Nobody downloaded yet

REFUTE letter - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
While the essay graders make a number of strong claims regarding the Bill Cosby essay, with this refutation letter I hope to offer my perspective when writing the essay and to respectfully disagree with the characterization of the essay as lacking focus and not understanding…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
REFUTE letter
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"REFUTE letter"

Download file to see previous pages ??take a position on the debate: is Bill Cosby’s criticism justified or, as William Ryan might ask, is he blaming the victim?” My response to this question was to formulate the essay as a rhetorical argument, and took the stance that all writing is persuasive writing. As a result, the responses to the arguments in the reading set were structured using the same logic Cosby, West, Dyson, and Ryan used; this means that rhetorical flourishes were used instead of the strict argumentative form that would be found in legal writing. You will notice that Cosby, West, Dyson, and even Ryan are guilty of using rhetoric to establish their arguments. Indeed, Dyson even refers to Cosby’s argument as, “classist, elitist, and rooted in generational warfare.” Furthermore, by referring to William Ryan’s ‘blaming the victim’ in the essay prompt, I took the statement ‘blaming the victim’ to be indicative of not only Ryan’s argument, but of the entire reading set that opposed Cosby.
When considering the Cosby argument, one grader noted that the essay did not fully grasp Cosby’s arguments. I must respectfully disagree and point the grader’s attention to the Boondocks comic in which the boy’s father chastises him for needing to pull up his pants and refers to the boy as ‘dirty laundry’. This comic is a satire on those that would take Cosby’s argument literally. In the essay, I set out to defend Cosby’s argument on the grounds that, “Cosby is not a social scientist and his message is not meant to be judged by these standards; rather, he is a respected and influential leader whose statements need to be understood for their rhetorical efficacy. In attacking Cosby, Dyson is willfully committing a socially irresponsible form of ignorance. While this example may seem a fairly basic formulation of a complex social problem…Cosby’s comments aren’t meant to be interpreted as the literal proscriptive formulation of a policy maker, but as a rhetorically ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“REFUTE letter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
REFUTE letter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562189-refute-letter
(REFUTE Letter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
REFUTE Letter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562189-refute-letter.
“REFUTE Letter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562189-refute-letter.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Refute paper
...Section/# The Trouble with Statistics: An Article Refutation of Michelle Malkin’s “Obama’s Layoff Bomb” The problem with using statistics to prove a point is that many individuals, Michelle Malkin included, measure them over a period of time that best helps prove their central thesis, relies on odd measurement data, and seeks to draw inference where none would otherwise exist. This is very much demonstrated in Michelle Malkin’s piece “Obama’s Layoff Bomb”. This brief refutation piece will seek to lay out some of the reasons why Malkin’s piece falls short as well as specifically engage and refute key points that are salaciously put forward by her. It bears emphasis that the title of the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Article
Confirm and refute
...? Assignment CONFIRM AND REFUTE Due CONFIRM AND REFUTE Introduction The maxim under considerationis “Swine wash in the mire, and barnyard fowl in dust” proclaimed by Heraclitus. This maxim has several constituent parts and symbolic contents that make it possible to present it for a confirmation and refutation context. In the maxim, we are told of two major choices, all of which are somewhat disgusting and appalling. This is because we read of a swine washing itself in mire and barnyard fowl washing itself in dust, which could imply to the evil and sinful choices that human make. As independent as the author could be said to have been in delivering this maxim, there are existing similar...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Letter
...Dear Mr. Orwell, After reading your essay 'Shooting an Elephant,' I decided I must write you, to respond from my perspective as an Antiguan woman. Perhaps these generic black letters on white paper is the only way two people as different as we are can communicate, for I cannot but think I would still be another native in the crowd in person. How did you feel such animosity towards the people of Moulmein The reason they could not riot against the English military was because you made sure they had no firearms. What were they to do, throw themselves in front of bullets These people you willingly policed each and every day had families to support under the subsistence of Colonial rule, and could not die in such an act of futility... Mr....
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Refute an Argument regarding Immigration
... Illegal Immigrants are the Real Losers The one-sided immigration debate is focused almost exclusively on the harms illegal immigrants perpetrate. The presence of these ‘aliens’ increases the cost of health care and education. Jobs are lost because they will accept much less pay. Areas with high concentrations of illegal immigrants are widely known to experience higher crime rates generally. Seemingly all we here about regarding this issue is the degree to which Americans are suffering due to illegal immigration. I submit it is the immigrants who are suffering to a much greater degree than legal residents. The scales of justice tip away from the illegal immigrant. It tips away from human and civil rights as well. In the United... Illegal...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
LETTER
...New York Children’s Zone Aug 9th Attention of New York Workers Compensation Board Bureau To Whom It May Concern: This letter isto inform the State of New York Workers Compensation Board Bureau of New York City Children’s Zone latest information regarding the nonprofit organization. The nonprofit organization was scheduled to have begun on June 30th 2011. Since the nonprofit organization has not yet begun and will not begin until sometime in 2012, certain coverage’s will not be provided. When the nonprofit organization does begin in 2012, New York City Children’s Zone will begin workers compensation insurance coverage for employees. We apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused. If you have any questions...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Refute
...Refute to “Raise Wages Not Walls” Trainer’s Affiliation The agenda of illegal immigration has raised sensitivity in the economic world as well as in the economic arenas. While those in the government contend about applying walls versus imposing strict rules of identification in the employment industry, author to the “Raise Wages, Not Walls” assert that raising minimum wages will solve the issue (Dukaki & Mitchel, 2006). This paper refutes the assertion of the authors on eliminating illegal immigration by raising wages. Raising the minimum wage will cost the economys considerable number of jobs as the employers are likely to reduce the number of employees. Even with the possibilities of encouraging the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Letter
...Abdullah Alkhaldi Essay As I started pursuing my topic, I considered it a public concern and a contemporary issue, leadingto a developed interest. I however had little background information on the topic. All I had was a general knowledge without even a single supportive proof for my ideas. I therefore lost confidence and my writing got weaker because I did not have much to talk about on the topic. With my peer’s feedback however, I developed a wider perspective into new ideas. Thoughts began rushing through my mind as I regained my confidence and I even incorporated my peer’s opinions in my topic and writing. They therefore helped me, in as much as my revision paper did, to brainstorm and develop a better understanding on how... Alkhaldi...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Letter
...of political science 1100, American national government, Weber Ogden, Utah 84408. Prof. Robert A Hunter, 2995 Harrison Boulevard, Suite 201 Ogden, Utah 84403. Dear Prof. Hunter, Subject Final Examination for American National Government (Spring 2014) Responding to the letter dated April 8, 2014, I would like to appreciate your efforts of wanting to know more about me after college. May I take this chance to inform you that I am well prepared and ready to face the real world. Armed with the information and skills I have gained so far in the class of political science, I wish to make the world a better place to live. During my career, I want to totally eliminate the social injustices, extrajudicial killings, terrorism and...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Letter
...Your Mailing Address ST Zip Phone Number E-mail (optional) Month Day, Year of Receiver Company Name Mailing Address City, ST Zip REF: CREDIT CARD APPLICATION I would like to bring to your attention that I already hold an account with your esteemed bank. Though, at the time of account opening I had not applied for a credit card. I urge you to consider this letter as an official application for a credit card with your bank. This appeal is in particular to the provision of credit limit to new customers, where new customers only receive a credit limit of $7500. However, owing to my family`s strong financial backing and the level of my business, I am convinced that I deserve a credit card whose limit exceeds $15000. Name,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Letter
...Nursing Letter February 06, Senator Mark Kirk Senate Bldg Room 230 South Derban IL 60604 Dear Senator Mark Kirk Re: SB 560 - Nurse Practitioners- Support My name is Johnson Andrew. I am an Advanced Practice Registered Nurse (APRN) in Illinois. Am writing to request your indulgence and help in the support of the bill SB 560, which intends to alter the scope of practice laws in Illinois to protect the Nurse Practitioners from Physician supervision (CNS, 2009). The bill seeks to recognize that the education and training of the Nurses instills them with the necessary skills that make them professionals in their field of study. Consequently, continued supervision is an act of downgrading the proficiency of nurses. Am writing...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic REFUTE letter for FREE!
Contact Us