Nobody downloaded yet

Crito- Socrates argument against escape via the voice of The Laws - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In response to Critos arguments Socrates considers three things: (1), why the opinion of the majority is not the most important opinion, (2), what the consequences of escaping would be Athens, and (3), whether escaping is an unjust action such that it would harm Socrates…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.2% of users find it useful

Extract of sample
"Crito- Socrates argument against escape via the voice of The Laws"

Download file to see previous pages Lastly, in his third argument Crito mentions Socrates responsibility to his children. As their father, it is Socrates responsibility to see that his children are brought up well and educated, and he cant do this if he is dead. (Woozley, 1979)
Socrates of course is flattered, but he does not agree. Most of his response involves his theory of political obligation. He is sceptical that he will be welcomed in any other state, or will be happy and comfortable there. He will see himself as a foolish old man willing to humiliate himself in order to buy a few more years of life. If another state accepts him at all, hell be treated as a comic and pathetic figure.
In addition, he is also is not swayed by the point about his children. If he flees, he will either take them with him, in which case they will be raised in a foreign land by a cowardly fugitive and lose the benefits of an Athenian upbringing, or they will be left behind to be raised by his friends. The first is undesirable, and the second is the same as what would happen if he were executed. ( Rudebusch, 2009)
As far as what people will think of Crito and the others for supposedly failing to rescue him, he reminds Crito that they would long since come to realize that the opinions of the masses typically are not true anyway, just as we shouldnt care what someone who isnt an expert in physical fitness and athletics thinks about your physical training regimen, we also shouldnt care what non-experts think morally about the choices we make in life. Any time there is a choice between doing whats right and doing what will placate other people and avoid the harm that comes from their ill opinion of you, you should always do what is right, up to and including at the cost of your life. This point provides a transition to Socrates discussion of political obligation. He reminds Crito and the others present that they ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Crito- Socrates argument against escape via the voice of The Laws Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1642790-crito-socrates-argument-against-escape-via-the-voice-of-the-laws
(Crito- Socrates Argument Against Escape via the Voice of The Laws Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1642790-crito-socrates-argument-against-escape-via-the-voice-of-the-laws.
“Crito- Socrates Argument Against Escape via the Voice of The Laws Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1642790-crito-socrates-argument-against-escape-via-the-voice-of-the-laws.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Crito
...to fight pollution, whether done by a stranger or a relative. This stand was not in the Athenian norms. Euthyphro thus construes his suit against his father as a demand of impartial justice (Kamtekar 1). Socrates used dialogues to write metaphorically about different issues that people would normally discuss. In Euthyphro, he uses his dialogue with a man named Euthyphro to expound on his disdain on what seems like the time’s blind discipleship to orthodoxy. Euthyphro can be said to be a religious fanatic, following the word of the law. He is overzealous to perform duties pertaining to religion, making Socrates wonder how precise his distinction of right and wrong is....
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
Argument against Tax Bailouts
...May 13, Argument against Tax Bailouts 2008 economic crises, triggered by the collapse of the subprime mortgage industry in the US, resulted in a need for massive government bailouts to prevent a sudden decline of large corporations going into bankruptcy. A bailout, is essentially, a government taking tax payer dollars and giving it to corporations on the verge of bankruptcy, as the collapse of these too big to fail corporations would not only result in job less at said company but will also impact all other corporations that have business associated with this failing company (Bezdecheck, 5).There are many advantages and disadvantages to a tax bailout, some which will be discussed in this paper....
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
Opinion argument for or against
...Putting good-performing and bad-performing together: for or against 2007 All in all, I approve putting the gifted kids in special classes, because as for me, it is only fair if they receive as much knowledge as they want and are able to handle. However, there are still some very important objections to this position, and they are not limited to the points of view that "students with lower scores will be deprived of the example and the competition they need" or because it is "undemocratic". In fact, these two arguments seem to me not strong enough to deprive the talented students with high motivation from getting the opportunities that they deserve and need. Generally, such gifted children are very...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
An Argument Against Platos Mimesis
...An Argument Against Plato’s Mimesis The philosopher Plato argued that poetry and literature in general leads people to an unhappy life. His conception of mimesis meant that literature was merely an imitation of true forms, and it therefore could not lead to any sort of knowledge. However, I am going to argue that literature can lead to knowledge and under no circumstances will it lead people to an unhappy life. I have chosen Homer’s The Iliad to illustrate my argument. To Plato, literature was immoral because it appeals to the emotional side of people. When people read a piece of literature, it causes an emotional response within them, and Plato felt that this was an undesirable...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
Crito
...his/her own rational decisions concerning the situation. Therefore, Socrates would have disrespected the state because of the unjust sentence and made his own rational decision to escape. With regard to the second premise concerning state loyalty, Socrates seems to contradict his own philosophical principles. The underlying reasoning concept in the Apology is that what matters is not the public’s opinion but the individual’s knowledge on the truth. The law that guides state loyalty is formulated from the public’s general principles on moral standards. In this context, Socrates seems to be conforming to the public’s opinion. This is not consisted to his...
2 Pages(500 words)Personal Statement
What is Socrates' argument against Crito in the argument of the same name Is it persuasive why or why not
...hatched to break Socrates out of prison. It is after learning about this that a debate ensues on the justification of Socrates escape (Anton 73) In his argument, Socrates fronts that while the sentencing he received was wrong to begin with, it got reached through a legitimate process. In his thinking, Socrates was of the idea that the trial he got subjected to got done according to the law, he had the chance to defend himself against the allegations, and the verdict got passed by citizens. The matter at hand in this argument was whether content justice, which refers to getting the best...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Argument essay against marxist idea
...Against Marx and Engels’ criticism of private ownership: One of the cornerstones of Marxist economic theory is the abolition of private property and in its stead have common communal rights. This is a noble and idealistic idea but one suffering from lack of applicability. It has been proven true on many occasions that people are motivated to work hard when they are offered material incentives. The possibility and potential to own a house or a car or a jewel is what motivates most of us to work. Such being human psychology, it is futile to think of idealistic conceptions espoused by Marx and Engels. A cursory look at the state of commons underscores the ineffectiveness of this mode of ownership. For example, our environment... Marx and...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
On Socrates argument in The Crito is actually an argument developed by each PHI 101 student that explicates and evaluates Socrates argument in The Crito. S
...SocratesArgument in the Crito According to Crito, until the boat which left before Socrates’ trial would arrive was not in Athens, then no execution should take place. However, since the boat would arrive in Athens on that day, Crito urgently requested Socrates to escape from prison. What followed and transpired between Socrates and Crito was a meaningful dialogue where the latter convinced the former that an escape from prison would be the best solution. The philosopher, however, through a Socratic dialogue, reiterated his refusal to...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Crito
...you agree and assent to me first principle, that neither injury nor retaliation, nor warding off evil by evil is ever right.” Socrates says that doing unjust is never appropriate – even repaying for some abusive acts. Man has always act just; never can he do evil, even suffering does not permit to act evil and unjust. The major premise is that man ought never act unjustly. The second is that man has an obligation to abide by the judgments of the state and not to seek individual exceptions to the law. That is why Socrates decides to abide the state and not to escape to save himself. I support his perspective, as if everyone acted like that, the world would be much...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment
Socrates and Crito
...many arguments for influencing Socrates to escape from prison. Crito believed that death of Socrates would create negative impressions on him and his friends. Crito and his friends supported Socrates and loved him a lot. For this reason they wanted to save him. But if they are unable to save Socrates then people would think that Crito and his friend did nothing for their dear friend. Crito stated that Socrates should not be concerned about the financial costs and risks which his friends had to bear for saving him. Crito and his friends...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic Crito- Socrates argument against escape via the voice of The Laws for FREE!
Contact Us