department would be involved in this scandal. This would require applying these recommendations in USA as well as Mexico as compliance with the law. Wal-Mart is an international retailer with headquarters in USA, and bribery cases in any region affect its worldwide activities. After the story broke out, Wal-Mart share price dropped by 5 percent in the USA. Investors had to weigh the likelihood of such amount of money being used to fuel international growth. The total sales in American and Mexico dropped after the allegations were made public due to loss of customer trust. Congress representatives Cummings and Waxman announced their interest in conducting an investigation into the scandal. Customer and investor trust can be won back by publicizing information about its business activities. Launching a corporate website would provide the necessary information worldwide. The top executives serving in USA who were implicated in the scandal have to be replaced. The company has a code of ethics that guards against corruption and affects all branches in the world. The company headquarters are situated in USA and applying these recommendations in the country would act as a lead before they are applied in other countries. Works cited Barstow, David. Wal-Mart Hushed Up a Vast Mexican Bribery Case. From http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/22/business/at-wal-mart-in-mexico-a-bribe-inquiry- silenced.html?_r=1&ref=business. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Wal-Mart's Recovery from the Bribery Scandal Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1453709-wallmart-mexico
(Wal-Mart'S Recovery from the Bribery Scandal Essay)
https://studentshare.org/business/1453709-wallmart-mexico.
“Wal-Mart'S Recovery from the Bribery Scandal Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1453709-wallmart-mexico.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Wal-Mart's Recovery from the Bribery Scandal

The Bribery Scandal at Siemens AG

This judgment is made based on considerations of the challenges that Kleinfeld was faced with as the CEO willing to rescue the company from the bribery scandal in order to sustain their growth.... Name Professor Business Date the bribery scandal at Siemens AG Question number 1: Discuss the use of bribes in securing contracts in international markets.... Decision of board whereby they failed to extend Kleinfeld's term can be considered personal due to lack of rational reason associated with the bribery scandal....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Bribery and Scandals

The decision had definitely created huge excited and enthusiasm and every thing looked good till an ugly bribery scandal was unearthed in 1998 and 1999.... "In January, when the scandal broke, it looked like SLOC had paid off 13 of the 114 IOC members with $393,000, mostly in "scholarships and stipends" for family members.... It was after the publication of a report by the ethics committee, that two main persons at the center of the scandal resigned and Governor Leavitt commented on the issue:"It must be made absolutely clear that the actions of a few do not reflect the values, moral expectations, or standards of behavior of this community and state....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Siemens bribery scandal

This paper tends to… The minority shareholders at Siemens have demanded the resignation of Heinrich von Pierer, the supervisory board chairman and CEO of Siemens for the Siemens bribery scandal The Munich based company Siemens was found involved in the acts of corruption in that it bribed workers of other companies for contracts.... The fact that Siemens appointed Hershman for the company's assistance in the development of an effective anti-corruption program after the scandal of Siemens bribery broke out also speaks of the fact that no adequate system of checks and balances was in place in Siemens at the time when the bribery was made....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Wal-Marts Mexican Bribery Scandal

Wal-Mart's Mexican bribery scandal Moral Issue Wal-Mart, which is the largest retailer in the world, is under accusation of breaking the law through the implementation of a bribery campaign in México aimed at winning market dominance.... Another serious twist to this scandal is that according to investigations carried out by the New York Times, some senior executives of the chain store in its home office in Bentonville had prior knowledge about the bribery but did not take any measures to stop it or try to alert law enforcement officers or their shareholders....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Corporate Bribery and Business Ethics

Many governments, particularly in Latin America, Asia, and the Middle East, are still unable to protect their citizens from the potential abuse of public resources that may arise due to corporate bribery.... The author of this paper provides an analysis of corporate bribery and business ethics.... Many American multinational business companies are increasingly facing the dilemma of whether to get involved in acts of bribery in countries and cultures that permit it....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review

Third Parties: The Wal-Mart Chain or Retail Store

The company involved itself in a massive bribery scandal that involves even the highest levels of management in the organization.... The company involved itself in a massive bribery scandal that involves even the highest levels of management in the organization.... Busted: Wal-Mart Caught in Huge bribery scandal - Senior Management Knew About It And Tried To Cover It Up.... The company began investigations into the scandal when it heard of its existence, especially because the Mexican branch was hiding the bribery acts from the headquarters, but shut it down systematically after realizing its existence, and the violation of both Mexican and US laws....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

IP 5 - Accounting

Inventories are valued at the lower of cost since the permanent markdowns are offset from the retail value of the inventory.... This scandal raised questions on the integrity of Wal-Mart's internal... Wal-Mart Company is infamous for the 24 million dollar cover up in Mexican bribery that occurred in 2012 (Frankel, 2012).... Also, debit and credit cards and electronic transfer transactions that take less than a week to be processed and cash from banks are included....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Bribing: Unethical or Legal

During 2006 and 2007, Siemens was in news and under (bribery scandal, 2009) investigation because of its bribery scandals.... To take any advantage for the person or for the company in the form of favor against the bribery is defined as an illegal activity.... In many ways, employees of different companies who are in need of business contracts, tenders, favors from the clients, offer bribery in form of money or gift.... The firm pays an exceeded amount to the customs officers to save itself from the interference and suffers....
14 Pages (3500 words) Admission/Application Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us